
Translator: Leonardo Silva Reviewer: Raissa Mendes
My story begins in a therapy session.
I imagine that you should not feel very original
a psychiatrist talk therapy session,
but I hope you enjoy the story; it is very interesting.
It begins about 10 years ago,
10-15 years ago.
It was a very hot March,
superquentes these marches that we have here in Porto Alegre,
late summer.
The patient then came to the session and told me of the holidays he’d had.
It was the first session after his vacation and my.
By the middle of the session, he told me the people he met,
of cool places that he met.
By the middle of the session, he took the phone
and began to show me pictures of places and people he had met.
At the time, I was horrified.
I said, “But that strange,”
because in my training as a psychiatrist and as a therapist,
we learn that the word is important,
healing is the word, the word is that it symbolizes.
The mobile photo was an absolutely concrete thing.
Good…
Some time passed, 10 to 15 years,
and today patients show much more than photos, right?
Patients bring cell and read texts of “Whats”.
They knew that people on Facebook.
They tell of secret meetings by Tinder.
Bring audio and show us, for we hear together.
The world changed. In fact, the world has changed.
But that world I’m talking about?
I think it’s important we make a parenthesis
because I’m talking about the world of social inclusion.
In this eslaide here, you can see
over the world including the Internet.
Basically, it is the Northern Hemisphere.
There are many shady spots, is not it? Where we are.
There are in fact 50% of world population
who do not have access to computer and internet.
There is a digital divide between us.
Nevertheless, I want to make clear that I will speak,
at this time and from now,
people who are included in the digital world,
but I surrender my tribute to those who are not.
Well, social networks have brought about profound changes
in the way we interact
and how we communicate with each other.
Facebook was created in 2004,
and it has 2 billion users people.
It is interesting that he has grown especially in underdeveloped countries.
For example,
Bangkok, Thailand, is now the capital of Facebook.
It has 25 million Facebook users.
Now the question that remains for us is:
which is the association has
between this increasing our access to social networks
and our mental health?
The results of the research are absolutely contradictory,
probably due to methodological differences and other problems.
At least three conclusions about you can get to this point.
There is an association between excessive use of social networks
and depressive symptoms;
another association of social networks with self-esteem;
and finally a dependency association with social networks.
I’ll start talking about depression.
Depressive symptoms may happen
in people who really use social networks.
Especially sadness and loneliness are very senses
by people who use a lot of social networks.
But on the other hand, people who make online communication, for example WhatsApp,
with family and close friends,
feel less alone, it is the opposite.
They feel less sad.
I think this is an example of the beneficial effects
of social networks on people.
What about self-esteem?
Self-esteem is an absolutely important and fundamental element
development and maintenance of our mental health.
It seems that people with decreased self-esteem
They make more use of social networks as well.
Mostly, usually post self-promotional content.
Thinking of self-promotion, it has a very interesting study,
recently published
with 2000 girls, girls from 16 to 25 years in England.
Look how interesting:
they remain five hours a week involved in their “selfies”.
This gives an average of 48 minutes a day
involved in activities with selfies.
And a very interesting thing:
every seven selfies they think to post,
they choose just a perfect selfie.
So it’s long on self-promotion.
If we put on Instagram “#selfies”
we’ll have today 275 million images.
This is a selfie, is not it?
A self-portrait of Frida Kahlo, is not it?
we think this is interesting self-portrait.
If you look, everyone is on the left side of the face.
In February this year, an article about it was published,
an article that research which side of the face of the people
It is posted as more selfie.
Amazing. What is the result?
The left cheek.
Both in the mirror … in the middle between the mirror and normal selfie,
the left side is the most posted.
Maybe it’s a spurious theory means something kind of bizarre and curious …
(Laughs)
but maybe that, maybe we are starting
the question of knowledge on social networks.
The third thing I wanted to talk to you is about the dependencies,
dependency on social networks.
It is very interesting to us to see this issue in a continuous,
where people make a very appropriate use of social networks
and others are dependent;
dependent because they have “craving”, have cleft;
dependent because they have abstinence-dependent because they have relapses,
as someone who uses nicotine, alcohol and drugs.
It is very important that, in fact,
only a minority of people who access social networks are dependent,
but it gives very interesting, about 6% of world population
that has some dependence:
or “smartphone” or “games”, or social networks.
This dependence puts people often at risk.
People at risk when driving the car and access their social networks.
Other situations are also very strange
when people access social networks.
How do we evaluate this dependency?
Researchers from Norway have made an instrument
specifically to evaluate the dependence on Facebook.
This instrument has 18 items.
What is most important is that a specific item of this instrument
evaluates the quality of the resulting sleep access to social networks,
especially Facebook.
We know that people dependent on Facebook spend sleepless nights,
and this has a major impact on mental health.
The question becomes: this is a psychiatric diagnosis? Do not.
According to ICD-10 and DSM-5,
the addition, dependency on social networks
and dependence on the internet is not a psychiatric diagnosis.
The psychiatric diagnosis made in DSM-5
It is the diagnosis of dependence of games.
Now we have to think of risk factors.
What is the population that has more risk of becoming dependent on social networks?
Young women, people with uncontrolled impulses,
introverted, perfectionists with low self-esteem
and those persons in need of approval.
Now, when it comes to health care,
the subject that we are talking here today,
it is important to think like this:
no, no one is saying that people should use
or that are prohibited from using social networks.
The issue we’re talking about
It is a more restrained use of social networks.
And what are the prospects just for us better understand
this relationship between social networks and mental health?
The outlook relate to better design studies.
All studies that are known so far are association studies.
For example, I told you
that people who have more access to social networks
They have more depressive symptoms.
This is an association. This is not a cause and effect.
Does not mean that people who make more use of social networks
They have more depression.
To do studies of cause and effect,
You have to follow people for a long time.
Most studies are made with “normal” people.
We need to know from studies of people with psychiatric disorders;
eg depression, bipolar disorder and others.
The studies are done in a way that generalizes social networks.
Social networks are very different: Instagram, Facebook, Whats.
The idea is that you need to do very specific studies for each social network.
Probably what we’re talking about, then,
is an education for new users,
and it passes through the schools, through the elementary school,
It passes by teachers and passes especially by parents.
And in Brazil, folks, we have a very serious problem.
Brazil is one of the countries
in which children access the Internet earlier:
at nine years old, on average.
And they are more vulnerable,
vulnerable to exposure situations to self-harm;
for example, the “Blue Whale”.
They are more vulnerable to the behavior “fitness”
which can lead to eating disorders such as bulimia and anorexia.
They are more vulnerable to “cyberbullying.”
What is expected? What to do?
We need to shorten the bridges between generations,
between digital natives, who are now under 30,
and we, the digital immigrants.
It is very important to close this dialog,
that this dialogue is closer.
For that, we have to stimulate an absolutely open, honest
and genuinely interested in the technology,
genuinely interested to know how the game works,
how social networking works.
Look how interesting:
currently, 60% of children who have two to five years
They have the ability to play games – the ability to play games –
computers.
Twenty percent of them can play on the “smartphone” apps
and only 11% are able to tie their shoes.
What world is this?
The world has changed, changed utterly,
changed in privacy.
Social networks have made us less private.
On the other hand, we have much more transparency.
The noun has changed:
what “privacy” became “transparency.”
I’ll finish remembering the story I started counting for you.
It was March 1, hot summer in Porto Alegre,
and I was in a therapy session,
attending to a patient brought me photograph,
and I was absolutely amazed.
That’s something, is not it? How much it spent.
Today, what is known, and this is very interesting,
It is that social networks, on the one hand have association with depressive symptoms,
with low self-esteem and dependency,
they are also providing the people who have a hard time interacting
a very different possibility to interact.
You have to be able to think of a way and that, making a balance.
We have to undress of prejudices,
look at social networks in another way,
with a much less alarmist and less reductionist view,
and hoping that future research can give us lights
for us to better understand the relationship between mental health and social networks.
Thank you.
(Applause)
My story begins in a therapy session.
I imagine that you should not feel very original
a psychiatrist talk therapy session,
but I hope you enjoy the story; it is very interesting.
It begins about 10 years ago,
10-15 years ago.
It was a very hot March,
superquentes these marches that we have here in Porto Alegre,
late summer.
The patient then came to the session and told me of the holidays he’d had.
It was the first session after his vacation and my.
By the middle of the session, he told me the people he met,
of cool places that he met.
By the middle of the session, he took the phone
and began to show me pictures of places and people he had met.
At the time, I was horrified.
I said, “But that strange,”
because in my training as a psychiatrist and as a therapist,
we learn that the word is important,
healing is the word, the word is that it symbolizes.
The mobile photo was an absolutely concrete thing.
Good…
Some time passed, 10 to 15 years,
and today patients show much more than photos, right?
Patients bring cell and read texts of “Whats”.
They knew that people on Facebook.
They tell of secret meetings by Tinder.
Bring audio and show us, for we hear together.
The world changed. In fact, the world has changed.
But that world I’m talking about?
I think it’s important we make a parenthesis
because I’m talking about the world of social inclusion.
In this eslaide here, you can see
over the world including the Internet.
Basically, it is the Northern Hemisphere.
There are many shady spots, is not it? Where we are.
There are in fact 50% of world population
who do not have access to computer and internet.
There is a digital divide between us.
Nevertheless, I want to make clear that I will speak,
at this time and from now,
people who are included in the digital world,
but I surrender my tribute to those who are not.
Well, social networks have brought about profound changes
in the way we interact
and how we communicate with each other.
Facebook was created in 2004,
and it has 2 billion users people.
It is interesting that he has grown especially in underdeveloped countries.
For example,
Bangkok, Thailand, is now the capital of Facebook.
It has 25 million Facebook users.
Now the question that remains for us is:
which is the association has
between this increasing our access to social networks
and our mental health?
The results of the research are absolutely contradictory,
probably due to methodological differences and other problems.
At least three conclusions about you can get to this point.
There is an association between excessive use of social networks
and depressive symptoms;
another association of social networks with self-esteem;
and finally a dependency association with social networks.
I’ll start talking about depression.
Depressive symptoms may happen
in people who really use social networks.
Especially sadness and loneliness are very senses
by people who use a lot of social networks.
But on the other hand, people who make online communication, for example WhatsApp,
with family and close friends,
feel less alone, it is the opposite.
They feel less sad.
I think this is an example of the beneficial effects
of social networks on people.
What about self-esteem?
Self-esteem is an absolutely important and fundamental element
development and maintenance of our mental health.
It seems that people with decreased self-esteem
They make more use of social networks as well.
Mostly, usually post self-promotional content.
Thinking of self-promotion, it has a very interesting study,
recently published
with 2000 girls, girls from 16 to 25 years in England.
Look how interesting:
they remain five hours a week involved in their “selfies”.
This gives an average of 48 minutes a day
involved in activities with selfies.
And a very interesting thing:
every seven selfies they think to post,
they choose just a perfect selfie.
So it’s long on self-promotion.
If we put on Instagram “#selfies”
we’ll have today 275 million images.
This is a selfie, is not it?
A self-portrait of Frida Kahlo, is not it?
we think this is interesting self-portrait.
If you look, everyone is on the left side of the face.
In February this year, an article about it was published,
an article that research which side of the face of the people
It is posted as more selfie.
Amazing. What is the result?
The left cheek.
Both in the mirror … in the middle between the mirror and normal selfie,
the left side is the most posted.
Maybe it’s a spurious theory means something kind of bizarre and curious …
(Laughs)
but maybe that, maybe we are starting
the question of knowledge on social networks.
The third thing I wanted to talk to you is about the dependencies,
dependency on social networks.
It is very interesting to us to see this issue in a continuous,
where people make a very appropriate use of social networks
and others are dependent;
dependent because they have “craving”, have cleft;
dependent because they have abstinence-dependent because they have relapses,
as someone who uses nicotine, alcohol and drugs.
It is very important that, in fact,
only a minority of people who access social networks are dependent,
but it gives very interesting, about 6% of world population
that has some dependence:
or “smartphone” or “games”, or social networks.
This dependence puts people often at risk.
People at risk when driving the car and access their social networks.
Other situations are also very strange
when people access social networks.
How do we evaluate this dependency?
Researchers from Norway have made an instrument
specifically to evaluate the dependence on Facebook.
This instrument has 18 items.
What is most important is that a specific item of this instrument
evaluates the quality of the resulting sleep access to social networks,
especially Facebook.
We know that people dependent on Facebook spend sleepless nights,
and this has a major impact on mental health.
The question becomes: this is a psychiatric diagnosis? Do not.
According to ICD-10 and DSM-5,
the addition, dependency on social networks
and dependence on the internet is not a psychiatric diagnosis.
The psychiatric diagnosis made in DSM-5
It is the diagnosis of dependence of games.
Now we have to think of risk factors.
What is the population that has more risk of becoming dependent on social networks?
Young women, people with uncontrolled impulses,
introverted, perfectionists with low self-esteem
and those persons in need of approval.
Now, when it comes to health care,
the subject that we are talking here today,
it is important to think like this:
no, no one is saying that people should use
or that are prohibited from using social networks.
The issue we’re talking about
It is a more restrained use of social networks.
And what are the prospects just for us better understand
this relationship between social networks and mental health?
The outlook relate to better design studies.
All studies that are known so far are association studies.
For example, I told you
that people who have more access to social networks
They have more depressive symptoms.
This is an association. This is not a cause and effect.
Does not mean that people who make more use of social networks
They have more depression.
To do studies of cause and effect,
You have to follow people for a long time.
Most studies are made with “normal” people.
We need to know from studies of people with psychiatric disorders;
eg depression, bipolar disorder and others.
The studies are done in a way that generalizes social networks.
Social networks are very different: Instagram, Facebook, Whats.
The idea is that you need to do very specific studies for each social network.
Probably what we’re talking about, then,
is an education for new users,
and it passes through the schools, through the elementary school,
It passes by teachers and passes especially by parents.
And in Brazil, folks, we have a very serious problem.
Brazil is one of the countries
in which children access the Internet earlier:
at nine years old, on average.
And they are more vulnerable,
vulnerable to exposure situations to self-harm;
for example, the “Blue Whale”.
They are more vulnerable to the behavior “fitness”
which can lead to eating disorders such as bulimia and anorexia.
They are more vulnerable to “cyberbullying.”
What is expected? What to do?
We need to shorten the bridges between generations,
between digital natives, who are now under 30,
and we, the digital immigrants.
It is very important to close this dialog,
that this dialogue is closer.
For that, we have to stimulate an absolutely open, honest
and genuinely interested in the technology,
genuinely interested to know how the game works,
how social networking works.
Look how interesting:
currently, 60% of children who have two to five years
They have the ability to play games – the ability to play games –
computers.
Twenty percent of them can play on the “smartphone” apps
and only 11% are able to tie their shoes.
What world is this?
The world has changed, changed utterly,
changed in privacy.
Social networks have made us less private.
On the other hand, we have much more transparency.
The noun has changed:
what “privacy” became “transparency.”
I’ll finish remembering the story I started counting for you.
It was March 1, hot summer in Porto Alegre,
and I was in a therapy session,
attending to a patient brought me photograph,
and I was absolutely amazed.
That’s something, is not it? How much it spent.
Today, what is known, and this is very interesting,
It is that social networks, on the one hand have association with depressive symptoms,
with low self-esteem and dependency,
they are also providing the people who have a hard time interacting
a very different possibility to interact.
You have to be able to think of a way and that, making a balance.
We have to undress of prejudices,
look at social networks in another way,
with a much less alarmist and less reductionist view,
and hoping that future research can give us lights
for us to better understand the relationship between mental health and social networks.
Thank you.
(Applause)
Please follow and like us: