Press "Enter" to skip to content

Yes, Read the Comments Section | Simon Tam | TEDxBend


[Music]
On February 26 2015 a major conflict was
taking over the news cycle people around
the world started weighing in and taking
sides over the issue often times leading
to heated exchanges that resulted in
broken relationships and in some cases
and death threats in less than seven
days almost ten million tweets were
shared this wasn’t a divide that was
fueled by partisanship there was no
terrorist attack Donald Trump had not
even begun tweeting about being
president yet this in fact was about the
dress
the dress was a viral internet photo
that had people disagreeing whether this
article of clothing in question was
black and blue or white and gold in less
than 24 hours it broke BuzzFeed’s record
for the most number of concurrent users
and reached almost 33 million people
that’s more than either Democrats or
Republicans had participating in the
respective primaries now as somebody who
studies online coach for I actually care
not that much about the number of people
that see something but what I really
care about is the engagement factor the
interactions that people have with one
another especially how those
interactions ultimately drive behavior
so when people say things like don’t
read the comments section that’s when I
get really interested because while not
every single remark made online is
thought-provoking neither yeah neither
is every single concept or remark you’ll
hear at a town hall or in Congress or
our places of worship either we know
that those opinions and those
experiences can vary pretty drastically
they could be things that are kind of
awkward or genuinely funny especially
when you see how they could kind of play
out and lead to further comments and
they could be kind of really
inappropriate depending the context of
of what’s being shared and there’s
certainly certainly the kind of comments
that actually make you question the
value of having a comment section at all
but that’s kind of the nature of
comments right
you hear that refrain all the time don’t
read the comment section but when people
say that they’re not referring to these
like hilarious or kind of awkward or
quirky comments that are out there when
people say that they’re actually
referring to actual beliefs that they
don’t share oftentimes shared in a way
that might be distasteful or even
offensive but unlike popular internet
advice out there I think it’s important
I think yes you should read the comments
section because you should learn how to
connect with people who you disagree
with this is my steadfast belief apathy
is not compatible with love ignorant is
not the fuel for compassion we’re living
in one the most divided areas of our
country right now recent Pew Research
poll found that 41% of Democrats believe
Republicans to be a serious threat to
our country on the other side 45% of
Republicans feel the same way about
Democrats tensions are rising over
interpretations of events of police
brutality and racism and oftentimes
those divisions fall along racial lines
and it seems like we’re getting more
divided than ever despite having
internet feeds that are curated
specifically for us it’s a phenomenon
known as filter bubbles in other words
your social media feed the news that you
read the world events that hear and see
through your mobile device you your
computer is actually curated for you
it’s supposed to address your own
personal bias so that you get things
that you agree with more often than not
depending on how you engage that’s
actually making me use more extreme
rather than more nuanced and balanced
and so some people start blaming the
internet itself the technology itself as
the problem and there are those who feel
that way and they actually begin
engaging they decide to turn off
Facebook or block people or unfriend
them but blocking in and from
unfriending people to have more
comfortable existence only leads to more
isolation of your own views some people
retreat and instead of reading major
news sites they go to their own trusted
sources but those tend to be sources
that have a clear bias because it speaks
to a very specific worldview
other people see technology as the
solution for example there’s this common
belief out there that it’s the anonymous
nature of the Internet that makes people
so vicious and aggressive and that’s why
Google actually links all YouTube
comments to personal accounts now
however a recent study from the
University of South Australia found that
it non anonymous users are actually more
aggressive than anonymous ones then
there are new sites who have lost all
hope and faith the Washington Post’s NP
R Us site a USA Today all have cancelled
the comment sections on the respective
websites there’s a couple of people that
are adapting to this phenomenon the
verge actually kept the comments section
but now they edit them for length and
treat it more like a letters to the
editor section Norway has this new site
called NRK and what they do is they make
you take a quiz about the article you
just read before being able to comment
it’s pretty smart so they’re hoping that
people are forced to kind of test their
way through it will actually have a more
nuanced conversation will any of this
actually work though maybe rather than
simply sing technology as a tool I think
we should instead treat it as a symbol
how does the Internet how does social
media represent society itself I
oftentimes like to think of social media
as the world’s biggest cocktail party
some people have obviously had too much
to drink but changing the dynamics of
the party and how people engage doesn’t
actually adjust the core issue we need
to begin with a new protocol one that’s
rooted in empathy one that’s rooted in
compassion a lot of times people have
this assumption that Americans are
divided because we have different values
but we don’t have different values we
only have different interpretations and
experience different emphases of values
that we already share as a country but
how will you ever know that if you don’t
actually see other people’s what would
see what they see or if you hear their
particular stories we need to reach out
and learn about other people’s
experiences there are so many benefits
of having a robust online conversation
you get a litmus test on how other
people are feeling you get to find out
instantly am i credible and more
importantly you get to test your own
values one of the best ways to test your
own values is to see if they can
resonate with somebody who has a
different experience than you the new
progress or advancement of our society
shouldn’t be based on if you win an
Internet argument or not but it should
be in said if you can learn how to
develop more compassion in the face of
opposition now I’m not saying that you
need to spend every waking moment
addressing every comment made on the
Internet but I’m saying you should at
least take a moment pause and think
about this and ask yourself is it worth
losing a valued relationship
with another human being because of
something in your Facebook feed will you
actually build a better community by
ignoring and shutting other people down
I don’t think so because the cure for
bad speech on the internet isn’t
censorship it’s better speech it’s more
nuanced speech and speech that and
actually resonate with other people’s
values remember apathy is not compatible
with love
ignorance doesn’t actually try of
compassion it might not be the nicest
place but I believe you can begin with
the comment section thank you
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: