Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Onion’s Layered Lesson On Identity | Hauke Ziessler | TEDxBrandeisUniversity


okay oh I wasn’t planned um so uh wait

let me get mine um yeah thank you for

the introduction um I’m going to talk

about I’m going to talk about identity

and yeah I want to ask you a couple

questions regarding this what is your

first impression of me who do you think

I am and what do you think is my

identity this is what interests me if I

had a more polished entrance that then

compared to what has happened would you

have a different perception of me your

perception right now influences how you

see my entire identity but also

influences how I structure my narrative

right now and how I interact with you as

the crowd now that I’ve acted activated

your brains to think a little more about

identity and the complexity of it and

thinking about Who I am I like to

explore the definition of identity with

you a little further and we have them

beamed up above me um what I found in my

research through looking at this

definition I found that there’s no one

clear definition that scientists are

working with but I’ve kind of brought

them all together in these two

definitions so the first is that it is a

socially established category that is

established through certain attributes

characteristics anticipated behaviors

and rules of membership these categories

can define kind of a public perceived

identity and the second is more personal

and these are the features that are

socially distinctive which a person

ascribes – these can be both static or

adaptable in nature but are personal yet

socially consequential

now what is this all mean features that

are socially distinctive and what I

mentioned the socially established

categories now I’d like to differentiate

the two between how you see me and how I

see myself for the purpose of the

conversation I’m going to look at it as

the perceived identity or how you see me

and personal identity how I see myself

daily subliminal inferences based on

your past experiences shape how you

structure this perceived identity the

beginning of the talk created this kind

of awkward interlude you aren’t sure who

is this guy what what is happening and

you automatically made certain

inferences past experiences your social

context and your upbringing impacted

this your perceived identity was perhaps

similar or diverging according to the

people around you maybe you still feel

kind of awkward about this whole thing

and you infer that I’m a white male

perhaps I’m attracted to people that

identify as woman

maybe there’s none of that in my life

what is this accent where does it fit

into your kind of identity boxes it’s

it’s kind of strange these now you’re

firing up cliches you bring up thoughts

that are triggered by memory or implicit

biases stories start popping into your

mind now

globalization has made this even more

complex as we move between nations we

start to see strange combinations of

identities and identities become ever

more fluid my personal identity perhaps

is a lot more elusive than you think it

is

and it’s difficult to define by my mere

appearance this causes a weird fissure

between what you see of me and what I

see of myself so let me give me you a

little example what do you see in this

the theoretical image that will appear

thank you

this image is an onion probably not an

ogre some of you expected but it is a

different onions of shapes and sizes and

diverse taste now what if I took another

layer off what would you expect you’d

probably expect more onion but what if

you went a couple a is deeper and

suddenly there was an apple your idea of

an onion would be strange what is this

it would be rocked and you’d maybe have

to reanalyze how you look at onions but

I was to come to you a couple days later

with a similar onion and ask you what’s

beneath these layers you probably still

answer an onion but you’d become more

open to the idea that there might just

be an apple within now if people have

never been exposed to the fact that

there might be apples that are disguised

as onions they might never believe you

and they might turn you down and think

you’re going a little nuts but my

identity feels a lot similar to this

analogy I’ve always been that outsider I

grew up in a German family but grew up

mostly in South Africa I was called

Hitler in school and when I moved back

to Germany I was often seen this African

that came from afar my friends would

introduce me as not hey this is how come

my friend where it’d be this is how come

my African friend now this was very

strange but I began to relish it I

looked at my advantages in this and I

quickly in South Africa became the class

clown earning myself the title of the

crazy German but I did not feel German I

did not feel like South Africa was my

home and even to this day I feel like my

I’m of an observer of my body going

through these daily motions and

structured especially on their pure

appearances and opinions of others I

adapt my identity according to what

people perceive of my outer onion layers

I do not feel connected to that though

unlike what you think I feel a lot more

like one of these apples stuck in an

onion but through this experience I’ve

become more aware of the apples and I

have adapted and morphed into the

context and into the local identity

politics of the situation where I was I

floated in between identities now I

became ever more way of how I was

complicit in my privilege as a white

male I was historically benefiting from

the context of this of this position and

my mere mere presence in certain

international contexts automatically had

an impact ident my identity was fluid

yet I was static I was deeply rooted in

my individualism and my identity but

because I noticed my role in the broader

community I had to have a reflexive

communal identity and nature that in the

social space I was adaptive and

understanding now social psychology as

we saw in the in the previous

definitions identifies so identity to be

rather adaptable but I found that public

perception of this is far more static my

mere framing of my narrative impacts how

you perceive me I’ve recently discovered

that when I mentioned that I’m a German

that grew up in South Africa people

would go oh yeah I can hear the German

accent where if I said I’m South African

and I grew up in a German I’m original

German people would say oh yeah I can

hear the South African accent so just my

me a choice of words impacted how people

already identified with me this is

rather anecdotal but my narrative it

shows on my narrative defined this

perceived identity why I say perceived

identity is very static it shows how

it’s also rather malleable and how we

need a reflexive nature to react to that

and also be accommodating to that we

need to understand our position in the

world so how do we move away from this

rather static definition of what we see

is identity

perhaps perhaps be more open to this new

fluidity you’ll need to become aware and

all of us need to become more aware of

how we shape identity and how we impact

how people act around us we are not

autonomous we influence the communities

and our very nature of speaking

influences how communities define

themselves now I’m wearing a suit I’m

not wearing my very cherished

multicolored onesie and this is for one

reason that you automatically take me

more seriously science has shown that

people that wear suits are rated as more

trustworthy as more intelligent as and

more far more serious so the mere fact

that you believe that I am more serious

right now wearing a suit perpetuates

that I need to wear suit to seem serious

and perpetuates this almost vicious

cycle so I want to challenge that and

say we need to start being more

ourselves being more unique and also

being aware of our own identities but

within that being accommodating and

being open to exploring other people’s

spaces and realities become open to this

fluidity of the layers of the onions my

experience in my experience I’ve been

very privileged privileged to travel

across very contrasting cultures and

multicultural spaces one cross-cultural

communication experience was in Bhutan

there I worked with various

international artists and I notice how I

had to stay reflexive in this situation

now what was a especially impactful is

that they were true to their traditions

and I had a huge respect for their motto

was a modernization but not

westernization I entered and I stayed

how could yet I also had to adapt to the

rhetoric to be more accommodating

Western artists that we invited would

come in and go this is how we’re going

to do it and we have this amazing plan

and who’s with me but no one was really

with me and the doors quick

he closed so when I entered I realized I

had to adapt to that I did not no longer

speak as was normal for a westerner but

I would walk in and I would try to let

the situation guide the conversation

ways of ideation quickly adapted and

became places of joint collaboration

where we learned from each other this

learning came deep was deeply rooted in

the mistakes that we made in

miscommunication but also in our

differences superiority was never the

goal in fact mutual understanding was

and this was quite beautiful to see as

it developed the most successful

projects of international artists that I

was working with were the ones I came in

with humility they do not say this is

how we’re going to do it but rather said

how are we going to do this what are

what are the options suddenly friendly

conversing developed and equal sharing

became the norm social differences were

no longer the divider but they became

the glue of the situation so why does

all this matter where do we stand with

all this knowing who you are as an onion

makes you more aware of the flexibility

that you experience in elements of your

personal identity you become more open

to the identities of others and you

approach diversity in a more reflective

and reflexive manner you become more

open to the idea that maybe there are

apples inside these onions as a white

male that’s extremely important you have

to be aware of the role as you’re

conversing across cultures and you have

to be aware of your position you have to

be reflexive and you have to address

your own complicity but that does not

mean you need to be paralysed to act

rather than every step you should it be

asking how do I act in this context you

should become aware of your perceived

identity your own identity

and you should learn to work with your

implicit and explicit biases you need to

question the in Faust in justices and

whether you are enforcing these and

justices but you can also work with the

beauty in our differences and in the

varying identities that we have in a

constructive manner so while I was

working in many different contrasting

contexts from South Africa Germany India

as mentioned Bhutan and now in the u.s.

there are couple pointers that I found

were Universal in how I was interacting

with others these were open up secondly

provides space to speak be open to

providing the space be open to your

failure in a respectful manner

be honest and challenge those around you

but also ask and explore yourself to

understand your identity your perceived

identity and as mentioned the implicit

and explicit biases you’re not the only

onion with an intricate beautiful story

there are onions walking around all over

this world with fascinating stories that

you can learn from so relish that soak

it up see the beauty in that and enjoy

the storytellers around you because as

much as they can teach you you can also

teach those around you in a constructive and respectful way thank you

Please follow and like us: