Press "Enter" to skip to content

Are We All Nationalists? | Chandler Rosenberger | TEDxBrandeisUniversity


[Applause]

so I have a slightly provocative

question to start off with it’s a little

bit ironic I’m the chair of the

International and Global Studies program

here at Brandeis but I’m actually very

interested in nationalism I’m very

interested in how nationalism still has

a major role in the world today and so I

have this provocative question that

maybe we are all a little bit more

nationalist than we think we are and

maybe we should pay attention to this

when we’re thinking about how global

politics are organized and even how we

operate and function in our own

societies so as was mentioned I had a

very sort of upfront and personal

experience of nationalism right after I

graduated from college I went out to

Eastern Europe where the great

multinational states like Czechoslovakia

Yugoslavia the former Soviet Union were

breaking up into these nationalist

elements these are some friends of mine

who were Bosnians who were defending the

city of Moscow against Croatian

nationalists who wanted to take over the

city and I saw an awful lot of this

during the wars in Yugoslavia in Moldova

in Western Civ akio broke up and it

really seemed like a kind of primordial

ER or instinctual response that people

were having in a moment of crisis that

they were sort of turning inward and

turning toward each other at a former we

have animate these ancient bonds in

order to get through a crisis and so in

the 25 years since we’ve had a lot more

globalization the globalization of the

economy the internet a lot of

international travel international

student exchanges that have made on the

world’s made this experience of

nationalism this burst after the Cold

War seemed like sort of an anomaly and

that in fact you know we’re moving

towards a much more globalized world and

then came the past few years and what do

we get in the past few years this total

reassertion of national identity the

british deciding to leave the European

Union the Russians reasserting

themselves in the former Soviet sphere

with explicitly nationalist goals

the Chinese moving into the South China

Sea in defiance of the United Nations

India has a new very explicitly Hindu

nationalist prime minister who talks

quite explicitly about being a

nationalist Hungary along with Poland

France Germany have seen the rise of

right-wing nationalist parties and in

the United States we of course have

Donald Trump who like him or not has

been very explicit about wanting to make

America great again about being an

American nationalist and so maybe this

nationalism that I thought had just sort

of flared up 25 years ago is actually

there’s more of it around them we think

and maybe it affects us more than we

might want to admit even ourselves um

now as I said when I saw nationalism

flare up back in the Central Europe it

had this kind of instinctive feel to it

this kind of primordial feel like a like

a tribal engagement of one side against

the other and I think that when we think

about nationalism or when we think about

how human societies are organized we

often want to say there’s some kind of

instinct behind this there’s some sort

of biological basis for this you know we

see ants organizing into ant hills very

naturally we see beavers form dams by

instinct we see wolves form wolf packs

by instinct you know maybe our human

societies like nationalism is just a

matter of instinct that’s very tempting

you know we think we’re rightly part of

the animal kingdom we think maybe you

know we’re just we just experienced this

ourselves and so we think that we just

have this instinct hardwired into our

brains we get some sort of stimulus from

outside and we all you know formed a

society together ought to respond to the

world around us in collective action but

there’s a problem with this if you think

about it it’s actually it actually

doesn’t really work for human societies

and one of the ways we know it doesn’t

work for human societies is that human

societies through history change much

faster than their biology could possibly

change than human biology changes you

know human societies have been evolving

to use a term I have been changing have

been negotiated and overthrown and

reconfigured much faster than by our

biological change you can see that if

you just compare the timeline of a

society that we know is based on

instinct Wolfpack societies to human

societies ah wolves have been organized

in gray wolves in particular been

organizing and hunting in wolf packs for

as long as human beings have observed

them they’ve been observed by human

beings for about thirty thousand years

we think the gray wolf has been around

for about eight hundred thousand years

and certainly in all the time that human

beings have been watching wolves they

haven’t changed how they behave they

form wolf packs our understanding of how

wolf packs work has changed but but the

wolf packs have not changed there’s no

new you know democratic revolution among

wolf packs a human society has actually

been around a lot less time than wolf

packs you know large-scale organized

societies of the kind we see first

emerging in Mesopotamia 9,000 years ago

and think about the diversity of

societies that you’ve had in 9000 years

Peter you’ve had theocracies you’ve had

large-scale empires you’ve had

colonization you’ve had communism Nazism

various forms of fascism liberal

democracy I mean human beings are

constantly changing their societies and

so it would be very strange

you know if our biology we’re changing

that fast

you know if somehow our instincts were

changing that fast in fact I have right

here a list of one of my favorite

countries in the world um the Czech

Republic the Czech Republic in just the

past 150 years there’s a little green

blip up there on the screen that

represents the last 150 years in last

150 years they’ve gone from being under

the Hapsburgs to having a democratic

Czechoslovakia to being occupied by them

Nazis to forming a communist government

after World War two then another

democratic Czechoslovakia and then

breaking up with the Slovak sin 1993 and

going their own way as the Czech

Republic all of that changed in 150

years the Czech Czech biology hasn’t

changed that much in 150 years right the

Czechs have to don’t have haven’t had

their instincts rewired in 150 years and

so we have to look someplace else if we

want to understand how our societies are

formed and the place that we should look

the way we should think about it is not

that we have instincts

although we have some instincts you have

instinct to eat women instinct to

procreate but we don’t have a lot of

instincts for how to form a society what

we have instead our minds that are

uniquely organized to absorb a massive

amount of cultural information that we

then sift through as we try to figure

out how our society should be organized

things that we reflect on and understand

in order to map our place in the world

and our relations with other people so

society what I’m telling you is what Max

Weber told us more than a hundred years

ago Society is fundamentally cultural it

is a it is not a matter of instinct it’s

a matter of a cultural creation that we

participate in – or get oriented and if

you think about society that way it’s

sort of like the software of human

beings then of course you know society

can change quickly even though our

hardware even though our biology doesn’t

change because we’re constantly updating

or changing that software that organizes

us we’re constantly tweaking the this

culture that we use as a means of

communication a means of understanding

each other so if we think about society

as cultural then we start to look at ok

well what is the culture of modern of

our modern societies it used to be well

before that let me just point out that

we need this culture we need

because we don’t have instincts if we

had instincts we wouldn’t need to be

constantly downloading the software to

tell us how to orient ourselves but in

fact if we don’t have that software we

experience what sociologists call enemy

which is the sense of disorientation a

sense of not really knowing where we are

not knowing what we can expect from

other people not knowing what other

people expect from us an extremely

uncomfortable position to be in

nobody likes enemy and human beings are

designed to move away from that as

quickly as possible and to generate new

cultural understandings of their

position in the world to figure out

where we are um so what well where how

do we get to the culture that we now

know it used to be that human societies

were organized largely around religion

that there was a sense that you the

social order had been mandated by some

sort of divine presence and that this

social order extended out to the cosmos

itself to route itself in this divine

legitimacy in medieval Europe that was

christened um and so you know everything

that happened in the political

organization and social organization was

mediated through the culture of

Christianity and through the culture of

the Catholic Church uh and that became

the common basis of understanding you

know peasants felt like they could

survive their terrible treatment because

this was just a veil of Tears that human

beings would pass through on their way

to an eternal life um that was the way

you know human societies were organized

for thousands of years not just in

Europe but in Asia and healeth Hinduism

as a major organizing principle of the

subcontinent with Islam at the center of

the Ottoman Empire the religion was the

way these social ideas this culture was

rooted for there’s a long complicated

story of how that traditional society

dissolved but it certainly did

sometime around the 15th century in

Europe it begins to be undermined by

secular ideas by other ideas about

political legitimacy and gradually the

divine mandate is beginning to fade away

is beginning to dissipate leaving

believing that threat of enemy leaving

that threat of not people not being

oriented in the world and so prompting a

search and exploration of new way to

orient ourselves of a new foundation for

societies this is the age of revolution

right this is the age of great change

starting from the 16th century with

Henry the 8th breaking England away from

the Catholic Church in forming the

Church of England the age of revolution

going forward to the French Revolution

overthrowing the ancien régime that

have been rooted in a Catholic sense of

order ultimately up through the 20th

century with the dissolution of the

great empires the Hapsburgs of the

Czarist Russia the Ottoman Empire all

collapsing and losing any sense of the

Divine Right of Kings of a divine

mandate for their rule and shifting

instead to a totally new basis to a

foundation in nationalism that our

societies are now these this cultural

conversation isn’t organized around the

church it isn’t organized around

religion it’s organized around the

people and what the people on all

governments are supposed to have their

legitimacy in serving the people and the

origin of our moral ideas or our values

they’re supposed to be oriented toward

our own national communities among among

these are the people whom we participate

in a cultural conversation it doesn’t

mean that we don’t pay attention other

countries of course we do

but the major conversation that we have

most we have most human beings on the

planet are participating in a

conversation that has the boundaries of

a nation there are some principles to

nationalism all nations are different

all national cultures are different but

there are some foundational principles

of nationalism very well described by

wonder

sociologists of nationalism Leah

Greenfeld at Boston University has come

up with this list of things that all

nations seem to share even as they

change very in their cultures um we

believe in popular sovereignty we

basically believe that if a government

isn’t at least paying lip service to the

idea of serving the people it’s doing

something wrong and even dictatorial

regimes say they’re doing they’re

protecting their people they’re

defending their people we believe in a

certain amount of solidarity with our

fellow Nationals we expect them to obey

the laws they expect us to we expect

them to treat us with some respect and

that goes to this third principle it’s

very important um the idea of

fundamental equality within the society

as members of the national community and

getting a certain amount of dignity as a

member of the nation now all nations

struggle with this idea of equality the

United States particularly has struggled

you through decades of slavery through

you know the struggles over racial

rights and and women’s rights and then

the movement to acknowledge different

forms of sexuality we struggle to

acknowledge that everyone has that equal

dignity but the fact that we struggle is

evidence that we take it seriously and

nothing will get you on the you know

with page six of the New York Post

faster than treating somebody than some

rich businessman you know treating

somebody dismissively or some football

star saying you know do you know who I

am trying to elbow his way into a club

we expect to treat each other with a

certain amount of equality and dignity

within this within this community and

nationalism the last thing I would say

about the principles of nationalism is

it can be rooted in ethnic strife it can

be aggressive it can be xenophobic but

not necessarily not necessarily it can

instead just be this sense of having a

place in your community among fellow

equals um the one of the best

expressions of nationalism it gives you

a sense of its uplift and the sense of

the power of what we’re dealing with

comes from the English from Shakespeare

one of the first nations arguably the

first nation

the first community organized as a

nation when Henry the fifth in

Shakespeare’s play tries to encourage

his soldiers to join him in the fight in

the Battle of Agincourt um he tells them

he quotes it makes a speech that’s been

quoted for centuries since now as an

expression of a kind of national sense

of uplift and dignity he says we few we

happy few we band of brothers

for he today that sheds his blood with

me shall be my brother be he ne’er so

vile this day will gentle his condition

Henry’s not saying get out there and

fight for me I’m your King do it I want

he’s saying get out there and join me my

brother’s my equals in this battle you

may be a very low status you may be a

vile but this day will gentle your

condition this day will make you a

gentleman and obviously today we would

add sisters to that we would expand the

circle of equality but that sense of

dignity as a member of the nation is

still very important and that encourages

me to think that nationalism provides

this sense of orientation the sense of

dignity and probably isn’t going away

anytime soon

yes societies do change but this

particular formation that we have a

place you know oriented through a common

culture with our fellow centered

citizens

I would suggest probably isn’t going to

go away it just it just feels too good

it gives us too much of a sense of our

orientation in the planet and our

relations with our fellow citizens so to

manage it we should recognize it’s

probably not going away we should

recognize that different nations have

different operating systems different

cultures and respect those differences

and even consider how the national

culture your own national culture has

had an effect on you because I tell you

it can be more powerful than you think

it is thank you very much you

Please follow and like us: