
thank you for the introduction Ruben hi
I’m Patrick and yes you already heard I
do research in videogames and today I
would like you to follow me
together with Andre andreas a teenager
from Sweden and he’s playing World of
Warcraft and he’s really good at it
he’s so good in fact that he together
with 30 other guys venture into the last
level of World of Warcraft as it was at
that point to kill giant lava monsters
inside a really big evil volcano right
turns out that the lava monsters however
are not the biggest challenge that angry
antis 3839 companions are facing there’s
a problem with the interface design of
this game and the problem is that World
of Warcraft previously as this big
online title still only really supported
playing in groups up to 5 players that
meant that the interface was really only
built to give you information about
those other 4 dudes or players in your
party and now all of a sudden when you
were playing with 40 that was a bit of a
problem because if you were for example
leading that group you didn’t really
know what was going on with the other
players in your party where they dying
was everything okay you were sort of
bleeding blindly and especially if you
were for example somebody who’s keeping
your your team members of life that was
hard to do because you never know who
was about to die whom do I need to save
here this was something that Andre
together with another author fixed they
built an add-on which is a small piece
of software that runs on top of World of
Warcraft and that you can see here up in
the left corner and that exactly that it
does exactly that it gives you this
information about all 40 members of that
party so now you have all this
information that you need in order to
play these huge levels it was so
successful and so needed in this current
state of the game that this a little bit
shy Swedish teenager had just built a
piece of software that was used by
millions of players so it spread widely
it was the way of playing that
particular game so when I first
encountered World of Warcraft that was
also around the time that I moved to
Sweden I started studying in Uppsala
University and I actually came here for
my girlfriend at the time um it was a
little bit tricky to just move to
another country like that I didn’t speak
Swedish yet I didn’t have so many
friends and it was also a little bit
lonely so at that point I also played
World of Warcraft in order to keep
connected to people back at home and
Germany to speak German and also in
order to have the possibility of
experiencing myself as somebody who is
still social who can be a leader in a
group or who can deal with still with
other people and help them with problems
even though I didn’t have a such big
established social circles yet in Sweden
so I had a very positive first access in
that case to the game um in case you’re
wondering coming here to follow a girl
it did turn out well you know so we are
we made a for for more little gamers
they soon will be able to beat me in any
game out there and I’m painfully aware
of that so I have to sort of savor my
last moments of actually being able to
win anything but yeah when I played
World of Warcraft and that’s an actual
screenshot of me playing ungrazed
creations or derivative stuff of those
where everywhere in the game you also
see that I am really really bad at
creating sort of nice and functional
interfaces this is a mess right and this
is actually how I plate so I’m there in
the middle some bird it’s just a little
elf person standing in front of this
giant spider and absorbing the blows and
had shielding my my group members and so
that they they give me a life and
hopefully kill the itsy-bitsy spider we
will see it a bit so but that’s how I
played but you can see similar interface
features to Andres add on everywhere in
this there’s two of them on the left I’m
not sure why I had too much you know
kept them around another one down here
this is why it became such a mess but it
shows that these sort of interface
features were just a staple of playing
the game they were so different versions
of them and really everybody just just
used them because they were super useful
and they were just a part of what was
world a world of warcraft at that point
so the questions that came to me then
from also a scholarly perspective and
when they were seeing that us wow this
is really a big part of this game so how
far does this co-creation go how much of
this game is
actually in a way made by players and
then as the next step and that is of
course the critical social science
perspective here
do these coke here just get credit for
that work if they pick up so much and do
so much and in making a scam before we
follow these questions a quick word on
games research in general and games in
our society games have become really a
central part of contemporary culture
starting out from casual games
let’s see Hanson who in this room does
play anything any casual games maybe
Angry Birds candy crush minecraft I
think that’s the majority like most of
us especially with more casual things
thank you very much most of us have some
sort of connection to that or maybe our
your children or younger relatives play
these games all of these three titles
actually Nordic titles so the Nordic
countries are also very central and
really well fight a box above their
weight in global creation of digital
games but of course we also have the
more hardcore titles like for example
counter-strike which is a shooter game
that is so central to eSports for
example that it can fill entire stadiums
and in Swedish events like dream egg for
example is doing just that or a title
like League of Legends League of Legends
is oftentimes handled as the game with
the most players globally last year
League of Legends had 100 million
monthly players just taste that number
for a second one or a million monthly
that’s not one person counted twice
they’ll certainly virtual people and so
that that is round the size of the
population of Sweden Denmark Norway and
Germany
that’s a bubbling that’s sort of the
League of Legends population so this is
how many people are playing this and in
the same way it’s eSports subculture
where people play competitive against
each other and establish teams is
filling stadiums there’s a streaming
subculture where people watch these
games from far away and their computers
that is recently discussed to be
overtaking in global viewership analog
sports viewing
this is of course a little bit difficult
to measure but it looks like that games
and games culture are here to stay and
are a central part of contemporary
culture I also included a picture here
from tecnica Massey at the Swedish
Museum for science technology that had a
games exhibition a while back and we’re
still games are clearly recognized as a
part of contemporary culture and that we
need to maintain conserve and see as
something valuable in our everyday life
but let’s get back to Andre and his
story so at the top at the point where
the creators of World of Warcraft were
about to release the second version of
the game they weren’t so happy with how
the add-on culture had turned out
because they felt that add-ons were
taking over too much of the players
decisions and they thought about
removing them altogether but what they
did instead is that they invited central
add-on creators like for example Andre
and put them in a plane and flew them
over to California to their headquarters
and asked them to build an
infrastructure that would make it
possible for add-ons to continue
existing but limit what they would be
able to do in the game and that’s what
they did
so for Andre of course this was awesome
I mean he’s like this young enthusiastic
guy and now this company who makes the
game that he loves they pay his fly to
come over and help them work on it of
course he goes right that’s great for
him and so do many of the other add-on
creators and they come and build this
infrastructure after the specifications
of the company and basically sit there
and in the same space where the other
employees of the company work and code
and built an infrastructure that just
like that with that code goes into the
game so that is the maximum amount that
I have ever seen of how far play player
co-creation of games can go right at
this point you can’t even really
distinguish it any more from other kinds
of making a game right the only
difference between Andre as a player
co-creator and company employees is that
one of them is on the payroll of the
company and the other isn’t otherwise
they are sitting at the same place and
doing the same
so this is sort of the most extreme case
as an answer to the question of how far
does player co-creation go in these
games however this is not a lonely case
while it might be the most extreme that
I managed to dig up this player
co-creation as a phenomenon is
everywhere all over gaming culture those
big titles with millions of players that
I mentioned at the start counter-strike
League of Legends another one would be
the game dota that is quite similar they
are based on player creations to start
with their main idea that design that
has then been taken and been further
developed by for-profit companies that
comes from players who build this game
mostly as a modification for example
dota was first developed as a
modification to Warcraft 3 and
counter-strike was developed by two
motors as an alternative method to the
game half-life but these game designs
that then have proliferated so much and
spawned these huge eSports communities
they are based on players creativity so
what about the second question do
players get credit for what they do well
sadly here that’s a little bit more
sobering when we look at andreas story
he had to sign a nondisclosure agreement
together with the other add-on
contributors as well that meant that his
involvement in World of Warcraft was to
be kept a secret he did not get to put
on a CV his name was not in the credits
that rolled at the end of the game
instead he had to not tell anyone about
it
luckily now that expired so he was
actually able to tell the story but this
credit was not given in this case for
their contribution so we can see that
co-creation
is a central aspect of contemporary game
creation however there’s also a huge
imbalance in power here because the
player creators who put in their work
don’t really have the possibility to
stand up for themselves
maybe defend some sort of influence that
they want to have instead the most of
the power belongs to the company who
owns it
has control over the technological
infrastructure meaning that player
creators largely work under some sort of
Damocles Ian sort they don’t really know
if depth work that they put into that to
make this game into something better
something worse but they want to have
but what their community wants that
their their creative participation here
if that is going to stay around or if
maybe the company decides to kill it
tomorrow that is the possibility right
so also aster to bring the understory to
an end nowadays he doesn’t look quite as
favorable on his involvement in World of
Warcraft anymore but he feels that now
as a seasoned software engineer that
what they got with those player creators
got for their involvement was two years
free playing World of Warcraft so for
two years they got to play the game for
free that they were involved in building
right that was quite a bargain for the
company making the game to get these
amazing people that millions of users of
their add-ons already right so it’s a
little bit more nuanced perspective on
that than just enthusiasm there of
course ways out of this not all of them
are necessarily straightforward but a
good starting point could be to do
something about this power imbalance and
treat player creators as partners that
get some bit more of say of what is
happening with also the work that they
have put into something we have examples
for this happening and again and I’m
using most of these examples out of
World of Warcraft not because that is
the game where that happens a lot or
that is the worst case not at all this
is just because this is my field side
right this is what I knew well and that
is where I collected my data this is
really an issue for the entire industry
or for entire games as a culture or
maybe also other media but then I also
want to be fair and show positive
examples from that game and one of the
most positive examples are add-ons for
accessibility this is an initiative by
both the add-on player community and the
company who runs the game to make
modifications to the infrastructure that
allow piglia players with disabilities
to still play the game so this is not
sold or anything this is just made for
people to need it so that they can also
participate in the game a simple example
is down here the move pet Plus which is
an add-on that gives you virtual buttons
that you can press with the amount so
that you can move your character in the
game and that
people change makes it possible for
players who can only use one hand to
play with their friends otherwise they
couldn’t have done that because they
would have still needed the keyboard and
the mouse at the same time so now
players like that they can also be part
of what of Warcraft and play with their
friends together and this is just one of
number of examples that are part of this
add-ons for accessibility initiative so
some really amazing examples of this
open partnership between the company who
owns the game and the player community
who co creates it then giving credit
where credit is to put the names of
players into your credit roll if they
participate in the game there’s no clear
reason for keeping this a secret and
that would be a really big step for
giving them the possibility of showing
what they actually have done and being
honest about who participated in making
a scheme but the question that maybe
remains for some of you is why does this
matter is this about some nerds not
getting their names into the credit card
credits because they made a game now
that it has a little more Prader
implications than that this is also
about our culture we have already
established that games are a central
part of contemporary culture with
hundreds of millions of players this is
what we are playing with our youth is
playing this is part of our how our
youth and we express our ourselves it is
the culture that we maintain and keep
for ourselves to understand what this
moment in society looked like in our
museums so at that point when we really
have understood that games are a part of
our culture we also need to ask ourself
the question how is this made and this
is just made by a company that controls
it or maybe if we all have participated
in there’s so much as I’ve just shown
you that maybe we should recognize that
and game culture right now is this
beautiful very culture a very colored
garden where so many people have
contributed to build something and done
different things that they showed each
other and just kept open and modified
each other’s work and now we are at the
moment where there’s a wall built around
this and where it’s not clear anymore
that everybody can go in and modify
where it suddenly becomes look but don’t
touch
and we need to think about if we want to
keep this possibility of changing the
stories that games are telling of
modifying this culture that we have
another such a big part of our
contemporary understanding of the world
and keep this possibility open this is
not something only players can do or
only play a creators or just an industry
responsibility but this is something
where we need to think about what we
want games in the future to be and where
all of us need to combine our ripples in
order to create some wave that can
really push over the status quo and
change this and keep it open games as a
possibility for expression in the future
thank you very much
[Music]
you
I’m Patrick and yes you already heard I
do research in videogames and today I
would like you to follow me
together with Andre andreas a teenager
from Sweden and he’s playing World of
Warcraft and he’s really good at it
he’s so good in fact that he together
with 30 other guys venture into the last
level of World of Warcraft as it was at
that point to kill giant lava monsters
inside a really big evil volcano right
turns out that the lava monsters however
are not the biggest challenge that angry
antis 3839 companions are facing there’s
a problem with the interface design of
this game and the problem is that World
of Warcraft previously as this big
online title still only really supported
playing in groups up to 5 players that
meant that the interface was really only
built to give you information about
those other 4 dudes or players in your
party and now all of a sudden when you
were playing with 40 that was a bit of a
problem because if you were for example
leading that group you didn’t really
know what was going on with the other
players in your party where they dying
was everything okay you were sort of
bleeding blindly and especially if you
were for example somebody who’s keeping
your your team members of life that was
hard to do because you never know who
was about to die whom do I need to save
here this was something that Andre
together with another author fixed they
built an add-on which is a small piece
of software that runs on top of World of
Warcraft and that you can see here up in
the left corner and that exactly that it
does exactly that it gives you this
information about all 40 members of that
party so now you have all this
information that you need in order to
play these huge levels it was so
successful and so needed in this current
state of the game that this a little bit
shy Swedish teenager had just built a
piece of software that was used by
millions of players so it spread widely
it was the way of playing that
particular game so when I first
encountered World of Warcraft that was
also around the time that I moved to
Sweden I started studying in Uppsala
University and I actually came here for
my girlfriend at the time um it was a
little bit tricky to just move to
another country like that I didn’t speak
Swedish yet I didn’t have so many
friends and it was also a little bit
lonely so at that point I also played
World of Warcraft in order to keep
connected to people back at home and
Germany to speak German and also in
order to have the possibility of
experiencing myself as somebody who is
still social who can be a leader in a
group or who can deal with still with
other people and help them with problems
even though I didn’t have a such big
established social circles yet in Sweden
so I had a very positive first access in
that case to the game um in case you’re
wondering coming here to follow a girl
it did turn out well you know so we are
we made a for for more little gamers
they soon will be able to beat me in any
game out there and I’m painfully aware
of that so I have to sort of savor my
last moments of actually being able to
win anything but yeah when I played
World of Warcraft and that’s an actual
screenshot of me playing ungrazed
creations or derivative stuff of those
where everywhere in the game you also
see that I am really really bad at
creating sort of nice and functional
interfaces this is a mess right and this
is actually how I plate so I’m there in
the middle some bird it’s just a little
elf person standing in front of this
giant spider and absorbing the blows and
had shielding my my group members and so
that they they give me a life and
hopefully kill the itsy-bitsy spider we
will see it a bit so but that’s how I
played but you can see similar interface
features to Andres add on everywhere in
this there’s two of them on the left I’m
not sure why I had too much you know
kept them around another one down here
this is why it became such a mess but it
shows that these sort of interface
features were just a staple of playing
the game they were so different versions
of them and really everybody just just
used them because they were super useful
and they were just a part of what was
world a world of warcraft at that point
so the questions that came to me then
from also a scholarly perspective and
when they were seeing that us wow this
is really a big part of this game so how
far does this co-creation go how much of
this game is
actually in a way made by players and
then as the next step and that is of
course the critical social science
perspective here
do these coke here just get credit for
that work if they pick up so much and do
so much and in making a scam before we
follow these questions a quick word on
games research in general and games in
our society games have become really a
central part of contemporary culture
starting out from casual games
let’s see Hanson who in this room does
play anything any casual games maybe
Angry Birds candy crush minecraft I
think that’s the majority like most of
us especially with more casual things
thank you very much most of us have some
sort of connection to that or maybe our
your children or younger relatives play
these games all of these three titles
actually Nordic titles so the Nordic
countries are also very central and
really well fight a box above their
weight in global creation of digital
games but of course we also have the
more hardcore titles like for example
counter-strike which is a shooter game
that is so central to eSports for
example that it can fill entire stadiums
and in Swedish events like dream egg for
example is doing just that or a title
like League of Legends League of Legends
is oftentimes handled as the game with
the most players globally last year
League of Legends had 100 million
monthly players just taste that number
for a second one or a million monthly
that’s not one person counted twice
they’ll certainly virtual people and so
that that is round the size of the
population of Sweden Denmark Norway and
Germany
that’s a bubbling that’s sort of the
League of Legends population so this is
how many people are playing this and in
the same way it’s eSports subculture
where people play competitive against
each other and establish teams is
filling stadiums there’s a streaming
subculture where people watch these
games from far away and their computers
that is recently discussed to be
overtaking in global viewership analog
sports viewing
this is of course a little bit difficult
to measure but it looks like that games
and games culture are here to stay and
are a central part of contemporary
culture I also included a picture here
from tecnica Massey at the Swedish
Museum for science technology that had a
games exhibition a while back and we’re
still games are clearly recognized as a
part of contemporary culture and that we
need to maintain conserve and see as
something valuable in our everyday life
but let’s get back to Andre and his
story so at the top at the point where
the creators of World of Warcraft were
about to release the second version of
the game they weren’t so happy with how
the add-on culture had turned out
because they felt that add-ons were
taking over too much of the players
decisions and they thought about
removing them altogether but what they
did instead is that they invited central
add-on creators like for example Andre
and put them in a plane and flew them
over to California to their headquarters
and asked them to build an
infrastructure that would make it
possible for add-ons to continue
existing but limit what they would be
able to do in the game and that’s what
they did
so for Andre of course this was awesome
I mean he’s like this young enthusiastic
guy and now this company who makes the
game that he loves they pay his fly to
come over and help them work on it of
course he goes right that’s great for
him and so do many of the other add-on
creators and they come and build this
infrastructure after the specifications
of the company and basically sit there
and in the same space where the other
employees of the company work and code
and built an infrastructure that just
like that with that code goes into the
game so that is the maximum amount that
I have ever seen of how far play player
co-creation of games can go right at
this point you can’t even really
distinguish it any more from other kinds
of making a game right the only
difference between Andre as a player
co-creator and company employees is that
one of them is on the payroll of the
company and the other isn’t otherwise
they are sitting at the same place and
doing the same
so this is sort of the most extreme case
as an answer to the question of how far
does player co-creation go in these
games however this is not a lonely case
while it might be the most extreme that
I managed to dig up this player
co-creation as a phenomenon is
everywhere all over gaming culture those
big titles with millions of players that
I mentioned at the start counter-strike
League of Legends another one would be
the game dota that is quite similar they
are based on player creations to start
with their main idea that design that
has then been taken and been further
developed by for-profit companies that
comes from players who build this game
mostly as a modification for example
dota was first developed as a
modification to Warcraft 3 and
counter-strike was developed by two
motors as an alternative method to the
game half-life but these game designs
that then have proliferated so much and
spawned these huge eSports communities
they are based on players creativity so
what about the second question do
players get credit for what they do well
sadly here that’s a little bit more
sobering when we look at andreas story
he had to sign a nondisclosure agreement
together with the other add-on
contributors as well that meant that his
involvement in World of Warcraft was to
be kept a secret he did not get to put
on a CV his name was not in the credits
that rolled at the end of the game
instead he had to not tell anyone about
it
luckily now that expired so he was
actually able to tell the story but this
credit was not given in this case for
their contribution so we can see that
co-creation
is a central aspect of contemporary game
creation however there’s also a huge
imbalance in power here because the
player creators who put in their work
don’t really have the possibility to
stand up for themselves
maybe defend some sort of influence that
they want to have instead the most of
the power belongs to the company who
owns it
has control over the technological
infrastructure meaning that player
creators largely work under some sort of
Damocles Ian sort they don’t really know
if depth work that they put into that to
make this game into something better
something worse but they want to have
but what their community wants that
their their creative participation here
if that is going to stay around or if
maybe the company decides to kill it
tomorrow that is the possibility right
so also aster to bring the understory to
an end nowadays he doesn’t look quite as
favorable on his involvement in World of
Warcraft anymore but he feels that now
as a seasoned software engineer that
what they got with those player creators
got for their involvement was two years
free playing World of Warcraft so for
two years they got to play the game for
free that they were involved in building
right that was quite a bargain for the
company making the game to get these
amazing people that millions of users of
their add-ons already right so it’s a
little bit more nuanced perspective on
that than just enthusiasm there of
course ways out of this not all of them
are necessarily straightforward but a
good starting point could be to do
something about this power imbalance and
treat player creators as partners that
get some bit more of say of what is
happening with also the work that they
have put into something we have examples
for this happening and again and I’m
using most of these examples out of
World of Warcraft not because that is
the game where that happens a lot or
that is the worst case not at all this
is just because this is my field side
right this is what I knew well and that
is where I collected my data this is
really an issue for the entire industry
or for entire games as a culture or
maybe also other media but then I also
want to be fair and show positive
examples from that game and one of the
most positive examples are add-ons for
accessibility this is an initiative by
both the add-on player community and the
company who runs the game to make
modifications to the infrastructure that
allow piglia players with disabilities
to still play the game so this is not
sold or anything this is just made for
people to need it so that they can also
participate in the game a simple example
is down here the move pet Plus which is
an add-on that gives you virtual buttons
that you can press with the amount so
that you can move your character in the
game and that
people change makes it possible for
players who can only use one hand to
play with their friends otherwise they
couldn’t have done that because they
would have still needed the keyboard and
the mouse at the same time so now
players like that they can also be part
of what of Warcraft and play with their
friends together and this is just one of
number of examples that are part of this
add-ons for accessibility initiative so
some really amazing examples of this
open partnership between the company who
owns the game and the player community
who co creates it then giving credit
where credit is to put the names of
players into your credit roll if they
participate in the game there’s no clear
reason for keeping this a secret and
that would be a really big step for
giving them the possibility of showing
what they actually have done and being
honest about who participated in making
a scheme but the question that maybe
remains for some of you is why does this
matter is this about some nerds not
getting their names into the credit card
credits because they made a game now
that it has a little more Prader
implications than that this is also
about our culture we have already
established that games are a central
part of contemporary culture with
hundreds of millions of players this is
what we are playing with our youth is
playing this is part of our how our
youth and we express our ourselves it is
the culture that we maintain and keep
for ourselves to understand what this
moment in society looked like in our
museums so at that point when we really
have understood that games are a part of
our culture we also need to ask ourself
the question how is this made and this
is just made by a company that controls
it or maybe if we all have participated
in there’s so much as I’ve just shown
you that maybe we should recognize that
and game culture right now is this
beautiful very culture a very colored
garden where so many people have
contributed to build something and done
different things that they showed each
other and just kept open and modified
each other’s work and now we are at the
moment where there’s a wall built around
this and where it’s not clear anymore
that everybody can go in and modify
where it suddenly becomes look but don’t
touch
and we need to think about if we want to
keep this possibility of changing the
stories that games are telling of
modifying this culture that we have
another such a big part of our
contemporary understanding of the world
and keep this possibility open this is
not something only players can do or
only play a creators or just an industry
responsibility but this is something
where we need to think about what we
want games in the future to be and where
all of us need to combine our ripples in
order to create some wave that can
really push over the status quo and
change this and keep it open games as a
possibility for expression in the future
thank you very much
[Music]
you
Please follow and like us: