Press "Enter" to skip to content

From gated territories and urban fragmentation to permeable public realms | Tao Zhang | TEDxFuzhou


so when I was invited to this talk I was

quite fascinated by the theme boundary

because as the designers that’s

something that with you with on a daily

basis so you see boundaries could be

physical as you see in this picture is a

suburban gated community outside of

Beijing you see multiple layers of it

divided vertical walls in the city so

that’s a physical boundary

it could be intangible conceived in the

perceived in someone’s mind only even

though it has the dangerous potential to

become real

so unfortunately those two quick

examples showed us how boundaries could

make the world more segregated in a less

diverse even though in general to us

boundaries help us delineate and

differentiate things in the context so

the world could be more diverse and now

let’s do something fun it’s not a rocket

science

so don’t overthink – trust your eyes –

raise your hands if you think the second

oranda line or the middle the middle

line is longer than the rest with your

hands if you think the middle one is

longer so I see some hands okay but the

reality as the red lines are the exact

same length so all three of them is are

the same and let’s look at the MC

ensures classic mind-boggling peace

relativity in this drawing you see each

stairway is perfect perfectly logical

but once you see the whole picture were

baffled how different universes can

coexist without even a clear spatial

boundary you see they’re they’re logical

but the whole picture doesn’t make sense

and it’s getting more fun now wake up

raise your hands if you you can

recognize the celebrity okay I’m going

to turn this photo upside down 180

degrees so sometimes our perceptions can

can be deceiving now I showed you the

physical boundaries I showed you

perceive the boundaries they’re not

always aligned this happens to our

cities as well

this is this could be anywhere in China

if I review the second part of the city

it shows how our cities have extended

this so one of the typical urban fabric

that we see today in most of the Chinese

cities and unfortunately this is how we

accept the preconceived notion that we

need to divide the land we need to

impose boundaries first so we can have a

rule to follow this is not a different

from the upside-down picture that I

showed you and if we assume that we’re

doing the right thing

so in logic is it’s almost the same so

to me as a designer the city the cities

will look very raw unfriendly and

flavorless so it’s as if as a planner as

a designer I serve you a dish of

separated ingredients there is no flavor

what if you have a flavor you need that

mix you need that interaction you can

eat that magical chemical reaction

so in a result this is what our cities

look like today this is a corner of

Shanghai you see the urban fabric as

both homogenous and fragmented

and the high density of vertical

development as a nut layer of boundary

on top of natural natural boundary so

the otherwise beautiful water edge is it

orbited by these towers and that this is

supposed to be the biggest residential

block in Changsha so align the entire

why are we doing this to our cities it

has a history in China since 1950s the

Soviet Union inspired or influenced

urban planning has dominated Chinese

cities for decades and with the

monumental why drills in boulevards

lined with compound after compounds

government departments and military

agencies normally acquire a big swath of

land by providing their employees and

their residents with the wide array of

different amenities simple as a sign or

symbol of a privilege there’s another

reason behind this especially in the

recent decades we’ll see more and more

gated residential communities and this

graph shows that most of the local

governments get there about 20% of their

revenue from land Alesi so this is their

fifth favor to model by efficiently

outsource outsourcing at land if you

private developers so you can share some

of the cost and or even structure

development and so that’s what our

cities look like today so urban traffic

congestions has become a conundrum for

almost every city but we keep on

building more lanes the wider world but

the traffic gets worse and one of my

colleague has a really good metaphor he

was saying that keep on adding more

wider rows to deal with the traffic is

this it’s like someone keep loosening

his belt to deal with overweight and

even when there’s no traffic this is

early shot in one of the neighborhoods

in Beijing you see there there’s no

urban life there’s no street life and

there’s no interaction no connectivity

along the street and what are we trying

to protect us from with three layers of

walls into such a simple Street and the

neighbors are not even interacting to

each other and that you will notice that

there’s a narrow stretch of green

sandwiched between the wall and the

walk that is not accessible not a

recreational not even visible to most of

the residents behind the walls and this

is extremely inefficient in effective in

and so where is this going

now we see the trend we see the history

we see with we see the impact we see the

problems let’s look at the evolution of

land land use planning in Chinese cities

quickly so from the graph you’ll see

clearly that the trend it is from

completely separate second occasion of

different land uses industrial is here

open space Park is here and residential

is here towards a better integration and

a synergy among them all and today and

you all know the the top downturn term

from the central Chinese government it’s

called a Chang Chun Lanka or change in

your own code that means different land

uses different different urban

productions need to talk to each other

each you interact with each other also

like a cookie you’re creating that

chemistry that the reaction so you can

add more flavor to the cities and just

last spring in 2016 the central

government announced to ban all the

gated future gated communities and

gradually open over the existing ones

now a tool to alleviate traffic pressure

but we all know that traffic congestion

is just one of the symptoms it’s not the

core problem and we notice some of the

developments that they’re not a designed

to face outside there were in water

facing they’re not designed to interact

with with the river with outside of the

urban fabric and let’s look at what else

is needed for the cities there isn’t a

clear answer or for all and we can

easily done over the rating systems or

sustainable design and development let’s

look at some of the simple prerequisite

to see where we are or where

the Chinese cities are and it’s there

are two examples among many to measure

the conductivity and the openness of a

neighborhood of a community one is

density of intersection in an in the

proximity of a neighborhood

and the second one is proximity to to

open space for ninety percent of the

residents so eligible you need a fifty

four intersections per square kilometre

they’re just a benchmark but let’s look

at the same example that I showed you

earlier

the city has only 14 intersections this

is a new so-called eco city it’s only

about a quarter of the baseline per lead

and the question mark is you see that

the rivers the open space has no

connection to the large gated community

at all and that there’s a a lane road

separating the river from from from the

neighborhood

so the mental distance is much longer

even though you’re you can see the river

but it’s not accessible so now I’m going

to share it with you a few examples of

our own practice how designers deploy

concept of a boundary to promote a

stronger public realm and advocated for

ecology so this is green eco Park in New

York City in Manhattan that way we did

in the nineteen seventy this was one of

the earlier prototypes of new public

space even though as part of the private

prevalent owned

residential neighborhood it was not

completely gated at all instead it

opened to the public and 40 years later

today is still one of many people’s

favorite open space in New York and we

can ask John of this to this picture of

Chicago River Walk taken seven years ago

as you’ll see the hostile urban

waterfront that is supporting no

activities there attracting no

pedestrians or wildlife many many levels

but this is what it looks like

a-and for designers like us we see the

edges we see the boundaries as

opportunities where you bring different

experiences different if energies to

converge to collide to have their

chemical reaction to to add flavor to

the cities and the still to linear

narrow edge now it’s being celebrated as

a urban destination one of the most

popular ones in Chicago this this is

what now what it looks like today with

the various you know activities after

different seasons in different time of

the day and the next one is a pseudo

Creek and many of you may have been to

Shanghai Suzhou quick pens demos to

historical water water course meandering

through the oldest part of Shanghai the

core of downtown and for a long time for

generations the surgically has been

credited as one of the drivers behind

modern industrialization in Shanghai but

sometimes in the recent decades people

only remember sort of quick as urban

blight as a with the nickname black and

distinct in Chinese hey Cho I remember

in the 1990s I lived in Shanghai and

super-quick is not any where ever you

want to get close to or you want your

address to be associated with so this is

taken up with it and it’s not only a

divided by the self as a as a mental

mental boundary to between the socially

under represented the district on the

north bank and the wealthy cosmopolitan

district in the south so in 2015 the

combination of those two security

districts create the opportunity for

designers like us to look at their own

this linear feature or boundary could be

really valuable something really

celebrated in the city and to unleash

the potential of this otherwise this

would divide and they’re not much

different from most of the other urban

rivers in China you see is pretty much

blocked by industrial uses

infrastructure

in the narrow space in between and a two

meter tall flood wall and it provides no

visual or pedestrian connectivity and

let’s look at the residential

neighborhood is similar to those Anil

cities there their design if you ignore

the water even though water is right at

the edge and the fence is be able to

ride along edge even by removing the

edge the neighborhood has no intention

to react with the water so apparently

there’s other need that for designer to

intervene to not only remove the

physical boundary you need to really

make the neighborhood’s open and by

remove that perceived boundary and while

we were doing design the new tower to

start to started encroaching toward the

river so it was desperately need a

holistic framework to really advocated

for a public realm and open space and

just to avoid the avoid making the same

mistake of having that solid wall along

the pub public open space and that this

was the vision that we we created so you

see there are two interacting linear

corridors but I’m going to rewind and

explain the logic behind it so everyone

else was focusing on this trying to fit

the program in this linear waterfront

because when people talk about a

waterfront that’s what you see that’s

the boundary does the scope but you’re

given

but for us instead we look at the

block-by-block

social data as well as circulation study

and we strategically pull the water edge

out into the neighborhood so one one way

this you can overcome the the social

stigma that soda Creek has created a

long time ago then at the same time it’s

not a random this is connecting all the

major urban nose infrastructure

including the central Shanghai station

and public parks so it creates a episode

of different activities and the space

between these two the red line which is

urban frontage and the Green Line along

the river which is the recreational

corridor becomes the public realm that

as the connecting tissue between

the new frontage or new address of

pseudo Creek and the open space corridor

and instead of no supporting private

holiday development along River so this

is trying to maximize open space along

the along River and so the internship

buildings are preserved to not only

celebrate the heritage of the entire

site and they become the social just art

destination that responding to the oriT

already quite a successful art district

on the other side of the creek and as

you see the ground the ground floor of

some industrial buildings warehouses

open up as a extension of the landscape

and and that provides a permeable a

public realm to connect from the train

station all the way to to the river and

so it not only connects all the actives

along the the creek they also extend

into the neighborhood and the existing

parks in the city so to create a

dialogue between the city and the new

Waterfront and then the gated

neighborhood again so we were opening it

up and not only but simply removing the

physical boundary we’re adding or into

intervening with the preservation as

well as a new program as for example by

adding inserting extending and

connecting new program so it becomes a

vibrant open and open community with a

mixed-use with a strong corridor and

view indication towards the the creek

and then instead of generic semi-private

open space in gated in neighborhoods in

the Neal Community Center and the

community parks become the social hub

that not only recreational and is it

just where people interact instead of

remember that bridging neighborhood that

you cannot even cross the street and it

they’ll ask four to five hundred meters

long so those are those are examples

that with designers often battle against

the boundaries this example then

sometimes we reinforce or re-establish

as well so

for example the nature doesn’t follow

any boundaries you know for example

water only follows the law of gravity

and not a not at all care how we divide

the urban fabric so most of the wetland

and in the river corridors in Chinese

cities are engineered these days with

the concrete embankments with very

little ecological functions or no

aesthetic value but instead we maximize

the riparian zones more than five times

to reverse that simplification process

by reintroducing habitats by

reintroducing well and so the nature can

work for us to purify water to to

provide ecosystem services and this is

how late through a layperson sighs to

see this landscape so instead of having

a artificial boundary on top of on top

of the natural boundary we we reinforce

it let’s use boundaries to make the world more diverse thank you

Please follow and like us: