Press "Enter" to skip to content

Deaf Beginnings: A story of girl with no real native language | Krystal Sarcone | TEDxBrownU


I spent the first six years of my life
deaf
I had a eustachian tube disorder that
resulted in significant conductive
hearing loss in both ears normally this
type of hearing loss can be addressed
relatively successful medically with as
early as one year old but in my
situation that was not the case my
deafness was not addressed or medically
treated until I enrolled into school at
which point my apparent deafness
prompted referrals to appropriate
specialists I had surgery pretty much
immediately afterwards the results of my
first surgery were partially successful
my right ear for all intents and
purposes was fixed my doctors later
informed me that if the first surgery
hadn’t worked I would have had to go to
school for the – a school for the deaf
because I was already so behind on
language and I wasn’t exposed to any
language I hadn’t been exposed to a
language either formally signed or
spoken but I was so behind I couldn’t
afford any further delay now some of you
might be itching to ask if I remember
what it was like to first hear but sadly
the truth is that I don’t some research
says that language is actually a
critical part to forming memories and so
I have no more than a handful of
memories from when I was little but I do
have a few I have a memory of me sitting
less than an inch from the TV longing
for this faint something I was feeling I
also remember going into and coming out
of and waking up for my first surgery I
remember my doctor my ENT doctor sitting
in a swivel chair to my left as I laid
in the stretcher in the operating room I
remember the smell of the cherry flavor
that they put on the breathing mask as I
fell asleep
I remember my head feeling heavy from
anesthesia waking up afterwards
and I remember the fluorescent lights
peeking through the boringly beige
plastic machines to my right but for the
memories after my first surgery the
memories of elementary school well
they’re mostly of struggle and panic
struggle
to learn something obviously so
fundamental that everybody knew but me I
remember being made fun of because I
couldn’t correctly pronounce my best
friend’s name that I was constantly
calling out
I remember the perpetual feeling of
being wrong in my daily speech language
therapy lessons but word guessing I
remember the confusion of conversations
because I couldn’t understand someone if
they didn’t sit close to me or on my
good side
I remember the annoyance of my friends
because they would have to endlessly
repeat themselves because I couldn’t
make out what they were saying in the
noisy world of school hallways and
cafeterias and I remember being told I
was bad at singing more times than I can
count I can still feel the pressure
cooker sensation of being surrounded by
hearing people that had a huge head
start on things like reading and
speaking I spent the next 11 years of my
life essentially half deaf I got
accustomed to the world asymmetrically
and I had a strong dominant side that I
relied on for everything I use it to
make sense with my surroundings in my
world and to learn this English language
I also used it to learn music and
eventually foreign languages when they
became a requirement in my school
district I would have three more repeat
surgeries over the course of the next
eleven years every approximately every
three years on my left ear with the
occasional tongue selected me and
adenoidectomy to see if it would help my
chances but during this time I was very
much performing below par I was reading
at a first-grader level in the fifth
grade and I vividly remember this
because they would color code the books
and separate them into different bins
based on reading level it was so
embarrassing to be struggling through a
ten page children’s book well my friends
were flipping through the Goosebumps
series or even the first Harry Potter
book it was so embarrassing in fact I
would pretend to read higher reading
levels during silent reading in class
often timing my page turning and working
I’m
reading face learning from my classmates
so when it came time for current events
I would beg my best friend and neighbor
at the time if I could have an article
out of his family as a newspaper and he
would say to me if you can read the
headline you can have it
which seems fair and so I would first go
for things I thought might be
low-hanging fruit things I might have
seen on TV and I could match for the
picture in the paper but they didn’t
print paper or newspaper at my reading
level and so often I would end up crying
in tears struggling through the entire
paper without success Jimmy or as I
called him Timmy enforced a tough love
kind of approach now in elementary
school by the end of elementary school I
was starting to get a little bit better
but it’s really fascinating the
psychology behind assumed roles I’ve
always found it interesting how early we
can learn them we all know even in
elementary school who was the class
clown the teacher’s pet the smart ones
and I at least in the beginning
fulfilled the role of the dumb one very
little was demanded of me and there was
sort of a status quo of she can’t hear
too well allowance that I firmly believe
bumped me from one grade to another that
was until mrs. Rosenberg she didn’t
accept excuses and she demanded that I
meet her expectations what she said
exceedingly high she expected me to try
and she reminded me that everything was
a choice that everything I did was a
choice and in order to move on and to
move past her I would have to try and so
I did and so it took a long time before
I start to feel comfortable academically
or in school or even picking up a book
to be honest still today I have some
residual dread of taking a book off the
shelf I often think to myself oh my god
there’s so many words in here I probably
don’t know many of them I’ll have to
learn
but I won’t know how to pronounce them
how long is this going to take me but it
all started there with Timmy sending me
back home across the street without an
article in my hand because I had failed
to read every headline in the newspaper
and that love of a stubborn Jewish woman
that wouldn’t budge a negotiation that
was my future they would set into place
the mental habits that would lead me to
brown now nothing changed overnight or
neither nor within a few years middle
school was a real challenge but I was
trying and trying was having positive
results and so I and I was heading in
the right direction I naturally did
better with things like numbers and math
I found the predictability refreshing
and much less torturous than English and
I was middle school was also when I was
introduced to Spanish a subject that I
always liked and something that I have
historically not struggled with I found
the predictability of sound refreshing I
also loved phonetic nature of the
language
I loved that at times it was much easier
than English it was also in middle
school during our last year that we were
allowed to stop taking band which was
something that was required since we
were in fourth grade and even though I
was absolutely horrendous that band I
had no intention of stopping and this
was because not because I loved how band
sounded but I loved how it felt I love
that if we plywood played loud enough
and in unison and the and the drums had
a big part I could feel it in my body
and so when I entered high school I I
took all the required classes but I
continued Spanish and banned long after
I was required to take them so when it
came to Spanish when I went into high
school it was during my through my love
of world history and also the existence
of Microsoft Encarta see
that I learned that I loved other
foreign languages too and that at night
I could easily teach myself the
beginnings of other languages like
numbers and greetings and I found this
pretty easily from there my love of
languages has grown I now am fluent in
Spanish I am proficient in several other
languages and have successfully dabbled
in a dozen more eventually I would
realize that probably learning English
in a non-native way probably helped me
by the end of high school nobody
believed or even thought that I had a
hearing problem each day in each quarter
I was coming into my own academically
artistically and athletically but I was
still pretty much half deaf I so then it
came time after to about approximately
two years after my fourth surgery I was
about 18 years old to test if the tube
that they put in my ear worked that if
my eardrum could handle life and the
sound of war of the world on its own
without the pressure equalizing effect
that the tube afford in my ear so when
they took the PE tube out in the office
there was this pop and then I was in a
vacuum I felt like I had been placed in
a portable glass cave where the air was
different my mom wanted me to say
something and I would try but as soon as
I would try to push out a sound the
vibrations would resonate through my
head at full volume and I couldn’t bear
push out a word my doctor asked me and
chimed in if it sounded too loud for me
to talk and I nodded and responded with
a mild but affirmative mm-hmm to the
specialist that had been working on me
since I was a child this was a
celebratory moment and there were some
positive aspects to having hearing in my
left ear it was the first time that I
could hear the difference in notes in
band I had learned to play musical
instruments by memorizing hand positions
and finger locations but it wasn’t until
I had bilateral stereo hearing
that I could tell I had played the wrong
note simply by its incompatibility with
the person next to me I’ve been playing
an instrument for almost eight years and
had never experienced that but largely
for me my transition into full hearing
was rather painful everything in the
world was just too noisy and everything
just sounded too loud to me when people
would talk to me their voices would
naturally make their way through
intonation and pitches and it would be
painful and irritating I would have to
cover my ear and I would have to
constantly be on guard for abrasive
sounds that for the most part are not
abrasive to anyone else I also had to
get used to my surroundings like if I
went for a jog and I I wouldn’t be able
to tell which direction a car was coming
from because it sounded as if it was
coming from every direction I also had a
hard time sleeping at night because I
had always slept on my right side and
this had created a silent bubble but I
couldn’t recreate that anymore
my bubble was burst and it was polluted
but noise and I could no longer step
outside of the noisy world simply by
lying on my right side
so for me I wouldn’t necessarily say
that I was or am happier with full
hearing in fact I often appreciate the
other sensations of life a bit more like
with music I like the way it looks and
feels I like the way when you pluck a
guitar string it vibrates to a stop and
I like the way that wooden floorboards
feel when they carry sound by time I got
to college nobody knew better nobody
knew the deaf or dumb girl and I was but
my my relationship with my deafness and
my relationship with just having gotten
my full hearing was there not in the
distant past it was very much still part
of me and still is I was fortunate that
at the Kerr College my path between my
classroom and my dorm room led me
through the phenomenal music school I
would often go in and sit alongside or
like find a spot alongside
of the stage during rehearsals and be as
private and tucked away as possible and
just lay on the floor letting the music
soak into my body I love the way that
felt today my deaf beginnings are almost
undetectable that is unless you play
apples to apples with me and I read the
card and named Michelle Pfeiffer as
Michael puffy fur or if we’re watching
TV and I can’t go more than two minutes
without begging for subtitles
I will also have ringing in my ears
known as tinnitus I will always have
that and I will always struggle to read
or to know what you’re saying or hear
you or understand you if I can’t see
your face or read your lips
I only learn this after spending years
working in the operating room as an
adult and in this setting people often
say to me why are you standing so close
to me often I’d be leaning in with my
good ear now my relationship with
deafness has sort of a bittersweet story
but I’ve learned to appreciate how these
beginnings and breaking certain barriers
of adversity have positively shaped me
today I want to end on a note where I
stress that my life did not improve just
because I gained hearing my life and
crew because I was given access to a
language I was at the mercy of a medical
community in a culture that wanted to
fix me in my particular situation my
condition was for the most part fixable
but had the first surgery not worked and
I wasn’t able to gain hearing and learn
a spoken language I would have learned
sign language or ASL and I would have
had an equal opportunity to engage and
experience a full life in my particular
situation my deafness did not lead to a
relationship with the deaf community and
that was
immediately after diagnosis I was
treated and what surgically and treated
as a hearing person this was probably
the biggest disservice to me as a
patient my deafness was never
acknowledged and I had a very hard time
kind of making my way through the world
in which I was treated as a hearing
person it never taught techniques about
volume control by knowing the vibrations
of my neck or even just acknowledged as
a knowledge that I would see the world
differently
so as someone who has gone through the
spectrum of hearing abilities I wanted
to stress that even as a hearing person
an adult today as we age many of us will
lose our hearing my deaf beginnings and
my attention to an attempt to engage
with the ASL community in the deaf
community now will serve me well in that
capacity and I want to encourage all of
you to kind of challenge hearing centric
tendencies in our culture and to foster
participation and involvement includes
and inclusivity of people with different
abilities not just with a hearing loss
but also with diverse abilities and
disabilities that affect our sensations
mental health and also mobility thank
you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: