Press "Enter" to skip to content

It’s time to end toxic masculinity | Robert Salem | TEDxToledo


[Applause]
Josh Pacheco was 17 years old he lived
in Michigan with his parents and sisters
and by all accounts he was a great kid
his sister’s described him as funny and
entertaining and his parents described
him as loving and caring and Josh was
also gay and because of that he was
bullied severely by his classmates one
day Josh went home went to his garage
got into his truck closed the door
turned on the ignition and killed
himself he was found a little bit later
with a note next to his body that simply
said I’m sorry I wasn’t able to be
this is sivanna Holton Tavano was 15
years old she lived in Florida one day
she broke up with her boyfriend the very
next day he posted a nude video of her
on Twitter and you can imagine what
happened then other kids took the video
and began circulating it on social media
and they began to cyberbully her
sivanna’s mother found two vana in the
bathroom of their home with a
self-inflicted gunshot wound to her head
just a few days later and this is
finally nine-year-old Jamel miles from
Denver just weeks ago he came out to his
mother as gay she was driving him home
he was in the backseat of the car he
said mommy I have something really
important to tell you I’m gay and she
said I love you anyway and she said he
looked so scared and so small in the
backseat but he told her that he was
proud and he wanted to tell his
classmates which is what he did and his
classmates in turn bullied him and told
him that he should die four days later
now these kids all had something they
all came from different backgrounds they
came from different parts of the country
but they all had at least one thing in
common and that is that their lives were
cut short by what experts have called
hyper-masculinity
and you might hear the term also
referred to as toxic masculinity now
before I talk to you more about how
hyper masculinity plays a negative role
in our society and how it harms children
I want to offer a disclaimer there is
nothing wrong with being masculine okay
and there is nothing wrong with being a
man fortunately for me and many of you
in the audience masculinity and
masculinity is basically defined as a
set of traits that are associated with
being a man and depending on culture and
context some of those traits can be
viewed as negative at times other times
they’re viewed as positive the same can
be said for femininity however hyper
masculinity is often it’s basically
masculinity on steroids and it’s often
characterized by a high degree of a high
tolerance level for violence and
aggression so those of us who have ever
witnessed road rage incidents or if
you’ve ever been to a fraternity party
after lots of kegs of beer have been
consumed or if we’ve gone to sports bars
during a really important game we may
have seen some hyper masculinity on
display at that point hyper masculinity
is also characterized by a callous
disregard for there was for the dignity
of women women sometimes by hyper
masculine behavior are treated as sex
objects and this kind of objectification
leads to sexual assault and sexual
harassment and finally hyper masculinity
is also characteristic of a sort of
stoicism men who display hyper masculine
behavior tend to conceal their emotions
they have a hard time emoting except for
anger notably but men that have these
hyper masculine tendencies don’t feel
like they can show their true feelings
because to do so
shows femininity shows weakness and
therefore is bad it’s interesting
because there’s more and more research
now that shows that hyper masculine
behavior not only negatively impacts the
victims of hyper masculinity which are
generally girls LGBTQ kids gender
non-conforming people but the biggest
victims of hyper masculinity are boys
and men because this kind of behavior
leads to all kinds of negative
consequences from psychological health
consequences physical health
consequences increased uses of substance
abuse and it’s also interesting that you
know some research is like a niobe way
from New York University have linked
hyper masculine behavior with loneliness
among males American men which is unique
in the world among men American men tend
to report that they either have few
other male friends and when they do they
have a hard time talking to their male
friends about important life issues or
emotions and this is obviously a problem
because it leads to all these negative
consequences and it creates sometimes a
level of loneliness that increases as
men age and they report that their level
of loneliness increases as they age and
public health officials are alarmed
because loneliness now is seen as a risk
factor for all kinds of negative health
consequences and early death so let me
give you an example of something I’m
talking about a few weeks ago I was
shopping at Costco which all of us do
right and I over I couldn’t help but
overhear a young father with his son
here the son was about 3 or 4 years old
the boy picked up a toy and already
was that it was a pink toy I don’t
remember what it was and without missing
a beat the father said put that back
that’s for girls and the boy reflecting
his father’s disgust and revulsion just
threw it back and said yuck daddy that’s
for girls now this kind of attitude
leads to hyper masculinity and it leads
to all of the negative effects that I
just talked about and it leads to
given what we’re experiencing in our
world today this issue is taking on more
significance think about the news what
are we hearing we’re talking about the
me2 movement we’re talking about rampant
gun violence which by the way is almost
exclusively perpetrated by boys and men
and we’re talking about what I would
consider a hyper masculine culture in
our white house so it’s a very important
issue today and it’s taking on more
significance so this is me and I’ll get
to me in a little bit okay but you know
I was introduced as a law professor I am
a law professor and for many years I’ve
been doing a lot of work on bullying
prevention so early on in my work on
bullying prevention and I’ve gone around
and trained lots of teachers and
administrators around the state early on
I discovered something the vast majority
of bullying incidents are somehow in
some way related to hyper-masculine
behavior whether the victim is a girl or
an LGBTQ or a person with a disability
or even racial ethnic and religious
minorities what I found is that either
the motivation for the bullying was
hyper masculine or the tactics used to
bully or hyper masculine and I became
even more concerned when I started to
review bullying related suicides and
these are kids who have taken their
lives because at least in part because
of bullying and what I found was that
roughly 80%
of the kids who take their lives because
of bullying our boys who were gay or
perceived to be gay and girls who were
the victims of gender related or sexual
bullying so this obviously concerned me
a lot and I started to pay more
attention to how hyper masculinity
affects our kids what’s even more
interesting about bullying prevention
programs is that they don’t discuss or
address head-on how hyper masculinity
and rigid gender norms affect our kids
in school and how we can improve the
climate of our schools so that we can
prevent bullying
by addressing these issues we just don’t
talk about it what drives me crazy is
this I have been doing with this work
for a lot of years and just a few years
ago there was this revelation in society
that girls also bully big surprise and
all of a sudden as a culture as a
society we just like lobbed onto that
glob down to that and we we started
talking about Mean Girls and we coined
this term Mean Girls because of course
we need another way to vilify girls
right and so then we made a movie about
Mean Girls and that’s all we talked
about but the evidence related to
bullying is clear still the vast
majority of bullying perpetrators are
boys and the vast majority of bullying
victims are boys but we don’t talk about
scary boys we talked about Mean Girls so
this is me and you can tell maybe from
the picture that I wasn’t the most
traditionally masculine kid right if you
asked me why I was posed that way I
honestly don’t have a good answer for
you you’ll have to ask my mother but you
know I was also very I became very
interested in this subject when I start
to reflect on when I started to reflect
on my own childhood and my experiences
with hyper masculinity so I grew up in a
very loving large Lebanese American
family I had two
amazing wonderful parents three brothers
a sister I did very well in school I
participated in clubs and sports I was a
student leader throughout high school
and college I had friends I had
girlfriends so my memories should be
good of childhood right they weren’t
when I think of my childhood I mostly
have negative feelings I was actually a
pretty miserable kid and I attribute
that to the fact that I did everything
in my power to conceal the fact that I
was gay and I did everything in my power
to act like what I thought a boy should
act like and I’ll tell you some of my
most memorable experiences and these are
memories that they’re pretty innocuous
when you hear them and they shouldn’t
really be that memorable but for me they
were and here’s like here are some of
them so I remember in the fifth grade I
was brushing my friend Cheryl’s long
blonde hair because that’s what
ten-year-old boys like to do right and
and I was brushing her hair and the
teacher from across the room yelled at
me and said Robby Salem put that brush
down boys don’t brush girl’s hair and I
was devastated I was just deflated and I
wasn’t just devastated because Cheryl’s
hair was a mess but because because
I felt like I did something wrong I
committed a sin and I didn’t even know
what it was
I’ll tell you another time another
memory I had was when I walked into
school this was probably you in the
sixth grade and I was wearing my cherry
red pants and a teacher called me up to
the room and to the front and in front
of a couple of other kids she said Robby
don’t wear those pants again boys don’t
dress that way now I will give her this
much the pants were hideous and there
were also corduroys so visualize that
but still still that was pretty that’s
pretty cruel and then I remember the
time in middle school that I was
carrying my books in front of my body
like this and a boy in the hallway
laughed at me and called me a girl and
you can believe you better believe that
from that point on I carried my books on
my side and this was before backpacks
for a big thing so that’s how we carried
our books and and you know I just
thought it was more practical to carry
your books this way but apparently not
if you’re a boy
so those memories sort of pale in
comparison to some of the other things I
overheard and experienced like the time
in high school when I overheard a group
of boys laughing in the hallway and
talking about a disease that is going
around killing all the so I tried
really hard to fit in I did my best and
I mean I even tried but I pretended that
I liked watching sports on TV with my
three sports loving brothers even
baseball so it was tough it was tough
and I did my best but I was miserable
and like Josh Savannah and Jamel who I
showed you earlier I often wanted to
take my life so you know a few years ago
I started looking at pop culture and the
messages that we receive that kids
receive in pop culture and think about
the blockbuster movies the movies that
are most popular now
the best movies but the movies that are
most popular if you google blockbuster
movies of 2017 and 2018 what you’re
going to see are all kinds of films that
typify this hyper masculine behavior
that I’m talking about these are films
often with leading male characters who
are tall and muscular and tough and
stoic and there’s usually a woman or a
girl in the movie that’s going to
ultimately become his romantic or sex
partner and you see fantastic explosions
and fast cars and police chases and
these are the most popular movies and
the film and TV industry is not the only
industry that’s guilty of this here are
some more movies movies but the music
industry is guilty of this the ad
industry is guilty of this what the ad
industry does when they want to target
men is to talk about how men can reclaim
their manhood men are back consider your
man card reissued spray more axe Cologne
and get more get more what imagine and
this problem also exists in our video
game industry which is a real problem
for our young men today and of course we
see it often displayed in the sports
industry so a couple of years ago the
New York Times conducted a study on a
feature that is Michael Kimmel was a
scholar and Michael Kimmel would pull
his students and he would ask them on a
regular basis describe what a good man
is and describe what a real man is and
over time he saw themes emerging and
here’s what he found that his students
often described a good man as honest
caring and selfless and that same
students would describe a real man has a
take-charge risk-taker authoritative
never cry and don’t show weakness so
it’s no wonder that men and boys are
confused
and girls and women for that matter can
you be a good man and a real man it’s a
really an open question in our society
there’s all kinds of research that is
really interesting about how we treat
boys and girls differently based on our
perceptions of how they should behave
according to their gender there’s a
fascinating study that was conducted by
scholar Terry rial he showed a video of
a crying baby to hundreds of adults
adult participants in his study just for
some of the adults he said the baby was
a girl other adults he said the baby was
a boy and he asked the adults to convey
to describe what emotion the baby was
conveying overwhelmingly the adults who
thought the baby was a girl described
her as scared fearful the adults who
thought the baby was a boy
described him as angry so it goes
without saying and it’s pretty logical
that we treat our kids differently
well-intentioned parents treat their
kids differently based on how we think
they should behave according to their
gender
now there’s also kind all kinds of
surveys out there that that address what
are the most injurious words that kids
experience when kids want to hurt other
kids what are they here what do they use
these are the most common insults this
is what hurts kids whore bitch
gay retard all motivated by hyper
masculinity so it’s no wonder that 85%
of LGBTQ kids report being bullied in
school it’s no wonder that 83% of girls
report being sexually harassed in school
it’s no wonder that an estimated 5.4
million students skip school on a
regular basis during the school year
because they don’t want to confront
their bullies and get this according to
one study most adolescent girls fear
gaining weight more than they fear
cancer nuclear war and losing a parent
we have a problem folks and we need to
start taking this seriously the problem
doesn’t have an easy solution we’re not
going to resolve this overnight but I
think we can all do something in our own
small ways we can affect the people
around us the circle of people around us
by behaving in certain ways and being
more aware of these toxic messages first
of all let’s acknowledge that
hyper-masculinity is a problem
let’s also acknowledge that misogyny
homophobia and transphobia are
inextricably linked we’re all in this
together
whether you’re a man woman boy girl gay
straight we’re all in this together
because this is harmful to society and
in our own little way if you see a woman
or a girl being harassed in the street
if you’re comfortable intervene if you
hear a homophobic joke being told in the
locker room do the brave thing and call
it out for what it is offensive if your
son wants to buy a pink toy at Costco
either buy it for him or at least don’t
shame him I want to leave you with these
faces Josh to vana and Jamel I hope we
don’t just remember them today I hope we
honor them let’s honor them by all
changing our outlook on the messages
that we receive and let’s all be more
aware and help our kids help our kids
and if we can just start helping boys
and men learn that in order to be a good
man in order to be a real man you have to start by being a good man thank you
Please follow and like us: