Press "Enter" to skip to content

Adventures in Alkali Metal Chemistry | Declan Fleming | TEDxStGilgenInternationalSchool


this ladies and gentlemen is the
physicist Richard Feynman and he wants
describe science as an expanding
frontier of ignorance now the scientists
working on the front line not only of
their own frontiers of ignorance but the
frontier of ignorance of humanity itself
it can be a really daunting place to
exist staring out essentially intimate
at this a series of sites also have a
sense of being on their own expanding
frontiers of ignorance and our job as
educators essentially is to try and help
them to expand those frontiers why it’s
out there there are islands with
discoveries and possibilities for us to
perhaps go out and reach how do we get
there how do we expand our frontiers of
ignorance well it turns out that
scientists and students of science and a
very powerful tool and their disposal is
the question what it and I’d like to
share this evening a bit of a story to
do with what if my own personal what if
story and it concerns the alkali metals
these are the group of elements that
live on the left hand side of the
periodic table people tend to remember
them from school for their very dramatic
reactions with water we try and explain
the way in which they react using a
simple model to help us understand what
soil we imagine that we have small
positively charged balls we call ions
surrounded by negatively charged
electrons and the way that they sort of
hold this whole structure together is to
have these negatively charged particles
and the positively charged particles
attracting one another much in the same
way the advice rather than live on your
head and stick it up and as we go down
the group we find that actually that
these ions the atoms and serve they get
bigger and so we might predict that in
these reactions in which electrons are
lost from the metal we would expect
therefore as we go down the group just
like rubbing a balloon on your head and
holding it
further away from the wall it might fall
off it may not stick on to the wall at
all and in the same way these electrons
as we go down the group may be lost a
little bit more easily this is where I
began my what-if journey here’s me at
school with suspiciously similar hand
right into that of Richard Feynman the
returner and an obvious one if question
perhaps came to mind we’ve already seen
the reactants of lithium or sodium of
potassium and I wanted to work out we
were to put caesium in water surely
there should be a more exciting right
now my chemistry teacher much like me as
a chemistry teacher now hand over the
resources and nor the inclination to
demonstrate this to me but he did have a
video to help me to how to understand
what might happen if you had sowed into
water
thankfully we didn’t try that in the
classroom so yeah maybe caesium is gonna
react a lot more violently with water
but it turns out that with science it’s
not good enough to just do an experiment
once you’ve gonna try it more than once
and this is where I’d like to introduce
you to the team with the periodic tables
video channel from YouTube they wear the
University of Nottingham and they said
they wanted to repeat this experiment
you can see here they were a little bit
nervous about what was going to happen
they’ve got a contraption is not clear
we’ve got a hammer hanging from a wall
with a very long piece of string they’re
ready for something big to happen let’s
[Applause]
[Music]
[Laughter]
okay so that wasn’t quite as dramatic as
we just saw now at the time they put
this down to a bit of bad luck because
we know from the textbooks there this
reaction is supposed to go explosively
right I mean something something perhaps
must have gone wrong we better do this
reaction one more time let’s just for
comparison make sure we’ve got a clear
baseline to see what we’re looking at
first we’ll have a look at their
reaction of potassium on the table rest
should be less traumatic took them by
nearly took out perhaps an arm or leg at
the same time they then went back at a
right let’s get cesium right this one is
going to be big we’re gonna not just use
that same analysis in we have before
we’re going to throw in five times the
amount we’re gonna prime this little
puppy to go wait a second this guy Sam
back it’s gonna be when it’s men ago who
are explosively right those electrons
and stuff this further away that’s gotta
be what’s going on now for anybody who
has been paying attention something
isn’t adding up and somebody who was
paying attention a while ago back in
2006 was one of my chemistry heroes
feared of gray this guy is the sort of
guy who requires a large quantity of
sodium off of the ebay invites the
rancher a bunch of his mates and Roman
scientifically test
what’s going on with cesium this should
be big and once more he was disappointed
you can see him here with the
contraption that he made to definition
cesium this time under water to make
sure it was really all going it’s
supposed to be explosive right but he
asked himself after disappointment of
the disappointment of disappointment if
the reaction of cesium isn’t really that
violent despite what the textbooks would
say and his idea was remarkably simple
in fact I’ve been staring everybody in
the face because any school ever they
supposed to know that the atoms get
bigger as you go down the group but of
course they also get heavier which means
that if you have one promote lithium and
you have one whereas cesium if the
cesium atoms are heavier and you then
there are going to be fewer tons of
cesium
you’re going to produce less hydrogen
and therefore perhaps it might be less
explosive so we can see on my episode
Groff we love your ass in these poet
talks on the left-hand side the volume
was said the hydrogen that’s being
produced by the same mass of lithium
much greater than that of the cesium the
line going up here showing how much
easier it’s getting to remove these
electrons
Theodore’s idea I think that might be a
sweet spot here in the middle somewhere
sodium or potassium but there were two
weaknesses in his idea number one look
at the massive difference in the amount
of hydrogen being produced it can’t all
be down to that number two his idea was
that it was the hydrogen gas burning
causing the explosion let’s take a close
look at one of these reactions some
solid dropped in who know things no
oxygen the solid just atomizers
something else is going on here ladies
because as it turns out chemistry is not
just about the energetics of reaction
for those of you who owned any diamonds
I have some disappointing news for you
chemistry specifically the study of
thermodynamics tells us that all of
those diamonds right now are turning
into worthless pencil led graphite in
your purses right now thinking the row
three seat number four okay it’s not
about oh just whether or not it’s gonna
happen to these ladies diamonds down
here at the front it’s about how fast it
will happen actually as it turns out
nobody’s got anything to worry about
because this reaction to turn our
beautiful diamonds into graphite happens
far too slowly for it to be of any
concern for us this is where lithium
steps in and says I’m just going to take
my sweet time okay I’m going to produce
the most heat in the reaction I’m going
to produce the most hydrogen I’m just
not going to do it very quickly we’ve
got its buoyancy we’ve got its low
melting point which keeps its
temperature from getting too hot and
allowing the reaction speed up still
further we’ve got the fact that the
product is being produced from the
reaction dissolves the slowest it just
takes its time it’s not just down
the electrons it’s how fast we can get
them across here I found myself by the
edge of my frontier of ignorance it felt
pretty good hey all this stuff it may
seem as if it’s just simple textbook
stuff there’s a lot more to be thinking
about of course that led me back to my
original question when I was younger
I’ve been watching this video now
described literally I kid you not on
YouTube as the accurate version of this
reaction and being a bit of a chemistry
geek I spent some time tracking down the
guy who made it was a place in 50 years
ago now it was a bit confused as to why
this guy from Austria was was trying to
get in touch with him through about four
or five different people and he very
kindly agreed to go back and look at the
original footage again and every other
piece of footage that he gathered and at
that time decided to say that I’ll be
honest with you actually my impression
was and has always been that there’s
really no detectable difference between
rubidium and cesium we took a large
number of clips on that day the the
drama in that clip was purely a matter
of luck does it mean of course that
there was no reaction it’s just of
course we were going to put the best one
in the video we wanted it to be popular
so I asked myself well what if nobody
actually has any idea what’s going on
with these explosions because now
everything my entire world views been
torn apart so I started trying to work
out what’s going on with the actual
explosion then the traditional view has
explained here by Martyn Poliakoff again
at the University of Nottingham is as we
can see just at the bottom here it’s a
vapor explosion sounds fancy it’s very
simple actually what it is some very hot
stuff here we have some very hot salt
rapidly boiling water when the water
comes into contact with it that water
vapor takes up a lot more volume bursts
through the rest of the really hot stuff
bringing more water into contact with it
in this case boom that’s well and good
isn’t it apart from the fact that all we
need here is for some hot stuff it
doesn’t really matter when there
our electrons are easily lost or not but
we are seeing some kind of difference
going on with our metals and secondly if
we take a close look we have solid
potassium coming in here forget getting
hot enough to reach the superheat
temperature of water
it’s almost instantaneously exploding
but when I saw this video clip ladies
and gents I knew I had to get in touch
with the guy who’d been making it though
a guy by the name of phil mason who has
a youtube channel thunder and he’d been
experimenting with some high-speed
cameras and the alkali metals and the
reason that i got in touch was because i
had been furiously googling in the
meantime and what did I find I found a
paper back anything I could get my hands
oh this is from the 70s written by a
chap called Alan Ashworth for his PhD
thesis again Ashley with me enough at
the University of Nottingham and he’d
been looking at the reactions and sodium
and potassium particularly because
actually at the time we were interested
in their properties for use in nuclear
reactors and his idea based on his
entire PhD thesis was the electrons were
being lost from the surface of the metal
up into the water where they were
essentially dissolving a solution it
seems really weird we think of sodium
fluoride salts dissolving into water
colorless solution it turns out that
electrons can also dissolve in some
solvents the thing is when they do it in
water it tends to go with a bang
producing hydrogen and hydroxide ions
are incredibly vanishingly small speeds
but just in the seventies Alan Ashworth
caught a glimpse of blue blue the color
that we see when we see electrons
dissolved in solvent and this is why I
knew I had to get in touch with Phil
because when I was looking at his
high-speed footage look here just at the
moment of the explosion blue on the
right hand side just at the moment of
the explosion blue I think we’re seeing
a tiny fragment of the moment where the
electrons are being lost from the metal
being given to that water before we get
our bang I think we’re getting to the
crux of what’s going on with this
reaction we have a problem
and the problem is how the hell are
going to get these electrons fast enough
into the water to cause that explosion
because every time we do this we’re
giving up some gas which should be
separating the surface of the metal from
the place where we want our reactions to
happen the mint also is really hot also
helping to stop the water from the metal
making good contact and this is Phil’s
brilliant idea that was staying staring
us in the face the decades and decades
and decades and nobody thought to have a
think back to that GCSE their great hand
model of bonding what happens what’s
holding the structure together the
delocalized electrons negatively charged
attracting of positive ions if we move
those electrons out into the water we no
longer have those attractive forces
holding the structure together but we
still have the repulsive forces just
like too similar ended magnetic hauling
them close together the structure should
rip itself apart now there’s only one
way to know whether or not that’s going
to happen and that is see if you can
model it in real life so first of all
fill in his group they went to the
computers they were theoretical chemists
and they built a model of sodium atoms
here and blue surrounded by water
molecules there in red and within 10
picoseconds fantastically small period
of time their ball sodium had broken
down revealing spikes shooting out into
the surrounding water molecules can we
see this in real life well ladies and
gentlemen now thanks to a modern camera
technology we are able to see things
that fantastically small timescales and
Hill up in Braunschweig with his group
was able to get these images and you see
the fourth image down or the right hand
side followed by the fifth is the moment
where phil describes this ball of metal
turning into a hedgehog blasting it out
into the surrounding water increasing
its surface area ready to start a
reaction brilliant we’ve reached the
frontier of knowledge for Humanity but
the story doesn’t end there because
actually turns out that just because
something’s blue isn’t really good
enough for the scientific community to
be convinced
what you’re looking at is a solvated
electron they needed more proof and it
was around this time that I’ve got in
touch with these guys at the Frog and
pavo on the left here
Phills group leader was telling me that
he was receiving a bit of flack because
a guy Steve Brad bought who he described
as mr. Sol they to the electron we’re
saying basically listen listen pebble
just cuz it’s blue I’m not convinced you
need to do better and I said what’s
going on wait a minute we’ve known since
the 70s that solvated electrons have
been involved in these reactions oh no
where did you find that
well I’m Google and I just ran anything
I could get my hands on you guys well
that’s interesting because there’s
nothing in the the scientific literature
about this and like was I really been
able to get on to the expensive takes
places you guys have access to in just a
school teacher one owner I just read
this PhD thesis who’s then we need to
talk to this guy
so paddle set up a profiling and track
down Alan Ashworth and the call went
drive her through the trail windrow very
very quickly Sally
sadly appears Alan white there so we had
to go back and actually start again and
this is where Phil and his group went
once more up to branch Michael were able
to collect the fingerprint of this blue
color proving once it is a sort of aided
electron here we have reached the
boundaries of knowledge for Humanity
thank you very much ladies and gentlemen
we’re going to take the front cover of
one of the highest-ranked chemistry
journals on the planet with our solvated
electrons and inventor Kimmy last year
so they very kindly when they published
their paper gave me a cheeky little
mention down at the bottom
thanks mister
so what did Boyd have to do for me what
it took me from a school child ready to
step out into my boundaries of ignorance
through to the boundaries in the
frontier of ignorance of humanity itself
and the story won’t stop there because
the alkaline may have many many more
interesting properties to reveal to us
so I ask you guys what happens when you
ask what if where were your journey
thank you
[Music] [Applause]
Please follow and like us: