
tell from my title I’m going to in short
and show how much you love us by just
throwing money in big Bill’s it’s all
good that’s pretty much what i’m going
to talk about tonight okay you’re going
to be a hard crowd like that okay that’s
okay okay you know what I do want to
talk to about tonight is teacher
evaluations okay and I know we’re not
all teachers in here but I want to share
some stuff about that and so this
picture here is a school that I actually
got to visit last year and that’s an
actual school all right it’s right it’s
just around the corner no it’s actually
in England it’s in England and I got to
visit it because they asked me to come
out and evaluate their teachers they
have 60 teachers there and the thing
about this I mean I’m not joking that is
a real school and I’ve gained about 10
pounds because in England all the
teachers at this school have teen and
biscuits every day at ten-fifteen and
after school of 415 they have like the
serious pastries and of course t.t is
like they’re all the time 24 7 you can
get it all right so that wasn’t the
reason I actually went there though what
I went through they invited me to come
in and work with the teachers for those
of you who don’t know me I’m the
coordinator for the center of teaching
excellence here at Cerritos I get to
work with a lot of teachers all the time
not just here but all over the country
at this point and it is and it’s an
amazing experience but this one here
stood out and I’ll tell you why they had
60 faculty over there and the headmaster
their asset you know I want you to come
in and evaluate and check out the
teaching practices and just help our
teachers think differently and reflect I
said show me your school sure I’ll go
out of the 6044 decided to be evaluated
now well I say decided because none of
them were required to do this all right
when I showed up there I had to talk
with them all and I told them look I’m
couldn’t evaluate you and I’m not going
to assess you what I’m going to do is
sit with you I want to watch your teach
because I love to learn from other
teachers and I’m going to do that with
you and I’m also going to sit down and
talk with you after if you’re willing
because I would love to share the
practices that you’ve done and the
things that I noticed and just share
ideas 44 of them said yeah this sounds
cool and we did it and it was amazing
one of the cool things about it that I
didn’t realize it was going to happen is
for those of you who’ve ever any faculty
who ever done been
a team like that or been just evaluate
anybody have watched somebody to teach
44 is a big number all right i was doing
roughly five a day and keep in mind that
if I observed somebody I would also then
talk to them for a minimum of 30 minutes
I would sit there and we were just we
would talk and all kinds of stuff came
out of those conversation it was really
rich well that afforded me the
opportunity to do a lot of concentrated
practice on the skill of talking to
teachers about reflective teaching
practices it was awesome and when I left
that school I got so much fantastic
feedback but when I left I took the
short flight home it’s about 12 hours
from London so I had a lot of time to
think there’s one overriding idea that
just would not go away and it still
won’t go away and I suspect now will
never go away because it’s firmly
planted in there and that’s after doing
that and watch that happen I thought why
don’t we do that here why don’t we do
what I just did over there at Cerritos I
need to tell you what we do here in
order for you to understand the
difference so and this isn’t just a
cerritos by the way this teaching
evaluation process we do here for those
of you who aren’t teachers I want to
give you some insight okay well first
you got to get hired alright this is
what we do here so to get hired you got
to send in some paperwork right and
there’s like a hundred of you there’s
one job opening and there’s about a
hundred you that apply so you got to
submit an application yeah you got to
submit a cover letter you got to submit
your transcript where you went to school
you got to submit letters of reference
oh you got to submit what we call a
curriculum vita alright that’s like
everything you do in your career okay
and then just for good measure you
remember that your mom wrote a little
biography on you so you put that into
your just in case you don’t know what’s
going to happen all right now if you’re
lucky you you get from that hundred down
to maybe like six there’s a committee
that looks at all the stuff that goes
these six we’re going to take we’re
gonna want to interview them so you go
to the interview and there’s the
committee waiting for you and then they
do this huge interview there’s a lot of
stress going on they want maybe a
teaching demonstration all this goes on
right and then they teach it to tizzle
again and now you’re down to maybe three
guess what you get to do now you get to
go to another committee with the
president of the college and he gets to
pick who he wants on his committee and
they grill you for another hour pure joy
right there
make sure they got the right person and
guess what out of 100 it comes down to
one yeah and so now we’re sure we’re
confident if you’re on any committee we
have picked the absolute best candidate
with the best skill set the best overall
package for this job right that’s the
plan so you come in boom you get your
contract cool first day whoo you just
got hired guess what there’s a new
committee waiting for you it’s the
committee to fire now I’m just joking
it’s not a committed it’s not really
called that what they call it officially
is the evaluation committee okay and
then you’re out there you know they
don’t send him go we’re going to find
ways to fire you but here’s the thing
the process that we go through after
that and I get to deal with it in my
position with every new faculty on this
campus I get to work with him and help
them in any way I can and I tell them
from day one I want to help you in any
way that we can with our staff well they
come in and guess what they’re going to
go through an evaluation every single
semester for the first two years and
they’re called probationary factor of
faculty you know like when you don’t go
to jail but you did something wrong they
put you on probation yeah your
probationary faculty for two years and
this community comes and then each
committee is a little different some
committees come in their visit you five
times six times one time and then some
committees tell you we’re going to let
you know when we come some come years
ago we’ll just drop in we’ll just drop
in right it feels very punitive and I’ll
tell you right now from the word of the
faculty of the new faculty it’s
stressful all right it feels very big
feels like if they’re going they’re
going to catch me and so I’m thinking
here that we need to rethink how we do
that this is the feeling yeah right
there now they also come in with these
forms and these forms this is like
public record stuff so don’t worry I’m
not breaking any laws or if I am it
doesn’t matter thank you for somebody
laughs in there these are forms that you
know this is like two pages of like I
don’t know eight or nine pages a lot of
boxes yeah and these forms aren’t always
like you can’t really tell a lot I mean
it’s a checkup yeah they did yeah okay
no rule is broken here yup still legal
yep okay still yeah okay allowed to
teach and so you get evaluated it’s
very much like a math test right it’s an
evaluation it’s just you’re done your
past you’re good you get to do that 12
times in your first two years and if you
don’t mess up then you won’t be
probationary anymore now I think that
evaluations are important because the
feedback that you get is really
important the question I have for this
group today is how is that feedback
being given because as you saw from that
form it’s like a test right you just get
your grade you don’t really have the
chance to sit down with a group of
people who want to talk to you about how
to help you get better or that you can
bounce ideas off of or you can just talk
without feeling any threat towards your
job to just say look I know you hired me
and you feel I’m best candidate and
other certain things I want to do better
there’s a growth mindset the other says
you know I want to learn I want to be
able to keep learning as a professional
teacher okay so feedback is important we
know I mean there’s tons of studies that
show definitively that students that’s
one of the highest priorities is when
they receive feedback from from teachers
so why not do it for teachers as well
why not have the same mindset why not
have the same lifelong learning right so
here’s a cool graph and chart this has
nothing to do with my talk and I’ll tell
you why because I could show you all the
research about that and then I’ll spend
20 minutes showing you what each color
is and each graph and how the tall ones
are better than short want and the round
circles instead of a triangle so I’m not
going to do that I’m just going to
suffice to say the way that we provide
feedback for our teachers for our own
colleagues is paramount to their success
in the classroom so here’s what I’m
proposing why don’t we think about the
two possible ways to run the process
right there’s the morp unit I don’t know
if you can figure it out from the
pictures it might not be very obvious
here but we can do the more punitive
sort of like and the check the boxes and
let’s make sure that you know they pass
everything and your probationary right
yeah I’m probationary okay or maybe we
could just decide to lift them up from
day one the moment they arrive here
thank you for being here at Cerritos or
USC or any of it because I can’t stress
that enough this happens everywhere
right what
if we took our teachers and said
congratulations now let us help you be
part of this family this family there’s
a lifelong learners all of us here are
lifelong learners and we’re willing to
be better so that’s one object to go
towards the other one is of course the
forms now now don’t get the wrong idea
it just might be the forms might have a
better purpose but i’m thinking i don’t
know if you notice that back on those
forms there that here’s one example so
the forms have you know if you’re going
to get let’s say graded evaluate it
there’s the box that says unsatisfactory
no bueno then there’s the needs
improvement okay lifelong learning their
needs improvement and then if your top
top top satisfactory so we can talk all
day about the excellence that we want to
have on this campus or any campus and
talk about excellence in our standards
but when it comes to actually document
it what we say is that lesson was so
that was I want to say amazing but I
can’t i have to say satisfactory on the
form okay I can’t believe the level of
communication you have with their
students that was it made me cry that
was so satisfactory you know why not be
brave enough to say we’re going to
recognize excellence and we’re also
going to recognize that we’re all
learning as teachers and so it’s okay to
say that you need some more but it was
satisfactory but that you can strive
towards excellence what’s wrong with
that I don’t think there’s anything
wrong with that and I think we could do
it but why would we go through all the
trouble and some of you say well this
doesn’t sound like trouble okay let me
explain a little bit here so if we
decided to do that change the forms and
change the process you’re going to get
all the faculty involved that’s really
important you’re going to get our
faculty senate involved you’re going to
get our union involved you’re going to
get the managers involved the board had
they all have to be involved they’re
going to talk a lot and talking takes a
long time and there’s nothing wrong with
that but it’s going to take a lot of
grinding to get through that I don’t
mean a lot like a couple hours or two
weeks we’re talking years to get to this
so why would we do that the answer I
think it’s really simple
teaching matters okay there are studies
that show out there and we all know this
as teachers we’ve seen it that show that
students believe that teachers are the
number one reason why they succeed
academically what the teachers do with
them in the classroom so why wouldn’t we
help our teachers why would we leave him
in the dark and just come in once in a
while and see let’s see if we need to
fire you yet why would we do that right
and so I want to show you it may be a
different way how that impact would work
so if you can imagine you probably see
those gold nuggets up there and imagine
that one of those nuggets just one is
the impact right that this process and
these new forms let’s say would have on
a teacher the impact that would have on
a teacher okay everybody can see this
right it’s right in my hands nice and
easy now if you imagine this blue water
here is sort of the visibility of that
impact we can see it right there right
so we take that one little nugget from
that bit of impact and we throw it in
and what happens can anybody see it
nobody sees it did it happen it happened
it’s there and it’s rock hard it’s not
going anywhere it happened but we don’t
see it here’s the thing the teacher is
just one teacher right now but the
teacher has students is going to impact
the students this process could impact
the students so they’ve got students now
can you see it mmm a little bit more
right it’s a little bit clearer but
here’s the thing i’m not talking about
one teacher i’m talking about the entire
campus actually I’m talking about the
entire world but the entire campus that
means all the teachers who are willing
how can you see the impact the impact is
and so i’ll close by saying this i don’t
think it’s just an idea worth sharing i
think it’s an idea worth pursuing thank you love to I Love You Man