
they’re both classics but they’re also
both their own stories welcome to
watchmojo.com and today we’re counting
down our picks for the top ten
differences between the shining book and
movie before we begin we publish new
content every day so be sure to
subscribe to our Channel and ring the
bell to get notified about our latest
videos for this list we’re looking at
what changes between Stephen King’s
novel and Stanley Kubrick’s film
adaptation also beware of spoilers
number 10 book Jack’s weapon of choice
rock mallet the final 20 minutes or so
of Stanley Kubrick’s film are terrifying
with audiences watching from the edge of
their seats as the psychotic father
chases and attempts to kill his own son
with an axe and while this stays
relatively true to the source material
there is one major difference book jack
actually uses a rock mallet instead of
an axe in the novel Jack finds a rock
mallet and uses it first to break
Wendy’s leg and back then to attack dick
Halloran and finally to bash his own
face in in the movie Jack uses an axe to
kill Halloran with a swing to the heart
a fact that will come back later on this
list number 9
no hedge maze in the book but there are
hedge animals and they move the scene of
Jack chasing Danny in the hedge maze is
one of the most iconic scenes in horror
cinema and it was entirely the creation
of Stanley Kubrick there is no hedge
maze in the novel but there are hedge
animals the topiary serve as guardians
of the Overlook protecting both the
exits and the entrances of the hotel and
they seemingly come to life to hunt both
Jack and Danny at different times
perhaps knowing that it would be too
expensive or that it would look too
silly Kubrick decided to trim the
topiary animals from his film no pun
intended and replaced them with an
ominous maze number 8
sexy bathtub lady lives in room 217 in
the book one of the most famous scenes
of the movie sees jack entering room 237
and being greeted by a gorgeous nude
woman upon seeing her reflection he
realizes that the woman is actually
grotesque
bloated and decomposing and he’s chased
out of the room while bathtub lady is in
the novel the room was changed from 217
to 237 as management of the real-life
Timberline Lodge didn’t want patrons to
be afraid of staying in the actual room
217
oddly enough conspiracy theorists ran
wild with this change because it’s
roughly two hundred and thirty seven
thousand miles to the moon the room
number change was basically a
confirmation for them that Stanley
Kubrick helped fake the moon landing
number seven many of the movie’s most
iconic lines and scenes are not in the
book Stanley Kubrick’s The Shining is a
bonafide horror classic and it’s filled
with many iconic lines and scenes and
like the hedge maze the creepy hallway
girls the blood elevator Jack’s here’s
Johnny moment and the pages upon pages
of all work and no play are mostly the
creations of Stanley Kubrick sure there
are variations on some of these scenes
in the novel like the entity in the
playground asking Danny to play with him
but for the most part these celebrated
and visually striking scenes cannot be
found in Kings book how do you like it
number six
Danny’s invisible friend Tony is more
involved in the book can you remember
what you were doing just before you
start a fresh community like many
atmospheric elements in Stanley
Kubrick’s work the character of Tony
remains rather enigmatic we know Danny
has an imaginary friend named Tony who
talks through his finger but that’s
about all we ever learn
No
however Tony has given much greater
importance and depth in the novel in
Kings version tony appears as a physical
being to Danny and towards the climax of
the story we learned that Tony is Danny
from the future using the shining to try
and psychically warn his younger self
about going to the Overlook and then
trying to save himself
Kubrick did away with this explanation
preferring to keep the figure of Tony a
creepy mystery number five movie Wendy
is a wuss he seems absolutely fine
it’s a well-known fact that Stephen King
is not the biggest fan of Kubrick’s
adaptation and the movie version of
Wendy Torrance is a major contributing
factor to his opinion in King’s novel
Wendy is a strong force and protective
mother who does anything she can to
protect her son from the hotel and her
increasingly psychotic husband in the
film she’s far more submissive defending
Jack’s abuses when speaking to others
and showing passivity towards his
aggression and belligerence don’t be so
grouchy she also cries a lot King took
offense to this portrayal of his strong
character calling her quote the most
misogynistic character ever put on film
and you’re concerned about me number
four the Overlook in the book is more
alive its gritty haven’t I seen you
somewhere before
while both King and Kubrick depicted the
Overlook Hotel as its own character they
treated that character in completely
different ways and chances are the one
you prefer depends on what you want from
the story King presents a traditional
ghost story as his hotel is not just
haunted but also alive topiary animals
come to life ghosts attack and fire
hoses come off walls to chase and hiss
at characters as the hotel actively
while the film presents many weird and
eerie occurrences many of them are
presented in an ambiguous manner King
wants to scare you with ghosts
Kubrick wants you to feel disoriented
what would be number three book Jack is
a more layered character as is often the
case the book version of Jack is more
complex than his Kubrick counterpart
both characters share pasts of abuse and
alcoholism and both fall prey to madness
however novel Jack is a caring father
and husband whereas movie jack is
borderline psychotic seemingly from the
start see it’s okay on the television
book Jack also has a harder time with
alcohol with his descent into madness
characterized by the same traits he’d
exhibited when he was drinking
ultimately Jack earns Redemption at the
climax of the novel by regaining control
of himself telling Danny he loves him
and allowing him to escape
be ready film Jack dies a monster and
it’s debatable what caused his downfall
the hotel or himself well you can rest
assured mr. omen that’s not gonna happen
with me number two
Halloran doesn’t die in the book and is
really important in the sequel it’s one
of the most unpredictable and iconic
scenes of the movie after Halloran
receives a signal from Danny
he moves heaven and earth to get to the
Overlook Hotel including renting a
snowcat and traversing miles of icy
roads and blizzard conditions and then
just as he enters the hotel he’s
immediately axed in the chest so much
for the heroic rescue as mentioned
before novel Halloran is brutally
attacked by Jack with a rock mallet but
he survives and escapes with Wendy and
Danny he later becomes a comforting
father figure for Danny and even appears
in the novel sequel dr. sleep which kind
of feels like Stephen King saying a big
something like number one book jack dies
when the Overlook explodes while we
wouldn’t call the novel’s ending happy
it’s certainly more uplifting than the
film’s total downer in the novel Jack
regains consciousness and tells Danny he
loves him before running to the basement
to relieve the pressure in the boiler
however he arrives too late
dies in the resulting explosion and the
hotel burns down in the film there’s no
redemption for Jack
he simply freezes to death while
attempting to kill Danny and the
Overlook remains standing waiting for
the next jack to enter its malicious
grasp while Kings ending is perhaps more
satisfying and complete Kubrick’s is far
scarier and more in keeping with the
film’s grim and ominous tone do you
agree with our picks check out these
other great clips from WatchMojo and
subscribe for new videos every day
[Music] you
both their own stories welcome to
watchmojo.com and today we’re counting
down our picks for the top ten
differences between the shining book and
movie before we begin we publish new
content every day so be sure to
subscribe to our Channel and ring the
bell to get notified about our latest
videos for this list we’re looking at
what changes between Stephen King’s
novel and Stanley Kubrick’s film
adaptation also beware of spoilers
number 10 book Jack’s weapon of choice
rock mallet the final 20 minutes or so
of Stanley Kubrick’s film are terrifying
with audiences watching from the edge of
their seats as the psychotic father
chases and attempts to kill his own son
with an axe and while this stays
relatively true to the source material
there is one major difference book jack
actually uses a rock mallet instead of
an axe in the novel Jack finds a rock
mallet and uses it first to break
Wendy’s leg and back then to attack dick
Halloran and finally to bash his own
face in in the movie Jack uses an axe to
kill Halloran with a swing to the heart
a fact that will come back later on this
list number 9
no hedge maze in the book but there are
hedge animals and they move the scene of
Jack chasing Danny in the hedge maze is
one of the most iconic scenes in horror
cinema and it was entirely the creation
of Stanley Kubrick there is no hedge
maze in the novel but there are hedge
animals the topiary serve as guardians
of the Overlook protecting both the
exits and the entrances of the hotel and
they seemingly come to life to hunt both
Jack and Danny at different times
perhaps knowing that it would be too
expensive or that it would look too
silly Kubrick decided to trim the
topiary animals from his film no pun
intended and replaced them with an
ominous maze number 8
sexy bathtub lady lives in room 217 in
the book one of the most famous scenes
of the movie sees jack entering room 237
and being greeted by a gorgeous nude
woman upon seeing her reflection he
realizes that the woman is actually
grotesque
bloated and decomposing and he’s chased
out of the room while bathtub lady is in
the novel the room was changed from 217
to 237 as management of the real-life
Timberline Lodge didn’t want patrons to
be afraid of staying in the actual room
217
oddly enough conspiracy theorists ran
wild with this change because it’s
roughly two hundred and thirty seven
thousand miles to the moon the room
number change was basically a
confirmation for them that Stanley
Kubrick helped fake the moon landing
number seven many of the movie’s most
iconic lines and scenes are not in the
book Stanley Kubrick’s The Shining is a
bonafide horror classic and it’s filled
with many iconic lines and scenes and
like the hedge maze the creepy hallway
girls the blood elevator Jack’s here’s
Johnny moment and the pages upon pages
of all work and no play are mostly the
creations of Stanley Kubrick sure there
are variations on some of these scenes
in the novel like the entity in the
playground asking Danny to play with him
but for the most part these celebrated
and visually striking scenes cannot be
found in Kings book how do you like it
number six
Danny’s invisible friend Tony is more
involved in the book can you remember
what you were doing just before you
start a fresh community like many
atmospheric elements in Stanley
Kubrick’s work the character of Tony
remains rather enigmatic we know Danny
has an imaginary friend named Tony who
talks through his finger but that’s
about all we ever learn
No
however Tony has given much greater
importance and depth in the novel in
Kings version tony appears as a physical
being to Danny and towards the climax of
the story we learned that Tony is Danny
from the future using the shining to try
and psychically warn his younger self
about going to the Overlook and then
trying to save himself
Kubrick did away with this explanation
preferring to keep the figure of Tony a
creepy mystery number five movie Wendy
is a wuss he seems absolutely fine
it’s a well-known fact that Stephen King
is not the biggest fan of Kubrick’s
adaptation and the movie version of
Wendy Torrance is a major contributing
factor to his opinion in King’s novel
Wendy is a strong force and protective
mother who does anything she can to
protect her son from the hotel and her
increasingly psychotic husband in the
film she’s far more submissive defending
Jack’s abuses when speaking to others
and showing passivity towards his
aggression and belligerence don’t be so
grouchy she also cries a lot King took
offense to this portrayal of his strong
character calling her quote the most
misogynistic character ever put on film
and you’re concerned about me number
four the Overlook in the book is more
alive its gritty haven’t I seen you
somewhere before
while both King and Kubrick depicted the
Overlook Hotel as its own character they
treated that character in completely
different ways and chances are the one
you prefer depends on what you want from
the story King presents a traditional
ghost story as his hotel is not just
haunted but also alive topiary animals
come to life ghosts attack and fire
hoses come off walls to chase and hiss
at characters as the hotel actively
while the film presents many weird and
eerie occurrences many of them are
presented in an ambiguous manner King
wants to scare you with ghosts
Kubrick wants you to feel disoriented
what would be number three book Jack is
a more layered character as is often the
case the book version of Jack is more
complex than his Kubrick counterpart
both characters share pasts of abuse and
alcoholism and both fall prey to madness
however novel Jack is a caring father
and husband whereas movie jack is
borderline psychotic seemingly from the
start see it’s okay on the television
book Jack also has a harder time with
alcohol with his descent into madness
characterized by the same traits he’d
exhibited when he was drinking
ultimately Jack earns Redemption at the
climax of the novel by regaining control
of himself telling Danny he loves him
and allowing him to escape
be ready film Jack dies a monster and
it’s debatable what caused his downfall
the hotel or himself well you can rest
assured mr. omen that’s not gonna happen
with me number two
Halloran doesn’t die in the book and is
really important in the sequel it’s one
of the most unpredictable and iconic
scenes of the movie after Halloran
receives a signal from Danny
he moves heaven and earth to get to the
Overlook Hotel including renting a
snowcat and traversing miles of icy
roads and blizzard conditions and then
just as he enters the hotel he’s
immediately axed in the chest so much
for the heroic rescue as mentioned
before novel Halloran is brutally
attacked by Jack with a rock mallet but
he survives and escapes with Wendy and
Danny he later becomes a comforting
father figure for Danny and even appears
in the novel sequel dr. sleep which kind
of feels like Stephen King saying a big
something like number one book jack dies
when the Overlook explodes while we
wouldn’t call the novel’s ending happy
it’s certainly more uplifting than the
film’s total downer in the novel Jack
regains consciousness and tells Danny he
loves him before running to the basement
to relieve the pressure in the boiler
however he arrives too late
dies in the resulting explosion and the
hotel burns down in the film there’s no
redemption for Jack
he simply freezes to death while
attempting to kill Danny and the
Overlook remains standing waiting for
the next jack to enter its malicious
grasp while Kings ending is perhaps more
satisfying and complete Kubrick’s is far
scarier and more in keeping with the
film’s grim and ominous tone do you
agree with our picks check out these
other great clips from WatchMojo and
subscribe for new videos every day
[Music] you
Please follow and like us: