Press "Enter" to skip to content

Future of Distress: Education and Narratives of Discovery | Brendan Stone | TEDxUniversityofLeeds


[Applause]

hello I’m going to be talking to you

about two themes which ostensible seem a

long way apart one is the future of

education in this country and in

particular the future of higher

education and the future and a vision

for universities just like this one and

the second thing I’m going to be talking

about is the future of distress and by

distress I some of you may call that

mental illness I prefer mental distress

I’m going to be talking about how we as

a country address mental health I think

you probably agree with me that both of

those themes have faced their challenges

in recent times i think that the ways

forward to address both education higher

education and mental health are linked

so that’s the link and i’m going to try

and persuade you that there is a link

i’m going to start with the quotation

given by the great poet and little red

poet john masefield almost 70 years ago

not exactly on the edge of tomorrow and

at an event that an important ceremony

at my university and Masefield describes

what a university should be now I don’t

fully agree with mace filled with what

he says here but there are ideas here

that are important I’ve underlined them

and the theme that I think Masefield is

in part addressing in this piece is the

way in which it is critical for

universities to be porous entities not

to be sealed off from the worlds in

which they sit not to be sealed off from

their neighborhoods from their

communities and from there from their

cities and let’s just look at the first

few lines we’re not going to read all

this out of maize fields of text there

are few earthly things more splendid

than a university he begins in these

days of broken frontiers and collapsing

values when the dams are down and the

floods are made

King misery when every future looks

somewhat grim and every ancient foothold

has become something of a quagmire

wherever a university stands it stands

and shines what a vision 1946 1946 just

think about what was going on then the

challenges and uncertainties of that

time and let’s think too about the

challenges and uncertainties that we

live in right now universities I think

are undergoing a crisis of identity in

part and i want to lay out a vision for

higher education abroad idealistic

utopian some would say old-fashioned

vision for what universities are and

should be a vision which goes against

the grain which is not reactive which

doesn’t just roll over and respond to

market pressures which refuses to finish

our thoughts with the conclusion that

students are consumers I want to kind of

trace out a bigger more generous and

more important vision and what I want to

say drawing on the likes of Ernest Boyer

and John Dewey is that we need to

articulate an idea that education not

just education in universities education

is a way of living it is a way of being

and universities can articulate that

vision if we choose to we certainly need

in my view to inhabit that vision in

this view drawing on thinkers like Boyer

but actually going back to the ancient

Greeks education is not just a way of

obtaining the necessary knowledge and

qualifications to get yourself a job

education is

vital critical resource for social

progress and reform indeed education is

critical in these thinkers minds to the

nourishing of democratic free societies

democracy here is conceived as the good

life as a means by which citizens strive

for the good of their fellow citizens

and I want to think about citizenship

here in a global sense and the Academy

has something dedicated to the renewal

of society so in this view education yes

is about the acquiring of subject

knowledge absolutely critical it is

about individual good it is about social

mobility as crystal so beautifully

articulated and it is also about

learning what citizenship is its

learning to value and have a stake in

communities and society it’s

understanding the vital role for a

healthy democracy of being able to

critically engage with ideas and

contemporary issues above all for me

it’s about partnership teams and

communities ultimately education

scholarship is about the transformation

of the world an attempt to transform

reality to make life better for

ourselves and crucially for others to

work for change now practically in

universities what does this mean well it

poses challenges to us those of us who

teach like me who are educators it poses

challenges to those who manage

institutions like this

in their mission statement in terms of

teaching we need to be working with our

students collaboratively forming

communities of learning holding the

script the skills of inquiry and

critical reflection and for me above all

we need to provide opportunities for

students to learn alongside with and

from communities and organizations

outside the walls of the Academy and an

example of this which is a project that

I oversee in Sheffield is called engage

learning and a couple of quick slides so

our engage learning modules and courses

as it says they combine traditional

academic work with opportunities to

student for students to learn with and

from external partners real-world

challenges and experiences outside the

university with these learning

activities usually focused on issues of

of public concern in Sheffield many of

our engaged learning projects focus on

issues of inequality social

marginalization and exclusion and I see

this kind of work as intimately

connected to ideas concerning

citizenship and social responsibility

and I’m really delighted to know that

under rates leadership this university

is developing ideas for similar work

I’ve worked in this area myself a great

deal and I’ll mention some of what I’ve

done later on these are some of the

kinds of projects that we work with on

students like them we work with young

people in in in schools who are

struggling to read we work in dementia

education mental health with refugees

and asylum-seekers

and all of this activity is predicated

not on the notion that universities

might dispense their beneficence to be

knighted communities far from 0 in my

view knowledge is multiplied located it

doesn’t just live in places like this

it’s out there too in communities all

kinds of knowledge different kinds of

knowledge and to equip our students for

the worlds in which they will work for

the worlds in which they will take their

places hopefully active concerned

citizens it’s vital for us to provide

access not just to our libraries but

also to that citizen knowledge okay

that’s the bit about universities and

now mental health now I don’t know how

many of you know that there are such

things in this country as recovery

colleges but there are there’s quite a

lot most of them are owned by NHS trusts

with responsibility for mental illness

learning disabilities and the like it’s

a movement that’s been going probably

for about 10 years now and it’s

predicated on a notion that instead of

being service users people are students

they sign up to a recovery college and

they might take courses in for instance

learning to manage my bipolar disorder

how to stay active when my depression is

bad how to manage hostile voices in my

head how to manage on a budget if you’re

on disability benefits those kind of

courses if you look at the prospectuses

on the whole that’s what they they will

provide now recovery colleges emerged

from the recovery movement and the

principles of recovery were formulated

by mental hell

activists they weren’t formulated by

clinicians or academics though former

formulated in the 60s and 70s by mental

health activists in the States people

living with mental illness who decided

that instead of spending the rest of

their lives hoping that one day the

symptoms would go away people would

start building the lives that they

wanted to have right now I think these

principles are great but as with so many

good energetic ideas their

implementation has become somewhat stale

some of that energy seems to have been

chewed up as initial activity gets

passed through corporate sibs and as I

said the courses that recovery colleges

offer these days are often very focused

on symptom reduction on coping there

isn’t so much of that energy to have a

life now rather than whenever I get

better and look the problem with this is

that it locks people in two narratives

in which they’re defined by what they

can’t do rather than book by what they

can and it’s not an easy place to get

out of when you’re kind of locked into

this story and you’re so used to

defining yourself in terms of difficulty

lack dysfunction when you’re very unused

to speaking about what you love what you

hope for what you think about the

politics of the day how you might

contribute how you might mount a

campaign what you care about it’s a very

very different it’s a very very

different focus so

what would it be like I wonder if we

brought some of that energy from those

ideas about radical pedagogy critical

educational ideas into the recovery

college movement well this is something

we’re trying to do in Sheffield at the

moment so I have lots of different hats

I’m also a director of a mental health

charity as well as working for the NHS

and we’re beginning to try and do this

so watch this space what about if we

actually help people to enlarge their

imagination to develop their critical

skills what about if we drew on the

expertise that people already have the

expertise of living with a mental

illness but also their expertise in

whatever their life has led to at this

moment what about if our educational

offers were about empowerment and

participation and citizenship and the

strength and strengthening of

criticality the discovery of hope and

talent and community what if that was

what was going on in recovery colleges

and what if they were open to everybody

you don’t actually have to have a

diagnosis of mental illness what if you

were unemployed or lonely or old and

isolated what about opening up recovery

colleges and where my University’s fit

within this well I think universities do

have a place and in fact university is

already are beginning to make moves in

this direction certainly mine has I’d

like to see a course for undergraduates

let’s say it’s on the tragedies of

Shakespeare in which for the first six

weeks of the teaching term I know

nothing about Shakespeare but let’s just

pretend I do that I teach them about the

tragedies of Shakespeare and how to

teach the tragic

is a Shakespeare and then the students

put on a course in a recovery college

open and free to anybody who wants to

come and find out about the tragedies of

Shakespeare well something very like

that actually happening in Sheffield now

run by a colleague of mine and it’s been

going now for about two years I think

our universities are full of untapped

potential every year in sheffield in

leeds all these generally young and

energetic people energetic people arrive

wanting to learn wanting to develop

personally and this would be an

opportunity to add to those we already

offer these are pictures from some of

the student projects that i’ve been

involved with and you can see their

students working alongside citizens in

the classroom and a lot of those

projects come under the banner of the

story in sheffield initiative you can

google it and and find out more about it

storing chevy that actually has always

worked primarily with people with

long-term mental health issues and we

have many many different projects in

which students take a leading role

working alongside citizens from the

community learning from citizens and

also assisting citizens and with in

university settings or community

settings a relatively new project we’ve

started it’s called the narrative

masterclass where people with mental

health difficulties teach medical

students who want to be psychiatrists

about living with a mental health

condition and this is an amazing project

I cannot oversee it but it’s entirely

designed and run by people are not

connected with the university and have

long-term experience of mental health

conditions and that’s a picture from one

of them and you can go go on the website

and find out find out more about it and

one last example i’d like to mention of

the kind of work that’s going on is very

near here at York’s and john university

there converge program again you can

have a look at that Nick row the

director of the converge program at

York’s and john is a remarkable

individual who’s doing amazing things

there and so I’ll just finish by saying

that I’m really interested in the agenda

I’ve been laying out to you and we’re

beginning to try and build it in

Sheffield over the next two or three

years and hopefully you’ll see something

emerge I’m interested in the issue of

issues I’ve been talking to you about

because I’m an educator I’m a teacher I

work in mental health I oversee the

engaged learning project I’m really

interested in what inequality does to a

society and northern universities like

Leeds and Sheffield comparatively

speaking our centers of great affluent

compared to some of the areas around

them I’m also interested because I

believe it or not I’m now in my 50s late

fifties actually I know that’s probably

a shock to a lot of you ah but Natalie

for over 40 years with serious mental

illness myself I’m a professor with with

Nell a levels and only a couple of GCSEs

and between the ages of 16 and 35 I was

usually so psychiatrically disabled that

I I couldn’t work I was in and out of

hospitals homeless and what was it that

helped me start to build my life after

what had been in a period of well great

and considerable difficulty and I

wouldn’t want to put it down to one

thing but probably a very significant

thing was signing on to an access course

at the University of Sheffield and for

two nights a week i think it was i I

turn up and and learn about social

science and history and maths and

goodness knows what else with a mixed

group of people a right ragbag we were

and somehow through that I discovered

that I did have something to offer the

world that I was able to form meaningful

relationships with people that had

talent and such as it is but had

something

um and I enjoyed it too I enjoyed

learning learning is a wonderful

wonderful thing suddenly the world began

to open up before me and I wouldn’t want

to put myself up as any sort of example

I’ve had a lot of advantages in life

with which others haven’t and things are

very very difficult at the moment for

people with mental health problems I

wouldn’t want to put my own recovery

such as it is because I still live with

mental illness today down to just

education one of the things that

probably helped me before that was I’ve

got a secure place to live I can see the

lady at the back waving things are hard

now but I think probably one of the

reasons that I’m energetically invested

in this agenda is as much to do with my

own story as my reading of the academic literature so thanks for listening

Please follow and like us: