
there are many different questions
people raised regarding the ethics of
traveling such as how much one is
allowed to bargain or what type of
transportation one should use where to
stay so for example in a local guest
house on some Western Hotel chain and
there are many more questions like that
but since 2000 contributes to 9 percent
of global GDP and accounts for 1 in 11
jobs worldwide the answer to such
questions might be more important than
we would intuitively expect but what
some people already discuss where one
should stay once one has reached the
destination a much more important
question seems to be entirely neglected
and that’s the question where we ought
to travel to in the first place and
that’s pretty much where I want to focus
on today but I must admit that some
people do at least discuss where one
should not go so for example to places
where by going to the there one would
support an autocratic regime and that
makes at least intuitively a lot of
sense but even if that’s the case
there’s still quite a few places left
from which people can pick their
destination so does it then mean that
it’s morally equal to go to Kenya or to
Australia I don’t think so and in fact I
believe that one should rather travel to
low-income regions which are
disproportionately affected by poverty
than to high-income regions so in my
example one should rather go to Kenya
than to Australia or more are generally
speaking one should rather go to regions
and in South and Southeast Asia and many
parts of sub-saharan Africa and some
regions I guess in South America rather
than to Europe Australia where the vast
majority of people travel to nowadays so
for example last year there were more
tourists in France alone than an
all-over Africa combined and although
there are many different factors which
have to be taken into account in order
to ultimately decide where to travel to
I would like to focus on the two major
reasons today only which led me to
believe that travelling to low-income
rather than high-income regions is at
least a good rule of thumb to start with
but first let me mention that obviously
there are many different ethical fears
out there however I feel like most
people you believe that the consequences
of an
should matter at least to some extent
maybe it’s the decisive factor maybe not
but if they matter to some extent that
that’s enough for now
and among those consequences would then
certainly be the contribution of one’s
action to the overall happiness and or
well-being of those who are affected by
that action so in order to determine
where we ought to travel to we would
have to have a look at the impact
traveling has on the overall well-being
of those who were affected by your
travel and since one of the immediate
effects of traveling derives from the
fact that money is spent in a different
part of the world we would have to
analyze whether money spending one
region of the world leads to more or
less happiness than that money spent in
a different part of the world so we need
to know a bit more about the
relationship between money and happiness
and and more specifically whether the
same amount of money influences
everyone’s happiness equally I also must
admit that that analyzing happiness is
as I’m sure you can imagine rather
difficult and involves a number of
uncertainties however there seem to be
two main ways how service in this field
of study are usually conducted and the
first one asked whether somebody is
satisfied with their life as a whole so
called life evaluation or life
satisfaction and the alternative would
ask how happy are you these days
and while the data on this so-called
emotional being suggests that one may
not become any happier after having
reached a certain stable income well at
least not happier due to further
increase income which according to two
Daniel Kahneman and Angus Deaton was
estimated at around seventy-five
thousand US dollar per household in the
US the data on life satisfaction on the
other hand suggests a much stronger
relation between income and and
happiness or life satisfaction for that
matter
in fact it suggests that the more you
earn the more satisfied you are with
your life however even regarding life
satisfaction money seems to become less
and less important so if we have a look
at at this graph we can see the very
interesting pattern that life
satisfaction Rises by about point three
points whenever we double income right
so here we have
on the X ax where the difference between
each tick mark represents a doubling of
income and then on the y-axis we have
life satisfaction on a scale from 1 to
10 and if we double income as we can do
here for China we can see that life
satisfaction Rises by 0.3 points right
and we can see the same effect for Iran
for Japan and for many other places I
the blue one on the top represents the
US so it’s always the same regardless of
where you live how much you earn double
income and life satisfaction rises by
about 0.3 points so for instance if you
would like to increase the life
satisfaction of somebody living in the
US earning the median income of 31,000
US dollars per year you would need an
additional thirty one thousand u.s.
dollar per year but if you would like to
increase the life satisfaction of
somebody of an Indian farmer earning or
earning as little as three hundred
dollars you would only need an
additional three hundred dollars and due
to this extremely different effect money
can have on on people’s well-being which
is ultimately based on extreme global
economic inequality the philosopher will
make accurate calls this the 100 times
multiplier you may well say not all the
money you spend as a tourist will go to
somebody who earns as little as three
hundred dollars that seems highly
unlikely but even if that’s the case it
may still go to people who arguably
profit much more from that than anybody
in a high-income country could so let’s
take the case of the around three
hundred Sofra – at each in volcanoes
which is located in as you can hopefully
see in an Eastern Java and Indonesia who
earned about thirteen dollars per day so
much more than some of the poorest
people in the world have and also it’s
much more than some of the poorest or
rather poor people in Indonesia have but
that job does come at a rather high cost
as they frequently break their their
collar bones because of the heavy weight
of the so food I have to carry which can
be up to two hundred pounds a miner each
and also risk dying immediately from
toxic fumes blowing in their face from
which already 75 – died so there’s
actually a substantial risk that this
can happen any minor eating or
has a life expectancy of 20 years below
the Indonesian average so why did I tell
you this story to illustrate many two
points the first one is that even people
who earn much more than the current
threshold of extreme poverty at one
dollar ninety per day which is still the
case for on 700 million people worldwide
although those numbers are declining
those people may still live and work on
a pretty horrible conditions which to
most of us in the West are simply
unimaginable and the second point is
that even if your money doesn’t go to
someone who earns as little as three
hundred dollars and buy that achieves a
hundred times more good those people can
still massively profit from tourism at
each end for instance some – were able
to quit their jobs and offer guided
tours for tourists into the crater away
from the most dangerous and poisonous
traps even if this may not be their
dreams some at least to me seem at least
reasonably happy about what they were
doing but even if that is not the case
whatsoever they sure prefer to have this
option of showing some some tourists
around a beautiful landscape for a
couple of hours per day rather than
working on a life-threatening conditions
every single day for for about 16 hours
but travelling to low-income regions may
not only benefit the the local
population and and this now brings me to
my second point in fact I believe that
it may have better consequences for for
all of us and and more specifically I
believe that it may help us to overcome
certain intuitive moral gut reactions
which we have for evolution evolutionary
reasons but which may not necessarily
lead us to do the right thing so
something many philosophers or people in
general subscribe to is that the
interests of people should count equally
and although we like to tell ourselves
that we do in fact value interest
equally and practice at least that
that’s often not the case as one of
those intuitive gut reactions we have
evolved over time is to favor prefer and
empathize more with those who are like
us so if we have a look at the reaction
of the West to the terrorist attack and
in Paris on Charlie Hebdo in January
2015
where
12 people died and compare that to the
reaction of the West to the multiple
terrorist attacks in northern Nigeria
during the exact same week where two
thousand people died and the problem
seems to be that that this isn’t a
one-time thing
in fact it always occurs in a similar
way and I’m sure you can imagine that
there countless examples are left but
while multiple governments and even
Facebook were able to reconsider and
ultimately remove their one-sided
responses to such incidents altogether
our two intuitive gut reactions remain
and this may even be the bigger problem
will remain the same Josh green a
professor of psychology and his tune
Jamison conducted an experiment um which
is unfortunately not yet published but
hopefully will be soon in which they ask
participants to imagine that they are on
a vacation on a small beautiful island
in a rather poor country overlooking the
coast from your cottage in the mountains
and everything is going really well but
then a terrible typhoon hits the coast
and and and there’s flooding it and at
some point diseases become a big problem
and you can’t really go down there but
what you can do is that you can make a
donation and and to the aid organization
already working on the ground and then
they ask people what do you believe that
you have an obligation to help and in
fact sixty-eight percent or roughly 68
percent said yes we do believe that we
have an obligation to help under such
circumstances but then they ask a
slightly different question
so everything was exactly as I described
before but now instead of you being over
there it’s your friend who’s over there
and you’re at home but your friend is
showing your kinds of photos and videos
and news and whatnot so you have just as
much information as you had in the
previous case and since you also can
just equally donate to the aid
organization which is working on the
ground you also have just as much
ability to help but when they ask
participants now whether they believe
that they have an obligation to help
under such circumstances only about half
as many people said that they believe
that they have an obligation to happen
that’s somewhat strange right the only
difference is that once you’re sitting
there and now you’re sitting here
somebody would ask you whether would you
would like to donate it to a specific
cause you certainly wouldn’t respond by
asking that person whether the potential
recipients of that donations are more or
less than X miles away because that’s
simply where you draw the line from a
certain perspective that just doesn’t
make sense whatsoever
but from a biological perspective it
makes a lot of sense we evolved to
cooperate and in small groups and if
there’s somebody right in front of us
that’s when we act and we have and
that’s nice and so on and so forth but
if there’s somebody in danger far away
we don’t care much it’s not really a
problem our hunter-gatherer ancestors
had to face but but it is a problem
which we are facing right now when about
30 million people face starvation and
northern parts of sub-saharan Africa and
Yemen or when there are still 17,000
children dying every day from
preventable diseases and since our
thinking processes won’t adapt anytime
soon to solve issues of a globalized
world rather than tribe internal issues
for which those mechanisms have been
designed for I believe that we need to
change our environment we need to travel
to low-income regions rather than
high-income regions in order to
empathize with people with whom we would
otherwise not empathize with but
traveling may not only bring us
geographically closer together and they
ever enable us to to value people’s
interest at least a bit more equally but
it also has by now multiple studies have
shown increases trust of mindedness and
the ability to make more informed
judgments about global issues but to be
realistic traveling even to low-income
regions won’t expose you to some of the
greatest injustice is like extreme
poverty and most likely you won’t see
some of those 17,000 children dying
every day from preventable diseases that
seems highly unlikely but it will expose
you to some of the very common in
Justices like the situation of the
miners at each and volcanoes and by that
I believe that traveling can also shed
some light on our ways of thinking and
and and more specifically on how our
thinking is not it’s not just randomly
but but really systematically wronging
those who are not like us those who have
different beliefs
interests or simply have a few miles for
other way and although this reason is
not as quantifiable as the previously
mentioned immediate benefits on people’s
well-being I believe that in a
globalized world with nowadays
increasing tendencies of nationalism and
xenophobia overcoming tribalism is
really important and if we’re able to to
make all of us in a certain way better
off simply by traveling to low income
rather than to high income regions then
I believe that we should do so and I
also believe that we should try to
encourage others to do so as well
thank you
[Applause]
people raised regarding the ethics of
traveling such as how much one is
allowed to bargain or what type of
transportation one should use where to
stay so for example in a local guest
house on some Western Hotel chain and
there are many more questions like that
but since 2000 contributes to 9 percent
of global GDP and accounts for 1 in 11
jobs worldwide the answer to such
questions might be more important than
we would intuitively expect but what
some people already discuss where one
should stay once one has reached the
destination a much more important
question seems to be entirely neglected
and that’s the question where we ought
to travel to in the first place and
that’s pretty much where I want to focus
on today but I must admit that some
people do at least discuss where one
should not go so for example to places
where by going to the there one would
support an autocratic regime and that
makes at least intuitively a lot of
sense but even if that’s the case
there’s still quite a few places left
from which people can pick their
destination so does it then mean that
it’s morally equal to go to Kenya or to
Australia I don’t think so and in fact I
believe that one should rather travel to
low-income regions which are
disproportionately affected by poverty
than to high-income regions so in my
example one should rather go to Kenya
than to Australia or more are generally
speaking one should rather go to regions
and in South and Southeast Asia and many
parts of sub-saharan Africa and some
regions I guess in South America rather
than to Europe Australia where the vast
majority of people travel to nowadays so
for example last year there were more
tourists in France alone than an
all-over Africa combined and although
there are many different factors which
have to be taken into account in order
to ultimately decide where to travel to
I would like to focus on the two major
reasons today only which led me to
believe that travelling to low-income
rather than high-income regions is at
least a good rule of thumb to start with
but first let me mention that obviously
there are many different ethical fears
out there however I feel like most
people you believe that the consequences
of an
should matter at least to some extent
maybe it’s the decisive factor maybe not
but if they matter to some extent that
that’s enough for now
and among those consequences would then
certainly be the contribution of one’s
action to the overall happiness and or
well-being of those who are affected by
that action so in order to determine
where we ought to travel to we would
have to have a look at the impact
traveling has on the overall well-being
of those who were affected by your
travel and since one of the immediate
effects of traveling derives from the
fact that money is spent in a different
part of the world we would have to
analyze whether money spending one
region of the world leads to more or
less happiness than that money spent in
a different part of the world so we need
to know a bit more about the
relationship between money and happiness
and and more specifically whether the
same amount of money influences
everyone’s happiness equally I also must
admit that that analyzing happiness is
as I’m sure you can imagine rather
difficult and involves a number of
uncertainties however there seem to be
two main ways how service in this field
of study are usually conducted and the
first one asked whether somebody is
satisfied with their life as a whole so
called life evaluation or life
satisfaction and the alternative would
ask how happy are you these days
and while the data on this so-called
emotional being suggests that one may
not become any happier after having
reached a certain stable income well at
least not happier due to further
increase income which according to two
Daniel Kahneman and Angus Deaton was
estimated at around seventy-five
thousand US dollar per household in the
US the data on life satisfaction on the
other hand suggests a much stronger
relation between income and and
happiness or life satisfaction for that
matter
in fact it suggests that the more you
earn the more satisfied you are with
your life however even regarding life
satisfaction money seems to become less
and less important so if we have a look
at at this graph we can see the very
interesting pattern that life
satisfaction Rises by about point three
points whenever we double income right
so here we have
on the X ax where the difference between
each tick mark represents a doubling of
income and then on the y-axis we have
life satisfaction on a scale from 1 to
10 and if we double income as we can do
here for China we can see that life
satisfaction Rises by 0.3 points right
and we can see the same effect for Iran
for Japan and for many other places I
the blue one on the top represents the
US so it’s always the same regardless of
where you live how much you earn double
income and life satisfaction rises by
about 0.3 points so for instance if you
would like to increase the life
satisfaction of somebody living in the
US earning the median income of 31,000
US dollars per year you would need an
additional thirty one thousand u.s.
dollar per year but if you would like to
increase the life satisfaction of
somebody of an Indian farmer earning or
earning as little as three hundred
dollars you would only need an
additional three hundred dollars and due
to this extremely different effect money
can have on on people’s well-being which
is ultimately based on extreme global
economic inequality the philosopher will
make accurate calls this the 100 times
multiplier you may well say not all the
money you spend as a tourist will go to
somebody who earns as little as three
hundred dollars that seems highly
unlikely but even if that’s the case it
may still go to people who arguably
profit much more from that than anybody
in a high-income country could so let’s
take the case of the around three
hundred Sofra – at each in volcanoes
which is located in as you can hopefully
see in an Eastern Java and Indonesia who
earned about thirteen dollars per day so
much more than some of the poorest
people in the world have and also it’s
much more than some of the poorest or
rather poor people in Indonesia have but
that job does come at a rather high cost
as they frequently break their their
collar bones because of the heavy weight
of the so food I have to carry which can
be up to two hundred pounds a miner each
and also risk dying immediately from
toxic fumes blowing in their face from
which already 75 – died so there’s
actually a substantial risk that this
can happen any minor eating or
has a life expectancy of 20 years below
the Indonesian average so why did I tell
you this story to illustrate many two
points the first one is that even people
who earn much more than the current
threshold of extreme poverty at one
dollar ninety per day which is still the
case for on 700 million people worldwide
although those numbers are declining
those people may still live and work on
a pretty horrible conditions which to
most of us in the West are simply
unimaginable and the second point is
that even if your money doesn’t go to
someone who earns as little as three
hundred dollars and buy that achieves a
hundred times more good those people can
still massively profit from tourism at
each end for instance some – were able
to quit their jobs and offer guided
tours for tourists into the crater away
from the most dangerous and poisonous
traps even if this may not be their
dreams some at least to me seem at least
reasonably happy about what they were
doing but even if that is not the case
whatsoever they sure prefer to have this
option of showing some some tourists
around a beautiful landscape for a
couple of hours per day rather than
working on a life-threatening conditions
every single day for for about 16 hours
but travelling to low-income regions may
not only benefit the the local
population and and this now brings me to
my second point in fact I believe that
it may have better consequences for for
all of us and and more specifically I
believe that it may help us to overcome
certain intuitive moral gut reactions
which we have for evolution evolutionary
reasons but which may not necessarily
lead us to do the right thing so
something many philosophers or people in
general subscribe to is that the
interests of people should count equally
and although we like to tell ourselves
that we do in fact value interest
equally and practice at least that
that’s often not the case as one of
those intuitive gut reactions we have
evolved over time is to favor prefer and
empathize more with those who are like
us so if we have a look at the reaction
of the West to the terrorist attack and
in Paris on Charlie Hebdo in January
2015
where
12 people died and compare that to the
reaction of the West to the multiple
terrorist attacks in northern Nigeria
during the exact same week where two
thousand people died and the problem
seems to be that that this isn’t a
one-time thing
in fact it always occurs in a similar
way and I’m sure you can imagine that
there countless examples are left but
while multiple governments and even
Facebook were able to reconsider and
ultimately remove their one-sided
responses to such incidents altogether
our two intuitive gut reactions remain
and this may even be the bigger problem
will remain the same Josh green a
professor of psychology and his tune
Jamison conducted an experiment um which
is unfortunately not yet published but
hopefully will be soon in which they ask
participants to imagine that they are on
a vacation on a small beautiful island
in a rather poor country overlooking the
coast from your cottage in the mountains
and everything is going really well but
then a terrible typhoon hits the coast
and and and there’s flooding it and at
some point diseases become a big problem
and you can’t really go down there but
what you can do is that you can make a
donation and and to the aid organization
already working on the ground and then
they ask people what do you believe that
you have an obligation to help and in
fact sixty-eight percent or roughly 68
percent said yes we do believe that we
have an obligation to help under such
circumstances but then they ask a
slightly different question
so everything was exactly as I described
before but now instead of you being over
there it’s your friend who’s over there
and you’re at home but your friend is
showing your kinds of photos and videos
and news and whatnot so you have just as
much information as you had in the
previous case and since you also can
just equally donate to the aid
organization which is working on the
ground you also have just as much
ability to help but when they ask
participants now whether they believe
that they have an obligation to help
under such circumstances only about half
as many people said that they believe
that they have an obligation to happen
that’s somewhat strange right the only
difference is that once you’re sitting
there and now you’re sitting here
somebody would ask you whether would you
would like to donate it to a specific
cause you certainly wouldn’t respond by
asking that person whether the potential
recipients of that donations are more or
less than X miles away because that’s
simply where you draw the line from a
certain perspective that just doesn’t
make sense whatsoever
but from a biological perspective it
makes a lot of sense we evolved to
cooperate and in small groups and if
there’s somebody right in front of us
that’s when we act and we have and
that’s nice and so on and so forth but
if there’s somebody in danger far away
we don’t care much it’s not really a
problem our hunter-gatherer ancestors
had to face but but it is a problem
which we are facing right now when about
30 million people face starvation and
northern parts of sub-saharan Africa and
Yemen or when there are still 17,000
children dying every day from
preventable diseases and since our
thinking processes won’t adapt anytime
soon to solve issues of a globalized
world rather than tribe internal issues
for which those mechanisms have been
designed for I believe that we need to
change our environment we need to travel
to low-income regions rather than
high-income regions in order to
empathize with people with whom we would
otherwise not empathize with but
traveling may not only bring us
geographically closer together and they
ever enable us to to value people’s
interest at least a bit more equally but
it also has by now multiple studies have
shown increases trust of mindedness and
the ability to make more informed
judgments about global issues but to be
realistic traveling even to low-income
regions won’t expose you to some of the
greatest injustice is like extreme
poverty and most likely you won’t see
some of those 17,000 children dying
every day from preventable diseases that
seems highly unlikely but it will expose
you to some of the very common in
Justices like the situation of the
miners at each and volcanoes and by that
I believe that traveling can also shed
some light on our ways of thinking and
and and more specifically on how our
thinking is not it’s not just randomly
but but really systematically wronging
those who are not like us those who have
different beliefs
interests or simply have a few miles for
other way and although this reason is
not as quantifiable as the previously
mentioned immediate benefits on people’s
well-being I believe that in a
globalized world with nowadays
increasing tendencies of nationalism and
xenophobia overcoming tribalism is
really important and if we’re able to to
make all of us in a certain way better
off simply by traveling to low income
rather than to high income regions then
I believe that we should do so and I
also believe that we should try to
encourage others to do so as well
thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: