Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Money Flower and why Bitcoin is a ponzi scheme | Morten Bech | TEDxBasel


[Applause]
can you tell us a little bit of Wow
about what the BIS is I can so the Bank
for International Settlements an
international organization that has been
in Basel since it was created in 1930 so
we obviously a bank but we are special
one in that we only serve central banks
so we have about sixty shareholders and
they come from all corners of the world
and they are together they account for
about 95 percent of the global economy
so in addition to being the bank for
central banks we also have a mandate to
promote what we call monetary and
financial stability and we do that
through international cooperation so for
example the BIS is home to a number of
committees that set minimum regulatory
standards for the financial system at
the global level
did you guys do anything else there true
true true true they are a lot of
meetings but I would say there’s also a
lot to do so so I’m in charge of
something called the Committee on
payments and market infrastructure and
so we look after everything related to
money payments clearing and settlements
so for those that don’t know so those
are all the parts of the financial
systems you don’t notice until they
break down and then all hell is loose
okay so imagine if your debit or credit
card wasn’t working for a week or if the
stocks and bonds that you had purchased
did not appear in your brokerage
accounts okay so somebody once called us
a promising suit so I don’t know whether
that’s a good reflection but basically
right now there’s two things that are
high on our agenda one is cyber security
and the other one is cryptocurrencies
okay let’s talk about both those so why
cyber security what do you do with that
okay so maybe let me give you an example
so a couple years ago the Central Bank
of Bangladesh was hacked and the
criminals managed to transfer 81 million
US dollars out of an account with the
Federal Reserve Bank of New York so part
of that money went to a bank in the
Philippines and then on to a casino and
from there there’s no trail of the money
and the money’s probably lost forever
but the scary part was that the hackers
actually tried to steal upwards of 1
billion US dollars and only Locke
actually prevented that from happening
fortunately the hackers apparently had
been shirking in school so in the
fraudulent payments instruction that
they sent on behalf of the central
bank’s there were some very simple
misspellings and so that actually raised
some red flags and some of these
transactions were very locally stopped
well that’s really lucky so let’s go
back he also mention cryptocurrency
talk about that so yes cryptocurrency
said what what I cryptocurrencies I
think Tom did a great job yes
parts of it but crypto let’s break the
term down so crypto comes from
cryptography obviously and that’s about
computers and methods to protect
communications from your rivals or your
enemies and then currency is usually
used to describe money that’s in general
circulation in within a country say the
swiss franc here in switzerland and so
one short answer is the crypto currency
is a new form of money where
cryptography is used to generate and
transfer the currency units but maybe
easier explained was John Oliver the
British comedian said that
cryptocurrencies everything you don’t
understand computers combined with
everything you don’t understand about
money ok well let’s forget about you
keep
let’s forget about computers for a
moment
my background is art so okay why don’t
we talk about money like what is money
so it’s a good question obviously but um
and close to my heart but so money is
usually described by what it does and
money does three things so it serves as
a means of payments a unit of account
and as a store of value so let’s take
them one at a time so means of payments
basically you can pay for stuff with
money but fundamentally money is a way
of getting around the problems of just
bartering so I’m might want something
that you have but I’m unlikely to have
something that you want and so I can
give you an money instead in return for
whatever you have that I want and then
you can take that money and go somewhere
else and find whatever it is that you
want also the unit of account so what is
a unit of account well money is
basically the unit in which we measure
prices and services and goods as well as
value of our values and unfortunately
also our are liabilities so a unit of
account works to compare prices and to
transaction general so a liter of milk
is say two Swiss francs and not 0.03
music lessons okay and finally money can
be used to to store value over time and
especially if inflation is low then
money keeps it value and it’s a good way
to store okay so now we understand money
how does cryptocurrency fit into money
what type of house little form of money
but that’s a good that’s a good question
and actually last year I was struggling
to explain exactly that to central bank
governors so together with my professor
from university we developed a new
taxonomy of money to try and explain
exactly that
question and so the taxonomy is
basically just the Venn diagram we put
some colors on it and then we gave it a
fancy name and so we call it them money
flower okay I have to see this did did
you bring a slide or anything yes I
think we have so so this is the domani
flower so this is a Venn diagram and so
after a couple of iterations the
professor and I agreed on four key
characteristics of money and so money
can either be in physical or electronic
form it can either be issued by the
central bank or not and then it could
either be widely accessible to everyone
or just available to a few and then
finally money can either be based on
accounts or tokens so tokens can be say
dollar bills or glass pearls and tokens
allow money to be transferred from one
person to the other without the help of
a third party okay so that is known I
should just say known as peer to peer
which also appear up here on this line
okay you talked about accounts and
pearls tokens so are there other forms
of money and how would they fit into
this flower right so the classical
example of a token or peer-to-peer based
money is cash right so cash is likely
accessible it’s not electronic
but it’s issued by the central bank and
I can give it to you directly with you
without I need that back so and I can
give it to you directly without you know
asking the audience for for help or
phoning a friend so that’s an example of
peer-to-peer money okay another example
is this one and what is this this is a
Cowrie shell so these were used as money
in India in Asia in China so that’s
another example of a physical type of
money that’s widely accessible and we
can transact it peer-to-peer but this
one is not issued by the central pay
but rather mother nature okay an example
of an account-based form of money is
your deposits at a bank okay
nowadays they are mostly electronic they
are not issued by the central bank
they are claimed on your commercial bank
and you cannot transfer them
peer-to-peer right you need the help of
the bank to transfer to some other
person okay
another form of account based money are
what we call in the central banking
world reserves so those are the process
of money by banks with the central bank
and again these are calm paced
they’re also electronic but they are not
widely accessible right you need to be a
bank in order to hold this particular
kind of money okay
you mentioned mother nature and these
shells which reminds me of the speaker
we’ve had in the past
speaking on local currency can you tell
us where that would fit in yes so local
currencies are money that can only be
used in a certain geographical location
or at participating stores and if you
use them they usually get some kind of a
discount and so they would fit here in
the money flower and so they are
typically physical they’re not
electronic they’re definitely not issued
by the central bank and they are only
available in that particular location
okay so we can also fit new forms of
money in the money flower and so one
example is a Pokemon coin alright so
gaming money so Pokemon coin is
definitely electronic it’s not widely
accessible because you have to be
playing the Pokemon game and you cannot
transfer it peer-to-peer because you
need the help of the game developer to
transfer this taco Bunny and most
importantly it has nothing to do with
the Bank of Japan so it’s not a central
bank form of mourning
and then finally we get to what we’re
talking about which is which is Bitcoin
okay
it’s a Bitcoin it’s vitally accessible
it’s electronic it’s not issued by the
central bank and it’s token based so
that you can transfer peer-to-peer and
what is really important is that you
could transfer it without the help of a
bank or a central bank okay so our sorry
just say that the key innovation of
Bitcoin really is this that it’s an
electronic form of peer-to-peer money
that’s the key innovation okay you’ve
talked a lot about this and we have this
really cool diagram but what I want to
know is are there some that are better
than others like there’s some form of
monies superior yes so that’s a it’s
absolutely right so not all forms of
money are equal and I have an example
here so this is the example of a really
bad form of money so this is the said
boppin dollar which was abandoned in
2009 and at the end you had to pay 150
trillion Zimbabwean dollars just to buy
one US dollar so this is an example of a
very poor form of money and just because
we can fit Bitcoin into the money flour
that’s not the same as saying that
bitcoin is a good form of money okay
okay so if bitcoin is not a good for
money explain why so so if you go back
to the three things that money does so
big contacts ADIZ which was means of
payments unit of account and store value
bitcoin actually scores pretty poorly
against all those things that money can
do okay so in the big scheme of things
that’s actually not that many Bitcoin
transaction on a daily basis there about
200,000 but in comparison visa alone
handles over well over 200 150 million
transaction per day also nobody lists
prices in Bitcoin or is it only very few
dollars right and so what is the price
of a liter of milk in Bitcoin nobody
could tell you we looked it up and it’s
zero point zero zero three Bitcoin this
and it’s store value it’s true that a
lot of people have put money into
Bitcoin but they haven’t done it really
to store value they have done it to
speculate okay and so yes so they’ve
done it to to speculate and that there
was a recent survey that showed that
actually 92 percent of the people that
hold Bitcoin did it for speculative
purposes and only eight percent actually
did it to affect payments alright so if
this is not a good form of money what is
with the hype what’s up so I think
there’s at least three stages to to the
hive right so in the beginning it was
computer geeks that were just very
fascinated by the technology which we
just heard which is really really
fascinating then later on it was what we
call libertarians that were very excited
about the fact that you could actually
have a form of money that did not
involve the central bank and then lately
it’s just been people trying to earn a
quick buck or maybe they were fearful of
missing out so my boss at the Bank for
International Settlements
all questioned Caston recently gave a
lecture in which he described Bitcoin as
a combination between a bubble a ponzi
[Applause]
okay we have to talk about that so what
does he mean by bubble what’s a bubble
he just referred to the price of Bitcoin
so if you know it was around $1000 in
the beginning or 2017 then it rose to
about nine by October and then by the
end of the year it peaked at just below
$20,000 and just nothing Rises that
quickly without bursting or going down
in flames later and Bitcoin since has
dropped by 60% and now trades are around
7,500 but that’s still incredible okay
all right let’s so that’s bubble let’s
tell us about Ponzi scheme so the Ponzi
scheme reference was small in the fact
that there are actually elements of what
we call a pyramid scheme in Bitcoin in
the sense that early adopters make money
off later ones so one example is that
the so called mining fees that you get
are decreasing over time so early – or
adopters right now host of this poor
disproportionate amount of the bitcoins
that out there okay and then I think the
third thing was environmental disaster
can you tell us a little about before
you actually get to that you also
mentioned – a little bit about the
mining so the tool connected so that’s
easy
so mining is Bitcoin speak for the
creation of new bitcoins and so without
getting too technical Bitcoin is based
on the blockchain that we just heard
about so what does that mean it means
that the transaction are organized in
blocks that are somehow chained together
and miners compete in terms of getting
to add the next block to this chain and
if you win then you get an award of
bitcoins you used to get 50 now you get
about 12 and a half and in order to get
to add this block you have to solve a
really complicated mathematical problem
by brute force and so that means that
the more computers
have or faster computers they have a
higher light then you have a higher
likelihood of actually winning this race
and the problem you have to solve is
akin to a Sudoku but where you don’t
know the pre-fill numbers so the only
thing you can do is guess and keep on
guessing so this is what what mining
mining does and that’s also why bitcoin
is an environmental disaster because
this binding process consumes an
astonishing amount of energy in fact
some estimates have it that the
electricity used to run the computers
and cool the computers is on a daily
basis the same as my home country of
so I love this Sudoku this blank Sudoku
puzzle how many guesses does it take to
solve one block so long does this take
so that’s a bit complicated but it takes
about ten minutes for each block to be
added to the Bitcoin blockchain and some
simple back of the envelope calculations
shows that the average number of guesses
that all these computers have to do is
measured in what is called six Chileans
so that’s a one followed by 2100 us
running right now trying to guess the
next block it’ll get to add the next
block to the blockchain ok what you said
about the environmental disaster is
really interesting the electricity use I
have to ask why is this not being
regulated yet which is so saying has it
that there’s two things that are certain
in life like death and taxes but some
actually also at the ad regulation and
so the environmental this the
environmental impact is not the only
problem with Bitcoin another part of the
problem is that Bitcoin transactions are
anonymous or can’t be anonymous so
Bitcoin is actually also used for
criminal activities such as money
laundering tech
evasion drug trade ransomware or perhaps
even financing or further terrorism so
so yeah so it’s not necessarily maybe it
should be regulated right okay it
doesn’t sound like it’s coming soon
do you think central banks will get
start issuing crypto currencies so so
there’s a very light debate around that
at the moment but the central bank
should actually issue the crypto
currencies there’s another saying that
says if you can’t beat them then you
should join them so so that’s a that’s a
debate in in central banking and in
particular in in countries such as
Sweden and Norway and it’s gonna come as
a surprise to Swiss people but cash is
actually disappearing it’s actually
really hard to use cash for transactions
today if you were to go to Sweden so
central banks might think about it but I
think right now the technology is just
too unproven so I don’t see that
happening anytime soon
but one should never say never and there
are projects underway in countries such
as the Marshall Island Cambodia and
Venezuela all right so we’ve talked a
little bit about cryptocurrencies you
just mentioned the technology behind it
do you see any use for the blockchain or
that technology in the central banking
so I think at some point yes but but and
I have to say while one could be
skeptical about cryptocurrencies the
underlying technology is fascinating and
then and as was just argued it’s
potentially foundational in the same way
that the internet was and so there’s a
lot of experimentation going on and I
think that is very very exciting to see
what comes out but I would just say that
I usually compare Bitcoin today to what
was known as the Palm Pilot how many can
remember Pampanga right so those of you
that are old as me and remember the Palm
Pilot know that that was actually a
fairly useful handheld device but it
really pales in comparison to what we
have with
smartphones today so that’s another way
of saying the cryptocurrencies a
blockchain applications that we see
today are not the ones that we’re going
to be using in the future
okay so you’ve shared some skepticism
about cryptocurrency do you have
practical advice for those wanting to
get involved with it well I think that
depends on what you mean by getting
involved so if nothing criminal
hopefully okay so I think I think to who
if your thought asking about whether you
should invest I’m not the right person
to to ask and I’m definitely I’m not
even allowed to give investment advice
but if you’re interested in the
technology I would say hey go ahead but
if you were to think about investment I
would just say that the prices are very
volatile so I would think of it more as
akin to to gambling so I think the the
right advice I would give to you would
just to be proceed with the caution okay
so it sounds like you’re telling me to
sell it short for that I have absolutely
thank you so much for your time I was a
real pleasure to learn a little bit
about this and thank you very much [Applause]
Please follow and like us: