Press "Enter" to skip to content

Finding Authenticity in Discomfort | LB Hannahs | TEDxUF


[Music]
so the other morning I went to the
grocery store and an employee greeted me
with a good morning sir can I help you
with anything I said no thanks I’m good
person smile then we went our separate
ways I grabbed Cheerios and I left the
grocery store and I went through the
drive-through of a local coffee shop and
after I placed my order the voice on the
other end said thank you AM Drive right
around now in the span of less than an
hour
I was understood both as a sir and as a
man but for me neither of these people
are wrong but they’re also not
completely right this cute little human
is my almost two year old Elliot yeah
all right in over the past two years
this kid has forced me to rethink the
world and how I participate in it
identify as transgender and as a parent
and that makes me a transparent
[Laughter]
as you can see I took years this year’s
SEMA went super literal like any good
dad joke should so more specifically
identify as genderqueer and now there
are lots of ways to experience being
genderqueer but for me that means I
don’t really identify as a man or a
woman
I feel in-between and sometimes outside
of this gender binary and being outside
of this gender binary means that
sometimes I get served and ma’am in the
span of less than an hour when I’m out
doing everyday things like getting
Cheerios but this in-between land is
where I’m most comfortable this space
where I can be both a certain a man
feels the most right and the most
authentic but it doesn’t mean that these
interactions are uncomfortable trust me
that discomfort can range from minor
annoys to feel like physically unsafe at
the time at a bar in college when a
bouncer physically removing by the back
of the neck and threw me out of a
woman’s restroom but for me authenticity
doesn’t mean comfortable it means
managing and negotiating the discomfort
of everyday life even the times when
it’s unsafe and it wasn’t until my
experience as a trans person collided
with my new identity as a parent that I
understood the depth of my
vulnerabilities and how they were
preventing me from being my most
authentic self now for most people what
the child will call them is not
something that they gave much thought to
outside of culturally specific words or
variations on a gendered theme like mama
mommy or daddy Papa but for me the
possibility is with this child who will
grow to be a teenager and then a
real-life adult will call me for the
rest of our lives we both was both
extremely scary and exciting and I spent
nine months wrestling with the reality
that being called mama or something like
it didn’t feel like me at all and no
matter how many times their versions of
mom that I tried it always felt forced
and deeply uncomfortable I knew being
called mom or mommy would be easier to
digest for most people the idea of
having two moms is not super novel
especially where we live so I tried
other words and when I played around
with Daddy it felt better
better but not perfect it felt like a
pair of shoes that you really liked but
you needed to wear and break in and I
knew the idea of being a female born
person being called daddy was going to
be a harder road with a lot more
uncomfortable moments
but before I knew it the time had come
and Elliot came screaming into the world
like most babies do and my new identity
as a parent began I decided on becoming
a daddy and I knew and family face the
world now one of the most common things
that happens when people meet us is for
people to mom me and when I get moms
there are several ways of interaction
can go and I’ve drawn this map to help
help illustrate my options so option one
is to ignore the assumption and allow
folks to continue to refer to me as mom
which is not awkward for the other party
but it’s typically really awkward for us
and it usually causes me to restrict my
interaction with those people option one
option two is to is to stop and correct
them and say something like actually I’m
Elliot’s dad or Lda calls me daddy and
when I do this one or two of the
following things happen folks take it in
stride and say something like oh okay
and move on or they respond by pologize
‘ok profusely because they feel bad or
awkward or guilty or weird but more
often what happens is folks get really
confused and look up with an intense
look and say something like does this
mean you want to transition do you want
to be a man or say things like how can
she be a father only men can be dads
well option one is oftentimes the easier
route option two is always the more
authentic one in all of these scenarios
involve a level discomfort even in the
best case and I’ll say that over time my
ability to navigate this complicated map
has gotten easier but the discomfort is
still there now I won’t stand here and
pretend like I’ve mastered this it’s
pretty far from it and there are days
when I still allow option one to take
place because option two is just too
hard or too risky there’s no way to tell
that or to be sure of anyone’s reaction
and I want to be sure that folks have
good intentions that people are good but
we live in a world where someone’s
opinion of my existence can be met with
serious threats to me or even my
family’s emotional or physical safety
so I weigh the I weigh the cost against
the risks and sometimes the safety of my
family comes before my own authenticity
but
despite this risk I know as Elliott gets
older and grows into her consciousness
consciousness and language skills if I
don’t correct people she will I don’t
want my fears and insecurities to be
placed on her to dampen her spirit or
make her question her own voice I need
to model agency authenticity and
vulnerability and that lean means
leaning into those uncomfortable moments
of being mom’d and standing up and
saying no I’m a dad and I even have the
dad jokes to prove it now there already
been plenty of uncomfortable moments and
even some painful ones but there’s also
been in just two short years validating
and at times transformative moments on
my journey as a dad and my path towards
authenticity when we got our first
sonogram we decided we wanted to know
the sex of the baby the technician saw
Evolvin slapped the words it’s a girl on
the screen and gave us a copy and sent
us on our way
we shared the photo with our families
like everyone does and soon after my mom
showed up at our house with a bag filled
and I’m not exaggerating it was like
this I and it was filled and overflowing
with pink clothes and toys now I was a
little annoyed to be confronted with a
lot of pink things and having studied
gender and spent countless hours
teaching about it in the workshops and
classrooms I thought it was pretty
well-versed on the social construction
of gender on how sexism is a devaluing
of the feminine and how it manifests
both explicitly and implicitly but this
situation this aversion to a bag full of
pink stuff forced to force me to explore
my rejection of highly feminized things
in my child’s world I realized that I
was reinforcing sexism and the cultural
norms I teach is problematic no matter
how much I believe in gender neutrality
and theory in practice the absence of
femininity is not neutrality its
masculinity if I only address my baby in
greens and blues and Gray’s the outside
world doesn’t think oh that’s a cute
gender-neutral baby they think oh what a
cute boy
so my theoretical understanding of
gender and my parenting world collided
hard yes I want a diversity of colors
and toys for my childhood experience
I want a balanced environment for her to
explore and my sense of in her own way
we even picked a gender-neutral name
for our female born child but Jena
neutrality is much easier as a
theoretical endeavor that it is as a
practice and in my attempts to create
gender neutrality I was inadvertently
privileged in masculinity over
femininity so rather than toning down or
eliminating femininity in our lives we
make a concerted effort to celebrate it
we have pinks among the variety of
colours we balance out the cutes with
Handsome’s and the pretties with
Strong’s and smarts and work really not
hard not to associate any words with
gender we value femininity and
masculinity while also being highly
critical of it and do our best and to
not make her feel limited by gender
roles and we do all this in hopes that
we model a healthy and empowered
relationship with gender for our kid now
this work to develop a healthy
relationship with gender for Elliot made
me rethink and evaluate how I allowed
sexism to manifest in my own gender
identity I began to reevaluate how is
rejecting femininity in order to live up
to a masculinity that was not healthy or
something I wanted to pass on doing this
self work meant ahead the rejection
reject option one I couldn’t ignore and
move on I had to choose option two I had
to engage with some of my most
uncomfortable parts to move towards my
most authentic self and that meant I had
to get real about the discomfort I have
with my body now it’s pretty common for
trans people to feel uncomfortable in
their body and this discomfort can range
from debilitating to annoying and
everywhere in between and learning my
body and how to be comfortable in it as
a trans person has been a lifelong
journey I’ve always struggled with the
parts of my body that can be I can be
defined as more feminine my chest my
hips my voice and I’ve made this
sometimes hard sometimes easy decision
to not take hormones or have any
surgeries to change it to make myself
more masculine by society’s standards
and while I certainly haven’t overcome
all the feelings of dissatisfaction I
realized that by not engaging with that
discomfort and coming to a positive and
affirming place with my body I was
reinforcing sexism transphobia and
modeling body shaming if I hate my body
in particular the part society deems
feminine or female I potentially limit
or damage how my kid can see the
possibilities of her body and her
feminine and female parts if I hate I’m
uncomfortable with my body
can I expect my kid to love hers now it
would be easier for me to choose option
one to ignore my kid when she asked me
about my body or to hide it from her but
I have to choose option two every day I
have to confront my own assumptions
about what a dad’s body can and should
be so I work every day to try and be
more comfortable in this body and in the
ways I express femininity so I talk
about it more I explore the depths of
this discomfort and find language that I
feel comfortable with in this daily
discomfort helps me build both agency
and authenticity and how I show up in my
body and in my gender I’m working
against limiting myself I want to show
her that a dad can have hips a dad
doesn’t have to have a perfectly flat
chest or even be able to grow facial
hair and when she’s developmentally able
to I want to talk to her about my
journey with my body I wanted to see my
journey towards authenticity even when
it means showing her than Messier parts
we have a wonderful pediatrician and
have established a good relationship
with our kids doctor and as you all know
while your doctor stays the same your
nurses and nurse practitioners change it
in and out and when Elliot was first
born we took her to the pediatrician we
met our first nurse we’ll call her Sarah
now very early in on our time with Sarah
we told her how I was going to be called
dad and my partner is mama
Sarah was when most folks that took it
in stride and our subsequent visits went
pretty smoothly and about a year later
Sarah switched shifts and we started
working with a new nurse will call her
Becky and we didn’t get in front of the
dad conversations and it didn’t actually
come up until Sarah our original nurse
walked in to say hi now Sarah’s warm and
bubbly it said hi to Elliot and me and
my wife and when talking to Elliot said
something like is your daddy holding
your toy now the corner of my eye I
could see Becky swinging around in her
chair and make daggers at Sarah and as a
conversation shifted to our pediatrician
I saw Sarah and Becky’s interaction
continued and I want something like this
Becky
shaking your head no and mouthing the
word mom Beck Sarah shaking your head no
and mouthing word no dad I know awkward
right so this went back and forth and
total silence a few more times until we
walked away now this interaction is
stuck with me
sara could have chosen option one
ignored becky and let her refer to me as
mom it would have been easier for Sara
she could have put the responsibility
back on me or not said anything at all
but in that moment she chose option two
she chose to confront the assumptions
and affirm my existence she insisted
that a person who looks and sounds like
me can in fact be a dad
and in a small but meaningful way
advocated for me my authenticity and my
family unfortunately we live in a world
that refuses to acknowledge trans people
in the diversity of trans people in
general and my hope is that when
confronted with an opportunity to stand
up for someone else we all take action
like Sara even when there’s risk
involved so some days the risk of being
a genderqueer dad feels too much and
deciding to be a dad has been really
hard and I’m sure it will continue to be
the hardest yet most rewarding
experience of my life but despite this
challenge every day has felt a hundred
percent worth it so each day I affirm my
promise to Elliott and that same promise
to myself to love her and myself hard
with forgiveness and compassion with
tough love and with generosity to give
room for growth to push beyond comfort
in hopes of attaining and living a more
meaningful life I know in my head and in
my heart that they’re hard and painful
and uncomfortable days ahead my head and
my heart also know that all of it will
lead to a more rich authentic life that
I could look back on without regrets
thank
you
Please follow and like us: