Press "Enter" to skip to content

Charity, one hell of a drug | Arsema Thomas | TEDxYale


[Music]

our Auto Show I will only do share and

he share photo the wealth that enslaves

the owner is not well this is the Yoruba

proverb my proud Nigerian father would

tell me every Monday before giving me my

allowance I would look at the 1900 and

think of all the ways I was going to

spend it for those of you unfamiliar

with Nigerian currency a thousand naira

is equivalent to about two dollars and

seventeen cents so my options were very

limited but I never really understood

exactly what he was trying to say until

2008 when I was old enough to understand

the World Bank’s development assistance

report and economist dumb visa Moyo

published dead aid 300 billion dollars

that’s billion with a beef a little bit

more than 1000 naira that’s the amount

of money that is washed over the African

continent since 1970 in some form of

development assistance like eight or

charity three hundred billion dollars

that have bypassed the people that

needed it the most while at times lining

the pockets of others three hundred

billion dollars somewhere on the African

continent but with very little to show

for it you see my favorite part of

growing up as the daughter of two

diplomats

besides very fast airport security was

the constant and consistency of setting

I’ve been to some pretty unpredictable

places in the most

predictable of times I was in Kenya

during some of the worst post-election

violence in 2008 I was in Ethiopia when

they celebrated the Millennium seven

years after everyone else I was in Benin

and Togo during the Ebola outbreak that

ravaged western Africa and I was a

toddler in Uganda during the Rwandan

genocide when the entire continent saw a

mass exodus like they haven’t seen in

recent history but the single recurring

character and the story of my life has

been Africa I love that continent with

every fiber of my being its beauty its

heterogeneity and its nuances

they’ve always enraptured me and you get

used to the mosquitoes at one point or

another but I had no idea that the

subject of Africa has a completely

different connotation outside of the

continent this first dawned on me when I

went to summer camp for the very first

time in the United States and I was

immediately pummeled with questions once

they found out where I’d come from I was

asked about the height of giraffes about

the size of my mud hut why I’m wearing

shoes that was a weird one

and if elephants were the African

equivalent of school buses but the most

shocking was when a girl came up to me

and asked me or told me really that her

family gave a hundred dollars every year

to Africa and that I should be grateful

because she was saving the country

besides the common misconception that

Africa is a single country what she told

me actually started me on a journey of

understanding just how systemic the

model around Aid is and the sense of

hierarchy that’s partnered with it you

see

been seventy years of the same model

built solely out of pity and with forty

five billion dollars now funneling into

the continent annually if you do some

investigating the number of people

actually living on a single dollar a day

has increased drastically there has to

be something wrong with a system that

has pushed countries to default on a

trillion dollar loans cause a lack of

government accountability compromise the

very idea of democracy and cultivated a

space for rampant corruption with all

these negative effects due to a problem

so ingrained in our global psyche you’d

actually be surprised that the solution

is not as radical as you think if we all

engage in it together nine must disclose

I am NOT an economist nor am I an

anthropologist or a historian and God

knows I am NOT a politician I’m just a

girl who grew up in a couple of super

cushy suburbs across sub-saharan Africa

who has seen way too much to not say

anything I’ve seen as how the simple

donation of clothing into African

countries has ruined the local textile

industry because would you buy clothes

when you can get them for free

I’ve sat back and witnessed as NGOs

brought in mosquito nets into a small

city in Tanzania which ended up hurting

the local economy because Tanzanians

were already producing and selling their

own mosquito nets but weren’t able to

compete with the ultra low prices of

handouts you see the problem lies in the

mutually destructive idea of charity

when it’s coupled with no sense of

accountability

the African people have lost their boys

and the practice of democracy has

metamorphosized

into this ugly yet tamable beast you see

in these transactions between

governments money is traveling with no

strings attached meaning that the

government has no reason to use the

money to benefit their own people and

without a proper system of checks and

balances citizens are left wondering

exactly what rights are beholden to them

because when a country depends so much

on aid the government has no real reason

to set up a proper system of Taxation

because the money is already coming from

somewhere else and while we would all

love to live in a world where we didn’t

have to pay taxes we then lose the power

to hold our government accountable to

provide us with crucial things such as

health care public had education and

just basic infrastructure think of it

this way

remember the 1909 stream of money

because it was coming every week like

clockwork my supply would be renewed

regardless and the way I spent it was

never dictated in addition to the fact

that I didn’t even work for it and I

didn’t earn the money meant that I lost

the understanding for the value of the

dollar or the naira in my case because

of that I spent it quickly and on things

I definitely didn’t need this is why

insouciance

is prevalent amongst African

policymakers because with aid there

lacks an impetus to find other more

viable ways of financing their country’s

long-term progress aid

is the wolf in sheep’s clothing it’s

really modern-day colonialism when you

think about it because it is shackled

the entire continent to development

assistance really the end of colonies in

the continent didn’t necessarily

liberate African countries to set their

own agenda because colonialism was

treated with charity to disrupt this

cycle money has to be used as an

investment people rarely realize that

Africa is filled with entrepreneurs who

understand the issues in their own

backyards and are creating innovative

answers to the questions of Africans

it’s not all giraffes and Tigers and

benefit concerts headlined by Bono it’s

so much more a biomedical smart jacket

was invented in Uganda that has the

ability to diagnose pneumonia four times

faster than a doctor in South Africa

they’re in the process of building the

world’s largest telescope Kenya is

making its headway in the car industry

by creating a cost-effective luxury SUV

that can withstand the rough terrain of

Kenyan roads and whoa labs a start-up in

Togo one of the world’s poorest

countries created the first made in

Africa 3d printer completely from a

waste this list alone can be its own TED

talk and not to blow your minds but

Africa is a good investment with 20% of

the population being between the ages of

15 and 24 the continent has a growing

workforce and with that prime example

for a potential market

and economic strength think about that

this youthful Africa is happening in

juxtaposition with an aging world it’s

no surprise that the International

Monetary Fund the IMF projects that

Africa will be the second largest

economy within the next few years that

being said there are some multinational

companies and investors that have deemed

Africa too risky to be worthy of

investment for reasons that have

actually resulted in years of donor aid

dependency the country the continent

hasn’t set backs

unlike Asia Africa doesn’t have economic

role models until recently we’re

starting to see sleeping giants awaken

with Rwanda a landlocked naturally

resource depleted country that went

through a genocide now making major

strides in economic transformation by

creating a sustaining a GDP growth rate

the thing is even government instability

has stopped investors in their tracks

because in Africa the struggle for

democracy has created an economic

dimension time and time again when we

see leaders abuse power they end up

compromising national prosperity but

countries such as Ethiopia and Uganda

are showing that even in the face of

political worry their leaders have been

able to stimulate a ethos of economic

the potential the economic potential of

Africa goes beyond that of the scenes of

blood diamonds and commodity trading

Africa has been able to offer the

highest return on foreign direct

investment in the world so you can

invest in the oil assets of the north or

the diamonds and gold of the south but

don’t forget to invest in the innovative

ven ventures that are sprouting across

the continent in accelerators and

incubators because in reality Africa has

been investing in the Western world for

quite some time having spent a total of

four trillion dollars in the

international market to date but now the

hard part how do you and I invest in

Africa there is the way of

exchange-traded funds and the market

vector index of Africa but there is a

more direct more real way for those of

us who operate outside of the business

world of stocks and bonds it’s by

visiting Africa by engaging in the local

tourism by enjoying and participating

and attaching your own personal value to

these 54 countries from the Nile to the

Cape and if you can’t take the long

flight you can invest in Africa right

here from the US by engaging with

African owned businesses either online

or in whatever city you’re in

with the growing interconnectedness of

our world I am willing to bet you more

than 1,000 IRA that wherever you are you

can find Ethiopian coffee beans a

Senegalese owned restaurant or a Kenyan

with a tech startup in the New Haven

area alone there is Lalibela an

Ethiopian restaurant just south of

temple there is a Nigerian

get off of Whaley Avenue and right

between West Haven and New Haven

there’s the headquarters for a Liberian

owned beauty shop in this area alone but

the issue is time and time again Africa

has been left out of the loop it’s not

been invited to the table as big

businesses and corporations have

leveraged and appropriated in stolen

African styles to maximize profits

profits that are never realized in the

continent or even worse they take

advantage of lacks regulations in these

countries and they employ children

forcing them into labor conditions you

wouldn’t wish upon your worst enemy just

to cut costs this has to stop in order

to fight against these old world views

and tactics we have to come at it with a

new world mentality we have to engage in

the dynamic relations that are governing

our society we have to stop perpetuating

and fuelling a decrepit system in which

the Western world’s is the donor the

savior and the low income countries are

the recipient in need of saving that

system is built for disaster Africa can

no longer be treated as a child waiting

for its allowance from the Western world

but rather should be viewed as equals if

not a potential competitor this is

something easily applicable across

emerging market countries many rife with

talent but constantly just constantly

overlooked we have to take note of the

changes afoot we have to wake up and we

have to shift our perception away from

charity and towards partnership because

then then we can see the advancement of

our global economy and finally the

dismantling of a hierarchical system

that is forced countries to stay down in

order for us to take and be a part of

some of the world’s fastest-growing

economies we have to rethink our

traditional business models so we can

encourage social and economic

advancement not only for the African

people but for our global community now

I have to give credit where credit is

due

a lot of what I’ve spoken about today

has been part of my own personal

narrative sitting on the lap of my

father as at a very young age as he

talked about theories of change and what

Africa could be and should be it was a

huge part of his career the enhancement

of the African landscape after I lost

him a little over a year ago now I tried

as best as I could to pick up where he

left off I mean he had a PhD and over 40

years of experience and I’m still

struggling for my masters but it’s been

his influence and the stories I’ve

picked up along the way that have

instilled in me a confidence in knowing

that there is no such thing as a low

resource country it’s these

conversations and the conversations that

stem from today that can and will

reverberate across borders it will do

away with this old practice of charity

and revolutionize the way we look and

interact with the world around us the

potential to do so is within you it’s

within me it’s within the new generation

and the

generation just waiting to be tapped so

don’t feel bad for Africa believe in Africa thank you

Please follow and like us: