
have you ever met a conflicted farmer
good afternoon my name is Nathan Peltier
I’m a professor I’m a father and I’m a
conflicted farmer as a professor my
research focuses on the intersection of
food and sustainability issues as a
father of two I’m very much concerned
with how my children eat and the
connections that they have to food and
as a farmer I’m conflicted I’m
conflicted because I find myself in the
rather awkward situation where my
intuitions and my lifestyle choices with
respect to food and farming are actually
at odds with my professional knowledge
with the objective realities that my
research and the research of others is
my field are bringing to light I like to
describe this conflict with the hope
that my perspectives can contribute to a
very necessary reflection and a social
discourse in which all of us must engage
regarding our options with respect to
the future of food and sustainability so
to begin a question who cares about food
of course we all do after all food is
clearly central to our well being
it’s central to our health to our
economies to our cultures often even to
our individual identities accessing food
of sufficient quality and quantity
satisfies a basic human need and for
this reason is enshrined as a
fundamental human right we ought to care
very much about food and we ought to
also care very much about the
sustainability of how we produce and
consume food why
because food is also at the center of so
many of our most pressing sustainability
challenges activities in the food system
together account for as much as 90
percent of our fresh water demands
producing food occupies over 30 percent
of the terrestrial surface area of our
planet for this reason food production
is a critical driver of biodiversity
loss it’s responsible for the majority
of nitrogen pollution and as much as
one-third of greenhouse gas emissions
nonetheless looking forward in face of
increasing competition for these scarce
resources and the uncertainties of a
changing climate our food systems will
be required to produce enough food to
feed a population of over 9 billion
people by mid-century and perhaps as
many as 12 billion by century’s end so
what are our options in order to
sustainably feed this growing human
population back in the 1970s a biologist
at Stanford named Paul Ehrlich proposed
an equation to describe the factors that
together contribute to determining
humanity’s collective impact on the
environment Eric suggested that our
impact is a function of three
interacting variables population
affluence and technology and this
provides quite a useful way to think
about the sustainability impacts of how
we produce and consume food as well as
what are the major levers that we might
exploit in order to reduce those impacts
let’s consider each in turn
beginning with population this is simply
about how many mouths we have to feed
all else being equal the more numerous
we are the more food we have to produce
to sustain ourselves the greater the
impact we are currently adding mouths to
feed at a net rate of over 200,000
people every single day
but we don’t talk about population do we
other than to acknowledge that we have
to figure out how to support a lot more
people in the future population really
is a proverbial elephant in the room
but even if we did choose to seriously
address this variable which requires
opportunity for education and
empowerment of women in developing
countries this is a long game the second
variable affluence refers to what and
how much we consume it’s
well-established that with increasing
affluence we tend to see a shift towards
diets that are higher in sugars fats
refined carbohydrates and animal
products and as the developing world
continues to industrialize and the
global middle class expands this is
precisely what we are seeing
unfortunately more affluent diets also
tend to be less sustainable diets now
this variable we are a little bit more
open to talking about in the least we
are reasonably open to talking about
personal food choices not so much public
policy and the food space but individual
dietary choice and clearly there is no
end to dietary advice out there some of
it concerned with sustainability of all
the dietary advice that I’ve encountered
the most pragmatic comes from Berkeley
professor of journalism and food writer
Michael Pollan who simply advises eat
real food not too much mostly plants
from a sustainability perspective that
is solid advice to which I would add
don’t waste it globally one-third of the
food that is produced for human
consumption does not get eaten in Canada
that number is 40 percent and it’s
largely linked to food waste
at the retail and consumer level 40% so
the second variable is potentially very
powerful in enabling us to reduce our
impacts but it requires that we accept
to constrain our food choices and to
change our food behaviors based on
sustainability considerations either
individually through diet or
collectively through food policy for
many people this turns out to be a
surprisingly hard sell the third
variable that we have to work with is
technology in other words how we produce
food now this is the one that everybody
is comfortable talking about and I
suppose this isn’t surprising we are
after all the technological species we
tend to default to seeking to solve our
problems through technological means
what is somewhat surprising however is
that when it comes to food many of us as
consumers are actually often less
willing to put our faith in technology
many of us are in fact anti
technological with respect to food
embracing instead a a romanticized
vision of the past as a preferred model
for food production small-scale low
intensity localized production and
consumption our comfort with the how
question also reflects I think that this
seems at first glance to be the least
value Laden but I’d like to ask you to
question that assumption because in
truth our choices about how we produce
food have direct and profound
implications not only for what kinds of
food we can produce but how much of that
food we can produce and for whom that
food is ultimately available now we live
and consume in a context where we are I
enlarge oblivious to the stories behind
most of the foods that we eat and
because we so rarely have an adequate
basis for making informed choices
we make assumptions based on intuition
and good intentions about the
sustainability of different ways of
producing food of different technologies
for producing food we tend to believe
that sustainable food production looks
like this this is my farm aesthetically
it’s beautiful for me it provides the
connections to food that I want for my
family for my customers it provides them
with the story to food food that they
cannot some level relate to and connect
with this is the stuff of dreams for
foodies and local wars but is it a
viable is it a realistic model for
sustainably feeding the world 100 years
ago the average Canadian farmer produced
enough food to feed ten people today
that same farmer feeds over 120 people
within this century we need our farmers
worldwide who are dwindling in
proportion to produce enough food to
feed half again as many people more than
70% of which will live in urban centers
by 2050 so it might be reasonable to
idealize farms like mine to idealize
small-scale low intensity localized
production and consumption as a model
for sustainable food production if our
population was half a billion people
strong and stable but it is not we are 7
billion people strong and growing I love
because I know that farms like mine
the farmers like me cannot will not feed
the world not even close
unless we are willing to radically
tackle the population lever through
concerted investments in education and
empowerment of women in developing
countries which we clearly should and
unless we are also willing to radically
change what and how much we consume and
reduce how much we waste which we also
clearly should we have to stop
pretending the farms like mine are a
viable strategy for feeding the world we
do not have the land or the water or the
environmental assimilatory capacity that
is necessary to produce sufficient food
in this manner we cannot look backwards
for solutions to the challenge of
feeding the future we have to look
forward now this is not intended as a
carte Blanc for industrial a grievance
Inc the praises of modern food systems
for a variety of reasons productivity
variety affordability food safety and we
can find a lot to criticize we can do
better and we have to do better but if
technology is to be our only recourse
then it is absolutely imperative that we
prioritize highly efficient strategies
for food production based on the best
available technologies that may actually
give us a fighting chance of sustainably
feeding seven and then nine and then
twelve billion people so what options
what strategies are at our disposal that
could potentially help us to meet that
challenge of sustainably intensifying
and expanding agricultural production
first
precision agriculture and biotechnology
will be critical to continuing to
increase the efficiency of crop and
livestock production in face of climate
change the use of remote sensing big
data and related technologies that
enable us to tailor nutrient delivery
irrigation and pest management at the
micro scale will be among the most
important variables and sustainably
intensifying traditional agriculture
second we can also expect what are often
called disruptive technologies will
precipitate profound changes in how we
produce and consume food things that
were in the realm of science fiction not
long ago will likely become tomorrow’s
normal already advances in renewable
energy and material science are opening
up opportunities to produce food and
highly controlled environments where we
can close nutrient cycles exclude pests
recycle water shortened supply chains
and reduce wastes third we can also
anticipate that the role of many
traditional foods in our diets will be
increasingly challenged by new kinds and
forms of food five years ago we were
collectively scandalized by the world’s
first hamburger made entirely from in
vitro cultured animal protein
alternative protein technologies will
become major competitors in the food
space at the same time blockchain and
similar technologies will enable a new
kind of transparency with respect to the
stories of the foods that we eat now for
many this will not be the most
intuitively appealing vision for the
future of food nor the most romantic but
romantic feeds very few of us now and it
will not feed the future food stands at
the center of so many of our
sustainability challenges
food also stands at the center of our
well-being we cannot do without it and
it is incumbent on all of us as voters
as consumers as participants in society
to engage in this reflection to engage
in a social discourse to demand better
to support better time may be an arrow
with one direction but there are
multiple possible trajectories towards
our common future we have the luxury and
the awful responsibility of choosing
among worlds that might be isn’t it time
that we put our options on the table
thank you [Applause]
good afternoon my name is Nathan Peltier
I’m a professor I’m a father and I’m a
conflicted farmer as a professor my
research focuses on the intersection of
food and sustainability issues as a
father of two I’m very much concerned
with how my children eat and the
connections that they have to food and
as a farmer I’m conflicted I’m
conflicted because I find myself in the
rather awkward situation where my
intuitions and my lifestyle choices with
respect to food and farming are actually
at odds with my professional knowledge
with the objective realities that my
research and the research of others is
my field are bringing to light I like to
describe this conflict with the hope
that my perspectives can contribute to a
very necessary reflection and a social
discourse in which all of us must engage
regarding our options with respect to
the future of food and sustainability so
to begin a question who cares about food
of course we all do after all food is
clearly central to our well being
it’s central to our health to our
economies to our cultures often even to
our individual identities accessing food
of sufficient quality and quantity
satisfies a basic human need and for
this reason is enshrined as a
fundamental human right we ought to care
very much about food and we ought to
also care very much about the
sustainability of how we produce and
consume food why
because food is also at the center of so
many of our most pressing sustainability
challenges activities in the food system
together account for as much as 90
percent of our fresh water demands
producing food occupies over 30 percent
of the terrestrial surface area of our
planet for this reason food production
is a critical driver of biodiversity
loss it’s responsible for the majority
of nitrogen pollution and as much as
one-third of greenhouse gas emissions
nonetheless looking forward in face of
increasing competition for these scarce
resources and the uncertainties of a
changing climate our food systems will
be required to produce enough food to
feed a population of over 9 billion
people by mid-century and perhaps as
many as 12 billion by century’s end so
what are our options in order to
sustainably feed this growing human
population back in the 1970s a biologist
at Stanford named Paul Ehrlich proposed
an equation to describe the factors that
together contribute to determining
humanity’s collective impact on the
environment Eric suggested that our
impact is a function of three
interacting variables population
affluence and technology and this
provides quite a useful way to think
about the sustainability impacts of how
we produce and consume food as well as
what are the major levers that we might
exploit in order to reduce those impacts
let’s consider each in turn
beginning with population this is simply
about how many mouths we have to feed
all else being equal the more numerous
we are the more food we have to produce
to sustain ourselves the greater the
impact we are currently adding mouths to
feed at a net rate of over 200,000
people every single day
but we don’t talk about population do we
other than to acknowledge that we have
to figure out how to support a lot more
people in the future population really
is a proverbial elephant in the room
but even if we did choose to seriously
address this variable which requires
opportunity for education and
empowerment of women in developing
countries this is a long game the second
variable affluence refers to what and
how much we consume it’s
well-established that with increasing
affluence we tend to see a shift towards
diets that are higher in sugars fats
refined carbohydrates and animal
products and as the developing world
continues to industrialize and the
global middle class expands this is
precisely what we are seeing
unfortunately more affluent diets also
tend to be less sustainable diets now
this variable we are a little bit more
open to talking about in the least we
are reasonably open to talking about
personal food choices not so much public
policy and the food space but individual
dietary choice and clearly there is no
end to dietary advice out there some of
it concerned with sustainability of all
the dietary advice that I’ve encountered
the most pragmatic comes from Berkeley
professor of journalism and food writer
Michael Pollan who simply advises eat
real food not too much mostly plants
from a sustainability perspective that
is solid advice to which I would add
don’t waste it globally one-third of the
food that is produced for human
consumption does not get eaten in Canada
that number is 40 percent and it’s
largely linked to food waste
at the retail and consumer level 40% so
the second variable is potentially very
powerful in enabling us to reduce our
impacts but it requires that we accept
to constrain our food choices and to
change our food behaviors based on
sustainability considerations either
individually through diet or
collectively through food policy for
many people this turns out to be a
surprisingly hard sell the third
variable that we have to work with is
technology in other words how we produce
food now this is the one that everybody
is comfortable talking about and I
suppose this isn’t surprising we are
after all the technological species we
tend to default to seeking to solve our
problems through technological means
what is somewhat surprising however is
that when it comes to food many of us as
consumers are actually often less
willing to put our faith in technology
many of us are in fact anti
technological with respect to food
embracing instead a a romanticized
vision of the past as a preferred model
for food production small-scale low
intensity localized production and
consumption our comfort with the how
question also reflects I think that this
seems at first glance to be the least
value Laden but I’d like to ask you to
question that assumption because in
truth our choices about how we produce
food have direct and profound
implications not only for what kinds of
food we can produce but how much of that
food we can produce and for whom that
food is ultimately available now we live
and consume in a context where we are I
enlarge oblivious to the stories behind
most of the foods that we eat and
because we so rarely have an adequate
basis for making informed choices
we make assumptions based on intuition
and good intentions about the
sustainability of different ways of
producing food of different technologies
for producing food we tend to believe
that sustainable food production looks
like this this is my farm aesthetically
it’s beautiful for me it provides the
connections to food that I want for my
family for my customers it provides them
with the story to food food that they
cannot some level relate to and connect
with this is the stuff of dreams for
foodies and local wars but is it a
viable is it a realistic model for
sustainably feeding the world 100 years
ago the average Canadian farmer produced
enough food to feed ten people today
that same farmer feeds over 120 people
within this century we need our farmers
worldwide who are dwindling in
proportion to produce enough food to
feed half again as many people more than
70% of which will live in urban centers
by 2050 so it might be reasonable to
idealize farms like mine to idealize
small-scale low intensity localized
production and consumption as a model
for sustainable food production if our
population was half a billion people
strong and stable but it is not we are 7
billion people strong and growing I love
because I know that farms like mine
the farmers like me cannot will not feed
the world not even close
unless we are willing to radically
tackle the population lever through
concerted investments in education and
empowerment of women in developing
countries which we clearly should and
unless we are also willing to radically
change what and how much we consume and
reduce how much we waste which we also
clearly should we have to stop
pretending the farms like mine are a
viable strategy for feeding the world we
do not have the land or the water or the
environmental assimilatory capacity that
is necessary to produce sufficient food
in this manner we cannot look backwards
for solutions to the challenge of
feeding the future we have to look
forward now this is not intended as a
carte Blanc for industrial a grievance
Inc the praises of modern food systems
for a variety of reasons productivity
variety affordability food safety and we
can find a lot to criticize we can do
better and we have to do better but if
technology is to be our only recourse
then it is absolutely imperative that we
prioritize highly efficient strategies
for food production based on the best
available technologies that may actually
give us a fighting chance of sustainably
feeding seven and then nine and then
twelve billion people so what options
what strategies are at our disposal that
could potentially help us to meet that
challenge of sustainably intensifying
and expanding agricultural production
first
precision agriculture and biotechnology
will be critical to continuing to
increase the efficiency of crop and
livestock production in face of climate
change the use of remote sensing big
data and related technologies that
enable us to tailor nutrient delivery
irrigation and pest management at the
micro scale will be among the most
important variables and sustainably
intensifying traditional agriculture
second we can also expect what are often
called disruptive technologies will
precipitate profound changes in how we
produce and consume food things that
were in the realm of science fiction not
long ago will likely become tomorrow’s
normal already advances in renewable
energy and material science are opening
up opportunities to produce food and
highly controlled environments where we
can close nutrient cycles exclude pests
recycle water shortened supply chains
and reduce wastes third we can also
anticipate that the role of many
traditional foods in our diets will be
increasingly challenged by new kinds and
forms of food five years ago we were
collectively scandalized by the world’s
first hamburger made entirely from in
vitro cultured animal protein
alternative protein technologies will
become major competitors in the food
space at the same time blockchain and
similar technologies will enable a new
kind of transparency with respect to the
stories of the foods that we eat now for
many this will not be the most
intuitively appealing vision for the
future of food nor the most romantic but
romantic feeds very few of us now and it
will not feed the future food stands at
the center of so many of our
sustainability challenges
food also stands at the center of our
well-being we cannot do without it and
it is incumbent on all of us as voters
as consumers as participants in society
to engage in this reflection to engage
in a social discourse to demand better
to support better time may be an arrow
with one direction but there are
multiple possible trajectories towards
our common future we have the luxury and
the awful responsibility of choosing
among worlds that might be isn’t it time
that we put our options on the table
thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: