
[Applause]
is creativity special so creativity is a
relatively modern concept the Greeks
didn’t really sort of understand it when
they had a Greek play they imagined that
that was just documenting the human
condition and it designed a trireme that
was just an inevitable solid just like a
type of green solid but around the
release most time we started to accept
the creativity dimension it was like a
thing and often Leonardo da Vinci is
credited as the first inventor but in
1474 Venice enacted a patent Act and so
there were quite a lot of inventors
around at that time and then over the
next few centuries
invention we took off or at least with
documentation of invention and we ended
up where the postal system and
communications and flight and computers
with touchscreens which I was quite
involved in and then the World Wide Web
and all the things that are kind of
accelerated from there but what I want
to do I asked is really is it is it
really a special thing that’s creative
do you think or is it just something
kind of some ordinary could you automate
it you know is it a mechanistic thing
and that’s a sort of similar question
it’s a dual question with with whether
you can sort of simulate reality you
know if you can simulate we have an
beautiful then you can sort of simulate
creativity because creativity is a part
of what we do so I’ve got a bit of an
admission to make
I’ve actually simulated this half of the
audience okay so you’re all simulated
actually on largest computer and you’re
all real okay
and we we project I’d like hologram and
all these people here so not freak you
out so that’s why it doesn’t look empty
and by the way just before any of you
get any kind of weird ideas all the
usual rules law like if you come as a
cry and you’ll go to jail in the
simulation for the rest of your life
so no running amok and kind of you know
doing nutty things and of course and
then the problem is I set the production
up earlier I wasn’t my call which way
around the room with these so actually
you might be the simulation into my
dream okay and the question then is if
you’re sitting there wondering whether
you’re you know whether you’re really
doing things for real how would you test
it how would you know whether you were
something that was mechanical just
through the motions of creating
something or whether you were a real
thing really being creative so kind of
good analogy is if I said to you that if
you’re real right you can run up up
against the wall and do a handstand but
if you’re yeah if you all simulate if
you can’t you just get up run against
the wall do a handstand right okay I
can’t real and this is the question
about how can you tell something that’s
automatic and something that is so
creative and the question of whether
things were all kind of automatic with
questions that both mathematicians at
the turn of the last century and this
chap called
David Hilbert asked the question whether
everything that we have is could just be
simulated by a computer and two people
answered that question a chap called
Kirk girdle whose proof is quite
complicated and a chap called Alan
Turing now we all understand out
ensuring because because he invented the
computer is creating that proof and we
all using computers everyday and so his
thought was that when we go through some
me
or process like long multiplication fool
you learnt at school we write out the
numbers in a particular format and then
we add them all up and we carry and so
on and without any thought without any
creativity or intuition we just go
through the process he said well you can
imagine this as laid out as sort of as a
tape isn’t it as a sequence of those and
you could then generalize this and you
can do all sorts of things with it so
for example you could decide should I
fall in love with this person or not and
that would be just a sequence of
processes right
should I sort of fall in love with this
person yes or no it’s a decision problem
but there’s a problem with decision
problems because you can say well that
means should I fall in this putt with in
love with this person and you could be
waiting for the results to come out and
of course the thing can get stuck in a
loop blue screen or whatever and you
never get the answer you’d never know
whether you were supposed to do it or
not
and so Turing had this kind of really
better insight when she said that if you
knew if a process was going to stop or
not that would give you immense power
because what you could do is you can put
some programming and some input and if
you knew whether it was going to stop or
not you wouldn’t know the answers have
many puzzles so you could for example
put a program in and say will this stock
go up tomorrow and you can put in you
know Apple or whatever and into the
thing bolts you know it’s going to go up
and if it doesn’t it’s gonna go well
it’s not gonna do anything right you
could do that almost any question you
imagined and this was a this was a
puzzle actually if you’ve watched the
movie the imitation game this is this
kind of Dennison he says you’re that
clever chap from Cambridge that solve a
puzzle so concretely can’t even
pronounce it which is the uncial Dickens
problem and that’s whether you make
anything halt
so Alan Turing then looked at this and
said well can you solve any problem
mechanically he said well if you can
solve any problem
you could actually take the halting
problem itself and see whether that’s
not and it actually turns out it’s a bit
like this sentence is a lie I’d say this
sentence is a lie is that true what if
it’s true it’s false if it’s false is
true and your head explodes right so you
said if you take the halting problem and
you apply it to itself you also get a
paradox and any time a mathematician
gets a paradox it means the thing not be
true so you trace it back and say okay
well unfortunately all too can’t exist
so what cheering had done is to say that
some things are not solvable by computer
this is so what some things are not
solved by computer but many things are
we do our Excel defenses we do a word
processors lots and lots of things are
solved what we really really want to do
is to be able to tell whether one
picture one piece of artistic creativity
is automatic like one on the left in our
one pieces is a true piece of human
creativity and this is quite a difficult
problem to solve and it’s really
unfortunately I think impossible to do
for something like art because what I
would need to do is I think to take your
brain and freeze it dissect it read out
the rules and then demonstrate piece of
art on the right had been created by
extending those rules in someone some
creative way and we just can’t can’t cut
people’s heads open in that way yet
maybe soon by the one place that you can
do it is in mathematical creativity so
there are a whole bunch of mathematical
problems around that we could kind of
think about but a good one to think
about is Fermat’s Last Theorem so Pyrrha
permit was a mathematician who lived in
the 15th 16th century and he did
mathematical puzzles for of fun he was
actually a lawyer for his jaw
and of course the paint TV so you had to
do kind of you know something to keep
you interested in the evening and he had
an old book from antiquity called
arithmetic ax and he would go through
all the puzzles in that there was all
things that were left by Pythagoras and
so on and he would solve these puzzles
and in the margin of the of his book you
would say oh well what you do is you
just kind of take a and B and you trick
and you know it’ll be fairly obvious how
you solve it and when he died his son
took that book he published that book
and then mathematicians for the next you
know seventy of years go through them
trying to repeat all the puzzles of
Fermat’s any taller and at the end of
that sort of period there was one puzzle
left and cheekily Furman had put them he
had a cunning proof of this puzzle but
it wouldn’t fit in the margin of his
book and it’s a very simple puzzle right
and the puzzle is if you remember three
four five trump girls from school
probably you either remember them or you
remember them with fear but way free
square passports burying spiced bad and
there are actually an infinite number of
whole number solutions to that right all
of these you know plotted out here and
Fermat said there are no solutions if
you do a cube or a fourth power or any
other power there’s absolutely no other
solutions and that was his and he said
he had a proof friend and that was his
theory I’m a smart theory and the
interesting question then that Roger
Penrose asked in his book was oh if
these problems are caused by human being
right does that mean that especially
creative in some way the problem though
is that at the time that that Roger
wrote the book we didn’t really know
whether Fermat’s Last Theorem was
provable it had been proven at the time
and we also didn’t know whether it was
accessible by a computer but in 1982 a
chap called Matty average Russian
mathematician showed that finding a
solution to Fermat’s Last Theorem is
part of non computable mathematics so
that means that if you could find it
you’d be able to solve the halting
problem and we already just proved to
ourselves you can’t solve the halting
problem so that meant that Fermat’s Last
Theorem is not solvable in a mechanical
way and then Andrew Wiles in 1905 solved
it so we’ve got a paradox so we’ve
proven the unprovable right something
that shouldn’t be possible to solve if
you’re a machine that we solved and the
only answer that I think you can
reasonably give is that Andrew Wiles is
not a computer right it’s normal she
okay what that means is that creativity
is special right that a human being when
they’re creative and I think that that
generalizes to all sorts of creation
that we do art and literature and
musical composition and so on I think
all of those fortunately I can’t prove
that mathematically but we cannot do it
for all the sort of mathematical puzzles
that we have so creativity is special
and then the interesting thing about
creativity is being special is that it
implies that our universe is special as
well because Andrew Wiles is software
running on the hardware of the universe
so if Andrew Wiles is able to solve non
computable puzzles our universe must be
non computable and therefore it’s not
being did by a computer and therefore
none of yours you are simulated you’re
all for real
[Applause]
is creativity special so creativity is a
relatively modern concept the Greeks
didn’t really sort of understand it when
they had a Greek play they imagined that
that was just documenting the human
condition and it designed a trireme that
was just an inevitable solid just like a
type of green solid but around the
release most time we started to accept
the creativity dimension it was like a
thing and often Leonardo da Vinci is
credited as the first inventor but in
1474 Venice enacted a patent Act and so
there were quite a lot of inventors
around at that time and then over the
next few centuries
invention we took off or at least with
documentation of invention and we ended
up where the postal system and
communications and flight and computers
with touchscreens which I was quite
involved in and then the World Wide Web
and all the things that are kind of
accelerated from there but what I want
to do I asked is really is it is it
really a special thing that’s creative
do you think or is it just something
kind of some ordinary could you automate
it you know is it a mechanistic thing
and that’s a sort of similar question
it’s a dual question with with whether
you can sort of simulate reality you
know if you can simulate we have an
beautiful then you can sort of simulate
creativity because creativity is a part
of what we do so I’ve got a bit of an
admission to make
I’ve actually simulated this half of the
audience okay so you’re all simulated
actually on largest computer and you’re
all real okay
and we we project I’d like hologram and
all these people here so not freak you
out so that’s why it doesn’t look empty
and by the way just before any of you
get any kind of weird ideas all the
usual rules law like if you come as a
cry and you’ll go to jail in the
simulation for the rest of your life
so no running amok and kind of you know
doing nutty things and of course and
then the problem is I set the production
up earlier I wasn’t my call which way
around the room with these so actually
you might be the simulation into my
dream okay and the question then is if
you’re sitting there wondering whether
you’re you know whether you’re really
doing things for real how would you test
it how would you know whether you were
something that was mechanical just
through the motions of creating
something or whether you were a real
thing really being creative so kind of
good analogy is if I said to you that if
you’re real right you can run up up
against the wall and do a handstand but
if you’re yeah if you all simulate if
you can’t you just get up run against
the wall do a handstand right okay I
can’t real and this is the question
about how can you tell something that’s
automatic and something that is so
creative and the question of whether
things were all kind of automatic with
questions that both mathematicians at
the turn of the last century and this
chap called
David Hilbert asked the question whether
everything that we have is could just be
simulated by a computer and two people
answered that question a chap called
Kirk girdle whose proof is quite
complicated and a chap called Alan
Turing now we all understand out
ensuring because because he invented the
computer is creating that proof and we
all using computers everyday and so his
thought was that when we go through some
me
or process like long multiplication fool
you learnt at school we write out the
numbers in a particular format and then
we add them all up and we carry and so
on and without any thought without any
creativity or intuition we just go
through the process he said well you can
imagine this as laid out as sort of as a
tape isn’t it as a sequence of those and
you could then generalize this and you
can do all sorts of things with it so
for example you could decide should I
fall in love with this person or not and
that would be just a sequence of
processes right
should I sort of fall in love with this
person yes or no it’s a decision problem
but there’s a problem with decision
problems because you can say well that
means should I fall in this putt with in
love with this person and you could be
waiting for the results to come out and
of course the thing can get stuck in a
loop blue screen or whatever and you
never get the answer you’d never know
whether you were supposed to do it or
not
and so Turing had this kind of really
better insight when she said that if you
knew if a process was going to stop or
not that would give you immense power
because what you could do is you can put
some programming and some input and if
you knew whether it was going to stop or
not you wouldn’t know the answers have
many puzzles so you could for example
put a program in and say will this stock
go up tomorrow and you can put in you
know Apple or whatever and into the
thing bolts you know it’s going to go up
and if it doesn’t it’s gonna go well
it’s not gonna do anything right you
could do that almost any question you
imagined and this was a this was a
puzzle actually if you’ve watched the
movie the imitation game this is this
kind of Dennison he says you’re that
clever chap from Cambridge that solve a
puzzle so concretely can’t even
pronounce it which is the uncial Dickens
problem and that’s whether you make
anything halt
so Alan Turing then looked at this and
said well can you solve any problem
mechanically he said well if you can
solve any problem
you could actually take the halting
problem itself and see whether that’s
not and it actually turns out it’s a bit
like this sentence is a lie I’d say this
sentence is a lie is that true what if
it’s true it’s false if it’s false is
true and your head explodes right so you
said if you take the halting problem and
you apply it to itself you also get a
paradox and any time a mathematician
gets a paradox it means the thing not be
true so you trace it back and say okay
well unfortunately all too can’t exist
so what cheering had done is to say that
some things are not solvable by computer
this is so what some things are not
solved by computer but many things are
we do our Excel defenses we do a word
processors lots and lots of things are
solved what we really really want to do
is to be able to tell whether one
picture one piece of artistic creativity
is automatic like one on the left in our
one pieces is a true piece of human
creativity and this is quite a difficult
problem to solve and it’s really
unfortunately I think impossible to do
for something like art because what I
would need to do is I think to take your
brain and freeze it dissect it read out
the rules and then demonstrate piece of
art on the right had been created by
extending those rules in someone some
creative way and we just can’t can’t cut
people’s heads open in that way yet
maybe soon by the one place that you can
do it is in mathematical creativity so
there are a whole bunch of mathematical
problems around that we could kind of
think about but a good one to think
about is Fermat’s Last Theorem so Pyrrha
permit was a mathematician who lived in
the 15th 16th century and he did
mathematical puzzles for of fun he was
actually a lawyer for his jaw
and of course the paint TV so you had to
do kind of you know something to keep
you interested in the evening and he had
an old book from antiquity called
arithmetic ax and he would go through
all the puzzles in that there was all
things that were left by Pythagoras and
so on and he would solve these puzzles
and in the margin of the of his book you
would say oh well what you do is you
just kind of take a and B and you trick
and you know it’ll be fairly obvious how
you solve it and when he died his son
took that book he published that book
and then mathematicians for the next you
know seventy of years go through them
trying to repeat all the puzzles of
Fermat’s any taller and at the end of
that sort of period there was one puzzle
left and cheekily Furman had put them he
had a cunning proof of this puzzle but
it wouldn’t fit in the margin of his
book and it’s a very simple puzzle right
and the puzzle is if you remember three
four five trump girls from school
probably you either remember them or you
remember them with fear but way free
square passports burying spiced bad and
there are actually an infinite number of
whole number solutions to that right all
of these you know plotted out here and
Fermat said there are no solutions if
you do a cube or a fourth power or any
other power there’s absolutely no other
solutions and that was his and he said
he had a proof friend and that was his
theory I’m a smart theory and the
interesting question then that Roger
Penrose asked in his book was oh if
these problems are caused by human being
right does that mean that especially
creative in some way the problem though
is that at the time that that Roger
wrote the book we didn’t really know
whether Fermat’s Last Theorem was
provable it had been proven at the time
and we also didn’t know whether it was
accessible by a computer but in 1982 a
chap called Matty average Russian
mathematician showed that finding a
solution to Fermat’s Last Theorem is
part of non computable mathematics so
that means that if you could find it
you’d be able to solve the halting
problem and we already just proved to
ourselves you can’t solve the halting
problem so that meant that Fermat’s Last
Theorem is not solvable in a mechanical
way and then Andrew Wiles in 1905 solved
it so we’ve got a paradox so we’ve
proven the unprovable right something
that shouldn’t be possible to solve if
you’re a machine that we solved and the
only answer that I think you can
reasonably give is that Andrew Wiles is
not a computer right it’s normal she
okay what that means is that creativity
is special right that a human being when
they’re creative and I think that that
generalizes to all sorts of creation
that we do art and literature and
musical composition and so on I think
all of those fortunately I can’t prove
that mathematically but we cannot do it
for all the sort of mathematical puzzles
that we have so creativity is special
and then the interesting thing about
creativity is being special is that it
implies that our universe is special as
well because Andrew Wiles is software
running on the hardware of the universe
so if Andrew Wiles is able to solve non
computable puzzles our universe must be
non computable and therefore it’s not
being did by a computer and therefore
none of yours you are simulated you’re
all for real
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: