Press "Enter" to skip to content

How Architecture can Revive Identity, Community and Purpose | Louis Smith | TEDxBeaconStreet


it can be said that church choirs street
gangs and sports teams survive and
thrive because they give their members
and supporters the same three things
identity community and purpose now I
believe this because it relates to
Maslow’s hierarchy of needs
the esteem belonging and
self-actualization are the top three of
Maslow’s hierarchy identity is a long
unrecognized aspect of architecture but
let’s start with purpose and we’ll hit
on community really lightly and then
after that we’re going to spend most of
our time on identity now purpose for the
individual is their choice of where they
want their life to go and what they want
to do that’s fairly simple but purpose
for a community is a little bit
different it’s about creating a richer
broader deeper experience of life
together it is about having cultural
experiences that enrich you and make you
more of a person and perhaps even
further your journey along in your
personal purpose now community is simply
any group of people who come together
around a certain issue something some
commonality they have it can be where
they live what they do their political
leanings the important thing about
community from this perspective is that
communities are malleable people come
and they go they change they form
different alignments but what is it what
is it
that
has identity relate to architecture and
sustainability well for that I got to
tell you where I come from I grew up in
the old North End of Detroit my parents
moved into the neighborhood because it
was a good neighborhood working-class
people mostly white and Jewish my family
was among the african-american dispersal
that caused Detroit’s white flight to
the suburbs I remember after the 1967
riots riding around in the family van
and watching building burn as I grew
older the vacant lots and the burn
buildings became more and more common
the places I used to go the breakfast
cafe the barber shop the candy store the
movie theater even some fine homes and
apartment buildings gradually
disappeared
it’s a shame it’s just a shame but that
disappearance was really my first lesson
in sustainability you see it wasn’t a
problem of the building’s not being well
built
they were finally built buildings in
fact included in that area were mansions
for the Dodge family yes that Dodge
family and other capitalists of the 20s
and 30s but it failed it failed because
the identity of the community failed the
identity had been a working-class
community free of african-americans
african-americans move in that identity
is broken people move out the community
fails but wait it continued to fail
because when the African Americans moved
in the economic base was undermined it’s
called redlining
they couldn’t get money to do the things
that need to be done to sustain a
community well there is an answer for
that
and the answer is that we need to be
sustainable and we need to broaden that
definition of sustainability so wait
wait wait wait what is sustainability in
our society sustainability is contextual
over here we have organizational
sustainability over there we have
industrial sustainability product
sustainability and in architectural
sustainability we have an evolving
definition back in the 70s when I was
studying architecture initially the
concern of the day was the Arab oil
embargo or multiple Arab oil embargos
and the price of fuel was skyrocketing
and everybody was concerned with energy
conservation as we went along through
the 90s the definition broadened and we
took insight sustainability stormwater
management access to transit and other
things on the block scale and larger in
the urban environment and then all the
other things that are listed on the
screen gradually got included in the
definition of sustainability and
although it’s last it’s really
consistent throughout is economic
sustainability if you can’t pay for it
it can’t stay now to those things I want
to add one more I want to add cultural
identity now wait wait wait wait don’t
be narrow I’m not talking about
ethnicity if you are building a building
for firefighters firefighters have a
culture it’s not the same as the culture
for nurses so what makes this identity
on September 7th of this year there was
an earthquake in Oaxaca Mexico that was
over 8 points on the Richter scale
many historic and traditional buildings
collapsed the Mexican architect
claudinha de Eva’s when interviewed by
Public Radio internationals the world
stated that she was shocked by the loss
of these buildings because it
constituted a loss of identity she said
many things constitute identity it’s not
just language clothing and food it’s
also the built environment the urban
surroundings I’m sure she said it in
Spanish so what makes a building
culturally relevant what gives it this
identity now Architects have a tendency
to design things for other architects
they have a tendency to consider
themselves great artists and many of
them are and they create works of art
that are twisty steel or towering glass
or whatever it is as a testament to
their ability as a visual artist some
architects take the other approach of
saying I want this building to be a
testament to my technological skill I am
going to program this computer to design
a facade and it’ll have 10,000 little
holes and precisely placed locations and
everything will be beautiful I want to
suggest to you that what architects
should do is that they should design a
building that reflects the identity of
the community they should design a
building that means something it’s about
culture this is my nomination as the
most culturally relevant building in the
US in the last 40 years this is the
Vietnam veterans memorial on the Capitol
Mall in Washington DC
it was designed by Milan an
asian-american I believe she was a
student at the time and it has become a
symbol an icon of our national grief but
why can we not have buildings that
express more than grief why can’t we
express joy celebration other emotions
this is my nomination for the second
most culturally relevant building this
building sits on the shore of Lake
Michigan it was designed by a Latino but
actually a Spaniard and his name is
Santiago Calatrava
and this building has a roof that is
designed to open and close and they do
this four times a day the roof emulates
the spread of a Gold’s wings on the
seashore which as it’s on the shore of
Lake Michigan there’s actually gulls in
the picture if you look really hard the
building is so evocative that they had
to publish the schedule for opening and
closing on the internet they made this
image of the building part of the city
of Milwaukee’s City logo well that’s
great for Milwaukee and that’s great for
Washington but but what’s the way that
we can get to having buildings with
meaning in our communities well the
first thing we have to do is that all of
us especially architects but all of us
must learn to see culture it’s starting
with our own now you probably say well
you know of course I see my own culture
and most people think that until they
get in contact with another culture and
they find out oh I never realized that
the way I do this doesn’t have to be
that way the second thing we have to do
is you have to take all the the relevant
cultural groups that this building is
supposed to represent and have them
participate from the design through the
construction so that the building is not
just some building somebody did it’s
their building the third thing we have
to do and all of us need to do this
is that we have to stop and learn and
look at the culture of the people it’s
being billed for we have to learn to see
their culture culture is very in very
basic ways it can be as simple as what’s
a good color or good colors and how do
you put them together what’s important
about anything is it more important that
a building Express privacy or community
is it more important that a building
express story or silence or is it more
important that it it conformed to a
style like modernism or Victorianism is
it important that it express a
technological miracle if you will there
is something about a living culture that
resists being crushed down to a set of
rules that one can program into an AI
and turn out meaningful buildings and
the problem with that is that real
culture is alive real culture grows it
evolves so whether you live work in play
whatever building that is ask yourself
these three questions does this building
take my past into account honor my
ancestors does this building take my
present into account does it have my
spirit now in my perspective on life
does it take my future into account does
it contain my aspirations and where I
want to go if you have a building that
cannot you cannot answer yes to at least
one of those things then will you love
that building is there is there going to
be a reason for that building to stand
if there is it doesn’t matter how
well-built technically a building is if
there is no love for it that building
will fall so
let’s finish up with a little refresher
on Detroit all of these things that I’ve
said should be part of sustainability
are in fact necessary you have to go
beyond the technological you have to
include the social the economic and the
cultural and it’s only when you do that
that you create enough value that that
building can stand for the ages
now Detroit is on its way back its
resurgent and many cities across the
country have had the same experience
from the disinvestment to the resurgence
new economic basis new people even
refugees coming in making a difference
Detroit is on the way to forging a new
identity a sustainable identity one that
includes identity community and purpose
thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: