Press "Enter" to skip to content

How your brain predictions interfere with what you see | Georg Keller | TEDxBasel


[Music]
what if I told you that you could
predict the future more so that you’re
experts at it you do it all the time
even right now you look skeptical well
what’s gonna happen next it’s obvious
this may seem so simple to you because
we do it all the time but it’s not
trivial you need to know about water you
need to know how it looks about gravity
how things fall out of buckets when
dropped you need to know about social
interactions about pranks people play on
each other about potentially staged
photographs for taking for the purpose
of a TED talk in a blink of an eye you
combine all of this knowledge to predict
what will happen next you can even feel
the cold of the water as it splashes
over your head and runs down near back
we do this all the time with ease you
can predict what the last word will be
at the end of this you can hear of
something happen to somebody and you
know what it would feel like if it were
to happen to you this is the basis of
empathy we continuously run a simulation
an internal model of the world in our
head to predict what will happen next
we call this thinking we can think about
what would happen if we were to do
something without actually having to do
this but if we do this all the time with
this not interfere with how we see the
world how we feel the world how we hear
the world it does of course it does
let’s take a simple example color black
jacket white shirt surely no two people
would ever disagree on the color of a
piece of clothing except we do of course
all the time you’ve probably see
in this photograph of address some of
you will see it as black and blue and
others of you will see it as white and
gold and there’s heated debates about
which of the two interpretations is
correct but whether you see it as black
and blue or white and gold simply
depends on the predictions your brain
makes about the lighting conditions this
photo was taken under and I can prove
that to you suppose we take two
identical patterns that are in this
image and we will give them context now
to change the predictions you make about
the lighting conditions suppose you saw
the snippet the pattern on the left on a
gray autumn day it might appear white
and gold now suppose you saw that same
scene again
half a year later on a bright spring
evening it might appear black and blue
note that nothing has changed about the
two patterns simply the context that’s a
suggest to your brain what the lighting
conditions are under which this photo
was taken have changed the predictions
we make about the world consciously or
subconsciously continuously influence
how we see the world the instance is
where we can prove that this is the case
we call visual illusions but this
happens all the time
the idea that we have direct access to
reality is a misconception so what’s the
purpose of doing this why would we
predict well the advantages are obvious
we can anticipate and we can filter the
information the sensory information for
salient deviations from our expectations
and anticipations anticipating the
movement of an oncoming car is what
allows you to avoid collision filtering
the sensory information of this stage
you’ve been looking at for a while now
is what allows you to pay attention to
what I’m saying
but how
this happen in the brain for this we
turn to neuroscience and these are
precisely the question our lab is
addressing how does the brain generate
predictions and what are they used for
to do this we typically start by
training a mouse to play a video game
the mouse sits on a spherical treadmill
and vietze locomotion controls a video
game shown to it on something like a
mouse IMAX screen excuse me as the mouse
does this we record from neurons in the
brain of the mouse from a part of the
brain that is responsible for processing
visual information the primary visual
cortex we use a method to visualize the
activity of individual brain cells that
you see here in this video as the mouse
plays the video game so we can watch the
mouse think now what happens as the
mouse first explores a virtual
environment and then learns about it and
then what happens if we change something
about the environment it doesn’t expect
suppose the mouse were to run down a
corridor at the end of the corridor
there’s a turn the mouse turns and
behind the turn as an image and the
mouse sees that image and this results
in a visual response in the brain of the
mouse it sees the image but now what
happens with time as it runs down this
corridor for hundreds of times just like
us mice actually quite enjoy doing this
they run down this corridor hundreds of
times and they learn what they’re about
to see so as the mouse comes up to the
same corner for the hundreds for the two
hundredth time what happens is it
generates a prediction of what it’s
about to see and these predictions start
suppressing the visual response to
actually seeing that image after the
turn so
happens if we remove that image if we
violate the prediction the mouse is
making now the mouse knows about the
image it knows that there’s after the
turn there’s an image it will see this
image it runs down the corridor it’s
still expecting to see it but we’ve
removed it we’ve taken the image away
what happens in the brain of the mouse
there’s a very strong response a very
strong deviation from expectation
response and this is the moment the
mouse updates it an internal model of
the world and learns so we continuously
compare what we expect to see with what
we actually see we predict explain away
things that are close enough to our
expectations to detect those moments
where there is a salient deviation from
expectation these are the moments we
update their internal model we learn
when we learn to speak for example what
we do is we compare an internal model
and memory of what we’re trying to say
with what we’re actually saying this is
the reason your voice our voice sounds
different when we hear it on tape what
we hear when we speak is a mixture of
what we expect to hear and what we
actually hear these predictions can be
so strong that they interfere with what
we’re seeing typos in our own writing
our partners new haircut our new glasses
we miss things that are right in front
of our eyes because we have a good
expectation of how he or she should look
like and what we see is what we expected
to see so perception is always a
comparison between what we predict to
hear to see to feel to smell and what is
actually there why does this matter
well suppose for a second this finely
tuned balance between predictions and
actually sensory input were skewed in
favor of predictions one might see
things that aren’t actually there one
might hear things that aren’t there
project intentions into other people
that aren’t there
hallucinations and delusions conversely
if predictions were too weak the world
might appear unpredictable and magical
and intentions of other people hard to
understand and one might resort to doing
the same thing over and over again in an
attempt to restore predictability in the
world the former are symptoms of what we
call schizophrenia the latter those of
what we call autism so these
neurological conditions may be the
result of an imbalance between an
internal model of the world and
imbalance in the comparison between an
internal model of the world and the
external world but what does that mean
for us here today well next time you
find yourself in this agreement with
somebody consider this because our
expectations depend on our very personal
experience we’ve had with the world we
differ in how we see the world in many
more ways than simply how we judge the
color of a piece of clothing we create
our own simulation our own reality to be
able to learn to predict what will
happen next thank you very much
you
Please follow and like us: