
when I was 15 years old I stood up in
front of my class and argued that the
American invasion of Iraq was justified
and necessary
had I been an American that might not
have been such an odd thing to do but I
grew up in Old Europe and I had recently
changed schools my new form teacher was
passionately against the war and of
course so are all of my classmates my
forum teacher probably feared that I
would infect the rest of the class the
other pupils and so he fought me tooth
and nail I was expelled from class and
made to see the headmistress who urged
me to abandon my view so that I would
have an easier time fitting in and
making friends nevertheless I persisted
by the end of the year my grades had
plummeted my teachers hated me and I had
no friends I was alone and miserable and
worst of all I was wrong the reason I’m
telling you this is because I want to
talk about bad ideas we all spend a lot
of time thinking about good ideas I’m an
academic and a novelist so I basically
make a living selling my best ideas here
they are all my best ideas and of course
we’re all here today because we’re
interested in ideas worth spreading
so the good news for all of us idea
addicts is the world is full of
fantastic ideas they’re all over the
internet through conferences like this
which means they’re literally everywhere
but if all these fantastic world saving
ideas are already out there then why
isn’t the world saved by now doesn’t
really seem to be getting at all better
at all does it by most accounts it’s
recently been getting worse so it turns
out the problem isn’t really that there
aren’t enough great ideas but that there
are too many bad ideas resurrecting when
we least expected so the real question
is how do we fight
a bad idea luckily I happen to know a
lot about bad ideas because I teach
undergraduate students undergraduates
don’t get me wrong they aren’t stupid um
but they’re young and inexperienced and
can’t always hide their worst ideas
successfully I’ll give you an example a
few months ago I was teaching a class
and I gave out an essay to my students
about presenting ideas incidentally and
I ask a few questions I pick a student
at random and the student says well the
author says this and he does this and he
and he he he he so I have to ask how do
you know the author’s male and my
student looks at me and says well he
must be male because he’s so very
logical I’ll give you a moment to let
that sink in it took me a moment because
well my student was female and so was
the author of the text me
this happens to me a lot by the way
whenever I ask my students why they
think an author’s a certain gender the
answer is always some version of he must
be male because he’s good at thinking or
she must be female because she’s so
emotional if I ask the same group of
students the ones that think that men
and women that women are less capable of
thinking logically if I ask the same
group of students whether they think
that men and women are intellectually
the same equal they will unanimously say
yes of course they are in fact most of
my students seem to hold these two views
one that men and women are
intellectually equal to that women are
less capable of thinking and writing
logically my students may not notice it
but their most fundamental beliefs about
the intellectual capacities of men and
women are utterly out of harmony with
one another they are quite literally
absurd and that makes me wonder how is
it possible that the same people who can
talk about literature or history for
hours without saying anything obviously
absurd as soon as the topic of gender
comes up they all abandon basic logic
and it’s not just gender that does it
it’s religion politics even meat
consumption and it’s not really just
students it’s all of us a few months ago
I was sitting next to a professor of
physics at Oxford during dinner and the
conversation turned to global warming
and so I had to ask if you’re so
convinced of manmade climate change how
come you’re eating steak and the
professor says to me well I fly to the
US every other week every other month
whether or not I eat meat makes no
difference to my footprint a
world-renowned professor of physics but
as soon as a steak is at stake something
as simple as adding up seems beyond him
once you pay attention to bad ideas you
notice they all have one thing in common
they happen because we care the more
important a topic is to us the more
absurd our ideas become and it doesn’t
seem to matter whether you’re left or
right rich or poor religious or atheist
vegan or meat-eater emotional investment
is the great equalizer
it turns us all into idiots when we care
our behavior towards ideas becomes
different protective whether it’s the
idea of equality the comfort of gender
stereotyping or the deliciousness of
steak when we care we stop thinking
critically we talk about the thing that
matters to us only when we need not fear
disagreement we quash any challenges
through an often comment a joke or brute
aggression we might still say correct me
if I’m wrong but what we really mean is
don’t correct me I know I’m right and
that has two consequences our good ideas
the ones that would only grow stronger
if we shared them if we let our
collective minds shine on them stay
feeble they never garner any kind of
complexity or layers of evidence our bad
ideas the ones that would never pass
muster if we put them to the test
can hide away the cost of protecting
ideas is that they stay exactly as they
always were which means the bad stay bad
and the good stay underdeveloped and
perhaps that’s all a bad idea really is
an idea we haven’t fully thought through
yet if we want to fight bad ideas we
need to examine all of our ideas
critically and openly especially the
ones that matter to us I know some of
you are probably thinking yes yes of
course but no
some things are better left unsaid we
don’t actually want every racist sexist
homophobic anti-semitic idea to be out
there
alternatively you might be thinking we
don’t want every blasphemous idea or
every sexually different one to be
discussed in public no matter our
politics we all fear that there are some
ideas that really should remain hidden
but there’s the rub ideas do not stay
hidden forever we do not need to speak
them for them to determine our behavior
and our culture and they live on in the
deepest corners of our souls and our
browsers they resurrect at the ballot
box what we try to suppress others turn
into our parliaments prime ministers and
presidents I know the alternative is
scary
in fact I chose every example today
because it scares me personally and what
I’m about to say next scares me even
more when my students say that men and
women are intellectually equal and that
women are less capable of thinking
logically than men they aren’t voicing
one bad idea but two because they
haven’t thought through either if they
had thought through one they couldn’t
even say the other and I’m sure some of
them are only saying that they believe
in equality because well that’s what you
say when a teacher asks but the idea of
equality is rooted in nothing they have
never thought it through any demagogue
could blow it in and that terrifies me
so what can we do well I’ll give you one
last terrifying example a few months ago
a Polish member of the European
Parliament said that women must must
earn less because they’re shorter weaker
and less intelligent and we all know
what followed of
course because it always follows angry
politician offended of op-eds and
finally a hefty financial punishment
from the European Parliament I wonder
would you change your mind because you
were being punished for it I know I
wouldn’t because I didn’t when I was 15
fighting my teacher so what if instead
of becoming offended we had looked at
his idea the Polish MVPs idea as an idea
so what did he say he said that women
must must not do in fact unless because
you know if we’ve all heard of the
gender peg it but that they must it is
morally correct that women should earn
less because of what because they’re
shorter obviously and I looked this up
the Polish MEP is freakishly tall about
well this high really and Mark
Zuckerberg is this my height actually
and I’m sure he will promptly hand over
his Facebook billions to the Polish MEP
and once the Polish I me piece vision is
turned into law employers will then have
to pay their employees using a yardstick
something like this
I’m very sorry John you did make the
company an absolute fortune but bill
over there’s three inches taller really
is that what he wants and and do we
really want people to be paid on the
basis of physical strength I mean okay
I work out six times a week and I’m in
my physical prime the Polish MEP on the
other hand was born in 1942 with all due
respect I could kick his skinny bottom
and when I do I’m sure he’ll gladly give
me his parliamentary paycheck as I
assume many very old very rich European
gentlemen will happily give their money
to the young muscular migrant men we see
working construction sites for example
the truth is if we started paying people
on the basis of physical strength
then inexperienced uneducated manual
laborers would far outturn our most
experienced researchers doctors or
politicians and somehow I doubt the
Polish MEP would want that woody and we
come once again to the vexed question of
gender differences in human intelligence
I wasn’t sure if I should tell you this
but I need to tell you the truth that
nobody wants you to know about the
differences in IQ between men and women
you ready okay nobody knows studies
differ results differ populations change
many scientists find that there are no
significant differences in IQ between
men and women some scientists suggest
that women are more intelligent others
men and of course there are those that
simply reject the underlying gender
binary at the heart of the question
those scientists that do find in DIF as
in intelligence between men and women
can of course never say whether these
differences are the result of nature or
nurture because from the moment we paint
nurseries pink or blue men and women do
not lead the same lives if the Polish
MEP really wanted to prove that men are
innately biologically intellectually
superior to women then he would of
course first have to abolish all
societal gender differences pink and
blue jand the jobs dresses and suits it
would all have to go until then nobody
knows and that’s pretty bad if like me
you’re emotionally invested in the idea
of equality but here’s the good news
those scientists that do suggest or do
claim that men are more intelligent than
women only claim a 1 to 4 percent
difference in intelligence the European
gender pay gap
is roughly 20% more if you take overall
earnings into account and that means if
we started paying people on the basis of
their intelligence then women even if we
assume that the most extreme findings
and claims on the intellectual
superiority of men aren’t that correct
would end up earning 16 percentage point
more than they do now 16 so basically
the powder time EP wasn’t really being
sexist at all he was merely advocating a
quasi communist revolution in which the
short a year the tall young proletariat
take away capital from short rich old
people while abolishing all societal
gender norms and basically closing the
gender pay gap how shockingly
progressive well of course he didn’t
actually say that I was merely reducing
his statements to their absurd
conclusion that can be quite enjoyable
actually but it isn’t always very
helpful because to most of us as our
obsession with differences in IQs shows
the idea of our own intellect can be the
most treasured idea of all so I’m sorry
Polish MEP I did it to show that what
you said was absurd rather than
offensive and we should have looked at
the absurdity rather than being offended
but you might have noticed that I didn’t
use your name because I have no desire
to shame you you might just be a human
being who sets up something really
really stupid and believe me I’ve been
there so if you want to talk send me an
email and perhaps that’s the best any of
us can do talk to each other listen to
each other the world is so complicated
and it’s comfortable to think that bad
ideas is what happens to other people
for
really ISM we’ve all been wrong before
we shall all be wrong again so we need
to seek people who see the world
differently we need to go out there and
change minds but most importantly we
need to be willing to have our own minds
changed will that save the world maybe
not
will it abolish all bad ideas overnight
what probably not perhaps not all Minds
can be changed and not all worlds can be
saved but if we want to deal with bad
ideas we need to remember that who is
human but to admit error to learn from
our mistakes and to help each other grow
makes us all better humans so I say with
all sincerity correct me if I’m wrong
thank you
[Applause]
front of my class and argued that the
American invasion of Iraq was justified
and necessary
had I been an American that might not
have been such an odd thing to do but I
grew up in Old Europe and I had recently
changed schools my new form teacher was
passionately against the war and of
course so are all of my classmates my
forum teacher probably feared that I
would infect the rest of the class the
other pupils and so he fought me tooth
and nail I was expelled from class and
made to see the headmistress who urged
me to abandon my view so that I would
have an easier time fitting in and
making friends nevertheless I persisted
by the end of the year my grades had
plummeted my teachers hated me and I had
no friends I was alone and miserable and
worst of all I was wrong the reason I’m
telling you this is because I want to
talk about bad ideas we all spend a lot
of time thinking about good ideas I’m an
academic and a novelist so I basically
make a living selling my best ideas here
they are all my best ideas and of course
we’re all here today because we’re
interested in ideas worth spreading
so the good news for all of us idea
addicts is the world is full of
fantastic ideas they’re all over the
internet through conferences like this
which means they’re literally everywhere
but if all these fantastic world saving
ideas are already out there then why
isn’t the world saved by now doesn’t
really seem to be getting at all better
at all does it by most accounts it’s
recently been getting worse so it turns
out the problem isn’t really that there
aren’t enough great ideas but that there
are too many bad ideas resurrecting when
we least expected so the real question
is how do we fight
a bad idea luckily I happen to know a
lot about bad ideas because I teach
undergraduate students undergraduates
don’t get me wrong they aren’t stupid um
but they’re young and inexperienced and
can’t always hide their worst ideas
successfully I’ll give you an example a
few months ago I was teaching a class
and I gave out an essay to my students
about presenting ideas incidentally and
I ask a few questions I pick a student
at random and the student says well the
author says this and he does this and he
and he he he he so I have to ask how do
you know the author’s male and my
student looks at me and says well he
must be male because he’s so very
logical I’ll give you a moment to let
that sink in it took me a moment because
well my student was female and so was
the author of the text me
this happens to me a lot by the way
whenever I ask my students why they
think an author’s a certain gender the
answer is always some version of he must
be male because he’s good at thinking or
she must be female because she’s so
emotional if I ask the same group of
students the ones that think that men
and women that women are less capable of
thinking logically if I ask the same
group of students whether they think
that men and women are intellectually
the same equal they will unanimously say
yes of course they are in fact most of
my students seem to hold these two views
one that men and women are
intellectually equal to that women are
less capable of thinking and writing
logically my students may not notice it
but their most fundamental beliefs about
the intellectual capacities of men and
women are utterly out of harmony with
one another they are quite literally
absurd and that makes me wonder how is
it possible that the same people who can
talk about literature or history for
hours without saying anything obviously
absurd as soon as the topic of gender
comes up they all abandon basic logic
and it’s not just gender that does it
it’s religion politics even meat
consumption and it’s not really just
students it’s all of us a few months ago
I was sitting next to a professor of
physics at Oxford during dinner and the
conversation turned to global warming
and so I had to ask if you’re so
convinced of manmade climate change how
come you’re eating steak and the
professor says to me well I fly to the
US every other week every other month
whether or not I eat meat makes no
difference to my footprint a
world-renowned professor of physics but
as soon as a steak is at stake something
as simple as adding up seems beyond him
once you pay attention to bad ideas you
notice they all have one thing in common
they happen because we care the more
important a topic is to us the more
absurd our ideas become and it doesn’t
seem to matter whether you’re left or
right rich or poor religious or atheist
vegan or meat-eater emotional investment
is the great equalizer
it turns us all into idiots when we care
our behavior towards ideas becomes
different protective whether it’s the
idea of equality the comfort of gender
stereotyping or the deliciousness of
steak when we care we stop thinking
critically we talk about the thing that
matters to us only when we need not fear
disagreement we quash any challenges
through an often comment a joke or brute
aggression we might still say correct me
if I’m wrong but what we really mean is
don’t correct me I know I’m right and
that has two consequences our good ideas
the ones that would only grow stronger
if we shared them if we let our
collective minds shine on them stay
feeble they never garner any kind of
complexity or layers of evidence our bad
ideas the ones that would never pass
muster if we put them to the test
can hide away the cost of protecting
ideas is that they stay exactly as they
always were which means the bad stay bad
and the good stay underdeveloped and
perhaps that’s all a bad idea really is
an idea we haven’t fully thought through
yet if we want to fight bad ideas we
need to examine all of our ideas
critically and openly especially the
ones that matter to us I know some of
you are probably thinking yes yes of
course but no
some things are better left unsaid we
don’t actually want every racist sexist
homophobic anti-semitic idea to be out
there
alternatively you might be thinking we
don’t want every blasphemous idea or
every sexually different one to be
discussed in public no matter our
politics we all fear that there are some
ideas that really should remain hidden
but there’s the rub ideas do not stay
hidden forever we do not need to speak
them for them to determine our behavior
and our culture and they live on in the
deepest corners of our souls and our
browsers they resurrect at the ballot
box what we try to suppress others turn
into our parliaments prime ministers and
presidents I know the alternative is
scary
in fact I chose every example today
because it scares me personally and what
I’m about to say next scares me even
more when my students say that men and
women are intellectually equal and that
women are less capable of thinking
logically than men they aren’t voicing
one bad idea but two because they
haven’t thought through either if they
had thought through one they couldn’t
even say the other and I’m sure some of
them are only saying that they believe
in equality because well that’s what you
say when a teacher asks but the idea of
equality is rooted in nothing they have
never thought it through any demagogue
could blow it in and that terrifies me
so what can we do well I’ll give you one
last terrifying example a few months ago
a Polish member of the European
Parliament said that women must must
earn less because they’re shorter weaker
and less intelligent and we all know
what followed of
course because it always follows angry
politician offended of op-eds and
finally a hefty financial punishment
from the European Parliament I wonder
would you change your mind because you
were being punished for it I know I
wouldn’t because I didn’t when I was 15
fighting my teacher so what if instead
of becoming offended we had looked at
his idea the Polish MVPs idea as an idea
so what did he say he said that women
must must not do in fact unless because
you know if we’ve all heard of the
gender peg it but that they must it is
morally correct that women should earn
less because of what because they’re
shorter obviously and I looked this up
the Polish MEP is freakishly tall about
well this high really and Mark
Zuckerberg is this my height actually
and I’m sure he will promptly hand over
his Facebook billions to the Polish MEP
and once the Polish I me piece vision is
turned into law employers will then have
to pay their employees using a yardstick
something like this
I’m very sorry John you did make the
company an absolute fortune but bill
over there’s three inches taller really
is that what he wants and and do we
really want people to be paid on the
basis of physical strength I mean okay
I work out six times a week and I’m in
my physical prime the Polish MEP on the
other hand was born in 1942 with all due
respect I could kick his skinny bottom
and when I do I’m sure he’ll gladly give
me his parliamentary paycheck as I
assume many very old very rich European
gentlemen will happily give their money
to the young muscular migrant men we see
working construction sites for example
the truth is if we started paying people
on the basis of physical strength
then inexperienced uneducated manual
laborers would far outturn our most
experienced researchers doctors or
politicians and somehow I doubt the
Polish MEP would want that woody and we
come once again to the vexed question of
gender differences in human intelligence
I wasn’t sure if I should tell you this
but I need to tell you the truth that
nobody wants you to know about the
differences in IQ between men and women
you ready okay nobody knows studies
differ results differ populations change
many scientists find that there are no
significant differences in IQ between
men and women some scientists suggest
that women are more intelligent others
men and of course there are those that
simply reject the underlying gender
binary at the heart of the question
those scientists that do find in DIF as
in intelligence between men and women
can of course never say whether these
differences are the result of nature or
nurture because from the moment we paint
nurseries pink or blue men and women do
not lead the same lives if the Polish
MEP really wanted to prove that men are
innately biologically intellectually
superior to women then he would of
course first have to abolish all
societal gender differences pink and
blue jand the jobs dresses and suits it
would all have to go until then nobody
knows and that’s pretty bad if like me
you’re emotionally invested in the idea
of equality but here’s the good news
those scientists that do suggest or do
claim that men are more intelligent than
women only claim a 1 to 4 percent
difference in intelligence the European
gender pay gap
is roughly 20% more if you take overall
earnings into account and that means if
we started paying people on the basis of
their intelligence then women even if we
assume that the most extreme findings
and claims on the intellectual
superiority of men aren’t that correct
would end up earning 16 percentage point
more than they do now 16 so basically
the powder time EP wasn’t really being
sexist at all he was merely advocating a
quasi communist revolution in which the
short a year the tall young proletariat
take away capital from short rich old
people while abolishing all societal
gender norms and basically closing the
gender pay gap how shockingly
progressive well of course he didn’t
actually say that I was merely reducing
his statements to their absurd
conclusion that can be quite enjoyable
actually but it isn’t always very
helpful because to most of us as our
obsession with differences in IQs shows
the idea of our own intellect can be the
most treasured idea of all so I’m sorry
Polish MEP I did it to show that what
you said was absurd rather than
offensive and we should have looked at
the absurdity rather than being offended
but you might have noticed that I didn’t
use your name because I have no desire
to shame you you might just be a human
being who sets up something really
really stupid and believe me I’ve been
there so if you want to talk send me an
email and perhaps that’s the best any of
us can do talk to each other listen to
each other the world is so complicated
and it’s comfortable to think that bad
ideas is what happens to other people
for
really ISM we’ve all been wrong before
we shall all be wrong again so we need
to seek people who see the world
differently we need to go out there and
change minds but most importantly we
need to be willing to have our own minds
changed will that save the world maybe
not
will it abolish all bad ideas overnight
what probably not perhaps not all Minds
can be changed and not all worlds can be
saved but if we want to deal with bad
ideas we need to remember that who is
human but to admit error to learn from
our mistakes and to help each other grow
makes us all better humans so I say with
all sincerity correct me if I’m wrong
thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: