Press "Enter" to skip to content

Question Everything: What leads to progress? | John Lambie | TEDxAngliaRuskinUniversity


thank you so my talk is going to be
about what leads to printer progress the
first thing I want to answer is what do
we mean by progress now I’m going to
illustrate this with this picture here
of the section of the solar system it
only goes up to Jupiter there but
there’s some good and s and bad news
about our future now the bad news is
this hater break it to you but the Sun
is going to become a red giant and it’s
going to be too hot to live on the earth
the good news is it’s not going to
happen for seven billion years so
there’s plenty of time we could escape
in a rocket and go and live in one of
the moons of Jupiter which would be in
the habitable zone that’s as long as we
survived that long of course we might
not survive that long and in any case
when we get to Jupiter we still need to
treat each other nicely if we don’t then
that doesn’t seem like like progress
so there’s a scientific element to
progress as technology like the rocket
that might take us away from the earth
but there’s also a moral element to
progress we we would need to reduce
suffering and actually if we don’t treat
each other nicely we won’t reduce
suffering so this science and scientific
progress and moral progress so this got
me thinking is there something that
underlies both of these things normally
people think science and morality are
two very different things
is there a style of thinking that leads
to both of these that underlies these
well I think there is and I call it
critical open-mindedness and I’m going
to illustrate critical open-mindedness
using my props here now imagine you’ve
got two different theories theory a and
theory B these could be theories of two
different scientific theories of global
warming for example or they might be the
views of the Palestinians and these
these Raley’s they might be the views of
a married couple in an argument I used
to argue a lot with my wife about who
did the most chores
we we don’t anymore on this but you
could have I do the most chores now I do
the most chores
well my chores are harder than yours and
my chores are harder than yours now
open-mindedness or rather closed
mindedness is where you closed one of
these down and you’re sure that your
view is right I know that I’m right
open-mindedness is where you keep both
open so you’ve got both points of view
open now what’s critical open-mindedness
now critical open-mindedness is where
you could you keep the theories open you
do think one point of view is better
than the other but you don’t completely
get rid of this other point of view and
you’re prepared to switch so there’s a
critical element to it now does this
style of thinking actually exist I’m
going to give you an example of it from
from history from Martin Luther and
Erasmus so these are two religious
thinkers at the time of the present
retro firm Asian and what I want to
illustrate to you is they’re different
styles of thought they were very similar
characters in a lot of ways they were
both as I say though they’re religious
thinkers they’re both Northern Europeans
they were both trained as monks but
their attitudes of mind are very very
different they had an argument about
freewill and they sent these books to to
each other and it’s a bit like the thing
you might get on internet comments pages
now Luther he says your book is so
contemptible and worthless although you
write wrongly I owe you no small thanks
because you’ve confirmed my view now
Erasmus is a very different attitude
even if I’ve understood what Luther
discusses it’s altogether possible I’m
mistaken I really want to enquire and
not to dogma ties and I’m ready to learn
so if I highlight these for you you can
see that there’s a very different style
Luther on the left this is very much
what you get on internet comments pages
people saying you’re wrong it’s actually
rarer that you get the style of Erasmus
he’s the critically open style he’s
saying I might be wrong I’m ready to
learn from from other people so there
you have an example of two religious
thinkers one is closed and one
one is open but what Galileo actually
talked about in a great book
16:32 dialogue concerning the two chief
world-systems he compared these two
theories whether the earth is at the
center or whether the Sun is at the
center and what he did is he was very
open about the arguments for both sides
although he was on the side of the Sun
being at the center he realized that
there were quite a lot of good exactly
arguments on the other side and he did
give a really good go at giving you
arguments for both sides so there’s a
critically open-minded aspect to it now
you might think well we know that
Galileo was right about the Sun being
the center so shouldn’t we be
closed-minded now shouldn’t we keep be
there you know we’re sure about that we
know the sun’s at the center well the
thing is Galilei wasn’t completely right
he got quite a lot of things wrong
he thought the planets went round in
circles and they don’t they go round in
ellipses they were better theories my
next lovely prop here is my credibility
thermometer of how strongly you you
believe in a theory now Galileo’s theory
may have been quite good at the time
there was reasonably good evidence for
it maybe he was at 70% it wasn’t a
hundred percent correct Newton’s theory
of the solar system was pretty good he
probably did maybe get up to 99 percent
his theory wasn’t the best theory
Einstein’s theory was better than that
maybe 99.5% the point of my credibility
thermometer it doesn’t go up to 100 you
keep your options open for better
theories now one thing that Galileo did
was he considered the opposite view now
this is something that psychologists
have looked at as a way of getting rid
of bias now there’s a thing called my
side bias which you’re probably all
familiar with which is that people tend
to think that arguments that support
their view a better quality so for
example if I support the death penalty
and I read an article that supports the
death penalty I’m more likely to say
yeah that was well-written that was a
good
argument it happens in sport as well if
you support a particular football team
and you’re asked to judge the quality of
the referee you will probably say the
quality of the refereeing is better when
it supports your team what’s interesting
about my side bias is that it’s quite
hard to get rid of it if you just tell
people look there’s this thing called
bias we’re all biased just try not to be
biased
try not to be biased in favor of your
team it doesn’t really work the only way
that you can get rid of bias is you have
to tell you to consider the opposite
view so you have to say imagine you
didn’t support the death penalty what
would you think now the arguments or
imagine you supported the other team now
how would you judge the quality of the
referee so so this is a good example of
seeing open-mindedness in action now I
we’ve talked about Galileo using this
but religious thinkers use it as well
and a real master of it is Jesus in
Luke’s Gospel now I’m not a religious
believer but I am struck by the
similarities with the how Jesus is
portrayed in Luke’s Gospel and this sort
of feature of open-mindedness so in
Luke’s Gospel there’s a lot of parables
that Jesus tells that are all about
asking people to consider a different
point of view one of the most famous
ones is the Good Samaritan now the Good
Samaritan everyone knows the story a bit
I think but often people don’t realize
what it’s about so I’ll put it into
context for you so the Good Samaritan
the story is that person is wounded and
you’re assuming this is a Jewish person
this is who Jesus is talking to Jews or
audience and three people walk by the
first person is a priest he walks by he
looks at the wounded man and he just
walks on by the second person is a
Levite who is someone of the priests
class he does the same thing he looks at
the man and he walks on by the third
person is the Samaritan he looks at the
man and he has compassion on him and he
looks after him he dresses his wounds
and he takes him to the inn now the
interesting the whole point of the story
is not just that oh somebody
the point of the story you need to know
is that the Jews and the Samaritans
hated each other they despised each
other so much that the Roman historian
at the time Josephus recorded how the
Jews destroyed the Samaritans temple and
you also need to know that the the
Powerball is aren’t the story it is told
in response to the question who is my
neighbor so Jesus says you know love
your neighbor and the disciple says who
is my neighbor and he tells this story
so the point of the story is your
neighbor is not who you think it is it’s
the out-group person the person who
despised is your neighbor he’s asking
you to consider the opposite if you told
the story now you’d have to have you
know it’s the the Jewish person who
helps the Palestinian or the Palestinian
who helps the Jew or the only person who
helps you is the supporter of the other
football team it’s the whole point is is
that your neighbor is is the out-group
member so and we’ve seen that critical
over – I’m saying it helps you to get
closer to the truth this is what Galileo
is trying to do compare different
theories get closer to the truth
you also see from sort of the example of
Jesus that there’s a kind of moral
element to this as well as asking people
to sort of consider other other views
and in fact there’s evidence from
psychology as well that um it does
critical open-mindedness helps to
resolve conflict so this study from soot
Velden tech look what they did was a
very interesting thing they looked at
international crises and they looked at
how open-minded the people who had to
solve the crisis were by looking at
their letters and their diplomatic
pronouncements and so on and they
compared the Cuban Missile Crisis in the
60s where we averted nuclear war it got
very close to a nuclear war between
America and Russia they averted it and
the first world war which we know ended
in war and they found very interesting
leader the discourse of Kennedy and
Khrushchev and also the secretaries of
state involved were incredibly
open-minded in the sense that they had
lots of options available and they were
prepared to switch right up until the
last mile
by contrast in the First World War the
statements of the leaders were very
closed very dogmatic no no sort of a no
awareness of a kind of shifting of the
point of view so again you have the open
and closed aspect of this just to bring
it up to date so today you know examples
of people being closed-minded or open
mind and of course people say things
like this all the time I’ve got an
example of someone from the Donald Trump
a team but people from all walks of life
say things like this you know that
they’re correct 100% and you see it in
extreme states while there’s no doubt
that I should be doing this from it from
a terrorist let’s say now that the
problem with closed mindedness or go
back to my thermometer here if you fill
this up to a hundred as you can see I
only got only gone up to 99 I’m prepared
to go to ninety-nine point nine nine
cetera if you fill this up to a hundred
there’s no room left for rational debate
because you know you’ve got the right
answer you haven’t left any room so how
else are you going to change minds if
you can’t use rational debate there’s a
danger that you might it leads you to
violence or it leads you to sort of
force you have to force people you
haven’t left any room in fact the
philosopher Karl Popper said you know
critical reason is the only alternative
to violence that we’ve discovered it’s
the only way you can change minds
without using violence so there’s a
danger when you there’s a moral element
to it so what I’m saying is not only
scientifically is it good to not be
certain but morally it’s good as well
now I called my talk questioned
everything and you might wonder am I
really serious am i serious about
questioning everything what about the
fact you know John Lambie that’s me
I’m standing here in Cambridge today
that certain isn’t it should I question
that well it’s possible I could be
dreaming
I did have a dream last night about
doing this talk and everything went
wrong but it felt at no point did I
think this is a dream I wish I had
thought that it seemed very very real so
it’s possible I could be dreaming it’s
possible my memories playing tricks on
me I’m not really in Cambridge I went to
Chelmsford and I can’t remember so I’m
not saying there isn’t truth there is
truth there is a fact of the matter
about whether I’m in Cambridge or in
Chelmsford but I should always leave a
little bit of doubt that I can’t be
completely certain and likewise you know
what’s the answer to 13 times 57
there is a right answer to that but it’s
always possible I calculated it wrong
maybe my calculator made a mistake maybe
I you know again my memory when I looked
at the answer and then I tell you the
answer so there is a truth there is a
fact of the matter but we shouldn’t
always think that we’re certain we
shouldn’t go to the hundred percent so I
am serious about that now how can we be
critically open-minded as I said it it
is a it is a difficult thing to do I
mean sadly I mentioned the internet
comments I gave you the example of
Luther and Erasmus the actual style of
Erasmus where he says oh I’m ready to
learn from other people that’s quite
rare on internet comments quite hard to
find that very easy to find the people
that say you’re wrong you’ve confirmed
my view yeah you would say that because
you are prejudiced and you know I I know
that I’m right but you know what you
have to do is consider other views and
if you don’t think you’re 100% certain
it’s much easier to do that because you
think well if I’m not 100% I should
consider other views because that’s the
only way I’m going to learn and of
course we need to live in a society
which helps with this that presents
different points of view and that allows
us to challenge authority whether it’s
scientific Authority or political
authority so really I had my question
which was you know what needs to
progress
and really the answer was there all the
time that you get rid of the question
mark question everything
it’s what leads to progress so so I say
to you go forth and question everything
thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: