Press "Enter" to skip to content

Dancing Instead of Crashing | Marcia Hale | TEDxDonovanCorrectional


[Music]
ten years ago I moved to Los Angeles
from a quiet life in Sedona Arizona
following even quieter one near Mobile
Alabama in the months before I left LA I
saw a film that wound up directing my
life the 2005 movie crash two picks the
complexities of prejudice patriarchy and
shame in the big city
rural forms of which I was all too
familiar for my time in Alabama but what
stayed with me almost unshakably was the
opening scene Don Cheadle plain LAPD
detective Graham Waters literally
crashes onto a crime scene and proclaims
in la nobody touches you we’re always
behind this metal and glass I think we
missed that touch so much that we crash
into each other just so we can feel
something before seeing this movie and I
moved to LA I was an ambulance chaser of
sorts for various issues animal abuse
crime war poverty women’s rights racism
international trade policy etc etc fedra
I was growing weary of these rabbit
holes and was looking for some common or
connecting thread and as it turns out
the scene from crash and the move to LA
were birthing something new inside of me
I began to see conflict as the central
core of all issues and couldn’t stop
seeing conflict itself it’s us crashing
into each other just to be in contact or
maybe more precisely crashing into each
other because we are never taught other
ways of connecting so over the last
decade I’ve been asking myself this
question almost non-stop what are the
alternatives to crashing after studying
various forms of conflict resolution and
trying like hell to stay conscious in my
own conflicts I began to connect the
feeling I have when dancing to the
feeling of navigating really difficult
times and then I started wondering what
would it look like to dance right
and crashed through conflicts now I love
to dance and if left alone on a dance
floor or in a field I can spin and move
like a liberated surfman and the full
ecstasy of life but it’s trickier with
someone else dancing with someone
requires some shared rhythm some shared
understanding of how both people are to
move which is why dance forms from
ballet to tango have been created to
help humans to flow together I’m a
social scientist and a mediator
practices that both use systems maps and
rhythms to guide and direct participants
which is so important because both
conflict and research are explorations
into the unknown and having some system
or form is crucial for navigating murky
and often turbulent waves which is also
crucial to being able to venture into
deep waters so while working actively
with conflict both my own and other
people in conflict
I found this stance that helps to soften
the impact if not avoid crashing all
together it’s – what’s three wise and –
what’s seven questions that delve deeply
enough underneath the surface to start
to bring back real answers it’s two
steps forward so that we can take three
steps back and two steps forward again
it goes something like this what did the
person actually say or do what was their
intention why did they do this why did
that thing happen why did it turn out
this way what could they do differently
what can I or we do differently I’ll
give an example of a 12 year old kid
from South Central that I mediated for
in a restorative justice conflict
restorative justice sees crime is a harm
that’s been done to relationships rather
than a crime that’s been committed
against a piece of properties or even a
person in a restorative justice
mediation victim and offender sit at the
same table in order to shed these labels
and talk as community members about
their shared vulnerabilities at the
mediation table that day there were two
police officers representing the
community the kid let’s call him Corey
and his two Guardians
so what did Cory actually do Cory was
charged with assault and battery a crime
that he had confessed to but it turns
out didn’t actually commit which was not
at all surprising given that Cory was 12
and didn’t look a day over 7 years old
and you could tell by the way he sat and
spoke the Cory was far more used to
being yelled at and talked to his
parents for his Guardians rather ran
down a list of grievances that included
Cory having left the windows of the
house unlocked so the gangsters could
come in and rob the place
so what was his intention the adults in
the room talked about these incidents as
though they were common adolescent
attempts to fit in or be cool and seemed
frustrated and angry at Cory for not
having the strength to resist influence
so why did he do these things it came
out the Cory often commits crimes for
other people and he also takes the rap
for crimes that others commit the room
was growing very intense with Cory
practically cowering in the corner so my
co mediator and I sent him out so that
we could try to get some ideas from the
adults about very concrete things he
should be doing differently so why was
all of this happening the police
revealed to us that Cory is caught
between two of the worst gang
territories in LA he lives in one and he
goes to school in the other and
especially given Cory sighs it’s a most
bound to happen the Cory is gonna be
forced into many things from being the
fall guy to the guy that actually pulls
the trigger so why is the gang situation
such an issue
no the gang scenario in the United
States is obviously a very complex and
complicated issue but it is due in no
small part to historic and racialized
policies such as zoning redlining and
urban renewal that created ghettos
combined with contemporary policies such
as the war on drugs
our privatized prison system and
associated mass incarceration to
continue to fabricate environments of
poverty and crime
so what could Cory do differently in the
situation it’s very tragic to hear the
police say there’s probably not a whole
lot he could be doing differently
Cory’s trapped in an environment where
extreme crashing is the norm and his
fate if he stays in that neighborhood
it’s most likely prison if not a very
early grave so what can we do
differently a change in consciousness is
needed that will impact the entire
system it requires compassion to
recognize what is happening in to
institute change in order to create
different policies we should dance these
seven steps of – what’s three wise and
two months it’s our collective
responsibility we must embody and teach
other ways of understanding each other
and working through conflicts because if
not we’re sentencing Cory and many other
kids like it to lives of violent
crashing moving beyond the policy
implications of the story I’m sure we
can all recognize a similar pattern in
our it’s business or personal
relationships because no matter how good
or bad life might be conflict is always
there perceive betrayal in the workplace
harsh words are hurt by a friend or
loved one and as I’ve described this
method for dealing with conflict it
sounds pretty easy right so why do we
continue our habit of crashing instead
of learning to dance one significant
factor seems to be shame on another TEDx
stage Renee Brown gave us the gift of
naming and defining shame that insistent
and persistent message and plan a deeply
inside of us by society religion family
that says we are somehow fundamentally
flawed her work suggests to me that
shame is the source of a lot of
conflicts because when I’m feeling and
focused on my own shame I can’t see
another’s pain and seen and being with
other people’s pain is crucial to
understanding and connecting with each
other so then recognizing shame in
ourselves becomes critical to being
present with others and really working
with rather than colliding in the
conflict
in my experience pain and fear have the
ability to connect us through empathy
but for so many of us Shane is often
hiding right behind fear and it’s
sitting right alongside pain and when
shame obscures empathy we hide and
disconnect and when we aren’t connected
to each other we’re out of the dance and
we crash now when I think of a car
accident the same comes to mind
don’t fall asleep at the wheel in this
scenario there’s an unmoving road and a
driver who for one instant stops paying
attention and calamity follows but I’m
beginning to think that life is much
more like driving a boat than it is like
driving a car I recently wrote a large
fairy with big windows that I stood in
front of watching us land approached in
the distance it’s the boat moved forward
and the sea moved underneath I could
feel the captain making very small turns
of the wheel to keep us on course almost
as though he were dancing with the water
and I had a moment of recognizing this
it’s a very powerful way of navigating
life in general and conflict very
specifically it’s staying aware and
making very small Corrections to keep on
the desired course and if we stay
focused on our desire to be in contact
then this dance of two what’s three wise
and – what’s kandel deeply enough
beneath the surface to provide those
small Corrections the dance is
essentially two steps forward to take
three steps back in order to come
towards each other again it’s in this
way that we can begin to redeem our
society by questioning and understanding
the impact of our policies so that we
can stop sentencing our kids to prisons
and Degraves and we can begin to redeem
ourselves and our relationships because
this compassion and understanding for
you might give me a way through my own
shame so that rather than continuing to
crash into each other we can begin to
dance thank you
[Applause]
you
Please follow and like us: