Press "Enter" to skip to content

Violence: As American as Apple Pie | David Schmid | TEDxBuffalo


hi tonight I’d like to talk to you about
violence and here’s the first thing you
need to know I have locked all the doors
in this building there’s no escape
there’s no way out so let’s begin
joy our story starts with this man
Edgar Allen Poe in 1844 Poe published a
short story called the purloined letter
it was the third and final of three
stories the Poe wrote they all feature
his famous amateur detective organs
Japan as the story’s title implies the
subject of the story is a stolen letter
the prefect the Paris police cannot find
it even though he knows it was stolen by
the minister D and he knows the letter
must be in the minister’s apartment when
he asked you can’t find the letter Japan
finds it immediately how because he
knows the minister is so cunning he
would never hide the letter in any of
the places people ordinarily hide things
instead he does something different he
hides it in plain sight now I begin with
this story because I want to argue that
violence in American life today is
exactly like Poe’s purloined letter it’s
right in front of us but we can’t see it
we’re surrounded by violence in our
popular culture in the news media
everywhere we look we may be fascinated
by it we may be scared of it sometimes
both but we don’t understand it this is
where we need to take a lesson from
Poe’s detective we need to look at
violence from a different point of view
and then it will come into focus
to demonstrate this point we need to go
back to the Puritans now I know that
seems counterintuitive because surely
the Puritans had their minds fixed so
firmly on what it took to get to heaven
but they wouldn’t be interested in
violence in fact the Puritans were just
as fascinated by violence as we are
today and we know this because the
largest gatherings of people in the
colonial era happened when people got
together to watch public executions
Puritan ministers took the opportunity
to address such large numbers of people
to preach sermons telling the audience
how to understand the demise of the
criminal and when these sermons were
subsequently published they became very
popular and very influential as you can
see from this example published in 1675
the message of the sermon is spelled out
very clearly by the title and at the
bottom of the page there are biblical
passages that are designed to drive the
message home even more firmly now we can
learn two lessons from the crowds of
people that attended executions during
the Puritan era first there is never
been a golden age of American history
where violence has not taken place or
where we haven’t been fascinated by
violence so we need to give up on the
golden age idea and instead focus on
what’s happening today the second lesson
to draw is to think that when those
people were watching the executions and
listening to the ministers and deciding
how to understand the deaths of these
criminals they will also gain in a sense
of what defined their community what to
find their connections with each other
what defined their values to put it
another way we all know that violence
can destroy communities but the
era tells us that it can also build
community now you can see exactly the
same thing happening if we now
fast-forward to the 19th century and
look at the rise of the popular press
believe it or not at one time the
American newspapers did not routinely
cover crime and murder partly out of a
sense of delicacy and restraint
it might be worth repeating that at one
time American newspapers were governed
by a sense of delicacy and restraint
that all changed in the 1830s with the
rise of the penny press during this time
coverage of murder exploded
thanks Empire to highly marketable
crimes like the murder a prostitute
Helen Durrett in 1836 and of shopgirl
Mary Rogers in 1841 now as you can
imagine the publishers and the editors
of these newspapers came in for a lot of
criticism because of the lurid
sensational way in which they covered
these crimes but they defended
themselves by saying we are performing a
public service what service they said
they were educating the millions of
Americans who were in the process of
moving from rural to urban areas they
were educated in about the dangers of
rapidly growing American cities now of
course that argument is self-serving but
it also contains a kernel of truth that
I think it’s important to hold on to yes
violence and the way it’s covered can be
trashy it can be sensationalized but it
can also be educational it can teach us
about ourselves about the people around
us and about our society as a whole we
can see that same thing going on if we
now move again this time to the 1970s
and look at how the serial killer
came the preeminent criminal icon of
that era in many ways that process
begins with this man Ted Bundy who in
the late 1970’s and early 1980s became
the public face of serial murder a crime
that at the time was described by the
FBI and the media of being of epidemic
proportions
Bundy was convicted of dozens of
assaults rapes and murders in four
different states
some people believe he may have murdered
hundreds of women during a ten year
period the profile of the serial killer
rose even more after the publication of
Thomas Harris’s famous novel The Silence
of the Lambs and then more game when the
even more famous film adaptation
directed by Jonathan Demi appeared
starring Anthony Hopkins in an
unforgettable performance as Hannibal
Lecter we can learn a great deal about
American culture by thinking about how
and why the serial killer became a
celebrity and I would make that same
argument about the more extreme aspects
of that same phenomenon take for example
murderabilia murderabilia refers to the
online sale of artwork and the personal
effects of incarcerated serial killers
if you visit a web site like murder
auction calm you can purchase a wide
range of objects including paintings
drawings lessers even hair clippings and
fingernail clippings but perhaps one of
the most controversial items of
murderabilia is this this is a painting
done by a man called John Wayne Gacy
arrested in Chicago in 1980 subsequently
convicted of the murder of 33 young men
and executed in 1994 in his years on
death row he did a large number of paint
some of Disney characters and some of
clowns
and if you happen to have a spare 10 or
$15,000 you can go online and buy one of
these put it in your living room you’ll
have the ultimate icebreaker and yes
there’s yet another reason to be scared
of clowns
now obviously murderabilia is an extreme
and controversial example of violence in
popular culture and for that reason most
people are happy simply to condemn it
why because we don’t want to think too
much about what it means that men like
Ted Bundy and John Wayne Gacy can become
famous but remember Poe’s detective it’s
precisely at the moment when we are most
tempted to look away to bury our head in
the sand to pull the wool over our own
eyes that’s when we need to look at
violence more closely than ever
why one word fear many of you know that
rates of violent crime have been
declining in America for many years and
hopefully we’ll continue to do so in the
future but the rates of our fear about
becoming victims of violent violent
crime have remained remarkably
persistent despite all the evidence that
the majority of us are safer than ever
this has led to a condition that we can
call ambien fear by which I mean a
constant low level of underlying anxiety
that so many of us feel about
potentially being a victim of violent
crime and we’ve come to accept it as an
ordinary part of our everyday lives now
let me be clear I’m not discounting fear
entirely there are some circumstances in
which fear and caution are entirely
appropriate but I do believe that if we
consume and think about violence
differently we can not only reduce our
levels of ambient fear
we can also improve our lives and the
lives of others in both small and large
ways how can we do that first as the
famous critic Frederick Jamison once
said always historicize part of the
reason I’ve taken you on this
Whistlestop tour of American history
tonight is to demonstrate to you that we
have always been fascinated by violence
violence has always played a fundamental
role in our culture this means we do not
have the luxury of ignoring it or have
simply condemning it instead we need to
understand it we need to analyze it now
the second thing we can do is to make
sure that we have a balanced media diet
we all know we should eat a variety of
foods to have a healthy diet exactly the
same is true of our media habits if the
only show you watch is cops and the only
websites you visit a tabloid crime sites
in other words sources that routinely
over report and sensationalized crime
your levels of ambient fear are going to
go through the roof if on the other hand
you make varied and self-conscious
choices about the forms of popular
cultural violence you consume then you
can manage your fear but that’s still
not enough what we need to do is to look
at and think about fear differently for
example all of the instances of pop
culture violence I’ve talked about to
name our what the philosopher Flavio
Jack would describe as subjective
violence and by that he means violence
that we can see very easily because it’s
so visual what we need to do is learn
how to see what she goes on to describe
as objective violence that is the kind
of violence that is more difficult to
visualize and talking about poverty
about racism about climate change
these things may not be as visual as
murder but they are just as if not more
dangerous to our culture and perhaps
it’s those things we should be worried
about but that’s still not enough we
need not only to identify the sources of
violence but also do something about
them to transform fear into action there
are various things we can do we can
resist the gentrification of our cities
we can reject the politics of fear and
hatred by welcoming refugees and
immigrants as they begin their new lives
in America and we can protect our
environment whatever we do the point is
we are identifying the source of
violence we are pushing back against it
by forming connections with others and
we are transforming ourselves into
agents of change and that I believe is
the most effective response to the
violence that continues to be at the
heart of American life thank you
you
Please follow and like us: