
[Music]
you
[Music]
so the next time you drive down a major
roadway or highway simply look you
likely see signs or billboards
advertising the services of a health
system or hospital or increasingly
emergency services pointing out things
like efficiency and quicker care and
faster care all obviously an attempt to
actually track paying patients but
there’s a story behind this and I think
it’s important for you to understand the
dimensions in the emergency care has not
just become an integral part of modern
health care but it’s become truly the
safety net for health system that’s a
need of repair with emergency department
visits actually growing to over 140
million visits a year hospitals
especially our safety net hospitals are
at a breaking point and costs are
mounting so one may ask the question how
do we get here how did our safety net
system actually evolve to this point
well we have to go back to more than 50
years ago to understand what happened
and this is the birth of emergency
medicine as a specialty so you see in
1961 a group of physicians family
physicians to be exact
decided that they were going to leave
their practices their well-developed
primary care practices the Philibert all
we need in the health care system at the
time and that was to fulfill the need to
provide after-hours care reliably during
that period of time so in the basement
of a hospital in Alexandria Virginia
they opened up a one-room to bad
emergency air practice and this was
called the Alexandria plan and this plan
actually served as one of the blueprints
for what emergency medicine has become
today a phenomenon that’s actually grown
from a neglected mission in the basement
of a hospital to one of the most
sophisticated and essential offerings in
healthcare today but a very costly
safety net for health systems failures
now pivotal to the growth of emergency
medicine
was the law that was passed in 1986
called EMTALA emergency medicine
treatment and active Labor Act now
believe it or not before 1986 there were
problems in the health care system big
problems because you see in parts of our
country patients critically ill patients
even patients who were dying were being
turned away from hospital after hospital
because of one problem they could afford
to pay and what was really interesting
about this was that this law
EMTALA essentially focused on ensuring
that these hospitals did not pursue the
discriminatory practice of not caring
for patients who could not afford the
high cost of health care of emergency
care of treating and managed those
conditions now what’s interesting about
this is hospitals before 1986 actually
did not have the legal obligation to
care for patients and so what happened
was that this law EMTALA essentially
also served as a safety net for patients
who were on Medicaid or patients who are
in government insurance but in fact what
it did was it protected everyone and
anyone who wanted to enter the emergency
care system for care EMTALA this law
essentially became national healthcare
policy for those who were uninsured and
underinsured this was a mandate it was a
mandate this lasted for more than 30
years this was a mandate essentially did
one thing it diminished access barriers
to health care through emergency
medicine more than in any other part of
the healthcare system so as a result of
this emergency departments today serve
as a safety net for society’s most
vulnerable including minority
communities and the poor but there were
challenges that actually lay ahead
significant ones because after 1986
emergency department visits continue to
escalate
perhaps because access to other parts of
the healthcare system
could not keep pace and were virtually
closed or inaccessible to those most
vulnerable matter of fact the emergency
department visits grew faster than the
u.s. population
fact between 1997 and 2009 US population
grew by 12% but during that period of
time emergency department visit group by
43% so make no mistake that emergency
departments especially their safety net
hospitals are crowded and the specter of
more uninsured or underinsured entering
our system in addition to the aging
population is a prescription for
emergency department visits increasing
throughout the United States but is this
really the direction we want to go an
ever expanding safety net system of
uncoordinated care complicated by
inconsistent information sharing
duplication of services and escalating
costs in truth this law EMTALA was a
victory for patients it was a victory
for some form of access to care but the
question is was this access truly
sufficient perhaps we needed to pay
attention to the fact that preventive
care or long term care or care based
upon relationships was important perhaps
some emergency department visits could
be prevented in this way because you see
it is wrong to force patients to enter
the emergency department system for care
when that care could have been avoided
or could have been perhaps provided and
the less resource intense more connected
less costly environment so you see in
emergency medicine you have to get it
right the first time and you have to get
it quickly oftentimes with insufficient
information and most of the time without
the benefit of a relationship with a
patient so this is precisely why in this
fragmented system of care that I have to
look very carefully at my practice
knowing that I may actually have to
order one more test or perhaps admit to
the hospital one more time simply
because I may not have a choice when our
health system fails and you may not see
that but I see that in the emergency
department with increasing cascades of
patients entering the safety net health
system for the care
cannot receive elsewhere so while our
health care system truly bristles with
the best of technology and gleaming
infrastructure and leads the world in
advancement in science and discovery and
medicine you need only look under the
hood to find that we’re failing to meet
the basic needs of society and what do I
mean by that well let me explain of the
thirteen most developed countries in the
world the u.s. ranks the lowest in life
expectancy the highest and infant
mortality and the highest and obesity
rates when you control for the size of
the economy comparatively speaking the
u.s. actually spends a V most in health
care and the least in social spending
and these are just but a few indicators
that point that our health system may be
in jeopardy here are some more facts 1/2
of patients that actually enter the
emergency department system for care are
either completely uninsured or maybe
underinsured under Medicaid one quarter
of acute care visits in this entire
country and virtually all such visits
that are after-hours or on weekends are
seen in emergency departments of all of
the uninsured visits for acute care in
this country 1/2 are seen in emergency
departments by physicians like me but
the emergency department is not just a
place for the uninsured or underinsured
because studies have shown that even
those with insurance one-third of them
actually access the emergency department
for care because they could not actually
get care elsewhere because elsewhere was
not available
so you see access to care to the
emergency care system is virtually
without any barriers compared to the
rest of the healthcare system and we
need to understand that we need to
debate this we need to discuss this we
need to repair this broken part of a
health care system people access
the health care system through the only
avenues that are available to them and
so in our society 9/11 millions of
people have essentially become access to
care so we have to think about this a
little bit the rate of rise of emergency
department visits and the increasing
burden our safety net system is going to
happen and we have to think about
whether or not this is truly sustainable
so how can we actually slow the cycle of
flawed and vicious fragmented care and
reliance on our burden healthcare system
well a colleague of mine actually wrote
in a recent paper that fear and
uncertainty is what most often drives
patients to seek care fear of the course
and the consequence of disease and the
need for insurance and the need for
information so what’s happening in our
healthcare system is actually exciting
because people are beginning to really
innovate around this one of the things
you’re probably seeing today is a
proliferation of free-standing emergency
departments and urgent care centers and
you know clinics in retail pharmacies
and even department stores trying to
meet this need but here’s what’s
happening in innovation and access to
care hospitals and organizations for
instance they’re looking at things like
extending primary care or hours or even
extending specialty care clinic hours or
how about telehealth where cellular
technology and Wi-Fi technology can be
used to connect a patient to a provider
and a healthcare transaction can
actually occur without an in-person
visit now here at UF we actually have an
example of an After Hours clinic that
you have orthopedics and sports medicine
Institute which a couple of years ago
began to offer extended hours both
during the week and also the weekends
and the impact that has had is that
emergency department visits for simple
uncomplicated orthopedic complaints and
injuries dramatically decreased what
about health information technology what
we must decrease the barriers to meaning
we share health information across
hospitals and across health systems in
our region while maintaining the safety
of patient information but why should we
be doing this so we can actually reduce
duplication of services so you could
reduce costs reduce unnecessary testing
and perhaps even reduce harm perhaps we
should develop systems that allow
patients to actually own their own
health records so they could actually
freely distribute it when necessary
hospitals and organizations need to look
at their own neighborhoods their own
populations to really look at unmet
needs so we’re doing some of this in
emergency medicine for instance and
we’ve done research that actually is
focus in public transportation policy
and finding that even that can impact
the numbers of patients who actually go
to the emergency department with
potentially avoidable visits and even
potentially avoidable hospital
admissions primary care redesign is
actually happening everywhere so instead
of fixed appointments during weekdays
you actually have open access there is
experimentation with what’s called
direct care where folks are actually
bypassing insurance companies and paying
physicians a very small fee like a gym
membership to receive basic health care
what about home visits by the primary
care workforce but used to happen
decades ago how about power medicine
where paramedics are actually visiting
the homes of patients who have just been
discharged from the hospital to ensure
that they’re safe and they understand
their healthcare needs you see we have
to innovate around primary care it’s not
just about expanding the primary care
workforce we must innovate and these
innovations I think become the future of
improving health care in this country
but I want to return to one particular
issue I mentioned and that was EMTALA
this mandate that was signed into law
more than 30 years ago
this was a mandate that we really could
learn from the mandate in health care it
had an unintended consequence obviously
because it helped to fuel the rise of
emergency department visits across the
country but this is a mandate that
actually worked quietly in the
background ensuring access to care for
those most vulnerable but also ensuring
access for those who have insurance who
could not find timely care elsewhere
EMTALA is an example of a mandate that
is demonstrated that mandates actually
can work in our health care system even
though in this particular case it wasn’t
perfect because it created one-way
street and health systems safety net but
maybe we should rethink this maybe it
shouldn’t be just assuring access to the
emergency care and high-cost care maybe
access to the very basic of health needs
should be assured regardless of your
ability to pay regardless of your social
or economic background regardless of
your cultural origins regardless of your
zip code perhaps we need to invest in
rather than abandon the idea that
long-term and trusting relationships
between patients and physicians should
be the cornerstone of good health policy
empowering patients advancing patient
centered care and yes improving outcomes
perhaps we need to rethink the fact that
our health system safety net only has a
one-way street
so this in this most developed country
in the world I have seen example after
example of failures in our health care
system I took care of that middle aged
man who would not have had that
devastating stroke if he actually had
timely and effective access to care and
could afford the medicines that would
have controlled his blood pressure
I personally grieve with that family of
that woman that wife that mother who I
tried to resuscitate and I couldn’t
because she actually died on the way to
the hospital
from asthma a completely preventable
disease why because she didn’t have
access to primary care or access to men
that could have saved her life I’ve seen
like my colleagues across the rest of
the country example after example of
failures in a health care system but
there is good news and the good news is
that we are seeing innovations in our
health care system people are thinking
about access to care people are thinking
about how we can truly improve care in
America and so we have to grab this
opportunity and truly rethink how we
approach health care in America thank
you
[Applause]
you
[Music]
so the next time you drive down a major
roadway or highway simply look you
likely see signs or billboards
advertising the services of a health
system or hospital or increasingly
emergency services pointing out things
like efficiency and quicker care and
faster care all obviously an attempt to
actually track paying patients but
there’s a story behind this and I think
it’s important for you to understand the
dimensions in the emergency care has not
just become an integral part of modern
health care but it’s become truly the
safety net for health system that’s a
need of repair with emergency department
visits actually growing to over 140
million visits a year hospitals
especially our safety net hospitals are
at a breaking point and costs are
mounting so one may ask the question how
do we get here how did our safety net
system actually evolve to this point
well we have to go back to more than 50
years ago to understand what happened
and this is the birth of emergency
medicine as a specialty so you see in
1961 a group of physicians family
physicians to be exact
decided that they were going to leave
their practices their well-developed
primary care practices the Philibert all
we need in the health care system at the
time and that was to fulfill the need to
provide after-hours care reliably during
that period of time so in the basement
of a hospital in Alexandria Virginia
they opened up a one-room to bad
emergency air practice and this was
called the Alexandria plan and this plan
actually served as one of the blueprints
for what emergency medicine has become
today a phenomenon that’s actually grown
from a neglected mission in the basement
of a hospital to one of the most
sophisticated and essential offerings in
healthcare today but a very costly
safety net for health systems failures
now pivotal to the growth of emergency
medicine
was the law that was passed in 1986
called EMTALA emergency medicine
treatment and active Labor Act now
believe it or not before 1986 there were
problems in the health care system big
problems because you see in parts of our
country patients critically ill patients
even patients who were dying were being
turned away from hospital after hospital
because of one problem they could afford
to pay and what was really interesting
about this was that this law
EMTALA essentially focused on ensuring
that these hospitals did not pursue the
discriminatory practice of not caring
for patients who could not afford the
high cost of health care of emergency
care of treating and managed those
conditions now what’s interesting about
this is hospitals before 1986 actually
did not have the legal obligation to
care for patients and so what happened
was that this law EMTALA essentially
also served as a safety net for patients
who were on Medicaid or patients who are
in government insurance but in fact what
it did was it protected everyone and
anyone who wanted to enter the emergency
care system for care EMTALA this law
essentially became national healthcare
policy for those who were uninsured and
underinsured this was a mandate it was a
mandate this lasted for more than 30
years this was a mandate essentially did
one thing it diminished access barriers
to health care through emergency
medicine more than in any other part of
the healthcare system so as a result of
this emergency departments today serve
as a safety net for society’s most
vulnerable including minority
communities and the poor but there were
challenges that actually lay ahead
significant ones because after 1986
emergency department visits continue to
escalate
perhaps because access to other parts of
the healthcare system
could not keep pace and were virtually
closed or inaccessible to those most
vulnerable matter of fact the emergency
department visits grew faster than the
u.s. population
fact between 1997 and 2009 US population
grew by 12% but during that period of
time emergency department visit group by
43% so make no mistake that emergency
departments especially their safety net
hospitals are crowded and the specter of
more uninsured or underinsured entering
our system in addition to the aging
population is a prescription for
emergency department visits increasing
throughout the United States but is this
really the direction we want to go an
ever expanding safety net system of
uncoordinated care complicated by
inconsistent information sharing
duplication of services and escalating
costs in truth this law EMTALA was a
victory for patients it was a victory
for some form of access to care but the
question is was this access truly
sufficient perhaps we needed to pay
attention to the fact that preventive
care or long term care or care based
upon relationships was important perhaps
some emergency department visits could
be prevented in this way because you see
it is wrong to force patients to enter
the emergency department system for care
when that care could have been avoided
or could have been perhaps provided and
the less resource intense more connected
less costly environment so you see in
emergency medicine you have to get it
right the first time and you have to get
it quickly oftentimes with insufficient
information and most of the time without
the benefit of a relationship with a
patient so this is precisely why in this
fragmented system of care that I have to
look very carefully at my practice
knowing that I may actually have to
order one more test or perhaps admit to
the hospital one more time simply
because I may not have a choice when our
health system fails and you may not see
that but I see that in the emergency
department with increasing cascades of
patients entering the safety net health
system for the care
cannot receive elsewhere so while our
health care system truly bristles with
the best of technology and gleaming
infrastructure and leads the world in
advancement in science and discovery and
medicine you need only look under the
hood to find that we’re failing to meet
the basic needs of society and what do I
mean by that well let me explain of the
thirteen most developed countries in the
world the u.s. ranks the lowest in life
expectancy the highest and infant
mortality and the highest and obesity
rates when you control for the size of
the economy comparatively speaking the
u.s. actually spends a V most in health
care and the least in social spending
and these are just but a few indicators
that point that our health system may be
in jeopardy here are some more facts 1/2
of patients that actually enter the
emergency department system for care are
either completely uninsured or maybe
underinsured under Medicaid one quarter
of acute care visits in this entire
country and virtually all such visits
that are after-hours or on weekends are
seen in emergency departments of all of
the uninsured visits for acute care in
this country 1/2 are seen in emergency
departments by physicians like me but
the emergency department is not just a
place for the uninsured or underinsured
because studies have shown that even
those with insurance one-third of them
actually access the emergency department
for care because they could not actually
get care elsewhere because elsewhere was
not available
so you see access to care to the
emergency care system is virtually
without any barriers compared to the
rest of the healthcare system and we
need to understand that we need to
debate this we need to discuss this we
need to repair this broken part of a
health care system people access
the health care system through the only
avenues that are available to them and
so in our society 9/11 millions of
people have essentially become access to
care so we have to think about this a
little bit the rate of rise of emergency
department visits and the increasing
burden our safety net system is going to
happen and we have to think about
whether or not this is truly sustainable
so how can we actually slow the cycle of
flawed and vicious fragmented care and
reliance on our burden healthcare system
well a colleague of mine actually wrote
in a recent paper that fear and
uncertainty is what most often drives
patients to seek care fear of the course
and the consequence of disease and the
need for insurance and the need for
information so what’s happening in our
healthcare system is actually exciting
because people are beginning to really
innovate around this one of the things
you’re probably seeing today is a
proliferation of free-standing emergency
departments and urgent care centers and
you know clinics in retail pharmacies
and even department stores trying to
meet this need but here’s what’s
happening in innovation and access to
care hospitals and organizations for
instance they’re looking at things like
extending primary care or hours or even
extending specialty care clinic hours or
how about telehealth where cellular
technology and Wi-Fi technology can be
used to connect a patient to a provider
and a healthcare transaction can
actually occur without an in-person
visit now here at UF we actually have an
example of an After Hours clinic that
you have orthopedics and sports medicine
Institute which a couple of years ago
began to offer extended hours both
during the week and also the weekends
and the impact that has had is that
emergency department visits for simple
uncomplicated orthopedic complaints and
injuries dramatically decreased what
about health information technology what
we must decrease the barriers to meaning
we share health information across
hospitals and across health systems in
our region while maintaining the safety
of patient information but why should we
be doing this so we can actually reduce
duplication of services so you could
reduce costs reduce unnecessary testing
and perhaps even reduce harm perhaps we
should develop systems that allow
patients to actually own their own
health records so they could actually
freely distribute it when necessary
hospitals and organizations need to look
at their own neighborhoods their own
populations to really look at unmet
needs so we’re doing some of this in
emergency medicine for instance and
we’ve done research that actually is
focus in public transportation policy
and finding that even that can impact
the numbers of patients who actually go
to the emergency department with
potentially avoidable visits and even
potentially avoidable hospital
admissions primary care redesign is
actually happening everywhere so instead
of fixed appointments during weekdays
you actually have open access there is
experimentation with what’s called
direct care where folks are actually
bypassing insurance companies and paying
physicians a very small fee like a gym
membership to receive basic health care
what about home visits by the primary
care workforce but used to happen
decades ago how about power medicine
where paramedics are actually visiting
the homes of patients who have just been
discharged from the hospital to ensure
that they’re safe and they understand
their healthcare needs you see we have
to innovate around primary care it’s not
just about expanding the primary care
workforce we must innovate and these
innovations I think become the future of
improving health care in this country
but I want to return to one particular
issue I mentioned and that was EMTALA
this mandate that was signed into law
more than 30 years ago
this was a mandate that we really could
learn from the mandate in health care it
had an unintended consequence obviously
because it helped to fuel the rise of
emergency department visits across the
country but this is a mandate that
actually worked quietly in the
background ensuring access to care for
those most vulnerable but also ensuring
access for those who have insurance who
could not find timely care elsewhere
EMTALA is an example of a mandate that
is demonstrated that mandates actually
can work in our health care system even
though in this particular case it wasn’t
perfect because it created one-way
street and health systems safety net but
maybe we should rethink this maybe it
shouldn’t be just assuring access to the
emergency care and high-cost care maybe
access to the very basic of health needs
should be assured regardless of your
ability to pay regardless of your social
or economic background regardless of
your cultural origins regardless of your
zip code perhaps we need to invest in
rather than abandon the idea that
long-term and trusting relationships
between patients and physicians should
be the cornerstone of good health policy
empowering patients advancing patient
centered care and yes improving outcomes
perhaps we need to rethink the fact that
our health system safety net only has a
one-way street
so this in this most developed country
in the world I have seen example after
example of failures in our health care
system I took care of that middle aged
man who would not have had that
devastating stroke if he actually had
timely and effective access to care and
could afford the medicines that would
have controlled his blood pressure
I personally grieve with that family of
that woman that wife that mother who I
tried to resuscitate and I couldn’t
because she actually died on the way to
the hospital
from asthma a completely preventable
disease why because she didn’t have
access to primary care or access to men
that could have saved her life I’ve seen
like my colleagues across the rest of
the country example after example of
failures in a health care system but
there is good news and the good news is
that we are seeing innovations in our
health care system people are thinking
about access to care people are thinking
about how we can truly improve care in
America and so we have to grab this
opportunity and truly rethink how we
approach health care in America thank
you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: