
hi everybody my name’s
crowd covey I’m a gay activist that
means I’m a homosexual
and basically I’ve come here not really
to talk about homosexuality in general
but I’m broadening out the subject and
looking at patriarchy as a prison and
how we homosexuals are equal prisoners
of it how we transcend some of these
barriers that patriarchy has put where
does it come from and I’m trying to look
at issues where homosexuality or
homosexuals become pioneers in attacking
some of the last barriers in the
Constitution where the articles on
equality before the law liberty freedom
of expression are fully expressed and
procured for the citizens of this
country so that’s my contention before I
start I must tell you
incident in my life 30 years ago and I
well I became a street councillor for my
organization call the hands of a trust
which is India’s oldest gay organization
it works with the government of India
with the Union Health Ministry but the
interesting part is that as a street
councilor we are we were on the street
and we used to meet up people who had
issues about their sexuality and I was
usually one of the four or five Street
councilors trained by with their
Subramanyam to go out we were not
allowed to meet them in any private
space we could meet them on park benches
or in say hotels they would sit on a cup
of tea and advice people and I met this
guy who said he had a problem so I said
okay we’ll meet and we met interestingly
in a small choice op outside the other
station and he said I want to tell you
that I’m heterosexual and married and I
have two children so I was wondering
what’s the problem he seemed happy so I
said yeah so so what so he said we sat
down the tea started again he repeated
the same thing he said I am a married
man and I love my wife I’ve got two
children but Sir I want to tell you that
whenever every day I I go for a shower
and come out
and I dry myself and I look at myself in
the mirror and I look at my butt and I
said what a beautiful but you have I
didn’t know I thought I thought that was
a interesting line to take you know I
mean but what I wanted to that set me
off a lot of things because there was a
total disconnect in his mind between his
orientation he was obviously a man who
was oriented towards homosexual you know
orientation but he was totally just
disconnected from his his identity was
homosexual but his behavior was
perfectly heterosexual he was happy with
his wife he had no issues he said that
everything was perfect he had children
but soon after about three years after
that he did come to me and says I think
I’m done with my married life do you
think I could get a male partner so
obviously people progress now I’m giving
with the story to tell you the journey
that I made over thirty five years in
the community and I have tried to
connect theory and practice and our
experiences on the street to come up
with certain ideas about where we are
heading you know as far as men in this
in this country are concerned if you
look around you’re you’re you must be
seeing and reading the papers and it’s
pretty bad the rapes formulated by our
downwards
a month ago we had two boys sodomized in
Hawaii they committed suicide so this
this sort of violence that the male is
indulging in I feel is a crisis in
patriarchy I’m not saying it’s happening
particularly in India it’s a crowded
country but it’s happening all over the
world if you go into the streets of
London you see the same type of sexual
violence if you see what’s happening in
Europe with or without them migrants
it’s happening there too so there is a
crisis in patriarchy throughout the
globe
all over the planet where man has
practically spread his wings and taken
up every ecological niche there is we
must understand look back a little bit
into evolution III want to run through
this very quickly because these notes
are very extensive anyway
I want to tell you that the whole
business of when you look at the Homo
Sapien as this incredible primate among
all the simians that you have around us
this primate is the only animal that has
sex in private if you look in the animal
kingdom you will not see this obsession
for privacy and private space and you
can see that obsession running it’s
happening in the Supreme Court right in
front of us today or the last ones eat
this obsession with privacy the very
fact that you have a smartphone your
privacy is gone but looking at the way
they are talking about biometrics and I
mean we had a huge fight in the
transgender community which was invited
to the u.s. consulate for a workshop and
most of the transgender refused to show
the ID because they have different ID in
the private lives on the street and they
have a different ID according to the
other car so one of the jobs of humsafar
trust is to get them other card in the
name of their transgendered identity
which means them if I’m Ashok on the
streets and Kalasha they want they want
to add her card in the name of Asha you
can see the sort of mess going on
between identities sexual orientations
and sexual desire I’m going to
concentrate on these four issues okay
let’s see I want to say that I have come
down from privacy and according to me
privacy required certain amount of
spaces that’s why today we are spread
all of the planet
due to all types of expansion wars
famines displacement man has spread all
over the planet and it’s not just for
space and for you know living that he’s
got there he’s got that because of
privacy needs privacy for himself for
his sexual practices and these sexual
practices are very interesting because
the more you look at sexual practices
right from Kinsey onwards to what we are
doing in in India you’ll be surprised at
the number of kings that human beings
have you know what is it due to frankly
looking at sexual desire by itself you
know very well that
something that this simian has your I
think the you homo sapien is the only
animal that breathes throughout the
earth there’s no such thing as a time
when there’s a breeding period or
anything like that we breed throughout
the earth we have out bread every other
species on this planet and this sexual
desire comes out in various ways now I
had to go back to a person called Michel
Foucault who is the father of the
history of sexuality
he was a French gay man who died of AIDS
much before ERT ever came in but if you
read his three books on the history of
human sexuality you get to know really
what is happening even today in India
you know he introduced something called
bio power and that’s interesting bio
power he defines as a power that is
within each human being that has you
know has a tendency to self discipline
the animal and understand its linkages
to the rest of society
now bio power according to me see
sexual desire has to play out in the in
society and from that to get sexual
behavior but sexual behavior called
according to Foucault has these two you
know arms and one is called sexual
orientation and that means who you’re
attracted to
it’s an outward centrifugal force and
then there is a sexual identity Who am I
it’s exactly not the story I told you
about this guy was counseling his
orientation was clearly homosexual but
his identity was heterosexual and if
they don’t match that’s where mental
science has come in and that’s the issue
that is happening today as far not just
with the homosexual community but I find
even among heterosexuals that there is
an issue in the sense after they
finished with certain practices I don’t
think my married life really exists in
India beyond a couple of years at least
most of my friends who were in class
with me are either divorced or separated
and whenever I ask them they say this
sparks gone out of their lives what does
that mean
there is no sex anymore so obviously the
sexual drive has ended up with sexual
behavior it’s played itself out or
orientation
is the direction in which you attracted
to another human being that may be as
powerful as possible but the identity is
an issue I didn’t know for example that
in India 8% of males are sexually
attracted to animals it’s constant
throughout the country that’s amazing
if we look at the homosexual orientation
for example the surveys that were done
in Chennai talked about six to seven
percent of the sexually active men who
permanent practicing homosexuals but if
you went across into say Rajasthan there
was another study done by dean dona and
ravi varma which put the number of men
having sex with other men at between 11
and 18 percent that’s a hell of a lot
where is this coming from when we try to
find out for example the questionnaires
that were there in public hospitals in
Bombay there was asking question like
are you a homosexual
have you had homosexual relations the
answer is no but if you divide it or
tried it them up into three separate
questions you know do you
there are many societies where men have
sex with other men do you know such men
answer was yes are there any such men
close to you yes has any such man made a
pass at you because of Indian men are
very nice you see in films you’ll see
only the women women not tempting them
otherwise they’re wonderful and pure so
the question has to be put the other way
he is a vestal virgin did anybody make a
pass at you answer was yes that answer
that question air came out with 22% in
sign hospital
22% of attendees in sexually transmitted
infections were having sex with other
men and not talking about it it’s a zone
of so much silence that one of the
chapters that I have written for a book
called Johanna which is the gay
anthology in India brought or Beth
Angwin it’s called the contract of
silence what I wanted to say was that
throughout you will see this type of
stuff going on in all around us nobody
wants to talk about sexual practices
that are very
are going on right under our noses are
criminalized marginalized kept out of
the realm of public discourse and are
not being looked into for the simple
reason a people will not talk about it
because they do not want to see it now
what I wanted to say was that this type
of rampant aggressive masculinity seems
to be to appropriate surpluses resources
corner them turf wars and this is what
is finally leading to my contention that
we gay men are actually subversives in
this system we are equal prisoners a lot
of women think that whenever in India
you talk of gender it’s always women and
children nobody talks of men also is a
gender males also a gender and males are
also prisoners of patriarchy do not
think that they are always the dominant
sex and deeming gee I mean when I say
gay men it includes a huge spectrum and
that’s why they are called a rainbow
spectrum there in the rainbow community
it means men having sex with men
bisexual men I’m going to take you to
that this was a diagram which I drew for
the Ministry of Health I had to show
that it is gay men within patriarchy who
are doing the transmissions the latest
now if you see what’s happening in the
Supreme Court and how we are taking the
Delhi High Court judgement forward we
are asking for certain laws to be framed
to protect even privacy for example
privacy of a woman if you read the Delhi
High Court judgement you’ll find that
privacy is defined in a completely new
way if a woman sits in a path all the
space around her is a private space so
there’s a new definitions of privacy
coming up now this is what the
homosexual community is fighting for
equality before the law the moment you
demand equality before the law a whole
lot of other laws goes out of the window
section 377 goes out of the window it
has created a second-class citizen by
the very nature of Who I am
so it definitely attacks constitutional
laws equality before the law doesn’t
stand because there is some the
Scheduled Tribes and cast act which was
actually removed in 1952 said if you
were born into a particular caste like
say the gypsies the word eras although
there are several criminal tribes and
castes who the british had termed as
criminal from the very day they were
born that had to be thrown out by
parliament in 1952 very closely attached
to that was sick section 377 we’ve had a
huge issues just the hump suffered trust
just to pay their employees has to have
a fight every day with banks so you can
imagine when this is what gay men are
fighting for equality before the law how
can you keep a hashida out of say a
hospital they are not allowed even into
hospital gates and they happen to be the
most visible sexual minority in this
country if you see what was happening
when the the transgender bill is about
to be passed this this month and it is
the most ridiculous bill there’s going
to be a screening committee where before
which you have to go and they’re going
to physically examine you and find out
whether you’re a hit or not or a
transgender which is insulting who the
hell is anybody in government or in a
court to try and certify whether I am
something or the other I am a citizen of
this country whether I pay income tax or
not I am a citizen of this country have
to be treated equal before the law
according to me only gay men will be
able to fight this out this is the last
frontier I don’t see other human rights
activists even interested even the
feminists I must tell you the failure
the Justice were my Committee which met
after the nearby our case we made a
deputation to Justice Verma that there
should be male I mean rape should be
gender-neutral and you’ll be surprised
the feminist groups attacked us and said
in a patriarchal society men can never
get raped now you and I know that it is
happening it’s happening in jails it’s
happening in the crowded places any homo
social place where more men are there
there is bullying of men there
sexual abuse of men that has not been
taken into consideration doesn’t require
a gay man to point this out that is
something that is so obvious though
again I wanted to say coming back to
this and this is the great MSM circle
that hamsa fortress has created for the
Ministry of Health and it will it was
basically done to see that it’s not a
monolith that it’s a very pluralistic
world and from this comes my little
motto that because it is such a
pluralistic and diverse world it’s a
very shadowy world how many of you know
that how many homosexuals there are in
this country according to me the
estimate is between 28 and 32 million
adults and that’s not a small number now
if if they are there they’re definitely
all within this circle you’ll observe
large parts of this yellow circle are
not populated because we don’t know what
types of men are there who have sex with
other men but we know some sort of
topography of this the ones on top are
all males whose gender is different from
in which they were born
these are male born sexual minorities
who feel they’re women or females all
the others at the bottom you’ll see
cotys panties gay identified these are
means who’s not whose identity is based
on behavior say someone like me I don’t
look like a woman I don’t behave like a
woman but I am attracted to other men
and I have sex with other men so these
are the ones below there are subdivision
there but don’t bother with it I’ll tell
you later on outside when I meet you on
this side are men whose vulnerability
comes because of their workplace into
end you know in the sense say cleaners
of lorries film extras so I exploit it
just like the women you know then there
are every big city in India has Monsieur
Zoot launches of a massage they also
have sex and boys in dancing bars do we
know that in the dance bars in bombay 20
percent of the girls actually
cross-dressing boys who dance very well
indeed as women so we on this side we’re
prison population bisexual who may be
behaviorally bisexual or they might be
identity as a bisexual and then right
down the center you have a bridge where
effeminate males in traditional Indian
society usually travelled towards Hydra
cultures in the Hydra cultures itself
these are all male born do not think
hydras 80% of hydras have got their male
organs are functional males who can have
sex with women but they cross dress and
do not gender identify as males that’s a
different cup of tea altogether now this
whole bridge is in the old days was used
by feminine men to travel into Hydra
cultures they were never kidnapped they
went there and I could tell you story
there’s no time so I would like to tell
you that these are the types of men who
are now fighting battles for the last
frontier what we have to achieve in the
Constitution thank you
crowd covey I’m a gay activist that
means I’m a homosexual
and basically I’ve come here not really
to talk about homosexuality in general
but I’m broadening out the subject and
looking at patriarchy as a prison and
how we homosexuals are equal prisoners
of it how we transcend some of these
barriers that patriarchy has put where
does it come from and I’m trying to look
at issues where homosexuality or
homosexuals become pioneers in attacking
some of the last barriers in the
Constitution where the articles on
equality before the law liberty freedom
of expression are fully expressed and
procured for the citizens of this
country so that’s my contention before I
start I must tell you
incident in my life 30 years ago and I
well I became a street councillor for my
organization call the hands of a trust
which is India’s oldest gay organization
it works with the government of India
with the Union Health Ministry but the
interesting part is that as a street
councilor we are we were on the street
and we used to meet up people who had
issues about their sexuality and I was
usually one of the four or five Street
councilors trained by with their
Subramanyam to go out we were not
allowed to meet them in any private
space we could meet them on park benches
or in say hotels they would sit on a cup
of tea and advice people and I met this
guy who said he had a problem so I said
okay we’ll meet and we met interestingly
in a small choice op outside the other
station and he said I want to tell you
that I’m heterosexual and married and I
have two children so I was wondering
what’s the problem he seemed happy so I
said yeah so so what so he said we sat
down the tea started again he repeated
the same thing he said I am a married
man and I love my wife I’ve got two
children but Sir I want to tell you that
whenever every day I I go for a shower
and come out
and I dry myself and I look at myself in
the mirror and I look at my butt and I
said what a beautiful but you have I
didn’t know I thought I thought that was
a interesting line to take you know I
mean but what I wanted to that set me
off a lot of things because there was a
total disconnect in his mind between his
orientation he was obviously a man who
was oriented towards homosexual you know
orientation but he was totally just
disconnected from his his identity was
homosexual but his behavior was
perfectly heterosexual he was happy with
his wife he had no issues he said that
everything was perfect he had children
but soon after about three years after
that he did come to me and says I think
I’m done with my married life do you
think I could get a male partner so
obviously people progress now I’m giving
with the story to tell you the journey
that I made over thirty five years in
the community and I have tried to
connect theory and practice and our
experiences on the street to come up
with certain ideas about where we are
heading you know as far as men in this
in this country are concerned if you
look around you’re you’re you must be
seeing and reading the papers and it’s
pretty bad the rapes formulated by our
downwards
a month ago we had two boys sodomized in
Hawaii they committed suicide so this
this sort of violence that the male is
indulging in I feel is a crisis in
patriarchy I’m not saying it’s happening
particularly in India it’s a crowded
country but it’s happening all over the
world if you go into the streets of
London you see the same type of sexual
violence if you see what’s happening in
Europe with or without them migrants
it’s happening there too so there is a
crisis in patriarchy throughout the
globe
all over the planet where man has
practically spread his wings and taken
up every ecological niche there is we
must understand look back a little bit
into evolution III want to run through
this very quickly because these notes
are very extensive anyway
I want to tell you that the whole
business of when you look at the Homo
Sapien as this incredible primate among
all the simians that you have around us
this primate is the only animal that has
sex in private if you look in the animal
kingdom you will not see this obsession
for privacy and private space and you
can see that obsession running it’s
happening in the Supreme Court right in
front of us today or the last ones eat
this obsession with privacy the very
fact that you have a smartphone your
privacy is gone but looking at the way
they are talking about biometrics and I
mean we had a huge fight in the
transgender community which was invited
to the u.s. consulate for a workshop and
most of the transgender refused to show
the ID because they have different ID in
the private lives on the street and they
have a different ID according to the
other car so one of the jobs of humsafar
trust is to get them other card in the
name of their transgendered identity
which means them if I’m Ashok on the
streets and Kalasha they want they want
to add her card in the name of Asha you
can see the sort of mess going on
between identities sexual orientations
and sexual desire I’m going to
concentrate on these four issues okay
let’s see I want to say that I have come
down from privacy and according to me
privacy required certain amount of
spaces that’s why today we are spread
all of the planet
due to all types of expansion wars
famines displacement man has spread all
over the planet and it’s not just for
space and for you know living that he’s
got there he’s got that because of
privacy needs privacy for himself for
his sexual practices and these sexual
practices are very interesting because
the more you look at sexual practices
right from Kinsey onwards to what we are
doing in in India you’ll be surprised at
the number of kings that human beings
have you know what is it due to frankly
looking at sexual desire by itself you
know very well that
something that this simian has your I
think the you homo sapien is the only
animal that breathes throughout the
earth there’s no such thing as a time
when there’s a breeding period or
anything like that we breed throughout
the earth we have out bread every other
species on this planet and this sexual
desire comes out in various ways now I
had to go back to a person called Michel
Foucault who is the father of the
history of sexuality
he was a French gay man who died of AIDS
much before ERT ever came in but if you
read his three books on the history of
human sexuality you get to know really
what is happening even today in India
you know he introduced something called
bio power and that’s interesting bio
power he defines as a power that is
within each human being that has you
know has a tendency to self discipline
the animal and understand its linkages
to the rest of society
now bio power according to me see
sexual desire has to play out in the in
society and from that to get sexual
behavior but sexual behavior called
according to Foucault has these two you
know arms and one is called sexual
orientation and that means who you’re
attracted to
it’s an outward centrifugal force and
then there is a sexual identity Who am I
it’s exactly not the story I told you
about this guy was counseling his
orientation was clearly homosexual but
his identity was heterosexual and if
they don’t match that’s where mental
science has come in and that’s the issue
that is happening today as far not just
with the homosexual community but I find
even among heterosexuals that there is
an issue in the sense after they
finished with certain practices I don’t
think my married life really exists in
India beyond a couple of years at least
most of my friends who were in class
with me are either divorced or separated
and whenever I ask them they say this
sparks gone out of their lives what does
that mean
there is no sex anymore so obviously the
sexual drive has ended up with sexual
behavior it’s played itself out or
orientation
is the direction in which you attracted
to another human being that may be as
powerful as possible but the identity is
an issue I didn’t know for example that
in India 8% of males are sexually
attracted to animals it’s constant
throughout the country that’s amazing
if we look at the homosexual orientation
for example the surveys that were done
in Chennai talked about six to seven
percent of the sexually active men who
permanent practicing homosexuals but if
you went across into say Rajasthan there
was another study done by dean dona and
ravi varma which put the number of men
having sex with other men at between 11
and 18 percent that’s a hell of a lot
where is this coming from when we try to
find out for example the questionnaires
that were there in public hospitals in
Bombay there was asking question like
are you a homosexual
have you had homosexual relations the
answer is no but if you divide it or
tried it them up into three separate
questions you know do you
there are many societies where men have
sex with other men do you know such men
answer was yes are there any such men
close to you yes has any such man made a
pass at you because of Indian men are
very nice you see in films you’ll see
only the women women not tempting them
otherwise they’re wonderful and pure so
the question has to be put the other way
he is a vestal virgin did anybody make a
pass at you answer was yes that answer
that question air came out with 22% in
sign hospital
22% of attendees in sexually transmitted
infections were having sex with other
men and not talking about it it’s a zone
of so much silence that one of the
chapters that I have written for a book
called Johanna which is the gay
anthology in India brought or Beth
Angwin it’s called the contract of
silence what I wanted to say was that
throughout you will see this type of
stuff going on in all around us nobody
wants to talk about sexual practices
that are very
are going on right under our noses are
criminalized marginalized kept out of
the realm of public discourse and are
not being looked into for the simple
reason a people will not talk about it
because they do not want to see it now
what I wanted to say was that this type
of rampant aggressive masculinity seems
to be to appropriate surpluses resources
corner them turf wars and this is what
is finally leading to my contention that
we gay men are actually subversives in
this system we are equal prisoners a lot
of women think that whenever in India
you talk of gender it’s always women and
children nobody talks of men also is a
gender males also a gender and males are
also prisoners of patriarchy do not
think that they are always the dominant
sex and deeming gee I mean when I say
gay men it includes a huge spectrum and
that’s why they are called a rainbow
spectrum there in the rainbow community
it means men having sex with men
bisexual men I’m going to take you to
that this was a diagram which I drew for
the Ministry of Health I had to show
that it is gay men within patriarchy who
are doing the transmissions the latest
now if you see what’s happening in the
Supreme Court and how we are taking the
Delhi High Court judgement forward we
are asking for certain laws to be framed
to protect even privacy for example
privacy of a woman if you read the Delhi
High Court judgement you’ll find that
privacy is defined in a completely new
way if a woman sits in a path all the
space around her is a private space so
there’s a new definitions of privacy
coming up now this is what the
homosexual community is fighting for
equality before the law the moment you
demand equality before the law a whole
lot of other laws goes out of the window
section 377 goes out of the window it
has created a second-class citizen by
the very nature of Who I am
so it definitely attacks constitutional
laws equality before the law doesn’t
stand because there is some the
Scheduled Tribes and cast act which was
actually removed in 1952 said if you
were born into a particular caste like
say the gypsies the word eras although
there are several criminal tribes and
castes who the british had termed as
criminal from the very day they were
born that had to be thrown out by
parliament in 1952 very closely attached
to that was sick section 377 we’ve had a
huge issues just the hump suffered trust
just to pay their employees has to have
a fight every day with banks so you can
imagine when this is what gay men are
fighting for equality before the law how
can you keep a hashida out of say a
hospital they are not allowed even into
hospital gates and they happen to be the
most visible sexual minority in this
country if you see what was happening
when the the transgender bill is about
to be passed this this month and it is
the most ridiculous bill there’s going
to be a screening committee where before
which you have to go and they’re going
to physically examine you and find out
whether you’re a hit or not or a
transgender which is insulting who the
hell is anybody in government or in a
court to try and certify whether I am
something or the other I am a citizen of
this country whether I pay income tax or
not I am a citizen of this country have
to be treated equal before the law
according to me only gay men will be
able to fight this out this is the last
frontier I don’t see other human rights
activists even interested even the
feminists I must tell you the failure
the Justice were my Committee which met
after the nearby our case we made a
deputation to Justice Verma that there
should be male I mean rape should be
gender-neutral and you’ll be surprised
the feminist groups attacked us and said
in a patriarchal society men can never
get raped now you and I know that it is
happening it’s happening in jails it’s
happening in the crowded places any homo
social place where more men are there
there is bullying of men there
sexual abuse of men that has not been
taken into consideration doesn’t require
a gay man to point this out that is
something that is so obvious though
again I wanted to say coming back to
this and this is the great MSM circle
that hamsa fortress has created for the
Ministry of Health and it will it was
basically done to see that it’s not a
monolith that it’s a very pluralistic
world and from this comes my little
motto that because it is such a
pluralistic and diverse world it’s a
very shadowy world how many of you know
that how many homosexuals there are in
this country according to me the
estimate is between 28 and 32 million
adults and that’s not a small number now
if if they are there they’re definitely
all within this circle you’ll observe
large parts of this yellow circle are
not populated because we don’t know what
types of men are there who have sex with
other men but we know some sort of
topography of this the ones on top are
all males whose gender is different from
in which they were born
these are male born sexual minorities
who feel they’re women or females all
the others at the bottom you’ll see
cotys panties gay identified these are
means who’s not whose identity is based
on behavior say someone like me I don’t
look like a woman I don’t behave like a
woman but I am attracted to other men
and I have sex with other men so these
are the ones below there are subdivision
there but don’t bother with it I’ll tell
you later on outside when I meet you on
this side are men whose vulnerability
comes because of their workplace into
end you know in the sense say cleaners
of lorries film extras so I exploit it
just like the women you know then there
are every big city in India has Monsieur
Zoot launches of a massage they also
have sex and boys in dancing bars do we
know that in the dance bars in bombay 20
percent of the girls actually
cross-dressing boys who dance very well
indeed as women so we on this side we’re
prison population bisexual who may be
behaviorally bisexual or they might be
identity as a bisexual and then right
down the center you have a bridge where
effeminate males in traditional Indian
society usually travelled towards Hydra
cultures in the Hydra cultures itself
these are all male born do not think
hydras 80% of hydras have got their male
organs are functional males who can have
sex with women but they cross dress and
do not gender identify as males that’s a
different cup of tea altogether now this
whole bridge is in the old days was used
by feminine men to travel into Hydra
cultures they were never kidnapped they
went there and I could tell you story
there’s no time so I would like to tell
you that these are the types of men who
are now fighting battles for the last
frontier what we have to achieve in the
Constitution thank you
Please follow and like us: