Press "Enter" to skip to content

What Were They Thinking? White Women and the 2016 Election | Charlotte Robertson | TEDxIthacaCollege


I was devastated

the next 54% of white women had voted

for a Republican candidate Donald Trump

and the media was out to condemn them

now the media was picking up on this gap

the gap between how white women voted

and how other American women voted as

you can see black women overwhelmingly

supported Hillary Clinton at 94% with

Latino women supporting her at 69

percent compared to them white women had

only voted for Hillary Clinton at 46%

now if you haven’t figured it out yet

I’m a card-carrying Democrat and as a

liberal white woman I was confused but

more than that I was curious what made

these women who looked like me vote for

a candidate who time and time again had

been labeled a misogynist well I was

determined to find out and as Donald

Trump was being inaugurated into office

in 2016 I took off on a research project

on my own so the first thing I wanted to

look at was at white womens various

identities it was obvious to me that the

country had assumed that white women

would vote based on their gender

identity however I hope that other

identities might be at play I decided to

use an in-depth interview method so

we’ve all taken a survey where none of

the actual answers match up with what we

really think our reply would be I was

hoping that this more conversational

style approach would really let me get

at why white women identified with

Donald Trump if they did

so I can’t different ages common they

were all white and they had all voted

for Donald Trump when I put out the call

for interviews I was actually really

surprised that he responded they were

people from my hometown of Charlotte

North Carolina they were relatives of my

friends and they were people from this

very college campus they came from a

wide variety of occupational backgrounds

they were agricultural workers and small

business owners they were students and

they were teachers I was quickly

realizing that they were my neighbors

and I’m here to tell you that they are

yours as much with people in the US like

to vilify people who have different

political backgrounds than ourselves

they’re still the same people that sit

with us let’s stand with us in the

grocery line so the thing that’s

different with them is they have

different lived experiences that have

shaped their different political values

today I want to talk to you about those

political values they’ve manifested

themselves in three different ways first

and what political issues white women

care about second and how they perceive

different candidates and third and their

partisan identity but before we can get

into any of that I have to let you know

something these women view themselves as

hard workers they think of both

themselves and their families as hard

workers and this identity has really

shaped all those political values that I

just told you about

they’ve also shaped which political

issues white women care about so the

women that I spoke to cared about two

different things first immigration and

no matter where women lived they thought

of undocumented immigrants as doing

something criminal and wrong

I had a retired schoolteacher in

Maryland tell me I just feel like the

laws and our country should be obeyed

I’ve always done what I’m supposed to do

while a single mother all the way down

in Texas said coming to her country

respectfully follow the law be like

every other person who is living here

legally does and you’re welcome and a

real estate agent all the way in New

York said we’re all immigrants but there

has to be a process and people just

can’t walk in here illegally so as you

can see it doesn’t matter if they came

from a border state or not they viewed

undocumented immigrants as rule breakers

and what do rule breakers do they take

from us so cultural sociologist Acker

Berg and Helpmann tell us that the

working class made us like immigrants

because they see them as competition in

the labor market while not all of the

women that I spoke to were part of the

working class almost all of them thought

of the American economy as a major issue

so they really believed in this idea of

the American dream now what that

basically means is that if we just try

hard enough people in this country can

accomplish anything they saw this as

being taken away from them a student

down in Arizona told me I think you

should work for what you want it’s not

fair for the people who work hard and

then get half of what they worked for

taken away by people who didn’t work as

hard so as you can see this identity of

being a hard worker continues to come up

again and again it continues to come

into play with how white women perceive

different candidates they saw Donald

Trump as a hard worker he was someone

who had worked his way up in the

business world and his business

expertise would be vital for the

American economy

however they thought of Hillary Clinton

as the antithesis of this in fact they

described her and what I like to call

the three

says sketchy shady and scheming they

thought of her and Bill Clinton as this

amoral political powerhouse and they

thought that she would be willing to do

anything to get to the presidency I had

some women even imply that she would be

willing to do something illegal I had

one woman tell me the Clintons have been

around they became very wealthy while

they were in government and government

doesn’t pay very well so time and time

again these women would talk about the

Clintons legacy of corruption but very

few of them actually mentioned specific

scandals I was sure that I was going to

hear about Benghazi or the email server

scandal however very few women actually

mentioned these another area in which

white women thought of the candidates

diverged was around the issue of Family

Values I had one woman tell me family to

me is everything and without it I don’t

know that you could have this success so

these women saw Donald Trump is quite

literally combining success with family

I had a small business owner from North

Carolina tell me that she liked how

Donald Trump included his family and his

business ventures as a small business

owner she was really hoping to keep her

own business within the family so these

women really liked that Donald Trump had

kept in touch with his children despite

multiple divorces they really picked up

on his relationship with Ivanka Trump I

had a woman from New York compare and

contrast Chelsea’s relationship with

Hillary Clinton to Ivanka’s relationship

with Donald Trump she saw Ivanka Trump

as a self-starter as someone who had

made it in the fashion industry by

herself while she labeled Chelsea

Clinton as riding on her mother’s

coattails another area and which these

identities of being a mother and being a

wife continue to come into play was

around the topic of Bill Clinton’s

infidelity

so this was brought up to me over and

over again and women that I spoke with

really thought that they really thought

that Hillary Clinton had only stayed

with Bill Clinton because of political

reasons and they saw this as a complete

power move for her they also thought

that it made her a poor role model for

her daughter Chelsea Clinton I had one

woman tell me I can understand standing

by your husband when he’s struggling but

he’s slapping you in the face you’re

raising a daughter and you’re showing

your daughter the wrong image to make I

would not have allowed my child to see

that so as you see even though Hillary

Clinton is a white woman a mother and a

wife these women that I was speaking

with still had trouble identifying with

her

so despite their deep dislike of Hillary

Clinton none of the women I spoke with

actually identified as part of the Farr

or alt right in fact they were all over

the political spectrum with many of them

identifying as moderates despite having

voted for the Republican Party they view

them in ways that I wouldn’t have

expected they saw them as judgmental and

stodgy and old-fashioned I had one woman

even tell me I don’t know how the tea

party group hijacked the whole

Republican Party I mean it just seems

that you can’t be a moderate Republican

or moderate Democrat anymore it just

seems very unpopular so they really had

this desire for bipartisanship they

wanted to see politicians reach across

the aisle and work together and someone

who votes on the opposite side of the

aisle I was actually really relieved to

hear this it was reassuring to know that

these white women that I was speaking to

want it unity in this time of division

so despite everything that I’ve learned

throughout this research my biggest

point is that there is a deep power and

listening

at the end of almost each and every one

of my conversations the woman on the

other end of the line would say thank

you thank you for just listening they

hadn’t felt comfortable talking about

their political values in their

classrooms and their offices and in

their communities in general and instead

of arguing with them point by point I

had taken the time to just listen and in

that time I learned about their greatest

fears and their deepest hopes for both

themselves and their families now don’t

get me wrong politics is personal when I

found out that Donald Trump had been

elected into office I felt like both he

and his supporters hated me and my

friends though I still don’t agree with

a lot of the political ideology of these

women I can now better understand where

they’re coming from

so the MU the liberal movement really

centers around this idea of sharing

experiences and understanding identities

however we don’t often offer up the

space to our conservative neighbors

there are days where I don’t want to

make this space the world is divisive

and there’s a lot of stuff happening in

Washington DC that I don’t agree with

but when I look back to who I was before

this project began I realized that my

attitude was often not productive so I

want to leave you with this question

tonight how do we create a new vision of

the future if we don’t even understand

half of America I don’t have a fix-all

solution for you just listening isn’t

going to solve the deep systemic issues

that plagued this nation however it is a

start and in this time of division we

could all use a starting point to unify

around thank you you

Please follow and like us: