Press "Enter" to skip to content

Searching for Extraterrestrial Intelligence | Erik Zackrisson | TEDxUppsalaUniversity


[Applause]
have you ever looked up at the night sky
and wondered whether it might be
intelligent life out there perhaps
another civilization well I certainly
have as an astronomer it’s pretty much
in my job description to try to sort of
crack the mysteries of the universe and
this problem the one about
extraterrestrial life has been with us
for a very very long time and it remains
unsolved we don’t know exactly how long
people have been thinking about this
stuff but we can trace speculations on
life in outer space at least back to
antiquity so a couple of centuries BC
compared to our ancestors however we are
in a privileged position thanks to the
very large telescopes that we have today
we are in a much better position to get
an answer to whether there is life in
outer space than all the iterations that
I’ve come before us so today I’m going
to tell you about new ways to search for
our cosmic neighbors it wasn’t that long
ago that SETI which stands for searching
for extraterrestrial intelligence so
basically intelligence beyond Earth was
considered something of a no-go area in
science generally very bad for your
career but this is changing and it
mainly has to do with discoveries that
have been made by the astronomers that
study exoplanets so exoplanets are
planets outside our own solar system so
in the early 1990s we didn’t have any
secure detection of any planets outside
the solar system but now we have
thousands and this has sent ripples
through the scientific community and
basically transformed the way we think
about the universe and our place in it
so we now know that there are lots of
rocky planets out there we also know
like the earth we also know that some of
these planets are at the right distance
from their host stars to sustain liquid
water on their surfaces and we call
these planets habitable and these ones
are important because at least on our
own planets planet Earth
all life that we know of relies on
liquid water so we have found lots
lots of habitable planets out there so
if we take everything we know about
exoplanets and combine this with
everything we know about the universe on
large scales we can estimate that there
are on the order of a billion billion
habitable planets in total in the
observable universe now that number is
huge it’s so large that it’s very very
difficult to wrap your head around so in
strong way we sometimes use the analogy
of sand so let’s let’s imagine that
you’re sitting on some lakeside beach
about the size of that one and you’re
putting out you’re picking up a handful
of sand at that point you’re holding on
the order of a million grains of sand in
your hand so that’s number it’s not even
close to this one in fact there are more
habitable planets in the observable
universe than there are grains of sand
on that entire beach okay so what this
means is that unless the probability for
the emergence of intelligent life on a
planet is very very very small then we
should have cosmic neighbors out there
somewhere it doesn’t mean however that
the aliens have to be nearby or easy to
find so how do we search for our cosmic
neighbors well it all started with
searching for communication signals back
in the 1960s so back then people were
using radio telescopes like this one to
search for communication signals sent
from other civilizations a couple of
decades later people started to look for
laser pulses as well but in both cases
you’re basically looking for the cosmic
equivalent over hello and in more than
50 years of searching no cosmic hello
has ever been received I don’t I mean
don’t get me wrong I think this is an
important endeavor I think it needs to
be allowed to continue but so far it is
led us nowhere and there may be several
reasons for this maybe the aliens are
too far away to communicate with us
directly or maybe they basically
consider us to be too primitive to be
worth communicating with if this is the
case then there is no no real hope in
this type of search luckily this is not
the only game in town
so I myself I’m involved in another kind
of city where we’re not searching for
communication signals but rather for
alien technology science that the aliens
have built something in outer space so
what sort of technology might aliens
have and now I need you to think big
okay there is no reason to suspect that
another civilization will be at exactly
the same technological level as ours as
us they could be thousands perhaps even
millions of years ahead of us so we need
to consider stuff straight out of
science fiction okay and the way we do
this is basically a three-step process
step one is we try to imagine the sort
of technology that the aliens can have
and then we try to figure out if this
technology exists how would this
actually affect what we see in our
telescopes that’s step two step three we
actually set out to look for those those
effects in our astronomical data so I’ll
give you an example this is a so-called
Dyson Sphere so this is a theoretical
construction is named after the
theoretical physicist Freeman Dyson who
came up with this in 1960s so basic the
basic idea is that this is something
that you build around your whole star
the Sun in our case in order to harvest
energy in the form of star light the
amount of energy emitted in the form of
light from stars is enormous so in the
case of our solar system some of that is
hitting earth and keeping us warm but
most of it is just lost from the solar
system if we could somehow tap into just
a tiny tiny tiny fraction of that we
would have access to more energy than
produced by all the power plants on
earth and the Dyson Sphere is designed
to do that so there are different
versions they’re different designs for
darkness figures but basically you build
a very large number of satellites where
each satellite is equipped with a very
large solar panel that collects
starlight so in this particular case you
have placed satellites on rings around
the Sun so the Sun would go in the
center of this structure so you might
ask okay so this collects a lot of
energy what would the aliens use this
energy for and we don’t know of course
but I could use it to fuel
colonies in part of the solar system
that would otherwise not be able to
sustain life they could use it for power
vessels colonization waves either on
interstellar scale so in between stars
perhaps even on intergalactic scales
which is in between galaxies it’s also
been argued that they could use this to
power some sort of cosmic scale
supercomputer for some serious number
crunching I myself am using this
telescope gaya to hunt for Dyson spheres
so when most people picture of telescope
they think about something standing on
the earth but Gaia is a space telescope
so it’s been launched and it’s actually
in the space and it’s actually orbiting
the Sun right now now the main goal of
Gaia is not to hunt for aliens but we
believe that this can be done and this
is how it works
so if we assume that we have a star and
we cover it with a Dyson Sphere so lots
of satellites covering the surface then
it will become fainter and fainter and
fainter as I add more and more
satellites that block the light at least
if I consider the sort of life that the
human eyes is sensitive to this actually
interferes with one of the standard
methods of estimating distances in
astronomy
so in astronomy in general if I know
what sort of star I’m looking at I know
how much light is emitted from this
every second and how faint or bright
this orbit appears in my telescope on
earth just depends on how far away of
this so the distance from our telescope
to this is what determines that the
problem is that if I cover this with a
dyson sphere it will become faint for
reasons that have nothing to do with
distance so usually if the star is
nearby its appears bright to us if it’s
far away
it appears faint but if I cover it with
a dyson sphere it will appear to be
further away than it actually is because
it’s faint the beautiful thing about
Gaia is that it allows us to estimate
distances to stars in a way that has
nothing directly to do with the
brightness so if this standard
brightness brightness method of
estimating distance tells me that this
particular star is far away but Gaia
tells me that no it’s actually nearby
I may have found a good candidate for a
Dyson Sphere and Gaia provides us with
enormous database that we can use to
search for these effects
so eventually Gaia will provide data
catalog with around 1 billion stars and
large databases like these are becoming
more and more important in astronomy
so astronomy has entered the so-called
Big Data era and it’s estimated that in
the coming decade we will have on the
order of 100 billion objects in our data
catalogs and this provides a very bright
future for this type of SETI we
basically imagine the technology and
then we set out to look for it in our
astronomical databases there’s just one
problem what if we simply don’t have
what it takes to imagine the sort of
technology that aliens might have no
matter how hard we try so I remember
once giving a talk on Saturday pretty
much like this one where I was trying to
impress the audience with these great
telescopes that we have today in this
enormous databases and afterwards this
elderly gentleman came up to me and I
could tell from the expression on his
face that he simply wasn’t impressed and
here’s what he told me imagine that
you’re living on Earth some 10 or 20
years twenty thirty thousand years ago
so during the Stone Age what sort of
fancy future technology do you think you
would envision and I have to admit I was
a bit dumbstruck I didn’t know to answer
so he sort of helped me along and I said
we’ll kind of make sense to wish for
things that would make life easier for
you right so maybe your wish for a fire
that would never go out maybe you wish
for a cave that members of rivaling
tribes wouldn’t be able to enter for
some reason or maybe you wish for a way
to communicate with members of your own
tribe if they’re off hunting somewhere
very distant and all that we made very
that made sense to me but then he sort
of smiled and put his hand into his
pocket and he said do you think you
would ever end up envisioning something
like this in our ways pocket he takes a
cell phone charger and I had to admit
know if I was living during the Stone
Age I would probably not envision that
sort of technology and that was exactly
his point
so basically wishing for something and
envisioning the sort of technology it
takes to make that wish come true or
very different things and certain things
are very very difficult to envision
until some other discoveries or
inventions are already in place so in
this case electricity and cellphones so
there is a limit to the sort of future
or alien technology that we can envision
given our own technological level and
this leads to a bias you see so when we
normally hunt for alien technology in
outer space we usually end up searching
for things there are extrapolations of
things we already have so if you
consider the Dyson Sphere for instance
if you think about that carefully it’s
really just a piece of technology we
already have a solar cell or a solar
panel just blown up to GOG antek
proportions and I basically think that
if you want to we have to ask yourself
the question would we really be able to
identify or understand the technology
that has been made by civilisation that
lies thousands or even tens of thousands
or millions years ahead of us and I’m
not so sure that we would so imagine
that you are an insect that has somehow
made it onto the circuit board of a
modern computer maybe you would notice
that this is a strange environment but
you would have no way of figuring out
what this piece of technology was for or
why somebody might build it on a cosmic
scale we might be no better off than
that insect so there’s a problem here so
how do we search for really really
advanced technology if we basically
agree that it’s you know doubtful
whether we would be able to understand
it and maybe there is a way so may may
be the way is not to look for specific
technologies but just to look for weird
stuff in outer space you can imagine
that some advanced alien tickets
civilization might be able to sort of
modify entire astronomical objects moons
planets stars perhaps even you know
entire galaxies through some fancy
astroengineering
and if that is the case those objects
may end up with properties that are very
different from natural astronomical
objects
and one way to find those is to look for
outliers in our enormous astronomical
data catalogues now in most cases the
outliers will have nothing to do with
aliens in fact in the the standard
assumption should be that it’s not
aliens the aliens should only be your
very last resort once every other
possibility has been ruled out but
spending time on looking at the outliers
it’s not a waste of time because even if
we don’t discover aliens we might learn
more about unusual astrophysics or the
universe in general so it’s not wasted
[Music]
there is also another way and that is
not to look for the unusual but to look
for the impossible so this is a famous
quote by the science fiction author of
the C Clark and it goes any sufficiently
advanced technology is indistinguishable
from magic
to one so one way to look for really
advanced technology is to take this code
quite seriously and look for magic in
outer space so how do we do that
we basically take our data catalog and
we have used yet the catalogs and then
we make a little list of all the stuff
given our knowledge about exoplanets
astrophysics cosmology and so on would
not expect to find in that database so
we basically make a list of stuff that
would seem to violate the laws of
physics and then we look for that if we
don’t discover something then we might
be on to something really interesting so
this there is a nice example of this so
this is these are some results from a
colleague of mine
Beatrice vrl who has been looking for
disappearing stars so stars shine for a
very long time the lifetimes of stars
are somewhere between three million
years and more than a hundred billion
years so for that reason the night sky
tends not to change very much during the
course of a human lifetime in fact the
vast majority of stars that you can see
in the night sky today
we’re also visible when the first humans
walked on earth now there are stars that
vary in brightness and there are stars
that explode but you do not expect two
stars just vanished without a trace
without any sort of fireworks but what
if they do
so Beatrice set out to look for these
effects in some very old data catalogues
and compare them to more modern ones so
to the left here you see an image from
the 1950s of a small patch of the sky
where I have marked five objects most
likely stars to the right you see a
negative image of the same patch of the
sky where one of the objects is gone
that’s not expected to happen now
personally I don’t believe that this has
anything to do with aliens but this is a
nice example of the sort of stuff that
we should keep an eye out for so SETI
searching for extraterrestrial
intelligence is usually considered the
most extreme form of a high-risk high
gain endeavor in all of science and some
people would even say that it’s more
related to science fiction down to
astrophysics on the other hand a few
people would contest that if we one day
were to detect an alien civilization and
this would be one of the greatest
discoveries of mankind ever we don’t
know how long we have to keep up the
search though it might be for a very
very long time so from that perspective
I think it makes sense to do this in the
cheapest most sustainable way possible
and I think the road forward is to use
this enormous astronomical databases
that we are getting in coming years so
these databases have been compiled very
general science goals and we will have
them regardless of whether we choose to
do use use them for setting so if we
will have these databases anyway doesn’t
it at least make sense to take a quick
look at what sort of weird stuff might
be hiding inside personally I think it
does thank you
thank you very much Eric
Please follow and like us: