
this is Anwar Syed
he’s an uber driver in February he was
out on a normal day driving for uber
when he picked up an abnormal passenger
named Phillip ganado
now as soon as Kannada have gotten mr.
sides vehicle he began to ask mr. Syed a
series of questions the first was where
are you from – which Syed responded I’m
from Pakistan Kannada then asked mr.
Syed what is your religion so I ad then
responded I’m Muslim Kannada then grew
noticeably irritated and asked mr. Syed
to pull over his vehicle to the side of
the road he then grabbed the flashlight
which was located on the center console
of mr. sides vehicle and began to
brutally beat mr. Syed he ended up
leaving him unconscious on the side of
the road with a fractured eye socket
this is how he looked after the attack
he was in the hospital for five days
recovering this is one of many Islamic
attacks that have occurred since the
2016 election and these attacks have
been worrying not only about myself
being that I identify as an American
Muslim of Pakistani descent but they
have been worrying a lot about my family
because it’s one thing to do that to me
but it’s another thing to do that to
someone who I care about to do that to
my mom or my dad or my grandma and I
find myself more and more being
concerned about their safety and I
really don’t feel like I should have to
worry about that and the fact that I do
really makes me angry and so what I find
also very troubling about the attack is
that it did really surprised me when I
heard about it because instances like
these are becoming so common in our
country and so here you can look at the
data for yourself the above graph is
from the Pew Research Center
showing a steep rise in anti-muslim
assaults in 2015 the bottom one is from
the Southern Poverty Law Center showing
a tripling in anti-muslim hate groups a
tripling now as I said this is no doubt
because of the 2016 election where we
saw a Slama phobic rhetoric become
normalized it became politically
advantageous to say things like we have
a Muslim problem in America or Islam
hates us now contrary to popular belief
this type of rhetoric is not just from
the right it also comes from the left
Bill Maher for example is the left’s
most prominent Islamic obe now if you
were to ask Bill Maher or even Donald
Trump for that matter about the attack
on mr. Syed they would no doubt condemn
it immediately however if you were to
talk to them about their rhetoric if you
were to talk to them about when they say
things like Muslims are inherently
opposed to American values they would
not take their foot off the gas now what
they failed to realize or maybe they
just don’t care is that that type of
rhetoric legitimizes the actions of
people like mr. ganado because it fuels
the flame burning inside those with hate
in their heart because it in a sense
proves them right for when someone
thinks that Muslims are evil when they
hear people like Donald Trump or people
on Bill Maher people from both sides of
this of the political spectrum there
there are in a sense proven right and so
really for anyone to say that Muslims
are inherently opposed the United States
is just flat-out wrong
there’s 1.6 billion Muslims on the
planet if 1.6 billion people really
wanted to see the downfall of the United
States the globe would be a much more
vital place nevertheless it is important
to discuss for the people who do wish to
commit terror in the Muslim world the
very small percentage of people out of
that 1.6 billion it’s important to
discuss where those motivations come
from and in order to find the answer to
that we do not need to look at scripture
but instead we must look at history so
let’s take a step back
it’s wardro one a series of entangling
alliances in a steep rise in nationalism
lead to the most catastrophic conflict
the globe has ever seen we see the
Allied powers featuring much of the West
squaring off against the central powers
featuring Germany the austrian-hungarian
empire the ottoman empire and bulgaria
now for our discussion the Ottoman
Empire is the most important because
their Turkish their Muslim and they
control large parts of the Middle East
large parts of the Muslim world and so
in the ottoman empires suspected decline
the European powers see great
opportunity so in 1916 during the middle
of the war a British diplomat named
Sykes and a French diplomat named picot
get together to plan out how they want
to divide up Ottoman territorial
holdings in the Middle East as you can
see here there’s a French zone of
control as well as a British zone of
control and now this is no doubt meant
to further their interests interestingly
this agreement will run in direct
contradiction to the US presidents
fourteen points for you see American
President Woodrow Wilson wanted to
remake the world at the end of World War
one for in his mind in order to prevent
such a conflict from ever occurring
again the world needed to be remade to
be free in which themes of
self-governance and self-determination
would be stressed and so he laid this
out in kind of his vision for the world
or in his fourteen points right here is
0.5 the second half of which is the most
important it reads the interests of the
populations concerned must have equal
weight with the equitable claims of the
government whose title is to be
determined so again we get that theme of
self-governance as well as consent to
the governor freedom however despite the
European powers tacit agreement with
Woodrow Wilson’s point following World
War one they went ahead and instituted
the imperialist governments which they
talked about in the sykes-picot
agreement and so they would become known
as Mandate governments now Arab leaders
were quick to call out the West on what
they viewed as hypocrisy for they would
say that okay so you spout
all this grand rhetoric about freedom
about self-determination however here
you are imposing imperialist governments
upon us and so there were revolts the
picture on the left is from the 1925
Syrian revolt where you saw Syrians
gathered together in their attempts to
break free from French control French
firepower proved superior
and so the French squash the rebellion
nevertheless this is a critical
contradiction between Western stated
values of freedom and self-determination
and Western actions of imperialism let’s
jump to World War two
in August of 41 the United States is not
completely committed to the war effort
however its sense is that it will need
to take an increasing role and so again
the American President Franklin
Roosevelt feels that the world needs to
be remade to be more free basically and
so him and the British Prime Minister
Winston Churchill signed the Atlantic
Charter which has a tone similar to that
of Woodrow Wilson’s fourteen points
Porter it reads both countries agreed to
respect the right of all peoples to
choose the form of government under
which they will live so again you get
that similar tone self-determination
consent of the governed however much
like the Europeans after World War one
America went back on its word after
after World War two you get the Cold War
where America squares off against the
Soviet Union now America and the West
feels that they need every advantage
possible to combat the Soviet Union and
so they feel one of their interests
being threatened in 1953 in Iran for you
see Iran at the time had a
democratically elected prime minister
pictured on the right named Mohammad
Mossadeq
and he wanted to nationalize the
country’s oil which would basically
benefit Iran and mitigate the amount of
Western influence being exercised on
Iran and it’s oil
America felt very threatened and so they
partnered with the British to overthrow
the democratically elected government
and installed their own ruler this
individual Mohammad Reza Shah Pahlavi
who ruled
like an autocrat he tortured political
dissidents abolished opposing political
parties and had a secret police and as
since he ruled in direct contradiction
to the values outlined in the Atlantic
Charter and so the Iranians grew
disillusioned with the Shahs rule and so
in 1979 they engaged in a revolution and
overthrew the American installed ruler
their leader pictured on the poster on
the left of the screen was Ayatollah
Khomeini he was a Shia cleric now when
people look at this revolution they look
at it primarily through a religious lens
when they say this is when
fundamentalists took control of Ron now
that is significant yes however what is
also significant is the social justice
narrative which really was utilized in
this revolution for you see ayat Oh
Ayatollah Khomeini painted the United
States as this oppressive power which
did not respect Muslim rights Muslim
lives or Muslim bodies I mean he really
didn’t have to try too hard to point
that out to the Iranian population
considering that their democratically
elected government was overthrown by a
foreign power in 1953 so it wasn’t too
difficult to really galvanize the
population let’s put this in a domestic
context for our sake right so right now
Americans are freaking out because
Russia interfered in our election by by
pumping out fake news and allegedly
colluding with the Trump campaign
imagine how ticked off everyone would be
have Russia came in and took over the
White House there’d be riots in the
streets right and so and so Iran ian’s
remember this this is something that is
still so key to their identity and so
what is even more troubling is that this
narrative of the of the u.s. acting in
this oppressive manner is what terrorist
groups utilize to recruit to legitimize
their actions and they just utilize it
in their overall propaganda campaigns
because as I said people in the region
remember the West and America acting in
this what they view as oppressive manner
Isis famously erased the border between
Iraq and Syria saying that they don’t
believe in the sykes-picot agreement
it’s really this dilemma of the u.s.
acting in a manner which is calm which
is contradictory to its values of
freedom of self-determination is best
summed up by Robert F Kennedy jr. and
this article he wrote for Politico in
which he said individuals in the Muslim
world do not look unfavorably upon
America because of our values but
because we betrayed our values because
our values did not apply to those in the
region unless it fit American interests
now it is very easy for us to say okay
well you know what that was forever ago
that was during World War two without
sharing the Cold War will you know and
so America is not doing that anymore
well um actually America still is acting
in a manner which is not conducive to
valuing Muslim lives or Muslim bodies so
let’s look at this in the contemporary
context airstrikes in the month of March
alone just in Iraq and Syria the u.s.
coalition killed nearly 1,800 civilians
1,800 innocent people now proponents of
the airstrikes would say oh well US
trade that was to take out terrorists
that was to liberate let’s say the city
of Mosul in Iraq from Isis now okay sure
I understand that however is it really
worth engaging in those airstrikes if in
our efforts to kill two Isis members we
kill 5 innocents for you see each of
those innocence who has died has friends
and has family members and so for us to
assume that those individuals are not
going to harbor ill will or ill feelings
is just naive and so yeah sure these
liberated cities from Isis they may not
join Isis right however they definitely
do not have a favorable view of the
United States and so what’s stopping
them from joining the ISIS of tomorrow
or Isis to point out let’s also look at
Yemen which by the way is being
incredibly underreported on right now in
the news the United States is funding
Saudi Arabia’s bombing campaign in Yemen
and the Saudis unfortunately have a
proclivity to
funerals this thing with that for a
second bombing a funeral where they are
mourning someone’s death now what did
the what do those type of actions do
they reinforce the narrative that the
u.s. does not value Muslim lives on
Muslim rights which in turn makes us
less safe because it makes it easier for
terrorists to recruit let’s look at
drone strikes the woman on the left is
Lisa Ling and she works on the
military’s drone program and when
talking about drones she says that she
considers drones to be tear for we
cannot fight a war on terror with more
tear as people take the humanity out of
the conversation and humanity is what we
need to be talking about again she’s
getting back to the whole idea of are we
really valuing the lives of people on
the ground Senator Chris Murphy pictured
there on the right I feel really hits
the nail on the head when referring to
this reckless u.s. foreign policy in
Yemen when he said that he fears the
entire Yemeni population which is
radicalized against the United States a
lot of people don’t know this but right
now in Yemen al Qaeda controls
significant portions of the country and
so part of that is because their message
is so attractive to those on the ground
because they’re consistently getting
drone strikes by the US or they’re
getting bombed by the Saudis which the
u.s. is funding them to do and people on
the ground are aware of this and so we
really need to start thinking about the
human cost of our policies are they
making us safer and a lot of this
reckless u.s. foreign policy comes from
the rhetoric utilized by our politicians
like I talked about earlier Donald Trump
famously said on the campaign trail when
when talking about Isis that he would
bomb the shit out of them and take their
oil right so when you put it like that
it sounds really easy
yeah sure like why not why don’t we just
kill them all right however again we
need to start thinking about the people
on the ground for the for the for the
territory that Isis controls there’s a
lot of innocent people there who also
wish to be free from that tyranny and so
when we just lay destruction to the
entire region and kill 1,800 civilians
we may have solved our terrorist
problems
but we’re only creating a lot more down
the road because we are literally
proving the terrorists right in their
message when they say that that America
does not care about Muslims and like I
said terrorists are incredibly adept at
using this and their propaganda
campaigns as well
shortly after Donald Trump said that he
wanted to ban all Muslims from the
United States al-shabaab the al Qaeda
affiliate in Somalia literally used that
clip of him saying that and then put it
out in a recruitment video to encourage
others to join their organization again
our elected officials are making it too
easy for them by by by saying that they
want to ban Muslims and by engaging in
his reckless military policy look I am
not advocating for a pacifist u.s.
foreign policy nor my excusing the
rights of those who wish to commit
terror I am however asking for a policy
which is congruent to our values which
stresses things like self-determination
freedom and values the human cost of
those on the ground because as we’ve
seen this reckless foreign policy is not
making us any safer peace will not be
restored in the region simply through
bombs
drone strikes or air strikes it will be
restored through coalition building
through diplomacy through handshakes and
hopefully through those handshakes we
will have the United States which is not
only insulated from terror but we will
have a United States in which American
Muslims such as mr. Syed feel safe
protected and accepted thank you
[Applause]
he’s an uber driver in February he was
out on a normal day driving for uber
when he picked up an abnormal passenger
named Phillip ganado
now as soon as Kannada have gotten mr.
sides vehicle he began to ask mr. Syed a
series of questions the first was where
are you from – which Syed responded I’m
from Pakistan Kannada then asked mr.
Syed what is your religion so I ad then
responded I’m Muslim Kannada then grew
noticeably irritated and asked mr. Syed
to pull over his vehicle to the side of
the road he then grabbed the flashlight
which was located on the center console
of mr. sides vehicle and began to
brutally beat mr. Syed he ended up
leaving him unconscious on the side of
the road with a fractured eye socket
this is how he looked after the attack
he was in the hospital for five days
recovering this is one of many Islamic
attacks that have occurred since the
2016 election and these attacks have
been worrying not only about myself
being that I identify as an American
Muslim of Pakistani descent but they
have been worrying a lot about my family
because it’s one thing to do that to me
but it’s another thing to do that to
someone who I care about to do that to
my mom or my dad or my grandma and I
find myself more and more being
concerned about their safety and I
really don’t feel like I should have to
worry about that and the fact that I do
really makes me angry and so what I find
also very troubling about the attack is
that it did really surprised me when I
heard about it because instances like
these are becoming so common in our
country and so here you can look at the
data for yourself the above graph is
from the Pew Research Center
showing a steep rise in anti-muslim
assaults in 2015 the bottom one is from
the Southern Poverty Law Center showing
a tripling in anti-muslim hate groups a
tripling now as I said this is no doubt
because of the 2016 election where we
saw a Slama phobic rhetoric become
normalized it became politically
advantageous to say things like we have
a Muslim problem in America or Islam
hates us now contrary to popular belief
this type of rhetoric is not just from
the right it also comes from the left
Bill Maher for example is the left’s
most prominent Islamic obe now if you
were to ask Bill Maher or even Donald
Trump for that matter about the attack
on mr. Syed they would no doubt condemn
it immediately however if you were to
talk to them about their rhetoric if you
were to talk to them about when they say
things like Muslims are inherently
opposed to American values they would
not take their foot off the gas now what
they failed to realize or maybe they
just don’t care is that that type of
rhetoric legitimizes the actions of
people like mr. ganado because it fuels
the flame burning inside those with hate
in their heart because it in a sense
proves them right for when someone
thinks that Muslims are evil when they
hear people like Donald Trump or people
on Bill Maher people from both sides of
this of the political spectrum there
there are in a sense proven right and so
really for anyone to say that Muslims
are inherently opposed the United States
is just flat-out wrong
there’s 1.6 billion Muslims on the
planet if 1.6 billion people really
wanted to see the downfall of the United
States the globe would be a much more
vital place nevertheless it is important
to discuss for the people who do wish to
commit terror in the Muslim world the
very small percentage of people out of
that 1.6 billion it’s important to
discuss where those motivations come
from and in order to find the answer to
that we do not need to look at scripture
but instead we must look at history so
let’s take a step back
it’s wardro one a series of entangling
alliances in a steep rise in nationalism
lead to the most catastrophic conflict
the globe has ever seen we see the
Allied powers featuring much of the West
squaring off against the central powers
featuring Germany the austrian-hungarian
empire the ottoman empire and bulgaria
now for our discussion the Ottoman
Empire is the most important because
their Turkish their Muslim and they
control large parts of the Middle East
large parts of the Muslim world and so
in the ottoman empires suspected decline
the European powers see great
opportunity so in 1916 during the middle
of the war a British diplomat named
Sykes and a French diplomat named picot
get together to plan out how they want
to divide up Ottoman territorial
holdings in the Middle East as you can
see here there’s a French zone of
control as well as a British zone of
control and now this is no doubt meant
to further their interests interestingly
this agreement will run in direct
contradiction to the US presidents
fourteen points for you see American
President Woodrow Wilson wanted to
remake the world at the end of World War
one for in his mind in order to prevent
such a conflict from ever occurring
again the world needed to be remade to
be free in which themes of
self-governance and self-determination
would be stressed and so he laid this
out in kind of his vision for the world
or in his fourteen points right here is
0.5 the second half of which is the most
important it reads the interests of the
populations concerned must have equal
weight with the equitable claims of the
government whose title is to be
determined so again we get that theme of
self-governance as well as consent to
the governor freedom however despite the
European powers tacit agreement with
Woodrow Wilson’s point following World
War one they went ahead and instituted
the imperialist governments which they
talked about in the sykes-picot
agreement and so they would become known
as Mandate governments now Arab leaders
were quick to call out the West on what
they viewed as hypocrisy for they would
say that okay so you spout
all this grand rhetoric about freedom
about self-determination however here
you are imposing imperialist governments
upon us and so there were revolts the
picture on the left is from the 1925
Syrian revolt where you saw Syrians
gathered together in their attempts to
break free from French control French
firepower proved superior
and so the French squash the rebellion
nevertheless this is a critical
contradiction between Western stated
values of freedom and self-determination
and Western actions of imperialism let’s
jump to World War two
in August of 41 the United States is not
completely committed to the war effort
however its sense is that it will need
to take an increasing role and so again
the American President Franklin
Roosevelt feels that the world needs to
be remade to be more free basically and
so him and the British Prime Minister
Winston Churchill signed the Atlantic
Charter which has a tone similar to that
of Woodrow Wilson’s fourteen points
Porter it reads both countries agreed to
respect the right of all peoples to
choose the form of government under
which they will live so again you get
that similar tone self-determination
consent of the governed however much
like the Europeans after World War one
America went back on its word after
after World War two you get the Cold War
where America squares off against the
Soviet Union now America and the West
feels that they need every advantage
possible to combat the Soviet Union and
so they feel one of their interests
being threatened in 1953 in Iran for you
see Iran at the time had a
democratically elected prime minister
pictured on the right named Mohammad
Mossadeq
and he wanted to nationalize the
country’s oil which would basically
benefit Iran and mitigate the amount of
Western influence being exercised on
Iran and it’s oil
America felt very threatened and so they
partnered with the British to overthrow
the democratically elected government
and installed their own ruler this
individual Mohammad Reza Shah Pahlavi
who ruled
like an autocrat he tortured political
dissidents abolished opposing political
parties and had a secret police and as
since he ruled in direct contradiction
to the values outlined in the Atlantic
Charter and so the Iranians grew
disillusioned with the Shahs rule and so
in 1979 they engaged in a revolution and
overthrew the American installed ruler
their leader pictured on the poster on
the left of the screen was Ayatollah
Khomeini he was a Shia cleric now when
people look at this revolution they look
at it primarily through a religious lens
when they say this is when
fundamentalists took control of Ron now
that is significant yes however what is
also significant is the social justice
narrative which really was utilized in
this revolution for you see ayat Oh
Ayatollah Khomeini painted the United
States as this oppressive power which
did not respect Muslim rights Muslim
lives or Muslim bodies I mean he really
didn’t have to try too hard to point
that out to the Iranian population
considering that their democratically
elected government was overthrown by a
foreign power in 1953 so it wasn’t too
difficult to really galvanize the
population let’s put this in a domestic
context for our sake right so right now
Americans are freaking out because
Russia interfered in our election by by
pumping out fake news and allegedly
colluding with the Trump campaign
imagine how ticked off everyone would be
have Russia came in and took over the
White House there’d be riots in the
streets right and so and so Iran ian’s
remember this this is something that is
still so key to their identity and so
what is even more troubling is that this
narrative of the of the u.s. acting in
this oppressive manner is what terrorist
groups utilize to recruit to legitimize
their actions and they just utilize it
in their overall propaganda campaigns
because as I said people in the region
remember the West and America acting in
this what they view as oppressive manner
Isis famously erased the border between
Iraq and Syria saying that they don’t
believe in the sykes-picot agreement
it’s really this dilemma of the u.s.
acting in a manner which is calm which
is contradictory to its values of
freedom of self-determination is best
summed up by Robert F Kennedy jr. and
this article he wrote for Politico in
which he said individuals in the Muslim
world do not look unfavorably upon
America because of our values but
because we betrayed our values because
our values did not apply to those in the
region unless it fit American interests
now it is very easy for us to say okay
well you know what that was forever ago
that was during World War two without
sharing the Cold War will you know and
so America is not doing that anymore
well um actually America still is acting
in a manner which is not conducive to
valuing Muslim lives or Muslim bodies so
let’s look at this in the contemporary
context airstrikes in the month of March
alone just in Iraq and Syria the u.s.
coalition killed nearly 1,800 civilians
1,800 innocent people now proponents of
the airstrikes would say oh well US
trade that was to take out terrorists
that was to liberate let’s say the city
of Mosul in Iraq from Isis now okay sure
I understand that however is it really
worth engaging in those airstrikes if in
our efforts to kill two Isis members we
kill 5 innocents for you see each of
those innocence who has died has friends
and has family members and so for us to
assume that those individuals are not
going to harbor ill will or ill feelings
is just naive and so yeah sure these
liberated cities from Isis they may not
join Isis right however they definitely
do not have a favorable view of the
United States and so what’s stopping
them from joining the ISIS of tomorrow
or Isis to point out let’s also look at
Yemen which by the way is being
incredibly underreported on right now in
the news the United States is funding
Saudi Arabia’s bombing campaign in Yemen
and the Saudis unfortunately have a
proclivity to
funerals this thing with that for a
second bombing a funeral where they are
mourning someone’s death now what did
the what do those type of actions do
they reinforce the narrative that the
u.s. does not value Muslim lives on
Muslim rights which in turn makes us
less safe because it makes it easier for
terrorists to recruit let’s look at
drone strikes the woman on the left is
Lisa Ling and she works on the
military’s drone program and when
talking about drones she says that she
considers drones to be tear for we
cannot fight a war on terror with more
tear as people take the humanity out of
the conversation and humanity is what we
need to be talking about again she’s
getting back to the whole idea of are we
really valuing the lives of people on
the ground Senator Chris Murphy pictured
there on the right I feel really hits
the nail on the head when referring to
this reckless u.s. foreign policy in
Yemen when he said that he fears the
entire Yemeni population which is
radicalized against the United States a
lot of people don’t know this but right
now in Yemen al Qaeda controls
significant portions of the country and
so part of that is because their message
is so attractive to those on the ground
because they’re consistently getting
drone strikes by the US or they’re
getting bombed by the Saudis which the
u.s. is funding them to do and people on
the ground are aware of this and so we
really need to start thinking about the
human cost of our policies are they
making us safer and a lot of this
reckless u.s. foreign policy comes from
the rhetoric utilized by our politicians
like I talked about earlier Donald Trump
famously said on the campaign trail when
when talking about Isis that he would
bomb the shit out of them and take their
oil right so when you put it like that
it sounds really easy
yeah sure like why not why don’t we just
kill them all right however again we
need to start thinking about the people
on the ground for the for the for the
territory that Isis controls there’s a
lot of innocent people there who also
wish to be free from that tyranny and so
when we just lay destruction to the
entire region and kill 1,800 civilians
we may have solved our terrorist
problems
but we’re only creating a lot more down
the road because we are literally
proving the terrorists right in their
message when they say that that America
does not care about Muslims and like I
said terrorists are incredibly adept at
using this and their propaganda
campaigns as well
shortly after Donald Trump said that he
wanted to ban all Muslims from the
United States al-shabaab the al Qaeda
affiliate in Somalia literally used that
clip of him saying that and then put it
out in a recruitment video to encourage
others to join their organization again
our elected officials are making it too
easy for them by by by saying that they
want to ban Muslims and by engaging in
his reckless military policy look I am
not advocating for a pacifist u.s.
foreign policy nor my excusing the
rights of those who wish to commit
terror I am however asking for a policy
which is congruent to our values which
stresses things like self-determination
freedom and values the human cost of
those on the ground because as we’ve
seen this reckless foreign policy is not
making us any safer peace will not be
restored in the region simply through
bombs
drone strikes or air strikes it will be
restored through coalition building
through diplomacy through handshakes and
hopefully through those handshakes we
will have the United States which is not
only insulated from terror but we will
have a United States in which American
Muslims such as mr. Syed feel safe
protected and accepted thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: