Press "Enter" to skip to content

(How) Can Small Languages Survive? | Eiríkur Rögnvaldsson | TEDxReykjavik


I’m going to talk to you about language
your language
imagine speaking a mother tongue that
you can’t use anywhere outside your own
country that’s not so hard to imagine is
it Icelanders are quite used to this as
are the fins and the Latvians and in
fact a great majority of the Earth’s
seven point six billion inhabitants
then imagine speaking language that you
cannot use everywhere within your own
country that shouldn’t be so hard either
this is for instance the everyday
experience of speakers of minority
languages like those who have iris or
wells or Britain or Basque as their
first language but finally imagine
speaking a mother tongue that you cannot
even use in all communication within
your own words that could be a bit
distressing and confusing don’t you
think however this might soon be the
reality for speakers of many languages
not only small languages like Icelandic
but also languages with millions of
speakers the main reason is the imminent
explosion in the use of voice control
most of you have probably tried to use
Siri and iPhones or some of the new
digital assistants like Amazon Alexa or
Google home or Microsoft Cortana did it
work out for you could you talk with
them in your mother tongue
I couldn’t YouTube has many videos
showing people trying to use voice
control unsuccessfully because the
Scottish accent or because they’ve just
come from the dentist and their
pronunciation is slurred and so on
this is often rather funny at first but
it ceases to be funny when you realise
that tomorrow
this
be your reality because everything
around you will be voice controlled your
cell phone your car your computer your
household appliances you name it
what will that retail for speakers of
small languages which are currently
unusable within this new technology it
has recently been claimed that at least
95% of the world’s 6 or 7,000 languages
are awaiting so-called digital death
this means that they don’t keep up with
the rapid development in speech and
language technology and will gradually
disappear from the digital realm or fail
to enter that realm altogether they will
not be used on the internet or in video
games and language technology tools and
applications like speech recognizers and
translation systems will not be built
for them of course this is only a
prediction not effect and things might
turn out differently if the necessary
measures are taken therefore it is
important to make effort to work to
ensure that Icelandic and other small
and vulnerable languages escaped digital
death and enter the digital realm it is
well known that speakers attitudes
towards their language are among the key
factors in determining the vitality of a
language if speakers generally foster
negative attitudes towards their
language it is doomed the attitudes of
young speakers are particularly
important in this respect young people
in Iceland and probably in most Western
countries at least think more globally
than their parents did
they see the whole world as their home
their stage their playground their
market they want to travel abroad study
abroad work abroad and live abroad these
young people know from the outset that
Icelandic is useless outside Iceland and
I think they can live with that
but if it turns out that they cannot use
Icelandic at home either
if Icelandic will be excluded from the
digital world of the future where these
young people want to find new and
exciting job opportunities and
entertainment the effects on their
attitudes towards Icelandic might be
very negative and even paved the way to
the test of the language but there is
more at stake here
we know that children in the language
acquisition period need a certain amount
of language input in order to acquire
the language of the community and build
their own strong internal grammar with
English dominating the digital world on
the internet in smartphones in video
games on YouTube and so on chances are
that these children’s exposure to spoken
Icelandic will be considerably lessened
perhaps even below the necessary
threshold for complete language
acquisition furthermore these children’s
parents might be preoccupied with their
smartphones instead of spending time
talking with their children this could
result in groups of children growing up
without mother tongue competence in the
native language nor in English for that
matter despite the great exposure they
received to that language
receptive input like watching TV for
instance does not provide sufficient
stimulus for successful first language
acquisition what is needed is
interactive communication conversation
we need to talk to our children listen
to them and respond to them now you
might ask why bother wouldn’t we be
better off if we just switched to
English wouldn’t that make life easier
for us and our children what’s the point
in clutching to language with limited
usability and spending great amounts of
time and money in keeping it alive and
functioning it is my firm belief that
despite technical advances and
globalization our mother tongue any
mother tongue is still invaluable to all
of us for a number of reasons every
language is a cultural treasure because
it’s unique in some sense its vocabulary
syntax and sound system is unlike any
other language and the semantic nuances
that it can express preserve the
experience of generations which is
different from that of other cultures
and societies a language that dies is
lost forever even if we have extensive
written texts and sound recordings which
is usually not the case a dead language
cannot be revitalized because complete
language acquisition is only possible by
direct transmission from one speaker to
another from parents to children every
language is also important and unique
from a scientific point of view because
it can help us learn something about the
nature of human language in general
Atlantic is for instance study
by a number of scholars around the world
and examples from Icelandic are used in
teaching in many universities outside
Iceland not because Icelandic is so
special but because its characteristics
can contribute to the model of our
language capacity that linguists are
building our language is also linked to
the nation’s history and culture in the
past this is especially evident for ice
lenders who enjoy the privilege of being
able to read without great difficulties
texts from the beginning of writing in
Iceland 900 years ago if Icelandic
undergoes radical changes or ceases to
exist as a living language we lose this
tired link to our past not only to our
celebrated medieval literature but also
to modern texts from the 20th and 21st
centuries language is also of course a
social phenomenon by far our most
important tool of communication with
other people
therefore it must not stagnate but has
to be vivid and adapt to the needs of
the society at any given time it must
tolerate variation in pronunciation
inflections and syntax and that new
words enter the language and old words
acquire new meaning it must not become
the private property of any special
group of people and language and
variation in its use must not be used to
discriminate people or characterize them
in any way last but not least language
is the most important outlet for our
feelings love and joy hatred and anger
sorrow and sadness hopes and desires but
also our tool for creative and
innovative
thinking a language that we acquire in
childhood is an integral part of
ourselves our private property but at
the same time public property belonging
to the whole language community and in a
sense even to the whole mankind
therefore preserving our language any
language is a matter of utmost
importance in the light of what I’m
insane in this talk it may seem a bit
ironic and paradoxical that I’m speaking
English today instead of my native
Icelandic you might ask whether I have
joined forces with the enemy but but
English is not the enemy English is at
present our most important and useful
tools for transnational communication
and outreach even though that may change
in the future due to development in
speech technology and an automatic
translation by giving his talk in
English I am merely selecting the tool
that best serves my need need to deliver
my message the battlefield where we
fight for our languages lies within the
language communities themselves not in
international communication our
languages are not doomed to die they can
be saved but we need a joint effort for
instance the Icelandic government is
investing considerably in language
technology as many other countries are
doing in order to make Atlantic digital
a viable within the next five years and
thus to spur positive attitudes towards
a language among its speakers but it’s
up to all of us to raise awareness among
parents and other adults about the
importance of interactive verbal
communication for the survival of our
languages
we must ensure that our children
received enough relevant input in the
mother tongue for them to become
proficient and confident language users
the future of our languages depends on
our children’s possibilities to use them
in all domains and on their willingness
to do so [Applause]
Please follow and like us: