
[Music]
so for the past two years I’ve been
working out in Hollywood with an at
major media companies behind the scenes
in the offices of the world which makes
the content you glue your eyes to every
day when I tell people that
imagine me strutting down the red carpet
with lights and cameras flashing
everywhere but in reality it was a lot
of getting coffee people organizing a
supply closet and staring up in awe at a
bunch of movie posters but when people
ask me why I want to go into this
industry I have two reasons the first
one is obvious I am obsessed with movies
and TV like I probably couldn’t list out
all 50 united states if he wanted but I
could give you the entire fictional
history of all the superhero universes
in fact in middle school I made this
picture of me lying down on all my DVD
collection fantastic and to prove my
superhero thing here’s a chart I made to
explain all the universes so obsessed
yes
but I thought to ask myself what is it
about these narratives that gets me so
excited why is it that I stay up late at
night reading movie analyses and
procrastinating and not doing my
homework for me it’s about the chance to
dive into a whole new reality when I’m
watching The Avengers
I’m not sitting there passively as
Earth’s Mightiest Heroes are fighting
aliens I’m there because I feel like I’m
there with them in New York on the
ground as this is happening around me as
much as we love bashing Michael Bay’s
transformers series the reason why
they’re so popular is because they’re so
good at making us feel like these giant
robots are fighting the battle for
Humanity right in our city we watch
these stories to immerse ourselves in
the world of the characters on screen
and to do that we map a level of truth
onto their narratives this is fun this
is exciting that’s why we do it but I
worry that it isn’t necessarily harmless
in addition to being a cinephile I’m
also an American Muslim as evidenced by
this picture of me and a job
fun fact I made the news that day anyway
my Muslim identity puts me in a very
unique position when I watch some of the
things that I watch because as it so
happens there is no dearth of Muslim
characters on screen there are a lot the
problem is that they’re all terrorists
murderers sociopaths and criminals and I
think they kind of look like me how do
you guys think here’s a side-by-side for
comparison I’m not gonna bother you all
with the data on how the vast majority
of Muslims are decent non-homicidal
human beings because I’m sure you know
all that but my question is when we’re
presented with a compelling piece of
fiction and it includes a factually
inaccurate negative depiction of a
Muslim and then we map a level of truth
on to that depiction because we are so
invested in the story how good are we
after that at separating the fact from
the fiction
I believe we suck at it it’s not wholly
our fault because the trends in the
entertainment industry make it so hard
for us let’s look at some of those
trends firstly it’s not like the
depictions on screen show us Muslims who
just happened to be bad by coincidence
let’s take for example homelands
Nicholas Brody he’s a US Marine who just
returned from war and people aren’t
entirely sure if they can trust him but
then in one shocking scene it is
revealed that Brody is praying like a
Muslim in his garage meaning he
converted to Islam while in Afghanistan
now as Professor James Cox Onagawa tells
us this twist is only shocking because
his Islamic turn is represented as a
prerequisite in his becoming a terrorist
meaning as soon as we learn this about
him we are meant to map onto him this
violent disposition and this largely
becomes the most salient part of his
character and audiences are meant to
constantly feel wary about this
terrifying Muslim label this mode of
depicting Muslims as by definition
terrorists is widespread in popular
media shows such as 24 sleeper cell and
even shows that don’t directly relate
terrorism like lie to me in this last
example in one episode even after the
entire mystery of the plot was resolved
the story never bothered to give us any
rational motive for the Muslim bombers
attempted crime because we were meant to
map onto him this Islamic jihadist
frame this was supposed to be obvious
and as very few people questioned it it
seems like it was another problem we
have is the conflation of the Muslim
identity into this one homogeneous blob
as religious scholar i’m hussein tells
us the international body of muslims
consists of South Asians Arabs Iranians
african-americans Latinos East Asians
and whites so it should be literally
impossible with this much diversity to
point out a person who looks Muslim and
yet entertainment doing this is very
much possible professor Evelyn al
sultani tells us that the Arab on screen
has distinctive dark features a hook
nose and as further visually
distinguished by clothing and so the
Muslim identity held by over a billion
people around the world is being boiled
down to this one Arab caricature weirdly
this conflation of other races in the
arab muslim caricature has been
administered so well that it’s now
possible to dress an actor of any race
for the role let’s take some examples
from 24 here we have the terrifying
Afghani Muslim terrorist Syed Ali but he
is of course played by Italian American
actor Francesco Quinn then we have the
scary scary Turkish terrorists habib
marwan played by south african american
actor arnold moslem and then we have a
generic Arab terrorist Navi Araz but is
he played by an Arab actor of course not
played by Puerto rican-american nestor
serrano so yeah this is a very common
thing that happens in our media and when
conflation is so rampant in this way
what will stop people from allowing
themselves separate the fact from
fiction after the credits roll not much
does if we look at the show sleeper cell
we find that this conflation has been
administered so well that even the
show’s own creators mix up their
characters races recorded interviews
have them calling their Pakistani
character an archetypal middle-eastern
father and calling their Persian actor
Arab both being of course wrong now fine
there are a lot of inaccuracies with how
Muslims are presented on screen sure but
why do we care why does this matter
again we know that this is fiction we
know it’s not real so how could any of
this be harmful a common critique
against this movement for better
representation on screen is that
entertainment is just that entertainment
it doesn’t need to be taken seriously
and we shouldn’t be getting so caught up
over it and doing things like writing
TEDx talks about it about it anyway and
that’s to prove to you that the things
you watch actually do have an impact on
you because when we see these narratives
as so emotionally real it’s hard for us
to not let that seep into our
understandings of reality professor is
Francis Henry and Carol tadder explained
that media represents one of the most
powerful institutions and democratic
society because they help transmit its
central cultural images ideas and
symbols as well as the nation’s
narratives and myths this idea that
television and media can found the
affect people’s perceptions is called
cultivation theory and there’s a lot of
research to back it one study of note by
professors James Potter and I catch Aang
shows that television has a substantial
impact on attitude formation and
constructions of reality among middle
school students middle schools I mean do
you guys remember what you were like in
middle school this was me in middle
school and so that means at this age two
things are happening one these kids
develop me acne and two if they watch
the shows and movies that I’ve been
talking about they’re growing these
homogenized views of Muslims that will
later be very difficult to overturn
shows like homeland know all this and
they use it to their advantage
James Cassandra describes a show by
saying it employs a paranoid style in
which they replay the trauma of 9/11
weekly to keep the image fresh in the
audience’s memory in fact the opening
credits of the show opened by running
through news clips of real terror
attacks in America’s history the show
opens by conflating the fact and fiction
and crucially it keeps Muslims front and
center while doing that so if this is
what’s happening how our audience is
meant to separate separate the fact in
fiction after the show ends not much is
there to help them
now some Shore runners still deny these
effects of media and exactly our
producer of homeland joel cirno states a
doesn’t believe that
behavior is shaped by watching a
television show well I wonder if he is
aware that according to CBS News the
independent and core testimonials West
Point students lawmakers government
officials and even a US Supreme Court
justice have all cited scenes from 24
for when arguing for why torture was
acceptable these are examples of adult
behavior in action being based on a
fictional narrative and that being used
to justify why human rights should be
denied to certain people that shouldn’t
terrify us but it’s also not that new
because we saw a similar thing happen
after the release of the movie Jaws
because after that movie became popular
despite the fact that shark
statistically posed a tiny threat to
human life the fear of sharks and a
desire to kill them off
spiked so what does it mean now that we
see the same sort of trend beginning now
for the Muslim identity I didn’t notice
that first how much these movies and
shows were vilifying Muslims but as I
kept watching and as I got older it
slowly became more explicit and so did
its effect on me not too long ago I was
going in to do one of my daily Muslim
prayers and in the process I realized I
felt strange and found reflection I
realized that I felt strange because I
was feeling guilty guilty not because I
had done anything wrong but because just
the week before I had seen a terrorist
on television praying the exact same way
I was praying now and I found this
really horrifying that if even I someone
who’s seen the beauty of the Muslim
community who’s seen the love the
connections the bond if even I could be
swayed to hold on to a negative
conception of a Muslim after watching a
couple hours of people saying some lines
and funny costumes then what must be
happening in the mind of minds of
general audiences recently I had the
honor of meeting resentment one of the
few prominent Muslim working actors
today when I asked him why he wanted to
go into this industry he emphasized how
he wanted to see more characters who
looked like him but were not caricatures
this is what I want to I want to help
this industry which we all love so much
finally get up to speed
with how the world looks and acts today
look I don’t believe that the full
diversity and nuance of a group of
people can ever be depicted on
television show or a movie that’s not
what necessarily needs to be done as
sociologist Stuart Hall says of the
television fiction of african-americans
what is it issue here is the recognition
of the extraordinary diversity of
subject positions social experiences and
cultural identities which constitute the
category black that is the only
resolution that is needed then the
Muslim identity with all of its nuance
and difference need only to be fully
recognized that casts it all as valid
and legitimate and I know all that is
easier said than done but only after
this is done well we avoid the
imagination of Muslims and actually do
you think we’ve made some progress here
the gain Lesbian Alliance Against
Defamation this recent report finds that
within the last ten years the number of
LGBTQ identifying characters on screen
has doubled also this coming year it’s
found that 20% of recurring characters
on TV will be black I’m not saying this
means we’ve entered this new era of
positive representation on screen but I
do think that the ground is ripe for
change but why why our executive slowly
becoming more conscious of this I
believe it’s because we’re finally
demanding it so I want to urge on you
all a new concept we have so far been
putting the onus on the entertainment
industry talking about how they must fix
their representation of minorities on
screen but to a large extent the fault
is also ours we as an audience American
and global have consistently supported
entertainment that is not positively
diverse and so from a studio perspective
changing form for more honest and
nuanced representations represents a
substantial risk and I’m part of that
problem too for all the love I have of
the Marvel Cinematic Universe I can’t
deny that 3-bits franchises are led by
white dudes named Chris for all the
bashing I did of 24 on homeland today I
was only able to talk about them because
I’m a huge fan of the shows but if this
doesn’t change
the lesson that executives will get is
that not only does marginalization of
minorities work but that it is extremely
profitable I want us to come to a new
understanding of how we evaluate our
entertainment we can love a movie like
American sniper for its amazing acting
Direction production all that but at the
same time we must condemn it for its
simplistic and vilifying depiction of
Muslims we can praise back to the future
as a great American classic
but we must detest that scene where our
protagonists are being chased down by
crazy living terrorists if we do this
then we are telling the industry that
representation proper representation
matters to us and we see this industry
as this gigantic untouchable monster but
we forget that they can be crippled down
to the ground if we just look away
they are bound by our attention or the
lack thereof and that is a lot of power
and so if we really truly care about
this we can make it known conclusion
watch responsibly thank you
[Applause]
so for the past two years I’ve been
working out in Hollywood with an at
major media companies behind the scenes
in the offices of the world which makes
the content you glue your eyes to every
day when I tell people that
imagine me strutting down the red carpet
with lights and cameras flashing
everywhere but in reality it was a lot
of getting coffee people organizing a
supply closet and staring up in awe at a
bunch of movie posters but when people
ask me why I want to go into this
industry I have two reasons the first
one is obvious I am obsessed with movies
and TV like I probably couldn’t list out
all 50 united states if he wanted but I
could give you the entire fictional
history of all the superhero universes
in fact in middle school I made this
picture of me lying down on all my DVD
collection fantastic and to prove my
superhero thing here’s a chart I made to
explain all the universes so obsessed
yes
but I thought to ask myself what is it
about these narratives that gets me so
excited why is it that I stay up late at
night reading movie analyses and
procrastinating and not doing my
homework for me it’s about the chance to
dive into a whole new reality when I’m
watching The Avengers
I’m not sitting there passively as
Earth’s Mightiest Heroes are fighting
aliens I’m there because I feel like I’m
there with them in New York on the
ground as this is happening around me as
much as we love bashing Michael Bay’s
transformers series the reason why
they’re so popular is because they’re so
good at making us feel like these giant
robots are fighting the battle for
Humanity right in our city we watch
these stories to immerse ourselves in
the world of the characters on screen
and to do that we map a level of truth
onto their narratives this is fun this
is exciting that’s why we do it but I
worry that it isn’t necessarily harmless
in addition to being a cinephile I’m
also an American Muslim as evidenced by
this picture of me and a job
fun fact I made the news that day anyway
my Muslim identity puts me in a very
unique position when I watch some of the
things that I watch because as it so
happens there is no dearth of Muslim
characters on screen there are a lot the
problem is that they’re all terrorists
murderers sociopaths and criminals and I
think they kind of look like me how do
you guys think here’s a side-by-side for
comparison I’m not gonna bother you all
with the data on how the vast majority
of Muslims are decent non-homicidal
human beings because I’m sure you know
all that but my question is when we’re
presented with a compelling piece of
fiction and it includes a factually
inaccurate negative depiction of a
Muslim and then we map a level of truth
on to that depiction because we are so
invested in the story how good are we
after that at separating the fact from
the fiction
I believe we suck at it it’s not wholly
our fault because the trends in the
entertainment industry make it so hard
for us let’s look at some of those
trends firstly it’s not like the
depictions on screen show us Muslims who
just happened to be bad by coincidence
let’s take for example homelands
Nicholas Brody he’s a US Marine who just
returned from war and people aren’t
entirely sure if they can trust him but
then in one shocking scene it is
revealed that Brody is praying like a
Muslim in his garage meaning he
converted to Islam while in Afghanistan
now as Professor James Cox Onagawa tells
us this twist is only shocking because
his Islamic turn is represented as a
prerequisite in his becoming a terrorist
meaning as soon as we learn this about
him we are meant to map onto him this
violent disposition and this largely
becomes the most salient part of his
character and audiences are meant to
constantly feel wary about this
terrifying Muslim label this mode of
depicting Muslims as by definition
terrorists is widespread in popular
media shows such as 24 sleeper cell and
even shows that don’t directly relate
terrorism like lie to me in this last
example in one episode even after the
entire mystery of the plot was resolved
the story never bothered to give us any
rational motive for the Muslim bombers
attempted crime because we were meant to
map onto him this Islamic jihadist
frame this was supposed to be obvious
and as very few people questioned it it
seems like it was another problem we
have is the conflation of the Muslim
identity into this one homogeneous blob
as religious scholar i’m hussein tells
us the international body of muslims
consists of South Asians Arabs Iranians
african-americans Latinos East Asians
and whites so it should be literally
impossible with this much diversity to
point out a person who looks Muslim and
yet entertainment doing this is very
much possible professor Evelyn al
sultani tells us that the Arab on screen
has distinctive dark features a hook
nose and as further visually
distinguished by clothing and so the
Muslim identity held by over a billion
people around the world is being boiled
down to this one Arab caricature weirdly
this conflation of other races in the
arab muslim caricature has been
administered so well that it’s now
possible to dress an actor of any race
for the role let’s take some examples
from 24 here we have the terrifying
Afghani Muslim terrorist Syed Ali but he
is of course played by Italian American
actor Francesco Quinn then we have the
scary scary Turkish terrorists habib
marwan played by south african american
actor arnold moslem and then we have a
generic Arab terrorist Navi Araz but is
he played by an Arab actor of course not
played by Puerto rican-american nestor
serrano so yeah this is a very common
thing that happens in our media and when
conflation is so rampant in this way
what will stop people from allowing
themselves separate the fact from
fiction after the credits roll not much
does if we look at the show sleeper cell
we find that this conflation has been
administered so well that even the
show’s own creators mix up their
characters races recorded interviews
have them calling their Pakistani
character an archetypal middle-eastern
father and calling their Persian actor
Arab both being of course wrong now fine
there are a lot of inaccuracies with how
Muslims are presented on screen sure but
why do we care why does this matter
again we know that this is fiction we
know it’s not real so how could any of
this be harmful a common critique
against this movement for better
representation on screen is that
entertainment is just that entertainment
it doesn’t need to be taken seriously
and we shouldn’t be getting so caught up
over it and doing things like writing
TEDx talks about it about it anyway and
that’s to prove to you that the things
you watch actually do have an impact on
you because when we see these narratives
as so emotionally real it’s hard for us
to not let that seep into our
understandings of reality professor is
Francis Henry and Carol tadder explained
that media represents one of the most
powerful institutions and democratic
society because they help transmit its
central cultural images ideas and
symbols as well as the nation’s
narratives and myths this idea that
television and media can found the
affect people’s perceptions is called
cultivation theory and there’s a lot of
research to back it one study of note by
professors James Potter and I catch Aang
shows that television has a substantial
impact on attitude formation and
constructions of reality among middle
school students middle schools I mean do
you guys remember what you were like in
middle school this was me in middle
school and so that means at this age two
things are happening one these kids
develop me acne and two if they watch
the shows and movies that I’ve been
talking about they’re growing these
homogenized views of Muslims that will
later be very difficult to overturn
shows like homeland know all this and
they use it to their advantage
James Cassandra describes a show by
saying it employs a paranoid style in
which they replay the trauma of 9/11
weekly to keep the image fresh in the
audience’s memory in fact the opening
credits of the show opened by running
through news clips of real terror
attacks in America’s history the show
opens by conflating the fact and fiction
and crucially it keeps Muslims front and
center while doing that so if this is
what’s happening how our audience is
meant to separate separate the fact in
fiction after the show ends not much is
there to help them
now some Shore runners still deny these
effects of media and exactly our
producer of homeland joel cirno states a
doesn’t believe that
behavior is shaped by watching a
television show well I wonder if he is
aware that according to CBS News the
independent and core testimonials West
Point students lawmakers government
officials and even a US Supreme Court
justice have all cited scenes from 24
for when arguing for why torture was
acceptable these are examples of adult
behavior in action being based on a
fictional narrative and that being used
to justify why human rights should be
denied to certain people that shouldn’t
terrify us but it’s also not that new
because we saw a similar thing happen
after the release of the movie Jaws
because after that movie became popular
despite the fact that shark
statistically posed a tiny threat to
human life the fear of sharks and a
desire to kill them off
spiked so what does it mean now that we
see the same sort of trend beginning now
for the Muslim identity I didn’t notice
that first how much these movies and
shows were vilifying Muslims but as I
kept watching and as I got older it
slowly became more explicit and so did
its effect on me not too long ago I was
going in to do one of my daily Muslim
prayers and in the process I realized I
felt strange and found reflection I
realized that I felt strange because I
was feeling guilty guilty not because I
had done anything wrong but because just
the week before I had seen a terrorist
on television praying the exact same way
I was praying now and I found this
really horrifying that if even I someone
who’s seen the beauty of the Muslim
community who’s seen the love the
connections the bond if even I could be
swayed to hold on to a negative
conception of a Muslim after watching a
couple hours of people saying some lines
and funny costumes then what must be
happening in the mind of minds of
general audiences recently I had the
honor of meeting resentment one of the
few prominent Muslim working actors
today when I asked him why he wanted to
go into this industry he emphasized how
he wanted to see more characters who
looked like him but were not caricatures
this is what I want to I want to help
this industry which we all love so much
finally get up to speed
with how the world looks and acts today
look I don’t believe that the full
diversity and nuance of a group of
people can ever be depicted on
television show or a movie that’s not
what necessarily needs to be done as
sociologist Stuart Hall says of the
television fiction of african-americans
what is it issue here is the recognition
of the extraordinary diversity of
subject positions social experiences and
cultural identities which constitute the
category black that is the only
resolution that is needed then the
Muslim identity with all of its nuance
and difference need only to be fully
recognized that casts it all as valid
and legitimate and I know all that is
easier said than done but only after
this is done well we avoid the
imagination of Muslims and actually do
you think we’ve made some progress here
the gain Lesbian Alliance Against
Defamation this recent report finds that
within the last ten years the number of
LGBTQ identifying characters on screen
has doubled also this coming year it’s
found that 20% of recurring characters
on TV will be black I’m not saying this
means we’ve entered this new era of
positive representation on screen but I
do think that the ground is ripe for
change but why why our executive slowly
becoming more conscious of this I
believe it’s because we’re finally
demanding it so I want to urge on you
all a new concept we have so far been
putting the onus on the entertainment
industry talking about how they must fix
their representation of minorities on
screen but to a large extent the fault
is also ours we as an audience American
and global have consistently supported
entertainment that is not positively
diverse and so from a studio perspective
changing form for more honest and
nuanced representations represents a
substantial risk and I’m part of that
problem too for all the love I have of
the Marvel Cinematic Universe I can’t
deny that 3-bits franchises are led by
white dudes named Chris for all the
bashing I did of 24 on homeland today I
was only able to talk about them because
I’m a huge fan of the shows but if this
doesn’t change
the lesson that executives will get is
that not only does marginalization of
minorities work but that it is extremely
profitable I want us to come to a new
understanding of how we evaluate our
entertainment we can love a movie like
American sniper for its amazing acting
Direction production all that but at the
same time we must condemn it for its
simplistic and vilifying depiction of
Muslims we can praise back to the future
as a great American classic
but we must detest that scene where our
protagonists are being chased down by
crazy living terrorists if we do this
then we are telling the industry that
representation proper representation
matters to us and we see this industry
as this gigantic untouchable monster but
we forget that they can be crippled down
to the ground if we just look away
they are bound by our attention or the
lack thereof and that is a lot of power
and so if we really truly care about
this we can make it known conclusion
watch responsibly thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: