
to talk about today is to ask the
question why do we draw and I want to
talk specifically about using drawing as
a way of supporting creative thinking we
can think of that separately for how we
use drawing as a means of communication
so for example say that you wanted to
design a new kitchen you might grab a
piece of paper and draw on the piece of
paper your layout in kitchen then you
can show that to someone to give them an
idea of what it was you were thinking
about there are some other situations in
which we use drawing light as a way of
just communicating with ourselves and we
use sketches and drawings as a way of
supporting problem-solving for example
this is a very famous painting organic
ax by Pablo Picasso in real life it’s as
you see now it’s a black and white
painting it’s also very large it’s about
three and a half by eight meters in
dimension and it represents an incident
which happened in the Spanish Civil War
in the 1930s what happens is that the
Basques town of Guernica was almost
completely destroyed in an aerial
bombardment and it led to great loss of
civilian life and Picasso intended his
painting to be to make a very strong
anti-war message and it’s regarded by
many people to be his masterpiece now
you see it’s a very complex composition
and it’s not something the Picasso just
came up with immediately
in fact he produced 67 preliminary
sketches and drawings and paintings in
which he played around with different
types of composition and different
appearances of the figures you see in
the scene until he arrived at the final
version that we know today now it’s
certainly not unusual for architects and
designers and artists to use sketching
as a way of thinking through ideas in
terms of what they want to produce and
normally when we draw we’d have a mental
image of what we expect the final
drawing to look like and that mental
image would guide the actual drawing
process that way is it an interesting
question if we can already imagine what
something looks like why is there any
value and actually going on to draw it
why can’t we just use the mental image
on its own now to understand that we
need to understand how perception works
now it feels to us as if the way we
perceive the world in front of us is
automatic
just open our eyes and we just see the
world effortlessly that is an illusion
in fact our brain has to entirely
construct our experience of seeing the
world and way it does that is by
interpreting the information that we
receive through our sensory systems so
for example in the case of vision our
brain has to interpret the way that
light stimulates the retina of our eyes
now the vast majority of cases our
brains interpret this information in the
same way and therefore we all have the
experience of seeing the world in the
same way but there are some
circumstances in which that does not
happen for example this is a photograph
of a dress that was posted on tumblr in
2015 and it very quickly went viral
because it became apparent that people
were seeing this dress in very different
ways so some people see this as being a
white and gold dress and some other
people see it as being a black and blue
dress and when you look at the internet
comments people were just amazed that
anyone else could see this dress in a
different way – that they were
perceiving it and I would count myself
in it so when I saw this dress I thought
well that’s clearly a white and gold
dress and I felt great sympathy for the
poor deluded fools and soy sauce or
black and blue dress that’s why it’s
quite disconcerting that it is in fact
very clearly a black and blue dress
in fact the manufacturers of this dress
have now created a white and gold dress
purely to capitalize on the publicity
that came about when it’s the original
photograph went viral but the point is
that the original photograph of the
dress it’s ambiguous so it can support
being our black and blue dress albeit in
a very overexposed photograph but it can
also support being a white and gold
dress as well and because the
information the picture is ambiguous our
brains can interpret it in different
ways and therefore that can translate as
having very different experiences about
what it is that we actually see if you
take a look at this picture here what do
you think that is so telling me this is
referred to as being the duck rabbit
figure so some people see this as being
a rabbit and other people see it as
being a duck so you can interpret it in
two entirely different ways it’s an
ambiguous picture what we call a
bi-stable picture so you can either see
it as red
anything and duck in which case you see
pointing to the left with the Bill of
the dog pointed towards the left or you
can see it as being a rabbit in which
case its facing towards the right with
the ears of the rabbit pointing back
towards the left now in 1985 two
psychologists Deborah chambers and
Daniel Rhys burg they come up with a
very interesting study so they said okay
when people normally look at this
picture it’s very easy for them to see
the alternative interpretations what
happens if they just imagine what the
picture looks like so they did a study
where they had a group of people who
haven’t seen this particular picture
before they showed it to them briefly
and then got them to imagine what the
picture looked like and then they said
to people okay what are you looking at
and some people said it was a picture of
a duck and other people said it was a
picture of a rabbit and then they said
can you see the alternative
interpretation of what the picture might
be and strikingly in their original
sample no one was able to see the
alternative interpretation so those
people reading sources a doc continued
to see it as a duck and those people
originally saw it as a rabbit continue
to see it as a rabbit now you might
think well maybe they just don’t
remember the picture accurately enough
so then change and rise burg gave them a
piece of paper and asked them to draw
from memory what they remember seeing
the picture was like I can show you a
representation there so these are people
drawing the picture from memory and you
see they don’t draw it exactly those
people saw it as a rabbit were more
likely to draw it as a rabbit and those
people saw it as a duck were more likely
to draw it as representing a duck but
nonetheless once actually drew the image
strikingly everyone once you actually
looked at their picture of what they
remembered it looking like was able to
work out the alternative interpretation
so why was it that drawing a picture of
the duck rabbit figure was so much
easier to reinterpret than just having a
mental image of it well again this ties
into the way in which our perceptual
system works so when we look at the
picture of the duck rabbit figure this
is an external picture our sensory
system processes it initially we see it
as a duck or a rabbit if we continue to
look at it then our perceptual system
can continue to reinterpret
it and we were able to see an
alternative way of thinking about it but
when we imagine the picture that is
already interpreted so we don’t have a
mental image of this scene as being an
ambiguous picture which could be a duck
or a rabbit we have a mental image of it
being a duck or being a rabbit and that
pre-existing interpretation what we call
in psychology a reference frame it can
actually constrain our ability to see
different interpretations now my own
research on this topic I’ve made use of
a task in which I ask people to imagine
things in response to verbal
instructions so I’m going to give you an
example of that I want you to try and
imagine the things they tell you to
imagine okay so I’d like you to first
would imagine a capital jj4 Juliet I
want you to imagine a capital J okay
then next to that I want you to imagine
a capital D D for Delta I now want you
to imagine rotating the D 90 degrees to
the left or if you prefer 90 degrees
anti-clockwise and now I want you to
imagine placing the rotated D on top of
the letter J okay what does that look
like to you
that’s right if you followed that
correctly you will see that it forms
something that people see as being an
umbrella as ever of a colleague Robert
Logie who’s at the University of
Edinburgh we did a study where we got
people to do a whole series of these
types of tasks but we manipulated the
circumstances in which they did them so
one group of people just did it using
mental imagery alone as I asked you to
do another group of people did it by
drawing in the air with their finger so
it with draw J drordy
draw the D 90 degrees to the left draw
the D on top of the J what do you think
it is a third group of people we gave
them a piece of paper and we asked them
to physically draw what they remember
seeing so they drew a J they drew a D
they drew the D 90 degrees to the left
and then they drew the D on top of the J
what do you think it is a final group
sat in front of a computer in front of a
graphics package there was a Jana D on
the screen
and they physically enacted all of the
movements so they clicked on the D with
a mouse that r8 ated it 90 degrees to
the left they physically move the D on
top of the J and then they’re again
asked what they thought it was and we
gave the series of these kind of
instructions where people manipulate
shapes to see if it produces a
recognizable picture at the end so what
you’re seeing here is a data on that
particular experiment it was published
in the Journal of thinking and reasoning
in 2015 and what you can see is what
you’re seeing is an average how many
people were able to work out what the
final picture looked like and you can
see that the more aspects of this the
tasks that people are actually able to
see the easier they found it to do so
when people were just using using
imagery alone performance was at its
lowest and when we had people doing it
fully externalized so they can see
everything performance was at its
highest so in order to do this task you
have to stop thinking about it as being
letters of the alphabet and you have to
start thinking of it as potentially
representing something else and
absolutely demonstrates that it’s easier
to do that the more aspects of those
shapes you’re actually able to see
rather than just imagine so to answer
the question I posed at the beginning
why do we draw I would argue that the
reason we draw is it allows us to
capitalize on the ability of our
perceptual system to more easily
reinterpret visual information so when
you draw something that you’re imagining
you’re taking an internal representation
your brain is creating itself and you’re
converting it to an external
representation of drawing which is
separate from you and your perceptual
system can process it as a separate
image and our brains are incredibly good
at being able to detect novel patterns
and familiar shapes in visual
information so to show you a final image
what do you think that is at kangaroo
some people see it as a rabbit some
people some sort of heard dinosaur it is
in fact a cloud
there is nothing there it’s just water
vapor but our perceptual system has
evolved so we’re very very good at being
able to detect familiar shapes and
patterns in even something random like a
cow a cloud that’s why the internet you
see pieces of burnt toast that look like
people’s faces or trees that looks like
dogs our brain is very very good at
doing that so drawing allows us to
capitalize on that ability of our brain
to more easily reinterpret visual
information so if you don’t currently
use drawing and sketching as a way of
supporting problem-solving and
supporting creativity then I would
encourage you to do so because imagining
what something looks like and actually
seeing what it looks like and not the
same thing thank you for listening [Applause]