Press "Enter" to skip to content

Honoring Indigenous Cultures and Histories | Jill Fish | TEDxMinneapolis


Johanna is gonna have guy off a Jill
fish good evening everyone my name is
Jill fish and I’m from schedu de guide
Accra the Tuscarora nation before I
begin I want to acknowledge that the
land that the Kohl Center is built upon
the land that we’re all standing on are
the traditional homelands of the Dakota
people the for you all to exist in the
city of Minneapolis today the Dakota
people had experienced genocide
displacement reservation confinement and
assimilation so that colonists could
take their homelands and turn them into
yours and this is settler colonialism
it’s not unique to the United States or
even though America’s you can see
instance of it all around the world
where a settler population presumes
racial and ethnic dominance over an
indigenous population and through their
settler tactics erases the indigenous
populations narrative to replace it with
a narrative of their own so when you
build a nation off of this narrative you
see one history one story it’s bad of
the settlers and this is a problem
because narratives are tool for us as a
people to understand who we are they
tell us where we’ve been where we are
and future possibilities for where we
might end up so when you fail to
acknowledge indigenous narratives in
favor of settler narratives the
narratives of conquest of exploration of
taming a continent the years and even
decades too many people have forgotten
that truth they forgotten is that our
ancestors trounced an empire came to
continent and triumph over the worst
evils in history you’re denying
indigenous people the right to exist how
do we as indigenous people honor and
transcend a past that a seldom
acknowledged and when it is it’s our
plight
not our perseverance a culture not seen
is thriving but is long lost
this is a question that I asked myself a
lot I’ve dedicated my research in
psychology to it and as a therapist I’ve
spent many times helping others
meaningfully integrate their past and
their present it is deeply personal for
me my past goes all the way back to the
15th century
that’s one our people the Tuscaroras
came together to reside around the Great
Lakes
over time my ancestors migrated to the
North Carolina region the United States
and that’s where they lived in the 17th
century when European colonists began
moving in our territory raiding and
capturing people from our tribe to sell
into slavery
these settler acts of violence ignited
the Tuscarora war and during this war in
one moment nearly 1,000 has grown men
women and children were killed or
captured at her stronghold nay you had
Ruka in this particular moment this
particular act of violence it started my
ancestors journey back to the Great
Lakes region and this is where they
would join the Mohawks Oneida Onondaga
as Cuba’s and Senecas in the Holden
Ashanti Confederacy that is a 1,300 mile
journey by foot and by water through
forests and through mountains while some
of my ancestors carried the remains of
those relatives lost a danger and
sacrifice and we survived our
present-day community is an area of land
given to us by the Senecas the test for
reservation is where I was born it’s
where I was raised in community with my
culture my language my beliefs and my
traditions it’s even where I was
educated through the sixth grade so not
only did we survive we still exist our
narrative has persisted for more than
300 years how many of you knew all that
about my tribe our migrations our
present-day community go ahead and take
a look around and see how many people
are raising their hands this is how it
often feels for me
as a toast for a woman and settler
spaces all these people looking at me
but not truly seeing me this is how it
felt when the sixth grade ended and my
reservation no longer had the resources
to continue our education there so we
were forced to mainstream in a school in
a nearby town I went from a cohort of
less than thirty hona nashoni students
so being thrust into a cohort of over
300 predominantly white students it was
all these people looking at me but not
truly seeing my history or my culture
icarver the word hate into my arm and so
there I was this 12 year old Native
American girl already hating herself and
it wasn’t one event that led up to this
moment of heartache for me and many
others that would follow it it was a
process one that took my humanity in all
its richness and complexity and instead
of calling it a strength stripped it
away bit by bit and called what was left
a weakness we call this the deficit
model in psychology it’s more than a
framework for understanding the
psychological experiences of those from
different cultural groups
it’s a worldview a belief system one
that perpetuates a very specific
narrative and the narrative is this not
only is my culture and history seen as
different from yours but it’s for that
reason that I’m deficient in this
narrative it became apparent to me
throughout all my mainstreamed
experiences I was immediately forced to
trade in my tusks oral language and
culture courses for French and US
history
I had peers spit on me and make fun of
me for being poor while I had Ferentz of
friends who I did make forbid their
children from coming over to hang out
with me on top of that school
administrators contacted my parents
threatening them to have the police come
to my birthday party to monitor it for
drugs and alcohol and this was all
because I was from the reservation and
while it’s true
come from a lot of money an addiction
was certainly present in my family these
things are not because I’m Native
American it’s because settler society is
an extension of the colonial dynamics
that this nation was built upon and
seeks to oppress in the present just as
it did in the past I didn’t know this
then so what twelve years old it left me
feeling alienated and unwanted and this
is how a lot of Native youth feel for
suicides Native youth between the ages
of 10 and 24 years old comprised 35% of
completed suicides compared to 11% of
whites for a high school education
Native Americans have the lowest high
school graduation rates across the
nation in comparison to every racial and
ethnic group and as for a college
education 1% of bachelor’s degrees
awarded go to Native Americans that’s 1%
where is 68% go to whites and so tonight
I want to know when are you all going to
stop asking what’s wrong with indigenous
and Native youth and start asking what’s
wrong with our society what would it be
like if instead of stripping away the
historical and cultural contacts that
are so central to our sense of selves
and ways of being in the world that we
use them as the foundation from which
all our experiences can and should be
understood can you imagine what that
would do for our development I sought
out to answer this question when I
became the first in my family to pursue
higher education and then we became when
I became a PhD student I came across a
model of human development that took
culture and history into consideration
it’s called the ecological systems model
by developmental psychologists Urie
bronfenbrenner the focus of the model is
on an individual and on an individual
and their interactions with their
environment and how those interactions
impact their development the model is
widely used in psychology but it’s also
used widely in our society people use it
to structure educational programming
around it as well as community
programming and this is what the model
looks like at the core the
of the individual you have their traits
and their characteristics if we were to
think of my experiences as an example
for this model this is where I would go
we would place me at the center of the
model at the second level of the models
there’s the micro system and the micro
system refers to environments that the
individual is directly involved in that
impacts their development for me micro
systems included my parents my peers and
even the school at the third level we
have the meso system and the meso system
refers to interactions between
environments that we identified at the
micro system that impact my development
a perfect example of this would be the
school contacting my parents and
threatening them with the police that’s
an interaction between two micro systems
that it had an impact on me and at the
4th level we have the exo system similar
to the meso system the exo system also
refers to interactions between
environments except this time one of the
environments does not directly involve
me so it has an indirect impact on me an
example of this would be the parents of
the friends that I made who forbid their
children from coming over to play with
me I didn’t know those parents I wasn’t
involved with them in any sort of way
but through their decision they had an
influence and an indirect impact on my
development at the 5th level of the
model we have the macro system and the
macro system refers to trends seen in
the previous environments in the
ecological systems model so these can be
trends in norms ideologies opportunity
structures but this is where we captured
culture and past the sixth grade my
culture was no longer the center of my
development it was effectively moved to
the margins and if culture was discussed
it often wasn’t mine it would be the
culture of mainstream society of settler
society so that be settler societies
language beliefs norms decades later
apart from the original model a final
layer was added to the ecological
systems model it’s called the chrono
system and the chrono system is the
third dimension of the model so it
cuts across all the other layers of the
ecological systems model and this is
this refers to consistencies or
inconsistencies seen over time
throughout the model so this is where we
would capture something like a personal
history or even an ancestral history the
unfortunate thing is is ticked orally
you can see that situated underneath the
model it’s hidden underneath there so it
makes it really easy to overlook these
historical pieces it was also developed
at such a later date that people will
often refer to the earlier version of
the model which doesn’t include the
chrono system in it so again it’s
overlooked so the ecological systems
model had all the components I was
looking for but in its current condition
it didn’t tell me anything new about the
Native American experience in fact as
they used it as a framework to
understand the research literature in
Native American psychology I found that
it encouraged a deficit perspective
because when you place the individual at
the core of the model it allows
researchers who use the model to use the
individual as the point of analysis and
then it allows those same people to
situate problems in individuals and the
communities that they come from
overlooking all the other factors at the
outside of the model and because my
ancestors didn’t pave the way to
resistance for 1,300 miles for me to
settle for the status quo I decided to
go back to the drawing board with the
ecological systems model to rearrange it
to reekin sexualize it so that it made
more sense for the Native American
experience and before using it in my own
research in our communities and so what
I did was I took this 39 year old model
and I proposed to do two things to it I
proposed to take the chrono system and
then move it to the core of the model it
would still be the third dimension but
it would all it would also now be the
starting point of the model and then the
second thing I proposed to do was to
take the macro system from the outside
of the model to move it to the inside it
would now be the second level of the
model everything else would remain the
same so be followed by the individual
the micro system the meso system in the
EXO system but this move this move to
put the chrono system in the macro
system at the core it accomplishes so
many goals by putting the chrono system
at the core of the model
we’re laying the foundation from which
all the other remaining levels of the
model can and should be understood the
any consideration of the present-day
experiences of Native American people
must be grounded in the past and then by
taking the macro system and putting it
from the outside of the model to the
second level of the model we’re moving
to Center culture and development so we
would be centering Native American ways
of being and knowing instead of pushing
it at the margins which is common in our
experiences and then by taking both the
Crono system in the macro system and
putting it the core before anything else
is discussed we are inextricably
connecting culture and history into the
remaining levels of the system making it
impossible to ignore the role that
culture and history play in our
development and the present-day
experiences of native people adopting
the Rican sexualized ecological systems
model it moves us away from a deficit
perspective because it forces you to
acknowledge that settler colonialism has
created long-standing incongruencies
between native people and settler
society in the present day it challenges
you to look beyond the individual to the
culture and history of the individual
and how these things interact with the
culture and history of settler society
it begs the question does settler
society support constrain indigenous
histories and narratives it also moves
you towards this place where you can no
longer contribute to the narrative that
natives are deficient you have to
acknowledge that settler society is
deficient in meeting the needs of people
who not come from a settler history or a
the society does not equally integrate
indigenous histories and cultures into
its framework and in so adopting the
Recon sexualized ecological systems
model it’ll also move you towards a
cultural strengths-based perspective
where by leveraging the chronal system
and macro system you can begin to
acknowledge and validate indigenous
histories and cultures but to do so you
have to start by asking yourself several
questions so are the spaces you create
are your actions or your institutions
are your classrooms structured around
settler society to the end of excluding
indigenous histories and cultures are
you working to shift paradigms so that
these spaces shift to be more inclusive
are you actively correcting for
inaccurate histories negative
stereotypes and the degradation of
indigenous histories and cultures
there are over 567 tribes in the United
States are you familiar with the
cultures and histories of those whose
land you’re standing on in to that end
are you familiar with your own culture
and history and how that’s influenced
you in the present day ask yourself
these questions and this is how you can
start to acknowledge and transcend your settler colonial past yawa thank you
Please follow and like us: