Press "Enter" to skip to content

The serious side of our mind | Ruth Byrne | TEDxTrinityCollegeDublin


your understanding of the world around

you and everyone in it depends on your

the imagination is one of the last

uncharted terrains of the human mind

there’s still a lot we don’t know about

yet we know that people can create

alternatives to reality we all know that

alternatives to reality are intriguing

in art in literature and theater in

cinema alternatives to reality entertain

us but recent discoveries in cognitive

science research about the human

imagination are surprising and one of

the big surprises is that the

imagination isn’t just for entertainment

the imagination carries out some of the

most serious work of the human mind we

all create alternatives to reality very

often in our everyday lives we imagine

how things could have turned out

differently if only especially after bad

things happen like a car accident we

create alternatives to reality to

explain the past we can think about the

events that occurred before a bad

outcome and we can work out the causes

between those events and the bad outcome

we can imagine that if one of those

things hadn’t happened the bad outcome

wouldn’t have happened either we create

alternatives to reality also to prepare

for the future we make better decisions

we learn from our mistakes how to

prevent bad things from happening again

because we can imagine alternatives and

those imagined alternatives give rise to

various emotional experiences we

experience regret and guilt and hope and

relief because we think about the way a

situation turned out we imagine how

turned out differently and in the

comparison of the two the emotion

emerges these imagined alternatives to

reality also give rise to our moral and

legal judgments and decisions we

allocate blame and fault and

responsibility because we can think

about not only what someone could have

done differently but also what they

should have done differently and when we

lose the ability to imagine alternatives

to reality that is devastating for us

individuals who acquire brain injuries

particularly to the prefrontal cortex

sometimes unfortunately lose the

capacity to spontaneously imagine how

things could have turned out differently

and they have difficulty in making

decisions in learning from mistakes and

an allocating blame and fault

appropriately so these are all examples

of some of the very serious and

important work that the human

imagination does for the mind but

there’s one other thing that we all need

to be able to do that we depend on our

imaginations for we all need to be able

to work out what’s in someone else’s

head we need to be able to figure out

what other people are thinking but

taking someone else’s perspective is

really difficult it’s not something that

we’re born with young children can’t do

it it has to develop over the course of

childhood by the age of 4 to 5 years

young children begin to appreciate that

other people may have a different

understanding of the world from them

they begin to get that their friend may

have a mistaken belief about where

objects are or what objects are made of

by the age of 7 to 8 years young

children begin to appreciate that others

might have a different understanding not

just of the physic

world but also of the mental world they

begin to get that their friend might

have mistaken beliefs about what someone

else’s thinking about what’s the reasons

for their actions about what’s going on

in their minds and that ability to

mind-read to work out what’s in someone

else’s head depends on our ability to

imagine alternatives to reality as we

understand it here’s one example of that

we invited young children to listen to

stories they listened to them over

earphones and they saw pictures

corresponding to them on screen they

heard lots of different stories about

lots of different everyday events here’s

one example they looked at pictures and

we’re told in the bedroom John sees and

picking up toys she says she wants to

find her ball to play with it

John goes into the kitchen while he’s

away Ann’s mother tells her to tidy her

room when John comes back he sees an

picking up toys we asked children a

question about an imagined alternative

to reality if Ann’s mother hadn’t told

her to tidy her room what would have

been the reason that she was picking up

toys we also asked them a question about

mind-reading we asked them what will

John believe is the reason that Ann is

picking up toys here’s how they managed

with the imagination questions what

would have been the reason if her mother

hadn’t told her to pick up toys you can

see that the young children at 6 years

of age have real difficulty answering

imagination questions correctly by eight

years of age they’re much better at it

and on a 10 that there are

perfect here’s how they fare on the

mind-reading questions what will John

believe is the reason that Ann’s picking

up toys you can see again that the six

year olds are having real difficulty

answering mind-reading questions

correctly and you can also see that

they’re having more difficulty with the

mind-reading questions than with the

imagination questions children’s

imagination skills develop before their

mind reading skills the two are really

very closely correlated children

generally will answer both sorts of

questions correctly or they’ll get

neither sort of question correct in the

transition period we sometimes see

children who are able to answer

imagination questions and not able to

answer the mind-reading questions but we

just don’t tend to see children who can

answer mind-reading questions so they

can take someone else’s perspective but

they can’t answer the imagination

questions they can’t imagine how things

could have turned out differently and if

the development of those imagination

skills is delayed for one reason or

another then so too is the development

of mind reading skills that happens with

children with autistic spectrum disorder

so here’s how children with

high-functioning autism and Asperger’s

syndrome fared when we asked them the

imagination question if Anne’s mother

hadn’t told her to tidy a room what

would have been the reason she was

picking up toys you can see that the

six-year-olds have real difficulty with

this question but you can also see now

that the eight-year-olds are having

difficulty with this question

unlike the typically developing children

here’s how they fare with the

mind-reading question again you can see

that the six-year-olds are having

difficulty with it and at 8 years

they’re having difficulty with it again

unlike the typically-developing show

and you can also see that once again

their imagination outstrips their mind

reading skill and importantly you can

also see that by 10 years of age they’re

beginning to get good at both this is

the developmental delay but otherwise

the shape of the development of their

imagination and mind-reading skills is

the same as for children who are

developing typically so this is one

example of the very serious work that

the imagination does the mind it enables

us to take someone else’s perspective to

work out what other people are thinking

because we can imagine alternatives to

reality as we understand it now there’s

a profound consequence of these

discoveries in cognitive science that

the imagination does serious work and

that consequence is that imagination and

reason are not opposites creativity and

logic are not in conflict instead it

seems to be the case than imagination

and rationality rely on the same sorts

of computations within the human mind

let me give you an example of that we

all have difficulties with certain

logical inferences so suppose a friend

of yours is describing the contents of a

nearby shop and says something about

what’s possibly there if there are

oranges there are pears and then suppose

subsequently you discovered that in fact

there are no prayers in that shop how

can you and fair most people who we

asked say that they can unfair that

there are no oranges about half of the

people we ask will make that inference

but the other half of people who we

asked to make this inference will say

that they can’t infer anything about

whether there are oranges or no oranges

the difficulty with this inference seems

to arise because people have

working memories and so we tend to

construct just a single mental model

corresponding to what has been described

to us in conversation so we tend to

think just about the oranges and pears

we don’t think about any other

possibility that all changes when our

imagination is engaged so if your friend

and they were describing what might be

in the nearby shop had instead said

something about an alternative to

reality and it said if there had been

oranges there would have been pears now

when you’re told that there are no pairs

in the shop everyone we ask says very

readily that there are no oranges that

inference seems to be very easy to make

when it’s couched in terms of

alternatives to reality our imagination

allows us to overcome the limitations in

our working memory it allows us to

envisage multiple alternatives

simultaneously so we are able to think

about reality and an alternative to

reality at the same time now one way to

examine that is to simply look at where

people look when they listen to stories

that include something about an

alternative to reality so we asked

adults to listen to simple stories about

lots of different everyday events they

listen to the stories over earphones and

they saw on-screen very simple visual

displays and tiny cameras recorded very

precisely where their eyes moved in

those visual displays so that we could

see what people are looking at and

figure out what they’re thinking about

as they’re hearing about an alternative

to reality so in the course of these

stories they’d hear something about a

possibility like if there are oranges

there are pears and they’d see an array

a visual

of simple images like an orange and a

pear an orange and a pair with a cross

strike through an image of an apple and

a strawberry and an image of no apple

and no strawberry and here’s what they

look at when they’re listening to the

possibility if there are oranges there

are pears they start out looking at all

of the four images but very rapidly

within a matter of milliseconds as they

hear about the possibility if there are

oranges there are pears their eyes move

to the image of the orange and the pear

and stay focused on last through edge

their eyes don’t move to the other three

images you see a very different picture

when instead the story contains a

reference to an alternative to reality

if instead they heard if there had been

oranges there would have been pears now

what you see is once again they start

out looking at all four images but they

begin their eyes move to the image of

the orange and the pear and the image of

no orange and no pear and their eyes

stay focused on those two images and

they don’t pay attention to the other

two images throughout hearing about that

alternative to reality and so this is an

example of how our imagination seems to

allow us to keep multiple alternatives

in mind it allows us to overcome our

working memory limitations and it’s in

that way that the imagination helps us

to reason and these are some of the

reasons why cognitive scientists are now

beginning to conclude that the

imagination far from being an optional

extra for our amusement is in fact at

the very core of our cognition so next

time you want to understand something

the world around you or the people in it

try creating an alternative to reality

i imagining how things could have been

different

use your imagination it’s more useful than you may think

Please follow and like us: