
[Music]
[Music] [Applause]
[Music]
[Music] [Applause]
hello Nashville I am here to talk to you
hello Nashville I am here to talk to you about why the backroom deal is dead in
about why the backroom deal is dead in
about why the backroom deal is dead in 2004 I was invited to speak at a major
2004 I was invited to speak at a major
2004 I was invited to speak at a major Music Conference I’d never been to a
Music Conference I’d never been to a
Music Conference I’d never been to a conference before I had no idea even
conference before I had no idea even
conference before I had no idea even what the purpose of a conference was and
what the purpose of a conference was and
what the purpose of a conference was and I had no idea why they had invited me I
I had no idea why they had invited me I
I had no idea why they had invited me I did happen to have a company that was
did happen to have a company that was
did happen to have a company that was doing quite well we were doing large
doing quite well we were doing large
doing quite well we were doing large music festivals and action sports events
music festivals and action sports events
music festivals and action sports events all around the world and we were booking
all around the world and we were booking
all around the world and we were booking about 3 to 500 acts a year but this was
about 3 to 500 acts a year but this was
about 3 to 500 acts a year but this was a conversation about the recorded music
a conversation about the recorded music
a conversation about the recorded music business
business
business this was not an area I was familiar with
this was not an area I was familiar with
this was not an area I was familiar with and I was going to be sharing the stage
and I was going to be sharing the stage
and I was going to be sharing the stage with some major music label executives
with some major music label executives
with some major music label executives totally out of my place but what the hey
totally out of my place but what the hey
totally out of my place but what the hey I thought I’d give it a try at least I
I thought I’d give it a try at least I
I thought I’d give it a try at least I would learn something new well within
would learn something new well within
would learn something new well within about five minutes of this conversation
about five minutes of this conversation
about five minutes of this conversation starting we devolved into an echo
starting we devolved into an echo
starting we devolved into an echo chamber talking about how creative
chamber talking about how creative
chamber talking about how creative artists and songwriters were going to
artists and songwriters were going to
artists and songwriters were going to lose their jobs and that the entire
lose their jobs and that the entire
lose their jobs and that the entire music industry was going to completely
music industry was going to completely
music industry was going to completely explode into a complete melting pot of
explode into a complete melting pot of
explode into a complete melting pot of illegal downloading but these guys had a
illegal downloading but these guys had a
illegal downloading but these guys had a very simplistic solution which
very simplistic solution which
very simplistic solution which essentially was to improve the moral
essentially was to improve the moral
essentially was to improve the moral character of young people by education
character of young people by education
character of young people by education or litigation I had a little bit of a
or litigation I had a little bit of a
or litigation I had a little bit of a problem with this I completely disagreed
problem with this I completely disagreed
problem with this I completely disagreed with the foundation of their position in
with the foundation of their position in
with the foundation of their position in my opinion we had a different situation
my opinion we had a different situation
my opinion we had a different situation we were dealing with a digital
we were dealing with a digital
we were dealing with a digital revolution and the horse had already run
revolution and the horse had already run
revolution and the horse had already run out of the barn and the barn was burning
out of the barn and the barn was burning
out of the barn and the barn was burning down to the ground and these guys are
down to the ground and these guys are
down to the ground and these guys are trying to put a lock on the door I could
trying to put a lock on the door I could
trying to put a lock on the door I could see where they were going but I think my
see where they were going but I think my
see where they were going but I think my problem with it was that they had just
problem with it was that they had just
problem with it was that they had just simply simplified things down a little
simply simplified things down a little
simply simplified things down a little bit too much so I wanted to talk about
bit too much so I wanted to talk about
bit too much so I wanted to talk about this idea that Tex
this idea that Tex
this idea that Tex logical disruption not even a word yet
logical disruption not even a word yet
logical disruption not even a word yet was about to manifest and that the
was about to manifest and that the
was about to manifest and that the traditional stakeholders of the music
traditional stakeholders of the music
traditional stakeholders of the music industry we’re about to lose their lunch
industry we’re about to lose their lunch
industry we’re about to lose their lunch high profitability was going to shift
high profitability was going to shift
high profitability was going to shift and there was going to be a whole new
and there was going to be a whole new
and there was going to be a whole new game in play
game in play
game in play the moderator came around to me at one
the moderator came around to me at one
the moderator came around to me at one point did I admit I was a little anxious
point did I admit I was a little anxious
point did I admit I was a little anxious I didn’t know what to say
I didn’t know what to say
I didn’t know what to say but you know what they’d invited me
but you know what they’d invited me
but you know what they’d invited me there they gave me an opinion I thought
there they gave me an opinion I thought
there they gave me an opinion I thought you know enrich the debate tell him the
you know enrich the debate tell him the
you know enrich the debate tell him the truth so I shared with them what I
truth so I shared with them what I
truth so I shared with them what I shared with you and I was booed off the
shared with you and I was booed off the
shared with you and I was booed off the stage gone shortly thereafter after I
stage gone shortly thereafter after I
stage gone shortly thereafter after I got over my humiliation a group of music
got over my humiliation a group of music
got over my humiliation a group of music publishers approached me to console me
publishers approached me to console me
publishers approached me to console me but more importantly they wanted to talk
but more importantly they wanted to talk
but more importantly they wanted to talk about the fact that they saw some deeper
about the fact that they saw some deeper
about the fact that they saw some deeper underlying issues and they felt that a
underlying issues and they felt that a
underlying issues and they felt that a couple of companies were managing the
couple of companies were managing the
couple of companies were managing the public agenda and blocking stuff I
public agenda and blocking stuff I
public agenda and blocking stuff I started to think about this the people
started to think about this the people
started to think about this the people weren’t the problem everybody in the
weren’t the problem everybody in the
weren’t the problem everybody in the room cared deeply around music the issue
room cared deeply around music the issue
room cared deeply around music the issue at hand here was that these guys had
at hand here was that these guys had
at hand here was that these guys had taken probably what was a very complex
taken probably what was a very complex
taken probably what was a very complex issue and they tried to simplify it down
issue and they tried to simplify it down
issue and they tried to simplify it down to something very simple I have no
to something very simple I have no
to something very simple I have no problem with simple things in fact I
problem with simple things in fact I
problem with simple things in fact I constantly look for elegant solutions in
constantly look for elegant solutions in
constantly look for elegant solutions in my work but there’s a big difference
my work but there’s a big difference
my work but there’s a big difference between simple and simplicity and in
between simple and simplicity and in
between simple and simplicity and in this case these guys had simplified the
this case these guys had simplified the
this case these guys had simplified the idea down that a bunch of pirates were
idea down that a bunch of pirates were
idea down that a bunch of pirates were stealing their music when in fact a
stealing their music when in fact a
stealing their music when in fact a whole new tech-savvy generation was
whole new tech-savvy generation was
whole new tech-savvy generation was coming along and these people were more
coming along and these people were more
coming along and these people were more interested in accessing music instead of
interested in accessing music instead of
interested in accessing music instead of owning it and they had voted with their
owning it and they had voted with their
owning it and they had voted with their keyboards another insight that I had was
keyboards another insight that I had was
keyboards another insight that I had was that most people in the music business
that most people in the music business
that most people in the music business odd is a ninety billion dollar industry
odd is a ninety billion dollar industry
odd is a ninety billion dollar industry primarily creating primarily about
primarily creating primarily about
primarily creating primarily about creators rights holders distributors and
creators rights holders distributors and
creators rights holders distributors and retailers I wanted to imagine a trillion
retailers I wanted to imagine a trillion
retailers I wanted to imagine a trillion dollar industry internet service
dollar industry internet service
dollar industry internet service providers telcos carriers device
providers telcos carriers device
providers telcos carriers device manufacturers we hadn’t even had
manufacturers we hadn’t even had
manufacturers we hadn’t even had smartphones yet and in particular
smartphones yet and in particular
smartphones yet and in particular there’s a whole new wave of companies
there’s a whole new wave of companies
there’s a whole new wave of companies that no one had even heard about that
that no one had even heard about that
that no one had even heard about that was going to change the experience
was going to change the experience
was going to change the experience around music the big issue I felt was
around music the big issue I felt was
around music the big issue I felt was about context these guys simply couldn’t
about context these guys simply couldn’t
about context these guys simply couldn’t see the forest from the trees and so I
see the forest from the trees and so I
see the forest from the trees and so I went on a journey to find out why we
went on a journey to find out why we
went on a journey to find out why we were having and suffering from issues of
were having and suffering from issues of
were having and suffering from issues of cognitive dissonance like this I started
cognitive dissonance like this I started
cognitive dissonance like this I started to study systems thinking cybernetics
to study systems thinking cybernetics
to study systems thinking cybernetics cognitive neuroscience
cognitive neuroscience
cognitive neuroscience I started looking in the complex
I started looking in the complex
I started looking in the complex adaptive systems I was particularly
adaptive systems I was particularly
adaptive systems I was particularly taken with process design but at the
taken with process design but at the
taken with process design but at the same time I felt I needed to look at
same time I felt I needed to look at
same time I felt I needed to look at other types of convenings where people
other types of convenings where people
other types of convenings where people were dealing with very complex matters
were dealing with very complex matters
were dealing with very complex matters leaders who are having to make hard
leaders who are having to make hard
leaders who are having to make hard decisions and I found myself studying
decisions and I found myself studying
decisions and I found myself studying the conference in Paris of 1919 let’s
the conference in Paris of 1919 let’s
the conference in Paris of 1919 let’s take ourselves back to 1919 in Paris the
take ourselves back to 1919 in Paris the
take ourselves back to 1919 in Paris the World War one had just wrapped up and
World War one had just wrapped up and
World War one had just wrapped up and millions of people were dealing with
millions of people were dealing with
millions of people were dealing with recovering from it 100 years ago almost
recovering from it 100 years ago almost
recovering from it 100 years ago almost to the day for leaders representing the
to the day for leaders representing the
to the day for leaders representing the United States United Kingdom Italy and
United States United Kingdom Italy and
United States United Kingdom Italy and France came together to talk about one
France came together to talk about one
France came together to talk about one thing and one thing only how to make
thing and one thing only how to make
thing and one thing only how to make sure that there would never be a war
sure that there would never be a war
sure that there would never be a war like this again it was a very unincluded
like this again it was a very unincluded
like this again it was a very unincluded affair a small group of guys going into
affair a small group of guys going into
affair a small group of guys going into a back room cutting up the entire world
a back room cutting up the entire world
a back room cutting up the entire world and resetting borders deciding what life
and resetting borders deciding what life
and resetting borders deciding what life would be like for people they had never
would be like for people they had never
would be like for people they had never met before and they never understood you
met before and they never understood you
met before and they never understood you see there had been no precedent for this
see there had been no precedent for this
see there had been no precedent for this no one knew how to deal with it and in
no one knew how to deal with it and in
no one knew how to deal with it and in particular the biggest issue was that
particular the biggest issue was that
particular the biggest issue was that they had introduced the same thinking
they had introduced the same thinking
they had introduced the same thinking that had got them into the problem in
that had got them into the problem in
that had got them into the problem in the first place but a deal got signed
the first place but a deal got signed
the first place but a deal got signed and as a result there was peace in one
and as a result there was peace in one
and as a result there was peace in one area but meanwhile millions of people
area but meanwhile millions of people
area but meanwhile millions of people suffered from 100 years of conflict with
suffered from 100 years of conflict with
suffered from 100 years of conflict with the greatest strategies taking place in
the greatest strategies taking place in
the greatest strategies taking place in communities that had never made a
communities that had never made a
communities that had never made a decision in terms of what their
decision in terms of what their
decision in terms of what their political or social orientation would be
political or social orientation would be
political or social orientation would be what went wrong well a lasting peace
what went wrong well a lasting peace
what went wrong well a lasting peace wasn’t going to be able to be designed
wasn’t going to be able to be designed
wasn’t going to be able to be designed by a few guys who won the war to tell
by a few guys who won the war to tell
by a few guys who won the war to tell everybody else what it was going to be
everybody else what it was going to be
everybody else what it was going to be like this was a fundamental issue and
like this was a fundamental issue and
like this was a fundamental issue and while things have changed some things
while things have changed some things
while things have changed some things stay the same people always will reject
stay the same people always will reject
stay the same people always will reject decisions made for them why are we still
decisions made for them why are we still
decisions made for them why are we still stuck here 100 years later I think that
stuck here 100 years later I think that
stuck here 100 years later I think that that’s my biggest issue right now I
that’s my biggest issue right now I
that’s my biggest issue right now I think about it constantly we are still
think about it constantly we are still
think about it constantly we are still dealing with a whole number of issues
dealing with a whole number of issues
dealing with a whole number of issues and in particular I can think of three
and in particular I can think of three
and in particular I can think of three highly dysfunctional non resilient
highly dysfunctional non resilient
highly dysfunctional non resilient behaviors that we see all of our
behaviors that we see all of our
behaviors that we see all of our institutions suffer from
institutions suffer from
institutions suffer from first we are addicted to reducing
first we are addicted to reducing
first we are addicted to reducing complex matters down to single issue
complex matters down to single issue
complex matters down to single issue problems secondly to few stakeholders
problems secondly to few stakeholders
problems secondly to few stakeholders are involved in making complex decisions
are involved in making complex decisions
are involved in making complex decisions on behalf of other people and three
on behalf of other people and three
on behalf of other people and three existing rules practices and processes
existing rules practices and processes
existing rules practices and processes are suffocating our capacity to take
are suffocating our capacity to take
are suffocating our capacity to take risks on new innovations and emerging we
risks on new innovations and emerging we
risks on new innovations and emerging we are essentially blocking or a capacity
are essentially blocking or a capacity
are essentially blocking or a capacity to step forward I know it’s been busy
to step forward I know it’s been busy
to step forward I know it’s been busy here in the u.s. kind of hard to see
here in the u.s. kind of hard to see
here in the u.s. kind of hard to see past what’s going on but up north
past what’s going on but up north
past what’s going on but up north there’s a major transformation taking
there’s a major transformation taking
there’s a major transformation taking place across society first of all entire
place across society first of all entire
place across society first of all entire communities are bounding together to
communities are bounding together to
communities are bounding together to talk about how to migrate away from
talk about how to migrate away from
talk about how to migrate away from non-renewable resources more importantly
non-renewable resources more importantly
non-renewable resources more importantly society as a whole has undertaken a
society as a whole has undertaken a
society as a whole has undertaken a process of reconciliation with 600
process of reconciliation with 600
process of reconciliation with 600 indigenous intimate and maytee
indigenous intimate and maytee
indigenous intimate and maytee communities across the land base we also
communities across the land base we also
communities across the land base we also have a new prime minister that’s what my
have a new prime minister that’s what my
have a new prime minister that’s what my wife says this guy and his team are
wife says this guy and his team are
wife says this guy and his team are making some incredible commitments to
making some incredible commitments to
making some incredible commitments to society right now and unless we get
society right now and unless we get
society right now and unless we get behind these things we’re gonna have a
behind these things we’re gonna have a
behind these things we’re gonna have a hard time moving forward expectations
hard time moving forward expectations
hard time moving forward expectations are very high for us now to solve some
are very high for us now to solve some
are very high for us now to solve some of these issues primarily issues around
of these issues primarily issues around
of these issues primarily issues around giving people the ability to make their
giving people the ability to make their
giving people the ability to make their own decisions but the stakes are high
own decisions but the stakes are high
own decisions but the stakes are high and if we don’t get this right we could
and if we don’t get this right we could
and if we don’t get this right we could suffer a lot so there’s a lot of talk
suffer a lot so there’s a lot of talk
suffer a lot so there’s a lot of talk about where this goes I want to take you
about where this goes I want to take you
about where this goes I want to take you to November of 2014 10 years after my
to November of 2014 10 years after my
to November of 2014 10 years after my epic conference experienced things have
epic conference experienced things have
epic conference experienced things have changed for me I now had the honor of
changed for me I now had the honor of
changed for me I now had the honor of leading a large global collaborative
leading a large global collaborative
leading a large global collaborative design practice focused on strategic
design practice focused on strategic
design practice focused on strategic advisory for both public sector and
advisory for both public sector and
advisory for both public sector and private sector focusing on
private sector focusing on
private sector focusing on organizational change in transformation
organizational change in transformation
organizational change in transformation a government official approached me with
a government official approached me with
a government official approached me with a very serious problem and this was not
a very serious problem and this was not
a very serious problem and this was not something that I was totally familiar
something that I was totally familiar
something that I was totally familiar with they were focused on building an
with they were focused on building an
with they were focused on building an integrated decision-making process
integrated decision-making process
integrated decision-making process across the land base focusing on natural
across the land base focusing on natural
across the land base focusing on natural resources incredibly complex and yet I
resources incredibly complex and yet I
resources incredibly complex and yet I knew that this would affect many
knew that this would affect many
knew that this would affect many Canadians in particular land based
Canadians in particular land based
Canadians in particular land based decision-making has negatively impacted
decision-making has negatively impacted
decision-making has negatively impacted indigenous community communities across
indigenous community communities across
indigenous community communities across our country for hundreds of years so we
our country for hundreds of years so we
our country for hundreds of years so we decided to look into this I want to
decided to look into this I want to
decided to look into this I want to share though a couple of statistics so
share though a couple of statistics so
share though a couple of statistics so we’re basically clear on the context a
we’re basically clear on the context a
we’re basically clear on the context a little bit because you might not be
little bit because you might not be
little bit because you might not be aware of this right now
aware of this right now
aware of this right now indigenous graduation rates are sitting
indigenous graduation rates are sitting
indigenous graduation rates are sitting at 36% as compared to 72% which is the
at 36% as compared to 72% which is the
at 36% as compared to 72% which is the Canadian average at the same time four
Canadian average at the same time four
Canadian average at the same time four percent of the population is indigenous
percent of the population is indigenous
percent of the population is indigenous 25 percent of the indigenous population
25 percent of the indigenous population
25 percent of the indigenous population is in the inmate is our inmates in jail
similar things
similar things at the same time young indigenous
at the same time young indigenous
at the same time young indigenous children die at four times more often
children die at four times more often
children die at four times more often from unintentional
community member in Canada and well the
community member in Canada and well the biggest issues that we face right now is
biggest issues that we face right now is
biggest issues that we face right now is that the fact that this population since
that the fact that this population since
that the fact that this population since 2006 has grown by 43 percent four
2006 has grown by 43 percent four
2006 has grown by 43 percent four hundred times faster than any other
hundred times faster than any other
hundred times faster than any other community so we acknowledge that
community so we acknowledge that
community so we acknowledge that something has to change so as a result
something has to change so as a result
something has to change so as a result of this request we decide to do some
of this request we decide to do some
of this request we decide to do some investigations we wanted to see what
investigations we wanted to see what
investigations we wanted to see what negotiating processes looked like at
negotiating processes looked like at
negotiating processes looked like at this point so we investigated we were
this point so we investigated we were
this point so we investigated we were alarmed by the details and the
alarmed by the details and the
alarmed by the details and the statistics in one region alone over 700
statistics in one region alone over 700
statistics in one region alone over 700 ago she ations were taking place on the
ago she ations were taking place on the
ago she ations were taking place on the land base involving 200 indigenous
land base involving 200 indigenous
land base involving 200 indigenous groups with the calculations that we
groups with the calculations that we
groups with the calculations that we made it would take 400 years to deal
made it would take 400 years to deal
made it would take 400 years to deal with this backlog with the current
with this backlog with the current
with this backlog with the current processes that we’re using something
processes that we’re using something
processes that we’re using something needed to fundamentally change so we
needed to fundamentally change so we
needed to fundamentally change so we decided to look at this problem a little
decided to look at this problem a little
decided to look at this problem a little bit more closely before I take this
bit more closely before I take this
bit more closely before I take this further though I think I want to share a
further though I think I want to share a
further though I think I want to share a couple points around collaborative
couple points around collaborative
couple points around collaborative design collaborative design in my
design collaborative design in my
design collaborative design in my opinion enables a whole different level
opinion enables a whole different level
opinion enables a whole different level of inclusive resilient decision-making
of inclusive resilient decision-making
of inclusive resilient decision-making this is a thing that has been around for
this is a thing that has been around for
this is a thing that has been around for 30 years but hasn’t quite touched but
30 years but hasn’t quite touched but
30 years but hasn’t quite touched but everybody has been talking about it and
everybody has been talking about it and
everybody has been talking about it and it’s time to move it forward
it’s time to move it forward
it’s time to move it forward collaborative design or sometimes as we
collaborative design or sometimes as we
collaborative design or sometimes as we call it Co design is about a whole
call it Co design is about a whole
call it Co design is about a whole different process of negotiation in one
different process of negotiation in one
different process of negotiation in one hand it changes the way traditional
hand it changes the way traditional
hand it changes the way traditional negotiations work where you have rappers
negotiations work where you have rappers
negotiations work where you have rappers natives speaking on behalf of
natives speaking on behalf of
natives speaking on behalf of participants primarily favoring
participants primarily favoring
participants primarily favoring bilateral single-issue negotiation
bilateral single-issue negotiation
bilateral single-issue negotiation instead collaborative design creates an
instead collaborative design creates an
instead collaborative design creates an opportunity for highly participatory
opportunity for highly participatory
opportunity for highly participatory multilateral alignment focusing on a
multilateral alignment focusing on a
multilateral alignment focusing on a greater diversity of perspectives while
greater diversity of perspectives while
greater diversity of perspectives while unpacking and exploring key ideas
unpacking and exploring key ideas
unpacking and exploring key ideas possibilities and future States in a
possibilities and future States in a
possibilities and future States in a much shorter period of time and at the
much shorter period of time and at the
much shorter period of time and at the same time collaborative design as a
same time collaborative design as a
same time collaborative design as a process does something very interesting
process does something very interesting
process does something very interesting you’re able to design processes without
you’re able to design processes without
you’re able to design processes without precedent and without use cases so think
precedent and without use cases so think
precedent and without use cases so think about it collaborative design is a
about it collaborative design is a
about it collaborative design is a design process that allows groups to
design process that allows groups to
design process that allows groups to design their own process well I can tell
design their own process well I can tell
design their own process well I can tell you government was rather uncomfortable
you government was rather uncomfortable
you government was rather uncomfortable with this idea it’s not something
with this idea it’s not something
with this idea it’s not something they’re familiar with nonetheless we
they’re familiar with nonetheless we
they’re familiar with nonetheless we felt that we should proceed with this so
felt that we should proceed with this so
felt that we should proceed with this so we undertook a process of beginning to
we undertook a process of beginning to
we undertook a process of beginning to integrate collaborative design process
integrate collaborative design process
integrate collaborative design process throughout a number of pilots that we
throughout a number of pilots that we
throughout a number of pilots that we were going to engage with between
were going to engage with between
were going to engage with between government and indigenous people across
government and indigenous people across
government and indigenous people across the country this led us into our first
the country this led us into our first
the country this led us into our first major design event in 2015 in July we
major design event in 2015 in July we
major design event in 2015 in July we sat down for our first time with an
sat down for our first time with an
sat down for our first time with an indigenous set of elders and government
indigenous set of elders and government
indigenous set of elders and government representatives one government
representatives one government
representatives one government representative who knew us well put our
representative who knew us well put our
representative who knew us well put our design process forward as 21st century
design process forward as 21st century
design process forward as 21st century bleeding-edge social technology never
bleeding-edge social technology never
bleeding-edge social technology never been done before
been done before
been done before we were a little uncomfortable with this
we were a little uncomfortable with this
we were a little uncomfortable with this moniker on the one hand yes we were
moniker on the one hand yes we were
moniker on the one hand yes we were future focused but a huge part of our
future focused but a huge part of our
future focused but a huge part of our work had been scanning ten-thousand
work had been scanning ten-thousand
work had been scanning ten-thousand years across the past across
years across the past across
years across the past across civilizations to better understand some
civilizations to better understand some
civilizations to better understand some of the things that we had potentially
of the things that we had potentially
of the things that we had potentially unlearned it was time for me to describe
unlearned it was time for me to describe
unlearned it was time for me to describe this approach to the elders I walked
this approach to the elders I walked
this approach to the elders I walked them through something quite different I
them through something quite different I
them through something quite different I talked about the fact that this would be
talked about the fact that this would be
talked about the fact that this would be more than just negotiators that we would
more than just negotiators that we would
more than just negotiators that we would have political leaders policymakers
have political leaders policymakers
have political leaders policymakers managers elders youth even conservation
managers elders youth even conservation
managers elders youth even conservation officers in the room and the opportunity
officers in the room and the opportunity
officers in the room and the opportunity would to be under one roof is to share
would to be under one roof is to share
would to be under one roof is to share stories no matter how painful to share
stories no matter how painful to share
stories no matter how painful to share our missteps no matter how embarrassing
our missteps no matter how embarrassing
our missteps no matter how embarrassing and to talk about this stuff with a
and to talk about this stuff with a
and to talk about this stuff with a little bit of humor she took a moment
little bit of humor she took a moment
little bit of humor she took a moment after I finished and
after I finished and
after I finished and quietly observed that this wasn’t a new
quietly observed that this wasn’t a new
quietly observed that this wasn’t a new way of working this in fact was a very
way of working this in fact was a very
way of working this in fact was a very old way of working there predated most
old way of working there predated most
old way of working there predated most Western political and legal practices
Western political and legal practices
Western political and legal practices this was something that could
this was something that could
this was something that could potentially bring communities together
potentially bring communities together
potentially bring communities together she saw the circular organic nature of
she saw the circular organic nature of
she saw the circular organic nature of our conversations as being something
our conversations as being something
our conversations as being something special something that could align as
special something that could align as
special something that could align as something that could create the most
something that could create the most
something that could create the most important foundation to the ongoing
important foundation to the ongoing
important foundation to the ongoing shared decision-making across the land
shared decision-making across the land
shared decision-making across the land base this idea of trust at the same time
base this idea of trust at the same time
base this idea of trust at the same time we were focused on some other projects a
we were focused on some other projects a
we were focused on some other projects a year later we were doing a multi-day
year later we were doing a multi-day
year later we were doing a multi-day collaborative design event between
collaborative design event between
collaborative design event between another indigenous group in government
another indigenous group in government
another indigenous group in government this brought to me a really important
this brought to me a really important
this brought to me a really important insight you see at the time indigenous
insight you see at the time indigenous
insight you see at the time indigenous people very justifiably can accuse more
people very justifiably can accuse more
people very justifiably can accuse more recent settlers of constantly painting
recent settlers of constantly painting
recent settlers of constantly painting them with the same brush and yet there
them with the same brush and yet there
them with the same brush and yet there are 600 different indigenous First
are 600 different indigenous First
are 600 different indigenous First Nations with over 60 languages spoken in
Nations with over 60 languages spoken in
Nations with over 60 languages spoken in Canada alone well I found interesting
Canada alone well I found interesting
Canada alone well I found interesting when I zero down to it is I started to
when I zero down to it is I started to
when I zero down to it is I started to recognize that there was another issue
recognize that there was another issue
recognize that there was another issue at hand here they were – making
at hand here they were – making
at hand here they were – making generalizations they saw government as
generalizations they saw government as
generalizations they saw government as one big machine conspiring against them
one big machine conspiring against them
one big machine conspiring against them but in a small group gathering an elder
but in a small group gathering an elder
but in a small group gathering an elder speaking to a group of officials these
speaking to a group of officials these
speaking to a group of officials these officials spent time explaining the
officials spent time explaining the
officials spent time explaining the arduous nature of their work the
arduous nature of their work the
arduous nature of their work the difficulty it was in making decisions
difficulty it was in making decisions
difficulty it was in making decisions and how rarely they even got to talk to
and how rarely they even got to talk to
and how rarely they even got to talk to each other and I remember the elder
each other and I remember the elder
each other and I remember the elder chuckling and turning to one of the
chuckling and turning to one of the
chuckling and turning to one of the leaders saying wow so much friction your
leaders saying wow so much friction your
leaders saying wow so much friction your job really sucks what they didn’t
job really sucks what they didn’t
job really sucks what they didn’t realize is that being a public servant
realize is that being a public servant
realize is that being a public servant working on these issues brings no glory
working on these issues brings no glory
working on these issues brings no glory brings no money and no celebrity status
brings no money and no celebrity status
brings no money and no celebrity status people don’t take jobs like this because
people don’t take jobs like this because
people don’t take jobs like this because they’re going to get to a place in a
they’re going to get to a place in a
they’re going to get to a place in a promotional level they do this because
promotional level they do this because
promotional level they do this because they genuinely care about this work they
they genuinely care about this work they
they genuinely care about this work they want this to happen they do take care of
want this to happen they do take care of
want this to happen they do take care of people in the third instance I want to
people in the third instance I want to
people in the third instance I want to share one story with you a chief that I
share one story with you a chief that I
share one story with you a chief that I met several months later after that last
met several months later after that last
met several months later after that last experience observed to me
experience observed to me
experience observed to me that he had observed his father
that he had observed his father
that he had observed his father negotiating on behalf of their community
negotiating on behalf of their community
negotiating on behalf of their community lands and write titles that they thought
lands and write titles that they thought
lands and write titles that they thought were going to wrap up in three years 25
were going to wrap up in three years 25
were going to wrap up in three years 25 years later this chief was still working
years later this chief was still working
years later this chief was still working on the same negotiation and it pained
on the same negotiation and it pained
on the same negotiation and it pained him greatly to think that his daughters
him greatly to think that his daughters
him greatly to think that his daughters and his sons might be here 25 years from
and his sons might be here 25 years from
and his sons might be here 25 years from now trying to work on the same
now trying to work on the same
now trying to work on the same negotiation as a father as a son as a
negotiation as a father as a son as a
negotiation as a father as a son as a husband and as a citizen I was deeply
husband and as a citizen I was deeply
husband and as a citizen I was deeply affected by these stories when I was
affected by these stories when I was
affected by these stories when I was asked to speak here I was very excited
asked to speak here I was very excited
asked to speak here I was very excited to share my passion about collaborative
to share my passion about collaborative
to share my passion about collaborative design I believe that this is a new way
design I believe that this is a new way
design I believe that this is a new way forward there is a future in this I
forward there is a future in this I
forward there is a future in this I believe that collaborative design will
believe that collaborative design will
believe that collaborative design will lead to collaborative decision-making
lead to collaborative decision-making
lead to collaborative decision-making and this is fundamentally important I
and this is fundamentally important I
and this is fundamentally important I was enabled by people in my own
was enabled by people in my own
was enabled by people in my own community to step up because I thought
community to step up because I thought
community to step up because I thought that I would be too scared to actually
that I would be too scared to actually
that I would be too scared to actually come here why because I feel like I’m
come here why because I feel like I’m
come here why because I feel like I’m trespassing into a place where many
trespassing into a place where many
trespassing into a place where many amazing people have dedicated their
amazing people have dedicated their
amazing people have dedicated their entire lives of solving these problems
entire lives of solving these problems
entire lives of solving these problems but at the same time we need to
but at the same time we need to
but at the same time we need to introduce new ideas we need to express
introduce new ideas we need to express
introduce new ideas we need to express our thoughts and define our failures and
our thoughts and define our failures and
our thoughts and define our failures and share them amongst each other over
share them amongst each other over
share them amongst each other over thousands of people I have worked with
thousands of people I have worked with
thousands of people I have worked with with dozens of organizations in the
with dozens of organizations in the
with dozens of organizations in the public and private sector I have learned
public and private sector I have learned
public and private sector I have learned one thing and one thing alone people
one thing and one thing alone people
one thing and one thing alone people love to solve problems people genuinely
love to solve problems people genuinely
love to solve problems people genuinely want to do the right thing and we are
want to do the right thing and we are
want to do the right thing and we are social by nature collaboration comes
social by nature collaboration comes
social by nature collaboration comes naturally to us there are eight billion
naturally to us there are eight billion
naturally to us there are eight billion people on the planet right now that’s
people on the planet right now that’s
people on the planet right now that’s okay by me if we all work together with
okay by me if we all work together with
okay by me if we all work together with an open mind and a line we can solve a
an open mind and a line we can solve a
an open mind and a line we can solve a lot of problems but we’re going to need
lot of problems but we’re going to need
lot of problems but we’re going to need eight billion people at the table to do
eight billion people at the table to do
eight billion people at the table to do it a lot of people where I come from
it a lot of people where I come from
it a lot of people where I come from would laugh at that idea but what’s the
would laugh at that idea but what’s the
would laugh at that idea but what’s the alternative for these white guys in a
alternative for these white guys in a
alternative for these white guys in a back room I want to thank you I was
back room I want to thank you I was
back room I want to thank you I was honored to speak in front of you today
honored to speak in front of you today
honored to speak in front of you today thank you for being patient with me
thank you for being patient with me
thank you for being patient with me you
[Music] [Applause]
[Music]
[Music] [Applause]
hello Nashville I am here to talk to you
hello Nashville I am here to talk to you about why the backroom deal is dead in
about why the backroom deal is dead in
about why the backroom deal is dead in 2004 I was invited to speak at a major
2004 I was invited to speak at a major
2004 I was invited to speak at a major Music Conference I’d never been to a
Music Conference I’d never been to a
Music Conference I’d never been to a conference before I had no idea even
conference before I had no idea even
conference before I had no idea even what the purpose of a conference was and
what the purpose of a conference was and
what the purpose of a conference was and I had no idea why they had invited me I
I had no idea why they had invited me I
I had no idea why they had invited me I did happen to have a company that was
did happen to have a company that was
did happen to have a company that was doing quite well we were doing large
doing quite well we were doing large
doing quite well we were doing large music festivals and action sports events
music festivals and action sports events
music festivals and action sports events all around the world and we were booking
all around the world and we were booking
all around the world and we were booking about 3 to 500 acts a year but this was
about 3 to 500 acts a year but this was
about 3 to 500 acts a year but this was a conversation about the recorded music
a conversation about the recorded music
a conversation about the recorded music business
business
business this was not an area I was familiar with
this was not an area I was familiar with
this was not an area I was familiar with and I was going to be sharing the stage
and I was going to be sharing the stage
and I was going to be sharing the stage with some major music label executives
with some major music label executives
with some major music label executives totally out of my place but what the hey
totally out of my place but what the hey
totally out of my place but what the hey I thought I’d give it a try at least I
I thought I’d give it a try at least I
I thought I’d give it a try at least I would learn something new well within
would learn something new well within
would learn something new well within about five minutes of this conversation
about five minutes of this conversation
about five minutes of this conversation starting we devolved into an echo
starting we devolved into an echo
starting we devolved into an echo chamber talking about how creative
chamber talking about how creative
chamber talking about how creative artists and songwriters were going to
artists and songwriters were going to
artists and songwriters were going to lose their jobs and that the entire
lose their jobs and that the entire
lose their jobs and that the entire music industry was going to completely
music industry was going to completely
music industry was going to completely explode into a complete melting pot of
explode into a complete melting pot of
explode into a complete melting pot of illegal downloading but these guys had a
illegal downloading but these guys had a
illegal downloading but these guys had a very simplistic solution which
very simplistic solution which
very simplistic solution which essentially was to improve the moral
essentially was to improve the moral
essentially was to improve the moral character of young people by education
character of young people by education
character of young people by education or litigation I had a little bit of a
or litigation I had a little bit of a
or litigation I had a little bit of a problem with this I completely disagreed
problem with this I completely disagreed
problem with this I completely disagreed with the foundation of their position in
with the foundation of their position in
with the foundation of their position in my opinion we had a different situation
my opinion we had a different situation
my opinion we had a different situation we were dealing with a digital
we were dealing with a digital
we were dealing with a digital revolution and the horse had already run
revolution and the horse had already run
revolution and the horse had already run out of the barn and the barn was burning
out of the barn and the barn was burning
out of the barn and the barn was burning down to the ground and these guys are
down to the ground and these guys are
down to the ground and these guys are trying to put a lock on the door I could
trying to put a lock on the door I could
trying to put a lock on the door I could see where they were going but I think my
see where they were going but I think my
see where they were going but I think my problem with it was that they had just
problem with it was that they had just
problem with it was that they had just simply simplified things down a little
simply simplified things down a little
simply simplified things down a little bit too much so I wanted to talk about
bit too much so I wanted to talk about
bit too much so I wanted to talk about this idea that Tex
this idea that Tex
this idea that Tex logical disruption not even a word yet
logical disruption not even a word yet
logical disruption not even a word yet was about to manifest and that the
was about to manifest and that the
was about to manifest and that the traditional stakeholders of the music
traditional stakeholders of the music
traditional stakeholders of the music industry we’re about to lose their lunch
industry we’re about to lose their lunch
industry we’re about to lose their lunch high profitability was going to shift
high profitability was going to shift
high profitability was going to shift and there was going to be a whole new
and there was going to be a whole new
and there was going to be a whole new game in play
game in play
game in play the moderator came around to me at one
the moderator came around to me at one
the moderator came around to me at one point did I admit I was a little anxious
point did I admit I was a little anxious
point did I admit I was a little anxious I didn’t know what to say
I didn’t know what to say
I didn’t know what to say but you know what they’d invited me
but you know what they’d invited me
but you know what they’d invited me there they gave me an opinion I thought
there they gave me an opinion I thought
there they gave me an opinion I thought you know enrich the debate tell him the
you know enrich the debate tell him the
you know enrich the debate tell him the truth so I shared with them what I
truth so I shared with them what I
truth so I shared with them what I shared with you and I was booed off the
shared with you and I was booed off the
shared with you and I was booed off the stage gone shortly thereafter after I
stage gone shortly thereafter after I
stage gone shortly thereafter after I got over my humiliation a group of music
got over my humiliation a group of music
got over my humiliation a group of music publishers approached me to console me
publishers approached me to console me
publishers approached me to console me but more importantly they wanted to talk
but more importantly they wanted to talk
but more importantly they wanted to talk about the fact that they saw some deeper
about the fact that they saw some deeper
about the fact that they saw some deeper underlying issues and they felt that a
underlying issues and they felt that a
underlying issues and they felt that a couple of companies were managing the
couple of companies were managing the
couple of companies were managing the public agenda and blocking stuff I
public agenda and blocking stuff I
public agenda and blocking stuff I started to think about this the people
started to think about this the people
started to think about this the people weren’t the problem everybody in the
weren’t the problem everybody in the
weren’t the problem everybody in the room cared deeply around music the issue
room cared deeply around music the issue
room cared deeply around music the issue at hand here was that these guys had
at hand here was that these guys had
at hand here was that these guys had taken probably what was a very complex
taken probably what was a very complex
taken probably what was a very complex issue and they tried to simplify it down
issue and they tried to simplify it down
issue and they tried to simplify it down to something very simple I have no
to something very simple I have no
to something very simple I have no problem with simple things in fact I
problem with simple things in fact I
problem with simple things in fact I constantly look for elegant solutions in
constantly look for elegant solutions in
constantly look for elegant solutions in my work but there’s a big difference
my work but there’s a big difference
my work but there’s a big difference between simple and simplicity and in
between simple and simplicity and in
between simple and simplicity and in this case these guys had simplified the
this case these guys had simplified the
this case these guys had simplified the idea down that a bunch of pirates were
idea down that a bunch of pirates were
idea down that a bunch of pirates were stealing their music when in fact a
stealing their music when in fact a
stealing their music when in fact a whole new tech-savvy generation was
whole new tech-savvy generation was
whole new tech-savvy generation was coming along and these people were more
coming along and these people were more
coming along and these people were more interested in accessing music instead of
interested in accessing music instead of
interested in accessing music instead of owning it and they had voted with their
owning it and they had voted with their
owning it and they had voted with their keyboards another insight that I had was
keyboards another insight that I had was
keyboards another insight that I had was that most people in the music business
that most people in the music business
that most people in the music business odd is a ninety billion dollar industry
odd is a ninety billion dollar industry
odd is a ninety billion dollar industry primarily creating primarily about
primarily creating primarily about
primarily creating primarily about creators rights holders distributors and
creators rights holders distributors and
creators rights holders distributors and retailers I wanted to imagine a trillion
retailers I wanted to imagine a trillion
retailers I wanted to imagine a trillion dollar industry internet service
dollar industry internet service
dollar industry internet service providers telcos carriers device
providers telcos carriers device
providers telcos carriers device manufacturers we hadn’t even had
manufacturers we hadn’t even had
manufacturers we hadn’t even had smartphones yet and in particular
smartphones yet and in particular
smartphones yet and in particular there’s a whole new wave of companies
there’s a whole new wave of companies
there’s a whole new wave of companies that no one had even heard about that
that no one had even heard about that
that no one had even heard about that was going to change the experience
was going to change the experience
was going to change the experience around music the big issue I felt was
around music the big issue I felt was
around music the big issue I felt was about context these guys simply couldn’t
about context these guys simply couldn’t
about context these guys simply couldn’t see the forest from the trees and so I
see the forest from the trees and so I
see the forest from the trees and so I went on a journey to find out why we
went on a journey to find out why we
went on a journey to find out why we were having and suffering from issues of
were having and suffering from issues of
were having and suffering from issues of cognitive dissonance like this I started
cognitive dissonance like this I started
cognitive dissonance like this I started to study systems thinking cybernetics
to study systems thinking cybernetics
to study systems thinking cybernetics cognitive neuroscience
cognitive neuroscience
cognitive neuroscience I started looking in the complex
I started looking in the complex
I started looking in the complex adaptive systems I was particularly
adaptive systems I was particularly
adaptive systems I was particularly taken with process design but at the
taken with process design but at the
taken with process design but at the same time I felt I needed to look at
same time I felt I needed to look at
same time I felt I needed to look at other types of convenings where people
other types of convenings where people
other types of convenings where people were dealing with very complex matters
were dealing with very complex matters
were dealing with very complex matters leaders who are having to make hard
leaders who are having to make hard
leaders who are having to make hard decisions and I found myself studying
decisions and I found myself studying
decisions and I found myself studying the conference in Paris of 1919 let’s
the conference in Paris of 1919 let’s
the conference in Paris of 1919 let’s take ourselves back to 1919 in Paris the
take ourselves back to 1919 in Paris the
take ourselves back to 1919 in Paris the World War one had just wrapped up and
World War one had just wrapped up and
World War one had just wrapped up and millions of people were dealing with
millions of people were dealing with
millions of people were dealing with recovering from it 100 years ago almost
recovering from it 100 years ago almost
recovering from it 100 years ago almost to the day for leaders representing the
to the day for leaders representing the
to the day for leaders representing the United States United Kingdom Italy and
United States United Kingdom Italy and
United States United Kingdom Italy and France came together to talk about one
France came together to talk about one
France came together to talk about one thing and one thing only how to make
thing and one thing only how to make
thing and one thing only how to make sure that there would never be a war
sure that there would never be a war
sure that there would never be a war like this again it was a very unincluded
like this again it was a very unincluded
like this again it was a very unincluded affair a small group of guys going into
affair a small group of guys going into
affair a small group of guys going into a back room cutting up the entire world
a back room cutting up the entire world
a back room cutting up the entire world and resetting borders deciding what life
and resetting borders deciding what life
and resetting borders deciding what life would be like for people they had never
would be like for people they had never
would be like for people they had never met before and they never understood you
met before and they never understood you
met before and they never understood you see there had been no precedent for this
see there had been no precedent for this
see there had been no precedent for this no one knew how to deal with it and in
no one knew how to deal with it and in
no one knew how to deal with it and in particular the biggest issue was that
particular the biggest issue was that
particular the biggest issue was that they had introduced the same thinking
they had introduced the same thinking
they had introduced the same thinking that had got them into the problem in
that had got them into the problem in
that had got them into the problem in the first place but a deal got signed
the first place but a deal got signed
the first place but a deal got signed and as a result there was peace in one
and as a result there was peace in one
and as a result there was peace in one area but meanwhile millions of people
area but meanwhile millions of people
area but meanwhile millions of people suffered from 100 years of conflict with
suffered from 100 years of conflict with
suffered from 100 years of conflict with the greatest strategies taking place in
the greatest strategies taking place in
the greatest strategies taking place in communities that had never made a
communities that had never made a
communities that had never made a decision in terms of what their
decision in terms of what their
decision in terms of what their political or social orientation would be
political or social orientation would be
political or social orientation would be what went wrong well a lasting peace
what went wrong well a lasting peace
what went wrong well a lasting peace wasn’t going to be able to be designed
wasn’t going to be able to be designed
wasn’t going to be able to be designed by a few guys who won the war to tell
by a few guys who won the war to tell
by a few guys who won the war to tell everybody else what it was going to be
everybody else what it was going to be
everybody else what it was going to be like this was a fundamental issue and
like this was a fundamental issue and
like this was a fundamental issue and while things have changed some things
while things have changed some things
while things have changed some things stay the same people always will reject
stay the same people always will reject
stay the same people always will reject decisions made for them why are we still
decisions made for them why are we still
decisions made for them why are we still stuck here 100 years later I think that
stuck here 100 years later I think that
stuck here 100 years later I think that that’s my biggest issue right now I
that’s my biggest issue right now I
that’s my biggest issue right now I think about it constantly we are still
think about it constantly we are still
think about it constantly we are still dealing with a whole number of issues
dealing with a whole number of issues
dealing with a whole number of issues and in particular I can think of three
and in particular I can think of three
and in particular I can think of three highly dysfunctional non resilient
highly dysfunctional non resilient
highly dysfunctional non resilient behaviors that we see all of our
behaviors that we see all of our
behaviors that we see all of our institutions suffer from
institutions suffer from
institutions suffer from first we are addicted to reducing
first we are addicted to reducing
first we are addicted to reducing complex matters down to single issue
complex matters down to single issue
complex matters down to single issue problems secondly to few stakeholders
problems secondly to few stakeholders
problems secondly to few stakeholders are involved in making complex decisions
are involved in making complex decisions
are involved in making complex decisions on behalf of other people and three
on behalf of other people and three
on behalf of other people and three existing rules practices and processes
existing rules practices and processes
existing rules practices and processes are suffocating our capacity to take
are suffocating our capacity to take
are suffocating our capacity to take risks on new innovations and emerging we
risks on new innovations and emerging we
risks on new innovations and emerging we are essentially blocking or a capacity
are essentially blocking or a capacity
are essentially blocking or a capacity to step forward I know it’s been busy
to step forward I know it’s been busy
to step forward I know it’s been busy here in the u.s. kind of hard to see
here in the u.s. kind of hard to see
here in the u.s. kind of hard to see past what’s going on but up north
past what’s going on but up north
past what’s going on but up north there’s a major transformation taking
there’s a major transformation taking
there’s a major transformation taking place across society first of all entire
place across society first of all entire
place across society first of all entire communities are bounding together to
communities are bounding together to
communities are bounding together to talk about how to migrate away from
talk about how to migrate away from
talk about how to migrate away from non-renewable resources more importantly
non-renewable resources more importantly
non-renewable resources more importantly society as a whole has undertaken a
society as a whole has undertaken a
society as a whole has undertaken a process of reconciliation with 600
process of reconciliation with 600
process of reconciliation with 600 indigenous intimate and maytee
indigenous intimate and maytee
indigenous intimate and maytee communities across the land base we also
communities across the land base we also
communities across the land base we also have a new prime minister that’s what my
have a new prime minister that’s what my
have a new prime minister that’s what my wife says this guy and his team are
wife says this guy and his team are
wife says this guy and his team are making some incredible commitments to
making some incredible commitments to
making some incredible commitments to society right now and unless we get
society right now and unless we get
society right now and unless we get behind these things we’re gonna have a
behind these things we’re gonna have a
behind these things we’re gonna have a hard time moving forward expectations
hard time moving forward expectations
hard time moving forward expectations are very high for us now to solve some
are very high for us now to solve some
are very high for us now to solve some of these issues primarily issues around
of these issues primarily issues around
of these issues primarily issues around giving people the ability to make their
giving people the ability to make their
giving people the ability to make their own decisions but the stakes are high
own decisions but the stakes are high
own decisions but the stakes are high and if we don’t get this right we could
and if we don’t get this right we could
and if we don’t get this right we could suffer a lot so there’s a lot of talk
suffer a lot so there’s a lot of talk
suffer a lot so there’s a lot of talk about where this goes I want to take you
about where this goes I want to take you
about where this goes I want to take you to November of 2014 10 years after my
to November of 2014 10 years after my
to November of 2014 10 years after my epic conference experienced things have
epic conference experienced things have
epic conference experienced things have changed for me I now had the honor of
changed for me I now had the honor of
changed for me I now had the honor of leading a large global collaborative
leading a large global collaborative
leading a large global collaborative design practice focused on strategic
design practice focused on strategic
design practice focused on strategic advisory for both public sector and
advisory for both public sector and
advisory for both public sector and private sector focusing on
private sector focusing on
private sector focusing on organizational change in transformation
organizational change in transformation
organizational change in transformation a government official approached me with
a government official approached me with
a government official approached me with a very serious problem and this was not
a very serious problem and this was not
a very serious problem and this was not something that I was totally familiar
something that I was totally familiar
something that I was totally familiar with they were focused on building an
with they were focused on building an
with they were focused on building an integrated decision-making process
integrated decision-making process
integrated decision-making process across the land base focusing on natural
across the land base focusing on natural
across the land base focusing on natural resources incredibly complex and yet I
resources incredibly complex and yet I
resources incredibly complex and yet I knew that this would affect many
knew that this would affect many
knew that this would affect many Canadians in particular land based
Canadians in particular land based
Canadians in particular land based decision-making has negatively impacted
decision-making has negatively impacted
decision-making has negatively impacted indigenous community communities across
indigenous community communities across
indigenous community communities across our country for hundreds of years so we
our country for hundreds of years so we
our country for hundreds of years so we decided to look into this I want to
decided to look into this I want to
decided to look into this I want to share though a couple of statistics so
share though a couple of statistics so
share though a couple of statistics so we’re basically clear on the context a
we’re basically clear on the context a
we’re basically clear on the context a little bit because you might not be
little bit because you might not be
little bit because you might not be aware of this right now
aware of this right now
aware of this right now indigenous graduation rates are sitting
indigenous graduation rates are sitting
indigenous graduation rates are sitting at 36% as compared to 72% which is the
at 36% as compared to 72% which is the
at 36% as compared to 72% which is the Canadian average at the same time four
Canadian average at the same time four
Canadian average at the same time four percent of the population is indigenous
percent of the population is indigenous
percent of the population is indigenous 25 percent of the indigenous population
25 percent of the indigenous population
25 percent of the indigenous population is in the inmate is our inmates in jail
similar things
similar things at the same time young indigenous
at the same time young indigenous
at the same time young indigenous children die at four times more often
children die at four times more often
children die at four times more often from unintentional
community member in Canada and well the
community member in Canada and well the biggest issues that we face right now is
biggest issues that we face right now is
biggest issues that we face right now is that the fact that this population since
that the fact that this population since
that the fact that this population since 2006 has grown by 43 percent four
2006 has grown by 43 percent four
2006 has grown by 43 percent four hundred times faster than any other
hundred times faster than any other
hundred times faster than any other community so we acknowledge that
community so we acknowledge that
community so we acknowledge that something has to change so as a result
something has to change so as a result
something has to change so as a result of this request we decide to do some
of this request we decide to do some
of this request we decide to do some investigations we wanted to see what
investigations we wanted to see what
investigations we wanted to see what negotiating processes looked like at
negotiating processes looked like at
negotiating processes looked like at this point so we investigated we were
this point so we investigated we were
this point so we investigated we were alarmed by the details and the
alarmed by the details and the
alarmed by the details and the statistics in one region alone over 700
statistics in one region alone over 700
statistics in one region alone over 700 ago she ations were taking place on the
ago she ations were taking place on the
ago she ations were taking place on the land base involving 200 indigenous
land base involving 200 indigenous
land base involving 200 indigenous groups with the calculations that we
groups with the calculations that we
groups with the calculations that we made it would take 400 years to deal
made it would take 400 years to deal
made it would take 400 years to deal with this backlog with the current
with this backlog with the current
with this backlog with the current processes that we’re using something
processes that we’re using something
processes that we’re using something needed to fundamentally change so we
needed to fundamentally change so we
needed to fundamentally change so we decided to look at this problem a little
decided to look at this problem a little
decided to look at this problem a little bit more closely before I take this
bit more closely before I take this
bit more closely before I take this further though I think I want to share a
further though I think I want to share a
further though I think I want to share a couple points around collaborative
couple points around collaborative
couple points around collaborative design collaborative design in my
design collaborative design in my
design collaborative design in my opinion enables a whole different level
opinion enables a whole different level
opinion enables a whole different level of inclusive resilient decision-making
of inclusive resilient decision-making
of inclusive resilient decision-making this is a thing that has been around for
this is a thing that has been around for
this is a thing that has been around for 30 years but hasn’t quite touched but
30 years but hasn’t quite touched but
30 years but hasn’t quite touched but everybody has been talking about it and
everybody has been talking about it and
everybody has been talking about it and it’s time to move it forward
it’s time to move it forward
it’s time to move it forward collaborative design or sometimes as we
collaborative design or sometimes as we
collaborative design or sometimes as we call it Co design is about a whole
call it Co design is about a whole
call it Co design is about a whole different process of negotiation in one
different process of negotiation in one
different process of negotiation in one hand it changes the way traditional
hand it changes the way traditional
hand it changes the way traditional negotiations work where you have rappers
negotiations work where you have rappers
negotiations work where you have rappers natives speaking on behalf of
natives speaking on behalf of
natives speaking on behalf of participants primarily favoring
participants primarily favoring
participants primarily favoring bilateral single-issue negotiation
bilateral single-issue negotiation
bilateral single-issue negotiation instead collaborative design creates an
instead collaborative design creates an
instead collaborative design creates an opportunity for highly participatory
opportunity for highly participatory
opportunity for highly participatory multilateral alignment focusing on a
multilateral alignment focusing on a
multilateral alignment focusing on a greater diversity of perspectives while
greater diversity of perspectives while
greater diversity of perspectives while unpacking and exploring key ideas
unpacking and exploring key ideas
unpacking and exploring key ideas possibilities and future States in a
possibilities and future States in a
possibilities and future States in a much shorter period of time and at the
much shorter period of time and at the
much shorter period of time and at the same time collaborative design as a
same time collaborative design as a
same time collaborative design as a process does something very interesting
process does something very interesting
process does something very interesting you’re able to design processes without
you’re able to design processes without
you’re able to design processes without precedent and without use cases so think
precedent and without use cases so think
precedent and without use cases so think about it collaborative design is a
about it collaborative design is a
about it collaborative design is a design process that allows groups to
design process that allows groups to
design process that allows groups to design their own process well I can tell
design their own process well I can tell
design their own process well I can tell you government was rather uncomfortable
you government was rather uncomfortable
you government was rather uncomfortable with this idea it’s not something
with this idea it’s not something
with this idea it’s not something they’re familiar with nonetheless we
they’re familiar with nonetheless we
they’re familiar with nonetheless we felt that we should proceed with this so
felt that we should proceed with this so
felt that we should proceed with this so we undertook a process of beginning to
we undertook a process of beginning to
we undertook a process of beginning to integrate collaborative design process
integrate collaborative design process
integrate collaborative design process throughout a number of pilots that we
throughout a number of pilots that we
throughout a number of pilots that we were going to engage with between
were going to engage with between
were going to engage with between government and indigenous people across
government and indigenous people across
government and indigenous people across the country this led us into our first
the country this led us into our first
the country this led us into our first major design event in 2015 in July we
major design event in 2015 in July we
major design event in 2015 in July we sat down for our first time with an
sat down for our first time with an
sat down for our first time with an indigenous set of elders and government
indigenous set of elders and government
indigenous set of elders and government representatives one government
representatives one government
representatives one government representative who knew us well put our
representative who knew us well put our
representative who knew us well put our design process forward as 21st century
design process forward as 21st century
design process forward as 21st century bleeding-edge social technology never
bleeding-edge social technology never
bleeding-edge social technology never been done before
been done before
been done before we were a little uncomfortable with this
we were a little uncomfortable with this
we were a little uncomfortable with this moniker on the one hand yes we were
moniker on the one hand yes we were
moniker on the one hand yes we were future focused but a huge part of our
future focused but a huge part of our
future focused but a huge part of our work had been scanning ten-thousand
work had been scanning ten-thousand
work had been scanning ten-thousand years across the past across
years across the past across
years across the past across civilizations to better understand some
civilizations to better understand some
civilizations to better understand some of the things that we had potentially
of the things that we had potentially
of the things that we had potentially unlearned it was time for me to describe
unlearned it was time for me to describe
unlearned it was time for me to describe this approach to the elders I walked
this approach to the elders I walked
this approach to the elders I walked them through something quite different I
them through something quite different I
them through something quite different I talked about the fact that this would be
talked about the fact that this would be
talked about the fact that this would be more than just negotiators that we would
more than just negotiators that we would
more than just negotiators that we would have political leaders policymakers
have political leaders policymakers
have political leaders policymakers managers elders youth even conservation
managers elders youth even conservation
managers elders youth even conservation officers in the room and the opportunity
officers in the room and the opportunity
officers in the room and the opportunity would to be under one roof is to share
would to be under one roof is to share
would to be under one roof is to share stories no matter how painful to share
stories no matter how painful to share
stories no matter how painful to share our missteps no matter how embarrassing
our missteps no matter how embarrassing
our missteps no matter how embarrassing and to talk about this stuff with a
and to talk about this stuff with a
and to talk about this stuff with a little bit of humor she took a moment
little bit of humor she took a moment
little bit of humor she took a moment after I finished and
after I finished and
after I finished and quietly observed that this wasn’t a new
quietly observed that this wasn’t a new
quietly observed that this wasn’t a new way of working this in fact was a very
way of working this in fact was a very
way of working this in fact was a very old way of working there predated most
old way of working there predated most
old way of working there predated most Western political and legal practices
Western political and legal practices
Western political and legal practices this was something that could
this was something that could
this was something that could potentially bring communities together
potentially bring communities together
potentially bring communities together she saw the circular organic nature of
she saw the circular organic nature of
she saw the circular organic nature of our conversations as being something
our conversations as being something
our conversations as being something special something that could align as
special something that could align as
special something that could align as something that could create the most
something that could create the most
something that could create the most important foundation to the ongoing
important foundation to the ongoing
important foundation to the ongoing shared decision-making across the land
shared decision-making across the land
shared decision-making across the land base this idea of trust at the same time
base this idea of trust at the same time
base this idea of trust at the same time we were focused on some other projects a
we were focused on some other projects a
we were focused on some other projects a year later we were doing a multi-day
year later we were doing a multi-day
year later we were doing a multi-day collaborative design event between
collaborative design event between
collaborative design event between another indigenous group in government
another indigenous group in government
another indigenous group in government this brought to me a really important
this brought to me a really important
this brought to me a really important insight you see at the time indigenous
insight you see at the time indigenous
insight you see at the time indigenous people very justifiably can accuse more
people very justifiably can accuse more
people very justifiably can accuse more recent settlers of constantly painting
recent settlers of constantly painting
recent settlers of constantly painting them with the same brush and yet there
them with the same brush and yet there
them with the same brush and yet there are 600 different indigenous First
are 600 different indigenous First
are 600 different indigenous First Nations with over 60 languages spoken in
Nations with over 60 languages spoken in
Nations with over 60 languages spoken in Canada alone well I found interesting
Canada alone well I found interesting
Canada alone well I found interesting when I zero down to it is I started to
when I zero down to it is I started to
when I zero down to it is I started to recognize that there was another issue
recognize that there was another issue
recognize that there was another issue at hand here they were – making
at hand here they were – making
at hand here they were – making generalizations they saw government as
generalizations they saw government as
generalizations they saw government as one big machine conspiring against them
one big machine conspiring against them
one big machine conspiring against them but in a small group gathering an elder
but in a small group gathering an elder
but in a small group gathering an elder speaking to a group of officials these
speaking to a group of officials these
speaking to a group of officials these officials spent time explaining the
officials spent time explaining the
officials spent time explaining the arduous nature of their work the
arduous nature of their work the
arduous nature of their work the difficulty it was in making decisions
difficulty it was in making decisions
difficulty it was in making decisions and how rarely they even got to talk to
and how rarely they even got to talk to
and how rarely they even got to talk to each other and I remember the elder
each other and I remember the elder
each other and I remember the elder chuckling and turning to one of the
chuckling and turning to one of the
chuckling and turning to one of the leaders saying wow so much friction your
leaders saying wow so much friction your
leaders saying wow so much friction your job really sucks what they didn’t
job really sucks what they didn’t
job really sucks what they didn’t realize is that being a public servant
realize is that being a public servant
realize is that being a public servant working on these issues brings no glory
working on these issues brings no glory
working on these issues brings no glory brings no money and no celebrity status
brings no money and no celebrity status
brings no money and no celebrity status people don’t take jobs like this because
people don’t take jobs like this because
people don’t take jobs like this because they’re going to get to a place in a
they’re going to get to a place in a
they’re going to get to a place in a promotional level they do this because
promotional level they do this because
promotional level they do this because they genuinely care about this work they
they genuinely care about this work they
they genuinely care about this work they want this to happen they do take care of
want this to happen they do take care of
want this to happen they do take care of people in the third instance I want to
people in the third instance I want to
people in the third instance I want to share one story with you a chief that I
share one story with you a chief that I
share one story with you a chief that I met several months later after that last
met several months later after that last
met several months later after that last experience observed to me
experience observed to me
experience observed to me that he had observed his father
that he had observed his father
that he had observed his father negotiating on behalf of their community
negotiating on behalf of their community
negotiating on behalf of their community lands and write titles that they thought
lands and write titles that they thought
lands and write titles that they thought were going to wrap up in three years 25
were going to wrap up in three years 25
were going to wrap up in three years 25 years later this chief was still working
years later this chief was still working
years later this chief was still working on the same negotiation and it pained
on the same negotiation and it pained
on the same negotiation and it pained him greatly to think that his daughters
him greatly to think that his daughters
him greatly to think that his daughters and his sons might be here 25 years from
and his sons might be here 25 years from
and his sons might be here 25 years from now trying to work on the same
now trying to work on the same
now trying to work on the same negotiation as a father as a son as a
negotiation as a father as a son as a
negotiation as a father as a son as a husband and as a citizen I was deeply
husband and as a citizen I was deeply
husband and as a citizen I was deeply affected by these stories when I was
affected by these stories when I was
affected by these stories when I was asked to speak here I was very excited
asked to speak here I was very excited
asked to speak here I was very excited to share my passion about collaborative
to share my passion about collaborative
to share my passion about collaborative design I believe that this is a new way
design I believe that this is a new way
design I believe that this is a new way forward there is a future in this I
forward there is a future in this I
forward there is a future in this I believe that collaborative design will
believe that collaborative design will
believe that collaborative design will lead to collaborative decision-making
lead to collaborative decision-making
lead to collaborative decision-making and this is fundamentally important I
and this is fundamentally important I
and this is fundamentally important I was enabled by people in my own
was enabled by people in my own
was enabled by people in my own community to step up because I thought
community to step up because I thought
community to step up because I thought that I would be too scared to actually
that I would be too scared to actually
that I would be too scared to actually come here why because I feel like I’m
come here why because I feel like I’m
come here why because I feel like I’m trespassing into a place where many
trespassing into a place where many
trespassing into a place where many amazing people have dedicated their
amazing people have dedicated their
amazing people have dedicated their entire lives of solving these problems
entire lives of solving these problems
entire lives of solving these problems but at the same time we need to
but at the same time we need to
but at the same time we need to introduce new ideas we need to express
introduce new ideas we need to express
introduce new ideas we need to express our thoughts and define our failures and
our thoughts and define our failures and
our thoughts and define our failures and share them amongst each other over
share them amongst each other over
share them amongst each other over thousands of people I have worked with
thousands of people I have worked with
thousands of people I have worked with with dozens of organizations in the
with dozens of organizations in the
with dozens of organizations in the public and private sector I have learned
public and private sector I have learned
public and private sector I have learned one thing and one thing alone people
one thing and one thing alone people
one thing and one thing alone people love to solve problems people genuinely
love to solve problems people genuinely
love to solve problems people genuinely want to do the right thing and we are
want to do the right thing and we are
want to do the right thing and we are social by nature collaboration comes
social by nature collaboration comes
social by nature collaboration comes naturally to us there are eight billion
naturally to us there are eight billion
naturally to us there are eight billion people on the planet right now that’s
people on the planet right now that’s
people on the planet right now that’s okay by me if we all work together with
okay by me if we all work together with
okay by me if we all work together with an open mind and a line we can solve a
an open mind and a line we can solve a
an open mind and a line we can solve a lot of problems but we’re going to need
lot of problems but we’re going to need
lot of problems but we’re going to need eight billion people at the table to do
eight billion people at the table to do
eight billion people at the table to do it a lot of people where I come from
it a lot of people where I come from
it a lot of people where I come from would laugh at that idea but what’s the
would laugh at that idea but what’s the
would laugh at that idea but what’s the alternative for these white guys in a
alternative for these white guys in a
alternative for these white guys in a back room I want to thank you I was
back room I want to thank you I was
back room I want to thank you I was honored to speak in front of you today
honored to speak in front of you today
honored to speak in front of you today thank you for being patient with me
thank you for being patient with me
thank you for being patient with me you
Please follow and like us: