Press "Enter" to skip to content

Can a systems thinking curriculum improve health outcomes? | Michele Battle-Fisher | TEDxDartmouth


how health system science will untangle
that’s so witty
wicked health ok oh my goodness who’s
that oh my goodness who could that be
oh I spoiled it it says me and 5th grade
I spoiled it I had lipstick on so that
was a very special day on the right was
my elementary school Lincoln Elementary
and in Portsmouth Ohio and the reason
why I’m mentioning this in showing this
picture this is when I discovered that I
was a systems thinker in fifth grade at
my school there was a fifth grade speech
contest okay and students were selected
to develop speeches I suppose like a TED
talk I must have done far better in
fifth grade that I’m doing now
we had international pen pals we wrote
letters this is before you sent emojis
we actually did write physical letters
okay so my pen pal lived in Vienna
Austria
so Vienna Austria is certainly different
from Portsmouth Ohio it was a social
network of to me and her one too
it was my friendship dyad and that’s
kind of one of the phrases we use in
networks but that’s what I was doing and
in the contest I decided to make a
poster and so I put all of the
consonants on the poster I should have
had my mom do it because she’s a great
artist but she made me do it
and above it I say I made a red bow
connecting all of the consonants
together and the title of my speech was
tie a bow for those you know that was
the name of my speech okay and so I told
my teacher it’s like that’s exactly what
this letter is doing for me you know I’m
being connected to this young lady that
I’ve never seen and we’ve only
communicated with what but they’re
letters but I said I really did talking
to her you know and so in fifth grade I
was talking about
links and nodes and homophony which is
birds of a feather and our our differ
differences social differences and
physical difference all of those things
our social network analysis about I was
doing it in fifth grade and I didn’t
need all of those fancy words right
because actually if you’re really doing
true systems thinking for all of us we
do not need fancy terms we don’t need
the dynamic images perhaps all you
needed was those continents with a boat
connecting all of them to get that
systems point across but ultimately I
did win the contest I did win but what I
really found out and what I learned in
that experience is that our
relationships are mapable and I’m
calling these mapable bits and bits you
can just define as just objects or units
of our reality okay but I was able to
map our relationship whether that I
could have mapped perhaps in in a chart
how many times we communicated with each
other that poster was mapping okay and
so mapable bits of human complexity
unfortunately she stopped writing me
okay when she stopped writing me I was
devastated and so what that left me to
do is try to impute ideas of what might
have happened we all do it right
systemically I’m trying to figure out
well I did this and then she said that
and so I’m building all this but in the
end I never really found out why she
stopped talking to me but I was blessed
with an opportunity to learn that the
world is really dynamic and if you go
away with any phrase tonight all right
somebody’s writing it thank you
all right system’s thinking is really
there to help us understand how dynamic
we human we are that is what system
thinking is supposed to do in its truest
sense so being human in my opinion is
the embodiment of a lot of bits whether
that’s our bodies whether that’s our
words bits of information and we’re
going to broaden our definition of
information sure when we communicate
that’s information but we can
communicate in other ways
bodily through motions okay so just
broaden our definition and they’re all
tied to systemic factors and a system
changes these are interconnected
elements that work with and against each
other right and so that’s what being
human is sometimes it’s just freaking
difficult right and sometimes you’re
wondering what factors are at play
that’s making your life so difficult why
it’s because your being human and there
are those systemic factors and so I say
that we live in a elegant ordered
sophisticated universe which is
simultaneously wicked okay I think my
son made the rocket right there by
wicked I mean these are problems with no
ultimate solution it’s so it’s wicked
being a healthcare provider as well
because they’re constantly working with
bits of information from their patients
some of the bits they know about but a
lot of the bits they don’t because
they’re not disclosed and when we are
living our lives that’s what health
really is health is navigating in a very
weird complicated world and just trying
not to mess ourselves up too much okay
and it’s also going to be wicked being a
medical student because now we’re
telling them that they need to orient
their understanding of the human
condition in a wicked way and so again
we call it health system science and
they do call it the third pillar of
medicine
the first pillar is basic science the
second pillar is clinical science the
third pillar is now called Health System
science because our lives are wicked we
need to also understand that we’re
physical beings okay
sometimes we compare system to physical
to physical systems and we heard quite a
bit about physical systems tonight the
physical systems there’s no cognition
there’s no social influence
there’s no ethical struggles to deal
with right that’s why it’s wicked
a physical system we have at least some
idea of how it’s supposed to work there
may be some variation like all of my
chemistry experience I just told it’s a
variation from the norm okay it wasn’t
quite right but it’s just a variation
you at least have some idea how are
protons going to work you have some idea
of how the kidney kidney reacts well you
don’t have any idea about is why your
patient cannot get to dialysis perhaps
it’s because they’re only caregiver has
to work during that shift and can’t take
them or maybe they’ve just decided that
they don’t want that to be a quality of
life that they don’t want to go to
dialysis because it’s more difficult
okay and I said we are not cells we are
composed of them we are a pile of aging
bits with agency that navigates a
complex worlds and those are from
diagnostic tests they’re able to measure
those they’re able to give physicals
okay
but they have no idea what’s happening
at home they have no idea what’s
happening on your job they have no idea
that you lost your support system but
perhaps you need to let the physician
did your mother or father ever say get
all of my beeswax have you ever heard
that phrase before that essentially
means get out of my business okay and
for some people getting into the
intimacy of their lives is get on my
beeswax that’s very uncomfortable for
some of us so it’s going to be a
learning curve
okay it’s going to be a learning curve
for these new physicians to have the
sensitivity and the ability to get to
those unseen bits but it’s also going to
be a change for us as patients because
these physicians are going to start
asking you questions and more questions
and perhaps coming into your homes and
asking more questions and that’s going
to be a change for you when I talked
about making systems decisions often we
talked about making rules okay making a
rule for a patient is giving them
directives okay and those rules are
based on the illness that they’re
dealing with what they need to get
healthy well what we need to understand
is the rules are not made for the public
that has to serve under them the the
patient has no ability to input into
what those rules are okay and that can
be quite difficult for us as a loss of
agency as a loss of self-efficacy as a
loss of our personal liberty when we’re
told to do something and so the we’re
going to have to build that savy that
sensitivity okay knowing that some of us
are going to be resistant to rulemaking
that’s in even in complexity based we’re
in an age of big data some of you may be
in data science now where you love the
fascination and the beauty of all of
these data points but remember each data
point if it’s social that’s a person
that’s some time yes sometimes gets
lost all of those data points in a
social network analysis graph each of
those people has children has a life has
disadvantages or advantages okay so in
my opinion our bits are lived and living
data it’s just not big data health
system science is there to extract those
unseen bits and for me that’s getting to
the crust of how people are living so
our data equals living and to end it is
wicked indeed wicked wicked wicked
wicked I use that word a lot so I’m
saying healthcare Taizo boo you get it
you get that tie the bow of these seen
and unseen complexities okay
Jurgen Habermas who was a political
philosopher once said that there are
three domains in which we exist in the
uncertainty of our world the first one
is the external physical world the
second is our internal world and the
third one is our social world and what
we often do in order to make sense of
our world is we concentrate on one of
them we’re going to concentrate on your
physical body or we’re going to
concentrate on your spiritual awareness
but we concentrate on one what he says
is that the other two were there
they’re like shadow assumptions that
were completely forgetting about and so
Health System science maybe is abiding
off of what Hamas is trying to get out
here okay we can’t just look at one
element of the system so to end so
there’s great responsibility for the new
clinicians who are being asked to see
our world from a complex point of view
but there’s also a power the patients
have felt that they haven’t had okay you
felt like you’re being told
rules right but then Health System
science we’re building a network a
system of collaboration
ideally that’s what we’re going to do
and so what we’re hoping is that your
bits will be healthy your bits will be
whole and that’s what Health System
scientists trying to accomplish together
as a network thank you very much [Applause]
Please follow and like us: