Press "Enter" to skip to content

Creative Thinking in Math Class | Samuel Grayson | TEDxUTD


I love math but I didn’t always like

math class because I was finding myself

doing the same thing over and over and

over again in fact one time in eighth

grade I was so bored of doing my

homework that I wrote a calculator

program to do the homework for me now

I’m a computer science student at UT

Dallas

I still love math and I love programming

I love using one to further the other

but that’s why it makes me so upset when

I see a math education system that fails

to inspire because we’re teaching math

as if it’s not a creative pursuit

imagine if we taught art the same when

we teach math you go to school and all

of your assignments look like this you

fill in the region with the color

associated with a number and then you

turn it and get a new one you don’t get

to draw the lines and you don’t get to

choose your own colors and that’s the

creative aspect of math or a creative

aspect of art rather and that’s no one

would teach an art class this way but

this is exactly how we’re teaching math

Moute because most of the assignments

look something like this

also cookie cutter except instead of

having six problems you have 60 there

are the exact same types of problems but

the numbers change the letters change

but other than that it’s the same thing

it’s the same color by number over and

over and over again it’s very easy how

someone can get bored with this the

problem is that in order to say the

demons of standardized testing teachers

have had to resort to teaching types of

problems they teach the template of the

problem template of the solution and

it’s the students job to just memorize

these pairs of templates for and

solutions for problems and then the test

they just identify the template

regurgitate the solution it’s all

templates and solutions and there’s no

original thinking involved it’s become a

memorization game and this is a problem

because teachers cannot accurately

predict every type of problem a student

is going to see

in their future so knowing how to solve

types of problems you never seen before

is a really valuable skill and that’s

valuable outside the math classroom

everybody needs to know how to think

outside the box and where better to

learn it then a subject that’s about

thinking outside the box

math here’s a checkerboard it’s 8 by 8

there are each Domino takes up 2

checkerboard squares you can put them

vertically or horizontally and this

checkerboard can be tiled with dominoes

without having any overlap or Oh

dominoes hanging off the edge such that

every square is filled with a domino

let’s say I take my magic scissors all

right you ready I cut off that square

and that square can this figure also be

tiled without having any dominoes

hanging off the edge it’s a pretty tough

question but in cases like this a

teacher can ask leading questions to

help a student arrive at the answer if

they just answer take all the answers to

the smaller leading question to put them

together for example I could ask how

many squares are there how many are red

and how many are black and in the

original photo 6 by 6 or sorry 8 by 8 so

that’s 8 times 8 64 squares 1/2 so 1/2

will read and half are black so half of

64 is 32 all right 32 red squares 32

black squares but that was before I cut

you off so now there are 30 red squares

and 32 black squares next question can I

place a domino such that it covers 2

black squares I don’t think so I think

every Domino no matter how I place it

has to cover one red square and one

black square a 1 black square on one red

square going back to the bigger question

if I’ve got 30 red squares and 32 black

squares in each Domino takes one of each

I’m going to be left over with two black

squares at the end no matter how you do

it so there are going to be some gaps in

the solution

therefore it cannot be titled and most

students when they get this problem will

say does this do I remember this one

from class any of my classes No

then I give up I don’t know how to solve

it instead of taking the answers taking

the things they do know and using them

now this art of asking leading questions

to try and explain a different question

I mean explain the equestria the more

questions sound could sounds confusing

but in some cases it can lead the

student to the answer it’s not new math

it’s called the Socratic method of

questioning and let’s just say it’s been

around a little while the thing about

the Socratic method is that it’s a

really good way of explaining things to

people and that’s the next element

that’s missing is explaining and I don’t

mean teachers explaining things to

students that happens all the time I’m

talking about students explaining things

to other students especially when the

other students don’t already understand

what’s being explained this is a really

valuable skill outside the math

classroom because no matter what job you

have you’re going to have to whether

it’s business or sales you’re going to

have to explain your ideas to other

people I mean a history essay is just

someone explaining their ideas to

someone who doesn’t already agree with

them that skill goes everywhere and

instead of learning it in a subject

that’s about explaining things to other

people

math were just not learning it at all

explaining is an art because there’s no

one best way to explain something

there’s rarely one best way to explain

something but some ways are better than

others so finding which ways are better

is pretty challenging and it just takes

a lot of practice to do and we’re not

giving students practice explaining

things because it doesn’t fit on a

multiple-choice exam and being able to

explain something in your own words is

indicates a much higher level of

understanding and Bloom’s taxonomy of

knowledge that’s a much higher level of

understanding being able to explain the

it’s rather than just compute the answer

but when we’re testing our students for

let’s go to an example so when I was in

middle school I would argue with my

friends about anything after class and

on this day we were debating the biggest

conundrum we could find is 0.9 repeating

equal to 1 most people thought that it

was a little bit less than 1 some people

thought it was approximately equal to 1

but once one of my friends said no it’s

equal to 1 equal to 1 we asked him to

explain why he thought that was the case

and he gave this explanation he started

by saying something that we all agree

with 1/3 is 0.3 repeating then he said

ok multiply by 3 the left-hand side

becomes 3/3 in the right-hand side each

3 becomes a 9 0.999 repeating now 3/3 is

another name for 1 in 30 seconds he had

explained his argument we were all

convinced because these are exactly

qualities are not approximations 0.9

repeating is just another name for the

quantity 1 the same way two – 3 – 2 is

another name for the quantity 1 the best

part about this example is that the

student used logical reasoning to

connect each step to the next each step

is well explained why it has to follow

and that’s it and then another thing

that’s missing from a math education is

logic you see because in science class

well since science is about using

reproducible experiments to find facts

about the world in science class you

learn the facts but you also learn the

experiments which verify those facts you

probably remember learning about

experiments in middle school and high

school maybe even doing some experiments

in middle school or high school science

class now math is about using logical

arguments

to find facts about the world and we

learn the facts we’re the facts all day

long but you don’t learn the logic

behind why they must be true if you ask

a student why is the quadratic equation

true they’ll probably tell you because

my teacher told me so or because it’s

written in my textbook somebody else is

smart and they think it’s true it must

be true that’s not acceptable because we

need students to be able to critically

evaluate arguments I mean they’ll have

to do that in their future anyway when

they get too political our brains have

to take the speaker and take their logic

and say I follow this I follow this but

you made a mistake there something like

that we want students people to

critically evaluate logic to be able to

raise their hand and say teacher I don’t

believe you why is that true

but we’re not giving them the

opportunity to do that I don’t think

that fit it’s a multiple choice exam

either so here is another time in middle

school I’m talking with my friends

someone has a proof that or the claims

to have a proof that 42 equals 1 and I

don’t believe that but if you can’t

point out a flaw in the logic you have

to accept the conclusion that 42 equals

1 so like okay try me so he starts by

saying that x equals 0 let X equal 0

okay sure now 42 times 0 equals 0 but so

does 1 times 0 so 42 equals 1 great now

he says let me divide both sides by X

sorry he says 42 x equals 1 X then he

says let me divide both sides by X and

now he has 42 equals 1 there must be a

mistake somewhere but where each step

seems like it follows from the previous

but it doesn’t quite because going from

step 3 to step 4 we divided by X and X

is 0 so you can’t you can’t divide by 0

because you can’t divide something by

nothing that doesn’t make sense like

what would 4 what would 42 X divided by

0 even be right that doesn’t make sense

so there is a flaw in the logical

argument we want students be able to

identify these flaws because identifying

this flaw is all

most the same type of thinking it takes

to identify flaws in other arguments

like political arguments take this

argument if we allow more interracial

marriages than marriages will become

more common

if marriages become more common than

incestuous marriages will become more

common and we don’t want that now this

is a real argument this is a real

arguments given in the Supreme Court of

California in the majority decision in

1948 against or in favor of

anti-miscegenation laws you see the

author commits a slippery slope fallacy

going from step one to step two to say

if we allow this type of marriage then

more of these types of marriages will

also happen that’s that’s a fallacy but

identifying that fallacy is the same

type of thinking that it takes to

identify the fallacy in the previous

example that step four did not follow

from step three in the previous example

step two does not follow from step one

now we’re not getting students to be

able to recognize these flaws because

they’re just accepting whether teachers

giving them in fact I’m surprised

students have any creativity or original

thought after twelve years of being

beaten over the head with the same

mindless memorization games day in and

day out it’s no wonder they hate the

subject it’s a shame because it’s not a

bad subject in fact I had some pretty

good math classes um um I was lucky to

have some pretty good math classes my

math teachers did not just give us

problems from the textbook I mean they

had to give us some problems from the

textbook so that we would be prepared

for some standardized test somewhere in

the future but after that we had

challenge problems and challenge

problems were not problems that the

teachers told us how to solve in class

he gave us all the tools to solve in

class but didn’t tell us how to solve

them instead that was our job to go home

put these tools together using logical

arguments connect them with logic and

then find the solution and then explain

our solution to the challenge problem as

if the person were explaining it to

doesn’t already know the solution and

that allowed me to not be bored in math

class because it gave some creativity

and finding that best explanation

or if you can’t find the best one try

and find the best one try to find one

that’s better than others and these are

changes that a lot of math teachers

already wanted to make we can do this

and if we do society can be improved but

it starts with improved education now

this is all about empowering the

connections that we have with each other

you may not be a teacher but if you’re a

sibling of someone trying to learn math

or a cousin or even a friend and they

ask you for help I urge you don’t just

explain what but also why things are

true because we need our next generation

to not only be able to solve for X but

also for any variable that comes their

way thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: