
one of the realest discussions I have
ever had in law school was with one of
my absolute favorite professors I had
gone out a few nights earlier with some
classmates all of whom were middle and
upper-class white youth except for
myself
they began drinking and access and
started swapping stories about all of
the illicit substances that they had
tried in the past one of my classmates
said that he hated going back to U of
Chicago where he had done his
undergraduate because every time he went
back he did coke he couldn’t help it
it’s what his undergraduate friends
considered fun I was incensed I was
offended at how casually they discussed
recreational drug use I be rated and
scolded them I told them that addiction
ruins lives and that people from my
neighborhood would be drug tested the
rest of their lives to work minimum wage
jobs while they my classmates got cushy
law firm offers cloaked in a presumption
of sobriety work got back to my
professor that I had killed the party
that I had gone on a righteous rant
tensions between my classmates and
myself lingered and my professor hoping
to ease some of that friction invited me
into her office after I relate my
concerns to her she said something to me
I will never forget she said that I
needed to realize that my perspective on
drugs and drug users was heavily
informed by my race my socio-economic
background and my upbringing that poor
communities especially poor communities
of color got an unequivocal message
about drug use that it was bad that it
led to no future and that it would
she said that middle and upper class
mostly white communities got a very
different message about drugs that
recreational drug use was just that it
was recreation to be enjoyed in
moderation and should the problem get
out of hand there were resources to
assist it was the first time that I
realized that race and income played a
tangible significant role in the way in
the distinction that my professor
articulated for me that day is
especially visible when you compare and
contrast the societal response to the
crack epidemic of the 80s and 90s and
the opiate epidemic that we are
grappling with today in the 80s and 90s
mini inner-city mostly black communities
were struggling with addiction to crack
cocaine now crack was not a drug
exclusive to those community
but that was the prevalent Association
and it’s the imagery we developed in our
collective conscience about what drug
users look like without saying it aloud
when you hear the phrase crack head what
image pops in your mind bye Felicia
a phrase that was all the rave on the
internet a year or so ago derived from
how dismissive we were of addicts crack
addicts specifically when they reached
out for help or money or food we
considered their request a symptom of
their addiction therefore unworthy of
our attention so bye Felicia or this
image this popular image from the
Chappelle show or Pookie from New Jack
city the association of crack cocaine
with poor black people was so prevalent
and the vilification and dehumanization
of these people so commonplace that it
became a tenet of popular culture we
humored it almost without thought
because none of these people are people
that you want to invite over your house
for dinner we did not respond to the
crack cocaine epidemic with compassion
or empathy we did not humanize addicts
or their families or their children in
fact these are the headlines that we ran
in Time magazine an in Rolling Stone and
in The New York Times about the children
of
crack kids their mothers used and now
it’s the children who suffer childhoods
end what life is like for crack babies
babies born to cracked addicted mothers
are like no others brain damaged yet
cracks told among babies a joyless view
the content of those articles were often
even worse than the headlines one
pediatrician from the University of
California opined that the part of the
brain that makes us human capable of
reflection and discussion is wiped out
in crack babies I don’t even know what
that means but what I do know is that it
means that if the part of the brain that
makes us human is absent from these
humans than they are something else they
are not like me they are other de recent
article where an author reflected on
publications featuring the phrase crack
babies from the 80s and 90s described it
this way quote crack babies calls to
mind
damaged hopeless children with birth
defects and intellectual disabilities
who will inevitably grow into criminals
it connotes inner-city blackness and
cost to mind careless unthinking mothers
who knowingly expose their children to
the ravages of cocaine
the term made brutes of people of color
who were living through wave after wave
of what was then the deadliest drug
epidemic in history
there was a campaign to dehumanize a
constant affront to the humanity of
infants exposed to cocaine in quote the
legal response was equally detrimental
beginning in the mid 80s to 90s
high-level politicians began using
criminal rhetoric to frame and describe
the crack epidemic President Richard
Nixon said the drugs were public enemy
number one and we had to wage an all-out
offensive to restore law in order
restoration of law and order does not
sound like addiction
it sounds like lawlessness neccessity
Meza tating law enforcement not medical
and health professionals and that’s
exactly what we did it was in those
moments that we decided to deal with the
crack epidemic as a public safety
problem not as a public health problem
punitive laws were passed three strikes
mandatory minimum sentencing artificial
distinctions between crack and powder
cocaine that stiffened penalties and
incentivized enforcement today there are
more people incarcerated for just drug
offenses then all people incarcerated
for all crimes in 1980 today there are
more people in prison for just drugs
than were incarcerated for all crimes in
over half of the state prison population
and over two-thirds of the federal
prison population are therefore just
drugs after declaring a war on drugs
drug convictions increased by a thousand
percent so how did we get from this
place where we vilified encaged addicts
well we encouraged them not to reproduce
this is a photograph of an actual
billboard that said if you are addicted
to crack we will give you free birth
control how did we get from this place
to where we are now in a rehabilitative
posture beginning in the 1990s a myriad
of factors started converging to create
what we now know is the deadliest drug
epidemic in history the opioid crisis
there was a growing heroin problem and
loosening regulation on prescribing
opiates coupled with a changing attitude
in medicine about the alleviation of
pain we begin describing pain as the
fifth vital sign and medical
professionals had decided that it was
their responsibility to alleviate pain
that pain was bad and we should
eliminate it at all cost
add to that an aggressive marketing
campaign by pharmaceutical companies
that mischaracterized the potential for
abuse of opiates all supported by an
addict base that was more fluent younger
and whiter than it had been in the past
it did not fit our conscious imagery as
a collective about what addicts look
like they weren’t the undesirable
parasitic Felicia
and pookie images that I just had up in
fact here are the headlines we’ve ran
about the children of the opiate crisis
children of the epidemic in the midst of
a national opioid crisis mother’s
addicted to drugs struggled to get off
of them for their babies sake for the
babies of the opioid crisis the best
care maybe mom’s recovery now I want you
the image on my wife am i right am i
I mean the image on my right there’s
flattering lighting the child is clothed
and white with a jovial or at least
serene facial expression and the first
word used to describe that child is
child children right now look at the
image on my right sorry the other image
on my left this image is on my right the
lighting is darker this child appears to
be in distress
crying presumably because he’s the child
of an addict and the first word used to
describe him is crack I don’t think it’s
a coincidence that I went after Doug
this is probably the only place I get to
call him Doug by first name like I know
him personally because this is one of
the spaces where our rhetoric did not
engineer positive outcomes where as an
audience it is imperative that we are
vigilant in analyzing and thinking
critically about what the messaging is
here because the ironic part is that the
thrust of both of these articles is
largely the same sober parents are
but the messaging and the packaging is
markedly different and arouses different
sentiments and public responses one of
the articles considered the crisis in a
vacuum void of any societal context
focused solely on the personal decision
to use the other while still involving
discussion of personal choice included a
holistic approach that discussed all of
the things infringing upon one’s present
condition that would lead you to use
illicit substances the result is that
one article fostered compassion an
empathy and human connection and
understanding while the other vilified
fostered other nests and disrupted our
ability to show compassion and to
connect and enabled us to create
the other thing that’s different is the
promising to lock up addicts almost
guaranteed you votes and understandably
if you vilify addicts constantly you
make them seem like a threat to your
safety everyone wants to lock those
people up try promising to lock up that
mother holding her children people are
going to be apprehensive about voting
for you legal scholars formerly
incarcerated persons filmmakers
advocates have all contributed to the
public dialogue to change our thinking
about crime criminals punishment and
prison many high-level politicians who
were very vocal and advocating for tough
policies in the 80s and 90s have
retreated from those positions many of
them have openly admitted that they were
wrong and now advocate being smart on
crime instead of tough on crime this
year Newt Gingrich wrote an article
where he indicated that the tough
policies of the 80s and 90s related to
crack quote failed miserably in quote
former vice president and Senator Joe
Biden who drafted the 1986 drug abuse
act partly responsible for some of the
prison statistics I discussed earlier
testified on record in an hearing in
President Donald Trump has declared the
opioid crisis a public health emergency
he has advocated for training and
educational campaigns to warn about the
danger
of opiates and to help federal
rehabilitation programs there was no
discussion in any of his remarks about
being tough on users about lawlessness
so we’ve abandoned many of those
policies we’ve now adopted programs like
dart encouraging law enforcement
officials to respond compassionately to
users or drug courts intervention in
lieu programs clean needle exchanges
give back your drug dais assistance
programs to help addicts find housing
and jobs on their way to recovery so
here we have similar drug problems that
we’ve responded to vastly differently
how how is such a discrepancy even
possible in the book dreamland Sam key
onus I think I said that correctly it’s
very difficult spelled in an interesting
way he writes a book where he chronicles
the opiate crisis in the states and in
his book he recounts conversations that
he has with drug court judges and he
asked them essentially that exact
question how do we have these vastly
different responses to these drug crises
and the judges answers are simple the
judge says it’s easy to support locking
up inner-city addicts that have been
vilified night after night on the
nightly news and in the media and by
political pundits it is much harder to
support that when that addict is
your child or the child of the local
police chief or your pediatrician and
those are the people who have been
affected by this crisis and I think in a
more critical nuanced way what that
means is that it is harder to throw away
people you empathize with that you have
compassion for that you can see yourself
in there’s a burgeoning group of
researchers who are studying empathy and
one of the things that they have found
is that your brain has what they call a
mirroring function seeing someone do
something and being able to envision
yourself in that predicament that could
be me
dribbling that ball getting hit by that
car suffering that addiction and the
less you believe yourself to be like
that person the harder it is to exercise
you’re mirroring function which fosters
compassion I think what Doug was saying
about being critical in thinking about
the rhetoric that we’re hearing and what
it means is so important because in part
it has contributed to this discrepancy
this is how tragedies like this are born
because we are not vigilant when we hear
things like crack babies about what that
means we don’t think about how it’s
different from the language of the
headlines that are presently being run
or what it means when we humor someone’s
addiction when we say they’re not like
so what do we do now well the first
thing I think we need to do is to raise
awareness that this has happened that
we’ve treated these two crises markedly
differently and the results of that
treatment do
reverberate today most poignant ly among
those most vulnerable in our society the
second thing we must do is support
initiatives aimed at remedying the harm
caused by the war on drugs
we messed it up we need to fix it it’s
not enough that politicians are saying I
got it wrong I’ll do better in the
future
that doesn’t work in a lawsuit someone
hits your car they don’t get to say you
know what I messed up your car I won’t
hit any more cars in the future you want
them to make you whole
you want them to fix it and rightfully
so
the last thing I think we need to do it
is our responsibility to hold judicial
officials the media and as a public
ourselves accountable when we hear
unchecked story lines that perpetuate
stereotypes and false narratives part of
what we have to acknowledge is that one
of the reasons that the opioid crisis
has in part spared the black community
is in part because we had poor access to
health care to begin with if we’re ever
going to be better if we’re ever going
to avoid crises like this and make
ourselves whole it is incumbent upon us
to be critical to be diligent and to be
proactive in remaining the mistakes from
the past and making better decisions
moving forward you all can eat now [Applause]
ever had in law school was with one of
my absolute favorite professors I had
gone out a few nights earlier with some
classmates all of whom were middle and
upper-class white youth except for
myself
they began drinking and access and
started swapping stories about all of
the illicit substances that they had
tried in the past one of my classmates
said that he hated going back to U of
Chicago where he had done his
undergraduate because every time he went
back he did coke he couldn’t help it
it’s what his undergraduate friends
considered fun I was incensed I was
offended at how casually they discussed
recreational drug use I be rated and
scolded them I told them that addiction
ruins lives and that people from my
neighborhood would be drug tested the
rest of their lives to work minimum wage
jobs while they my classmates got cushy
law firm offers cloaked in a presumption
of sobriety work got back to my
professor that I had killed the party
that I had gone on a righteous rant
tensions between my classmates and
myself lingered and my professor hoping
to ease some of that friction invited me
into her office after I relate my
concerns to her she said something to me
I will never forget she said that I
needed to realize that my perspective on
drugs and drug users was heavily
informed by my race my socio-economic
background and my upbringing that poor
communities especially poor communities
of color got an unequivocal message
about drug use that it was bad that it
led to no future and that it would
she said that middle and upper class
mostly white communities got a very
different message about drugs that
recreational drug use was just that it
was recreation to be enjoyed in
moderation and should the problem get
out of hand there were resources to
assist it was the first time that I
realized that race and income played a
tangible significant role in the way in
the distinction that my professor
articulated for me that day is
especially visible when you compare and
contrast the societal response to the
crack epidemic of the 80s and 90s and
the opiate epidemic that we are
grappling with today in the 80s and 90s
mini inner-city mostly black communities
were struggling with addiction to crack
cocaine now crack was not a drug
exclusive to those community
but that was the prevalent Association
and it’s the imagery we developed in our
collective conscience about what drug
users look like without saying it aloud
when you hear the phrase crack head what
image pops in your mind bye Felicia
a phrase that was all the rave on the
internet a year or so ago derived from
how dismissive we were of addicts crack
addicts specifically when they reached
out for help or money or food we
considered their request a symptom of
their addiction therefore unworthy of
our attention so bye Felicia or this
image this popular image from the
Chappelle show or Pookie from New Jack
city the association of crack cocaine
with poor black people was so prevalent
and the vilification and dehumanization
of these people so commonplace that it
became a tenet of popular culture we
humored it almost without thought
because none of these people are people
that you want to invite over your house
for dinner we did not respond to the
crack cocaine epidemic with compassion
or empathy we did not humanize addicts
or their families or their children in
fact these are the headlines that we ran
in Time magazine an in Rolling Stone and
in The New York Times about the children
of
crack kids their mothers used and now
it’s the children who suffer childhoods
end what life is like for crack babies
babies born to cracked addicted mothers
are like no others brain damaged yet
cracks told among babies a joyless view
the content of those articles were often
even worse than the headlines one
pediatrician from the University of
California opined that the part of the
brain that makes us human capable of
reflection and discussion is wiped out
in crack babies I don’t even know what
that means but what I do know is that it
means that if the part of the brain that
makes us human is absent from these
humans than they are something else they
are not like me they are other de recent
article where an author reflected on
publications featuring the phrase crack
babies from the 80s and 90s described it
this way quote crack babies calls to
mind
damaged hopeless children with birth
defects and intellectual disabilities
who will inevitably grow into criminals
it connotes inner-city blackness and
cost to mind careless unthinking mothers
who knowingly expose their children to
the ravages of cocaine
the term made brutes of people of color
who were living through wave after wave
of what was then the deadliest drug
epidemic in history
there was a campaign to dehumanize a
constant affront to the humanity of
infants exposed to cocaine in quote the
legal response was equally detrimental
beginning in the mid 80s to 90s
high-level politicians began using
criminal rhetoric to frame and describe
the crack epidemic President Richard
Nixon said the drugs were public enemy
number one and we had to wage an all-out
offensive to restore law in order
restoration of law and order does not
sound like addiction
it sounds like lawlessness neccessity
Meza tating law enforcement not medical
and health professionals and that’s
exactly what we did it was in those
moments that we decided to deal with the
crack epidemic as a public safety
problem not as a public health problem
punitive laws were passed three strikes
mandatory minimum sentencing artificial
distinctions between crack and powder
cocaine that stiffened penalties and
incentivized enforcement today there are
more people incarcerated for just drug
offenses then all people incarcerated
for all crimes in 1980 today there are
more people in prison for just drugs
than were incarcerated for all crimes in
over half of the state prison population
and over two-thirds of the federal
prison population are therefore just
drugs after declaring a war on drugs
drug convictions increased by a thousand
percent so how did we get from this
place where we vilified encaged addicts
well we encouraged them not to reproduce
this is a photograph of an actual
billboard that said if you are addicted
to crack we will give you free birth
control how did we get from this place
to where we are now in a rehabilitative
posture beginning in the 1990s a myriad
of factors started converging to create
what we now know is the deadliest drug
epidemic in history the opioid crisis
there was a growing heroin problem and
loosening regulation on prescribing
opiates coupled with a changing attitude
in medicine about the alleviation of
pain we begin describing pain as the
fifth vital sign and medical
professionals had decided that it was
their responsibility to alleviate pain
that pain was bad and we should
eliminate it at all cost
add to that an aggressive marketing
campaign by pharmaceutical companies
that mischaracterized the potential for
abuse of opiates all supported by an
addict base that was more fluent younger
and whiter than it had been in the past
it did not fit our conscious imagery as
a collective about what addicts look
like they weren’t the undesirable
parasitic Felicia
and pookie images that I just had up in
fact here are the headlines we’ve ran
about the children of the opiate crisis
children of the epidemic in the midst of
a national opioid crisis mother’s
addicted to drugs struggled to get off
of them for their babies sake for the
babies of the opioid crisis the best
care maybe mom’s recovery now I want you
the image on my wife am i right am i
I mean the image on my right there’s
flattering lighting the child is clothed
and white with a jovial or at least
serene facial expression and the first
word used to describe that child is
child children right now look at the
image on my right sorry the other image
on my left this image is on my right the
lighting is darker this child appears to
be in distress
crying presumably because he’s the child
of an addict and the first word used to
describe him is crack I don’t think it’s
a coincidence that I went after Doug
this is probably the only place I get to
call him Doug by first name like I know
him personally because this is one of
the spaces where our rhetoric did not
engineer positive outcomes where as an
audience it is imperative that we are
vigilant in analyzing and thinking
critically about what the messaging is
here because the ironic part is that the
thrust of both of these articles is
largely the same sober parents are
but the messaging and the packaging is
markedly different and arouses different
sentiments and public responses one of
the articles considered the crisis in a
vacuum void of any societal context
focused solely on the personal decision
to use the other while still involving
discussion of personal choice included a
holistic approach that discussed all of
the things infringing upon one’s present
condition that would lead you to use
illicit substances the result is that
one article fostered compassion an
empathy and human connection and
understanding while the other vilified
fostered other nests and disrupted our
ability to show compassion and to
connect and enabled us to create
the other thing that’s different is the
promising to lock up addicts almost
guaranteed you votes and understandably
if you vilify addicts constantly you
make them seem like a threat to your
safety everyone wants to lock those
people up try promising to lock up that
mother holding her children people are
going to be apprehensive about voting
for you legal scholars formerly
incarcerated persons filmmakers
advocates have all contributed to the
public dialogue to change our thinking
about crime criminals punishment and
prison many high-level politicians who
were very vocal and advocating for tough
policies in the 80s and 90s have
retreated from those positions many of
them have openly admitted that they were
wrong and now advocate being smart on
crime instead of tough on crime this
year Newt Gingrich wrote an article
where he indicated that the tough
policies of the 80s and 90s related to
crack quote failed miserably in quote
former vice president and Senator Joe
Biden who drafted the 1986 drug abuse
act partly responsible for some of the
prison statistics I discussed earlier
testified on record in an hearing in
President Donald Trump has declared the
opioid crisis a public health emergency
he has advocated for training and
educational campaigns to warn about the
danger
of opiates and to help federal
rehabilitation programs there was no
discussion in any of his remarks about
being tough on users about lawlessness
so we’ve abandoned many of those
policies we’ve now adopted programs like
dart encouraging law enforcement
officials to respond compassionately to
users or drug courts intervention in
lieu programs clean needle exchanges
give back your drug dais assistance
programs to help addicts find housing
and jobs on their way to recovery so
here we have similar drug problems that
we’ve responded to vastly differently
how how is such a discrepancy even
possible in the book dreamland Sam key
onus I think I said that correctly it’s
very difficult spelled in an interesting
way he writes a book where he chronicles
the opiate crisis in the states and in
his book he recounts conversations that
he has with drug court judges and he
asked them essentially that exact
question how do we have these vastly
different responses to these drug crises
and the judges answers are simple the
judge says it’s easy to support locking
up inner-city addicts that have been
vilified night after night on the
nightly news and in the media and by
political pundits it is much harder to
support that when that addict is
your child or the child of the local
police chief or your pediatrician and
those are the people who have been
affected by this crisis and I think in a
more critical nuanced way what that
means is that it is harder to throw away
people you empathize with that you have
compassion for that you can see yourself
in there’s a burgeoning group of
researchers who are studying empathy and
one of the things that they have found
is that your brain has what they call a
mirroring function seeing someone do
something and being able to envision
yourself in that predicament that could
be me
dribbling that ball getting hit by that
car suffering that addiction and the
less you believe yourself to be like
that person the harder it is to exercise
you’re mirroring function which fosters
compassion I think what Doug was saying
about being critical in thinking about
the rhetoric that we’re hearing and what
it means is so important because in part
it has contributed to this discrepancy
this is how tragedies like this are born
because we are not vigilant when we hear
things like crack babies about what that
means we don’t think about how it’s
different from the language of the
headlines that are presently being run
or what it means when we humor someone’s
addiction when we say they’re not like
so what do we do now well the first
thing I think we need to do is to raise
awareness that this has happened that
we’ve treated these two crises markedly
differently and the results of that
treatment do
reverberate today most poignant ly among
those most vulnerable in our society the
second thing we must do is support
initiatives aimed at remedying the harm
caused by the war on drugs
we messed it up we need to fix it it’s
not enough that politicians are saying I
got it wrong I’ll do better in the
future
that doesn’t work in a lawsuit someone
hits your car they don’t get to say you
know what I messed up your car I won’t
hit any more cars in the future you want
them to make you whole
you want them to fix it and rightfully
so
the last thing I think we need to do it
is our responsibility to hold judicial
officials the media and as a public
ourselves accountable when we hear
unchecked story lines that perpetuate
stereotypes and false narratives part of
what we have to acknowledge is that one
of the reasons that the opioid crisis
has in part spared the black community
is in part because we had poor access to
health care to begin with if we’re ever
going to be better if we’re ever going
to avoid crises like this and make
ourselves whole it is incumbent upon us
to be critical to be diligent and to be
proactive in remaining the mistakes from
the past and making better decisions
moving forward you all can eat now [Applause]
Please follow and like us: