Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why do we set out? / Miért indulunk el? | Nick Thorpe | TEDxBudapest


I’d like to tell you a story several
stories in fact just imagine it’s five
o’clock in the morning you’re at
Budapest Airport Terminal B your
bleary-eyed very tired you’ve hardly
slept but in your hand you have a piece
of a4 printed paper no priority no
reserved seat no insurance no hold
luggage no accommodation you ticked so
many knows when you were buying the
ticket you almost expected there to be a
box there saying no passenger anyway it
was cheap and it’s one-way you’re on
your way to London and you don’t know if
you’re coming back just a month ago you
thought you were a successful journalist
45 years old working for a Hungarian
weekly magazine then you woke up one
morning to find the magazine have been
sold to a new owner with different
political views to your own so you
resigned before you could be fired and
now you’re on your way to London a
friend has found you a job working as a
night watchman in a three-star Hotel
it’ll be dull watching closed-circuit
television all night but um we paid 8
pounds an hour and you won’t need
accommodation because there’s a sofa in
the back room so you’re on your way
towards security when your phone pings
in your pocket huh a text message from
your daughter just three words in
English send money soon
and is smiley or imagine you’re 29 years
old you’re in the bus station in dough
hook in northern Iraq there’s a smell of
cigarettes and diesel and your bus is
two hours late
all your family is there your cousin who
you’ll be traveling with and your mother
and your father
your father’s fallen into a stony
silence your mother tries every five
minutes to persuade you not to leave the
fact that bus is so late is not helping
then around midnight finally the
headlights of the bus swing round the
corner everyone starts crying you two a
few minutes later you’re on the bus
heading towards Turkey leaving a hole
behind you in the dark Iraqi night was
it a rational decision to leave you’ve
been fighting for the Peshmerga the
Kurdish militia against – the barbarians
of the Islamic state but you haven’t
been paid for three months you don’t
especially get on with your commander
and anyway you know that as soon as
you’ve defeated Islamic state the
Americans will abandon the Kurdish
people the government in Baghdad will
abandon or will not tolerate a separate
Kurdish state nor will the government in
Turkey but you’re young and you want a
life of your own you’ve got friends in
Europe so you’re on their way you’re on
your way to join them and nothing not
or imagine you’re 15 years old
an Afghan boy but born in Iran where
your family took refuge from the war in
Afghanistan to be lasting going on so
long you’ve already left school you’re
working in a factory for $200 a month
your parents are ashamed they took you
out of school to send you to work but
the family needed the money it’s not
easy to be an Afghan refugee in Iran
that morning in the factory a military
commander arrives you’re all the workers
are called into the canteen and the
commander says the following I’m looking
for volunteers he says to come to fight
with Iranian units alongside President
Bashar Assad in Syria this will be your
chance to give something back to Iran
the country that’s given you refuge and
to fight for your Shia faith and you’ll
before you can stop him the boy next to
you your friend blurts out and what if
we don’t want to go the smile on the
commander’s face turns to ice then you
and your whole faithless family can go
back to the ruins of your own country he
says so a month later you’re on the
frontline after only 10 days military
training you’re filthy you’re exhausted
and you’re hallucinating you’re not sure
if those are planes overhead or Birds
because the morphine your unit doctor
gave you that morning
to give you and your comrades the
courage to fight is wearing off a month
later two months later good news you
ought to be allowed home to Iran for a
religious holiday but back at home you
can’t begin to tell your parents your
family what you’ve done or what you’ve
seen and then just before dawn on the
morning you’re supposed to rejoin your
unit you climb quietly over the wall of
your compound there’s another lad from
your unit there and together you quietly
slip out through the suburbs it’s only
two weeks traveling at night to reach
the Iranian Turkish border if you can
get across that without being shot you
might have a chance where are you going
to Europe why are you going because you
want to play football again you want to
play computer games you want to listen
to music and you don’t want to kill
anyone
next months you will be 16 or you’re 29
you’re a Hazara woman also from
Afghanistan living in Iran you’ve got
two small children the little boy age 4
girl aged 13 it’s the summer of 2015 he
wake up one morning to find a note from
your husband he has another woman now he
says and they’ve gone to Europe together
he sends kisses to the children not to
you you cry for three days you cry for
30 days you comfort the children
sometimes their children comfort you
sometimes they blame you for what’s
happened your parents in law certainly
blame you they say you should move in
with them you don’t really have much
choice but they blame you for the loss
of their son who they feel has betrayed
them by going off to Europe with his new
flame after a few months living with
your in-laws you realize they’re not
interested in you at all they there’s no
new affection towards you they just want
your children they wish you’d disappear
so you decide to do just that so you
borrow some money from an uncle you sell
everything you have even your wedding
ring and then you steal your own
children back from their grandparents
and you set out you three to Europe and
finally you’re Hungarian 18 years old in
your first term as a law student at LTO
Budapest humanities University and
October the 23rd 1956 was a Tuesday you
had classes but there’s such an
excitement such a turmoil in the
university
and in the whole city that you decide to
skip classes and join the demonstration
along the banks of the Danube the
atmosphere is amazing people are
chanting and singing kids are cycling
along beside the crowd some people are
coming out of their doorways to join you
people are waving from the balconies
when you get to BEM square you even
catch a glimpse of the lecturer whose
classes you are missing he’s also there
in through the crowd that evening you
join the crowd outside the radio
building in the radio street trying to
get a petition read out on the radio and
when a short runs it brings out and then
another crowd panics flees through the
streets and the little later a lorry
pulls up outside the National Museum
they’re handing out guns and before you
know what you’re doing you’ve taken one
that evening you and some other lads
take over there any printing works in
Hanabi Dulce on Veit Street and for the
next 10 days you fight on the barricades
against the Hungarian secret police
against the Russians then finally you
wake up one morning the whole building
seems to be shaking and you open the
shutters to look out into the street and
you see a column of Russian tanks
rolling in the revolution is over it’s
time to go back to being a law student
so you wrap your gun in an old coat you
bury it under a tree just off Bocchetti
Street and you go home to your mother
but that evening ashen-faced
in the kitchen she sits you down and she
says you have to leave now
tonight the neighbors saw you with that
gun you’re sure to be reported you’ll be
arrested possibly possibly killed
stunned you pack a small bag you kiss
your mother goodbye and a few streets
and you leave the house a few streets
down the road you pick up a pebble and
you throw it up it
avis window she’s only 16 but she’s been
fighting with you on the barricades for
the past week a sleepy face appears at
the window are you crazy what you want
I’m going to Austria you coming for the
third time that day your hearts in your
mouth then she grins I’ll be down in a
minute with true stories like these and
a hundred others I could tell you if we
had time I would suggest that most
people who set out do so with rational
purposes it’s first and foremost a
rational decision to leave home most
refugees most migrants feel they don’t
have much choice they’re driven by fear
or impatience or hopes and dreams
there’s a voice inside them which says
it might be their own voice it might be
a some deep ancestral voice which says
to them their best your best chance of
survival is to leave home before the
walls fall in on top of you the dust is
it’s become fashionable in
anti-immigration anti-refugee circles in
eastern and western Europe to talk about
the so called Pula factor o mutti Merkel
invited them of course they came oh they
believe the little high-definition
pictures on their handheld devices and
they think the streets of Europe are
paved with gold oh now they’re coming
and they’re gonna steal the loaves of
bread off our tables or the crumbs from
underneath them worse still they might
impose their own ugly flat breads on us
but in the last four years traipsing up
and down the olkin route from Turkey to
Germany I’ve never met anyone who
many didn’t even know what country they
were going to it’s true they wanted a
safer life free from war or persecution
it’s true many wanted a fair day’s wage
for a fair day’s work it’s true they
imagined Europe as a continent where
they’d be free to think and speak to
practice their faith or not practice it
to marry who they liked or not get
married without the heavy hand of the
state or of anyone else resting on their
shoulders but I would argue that the
push factor the rational instinctive
carefully planned or unplanned decision
to leave was always much bigger than the
pull of factor the magnet pulling them
to Europe in conclusion I think it’s
also in our rational self-interest to
allow to welcome refugees and migrants
to Europe and let’s hope many of them
stay because they bring with them the
determination the energy the skills or
the willingness to learn new skills
which our aging continent needs our
aging societies need
and let’s hope many of them stay because
as the former Czechoslovakia mas Masaryk
once said about his own people without
them we are like frogs croaking at one
another across a pond and what this
country needs is a seacoast not a strip
of the Adriatic from which to launch our
gunships
but a strip of seacoast in our own minds
on which to meet people from across the
seas but let’s also hope many of them go
back because it’s in their rational
self-interest to rebuild their own
countries how will Syria Iraq Eritrea
Afghanistan ever be built with the loss
of so many people and let’s hope many of
them go back because we all like our
societies more or less as they are
though I think we should not
underestimate the resilience of our own
cultures they’re not such fragile things
as some people fear I don’t believe in a
melting pot where cultures or peoples
disappear I don’t believe in a clash of
civilizations civilizations have always
cross fertilized met learned things from
one another while staying more or less
the same the West Balkan route in a
sense is an extension of the old Silk
Road but let’s hope many of them find
their way home but if they don’t find a
way home let’s hope they make their
homes here because we all need homes
there’s no cure no medicinal cure for
homesickness but there’s also something
called love I wanted to go home to my
own parents to my own hills and fields
to my own trees and cliffs but I fell in
love here and what I thought was a
transit country which turned into my
host country and so I stayed and my
children who were born here feel at home
here and they feel at home abroad as
well
they even feel at home on the road just
before I came here this evening I was
checking where my oldest son is this
evening he’s 1200 kilometres off the
coast of South Africa and the small
sorry South America a small sailing boat
just passing the Galapagos Islands on
his way to Australia I guess he feels at
home in that small boat as well
migration as the British author John
Berger wrote has become the chief means
of survival of our time migration from
the village to the city migration from
country to country it’s not a good thing
and it’s not a bad thing it’s simply a
fact thank you very much [Applause]
Please follow and like us: