
[Music]
the day in way bleeds uncle Hanoi
returns a chat encounter they meet in
hung Bay the quick little boy is pretty
little satchel his quick little feet
his little head tilting his little
sailor hat slanted his mouth whistling a
little hummingbird hopping along the
yellow road delivering messages was such
fun in Fort monka better than being home
laughing eyes cheek so pink
until later comrade slowly he fades into
the distance I go my way you go yours as
June arrives news comes to home as it
turned out to be Oh Lula on a fateful
day like any other day
the little comrade put the letter in his
satchel swooshing past the Battlefront
whoosh whoosh the bullet defy a letter
reading urgent fearless Lee he goes the
country roads lonely rice fields of
Bunton his little sailor hat just
peeking above it all a flash of red Oh
God
oh look the little comrade a stream of
blood as he lies on the field hand
grasping a wheat stalk smelling of sweet
milk his soul ascends from the field
Oh Lula are you still there the quick
little boy is pretty little satchel his
quick little feet his little head
tilting his little sailor hat slanted
its mouth whistling like a yellow
hummingbird hopping along the yellow
road
this was the first poem I translated
over four years ago and to this day it
remains the only translated version of
it available the theme of this TEDx is
globalization and how we are moving into
a more interconnected society than ever
this is undoubtedly true and we becoming
more connected through we’re out of ways
such as economics and politics and music
yet we aren’t as thoroughly connected
with our literature the University of
Rochester has created a database of
translated texts in 2008 and since then
they have recorded 5,000 translated
texts this sounds like a lot until I
tell you that 1 million texts were
published in the US alone from 2011 to
2013 not to mention the top two
languages within translated texts are
English and French which goes to show
you how truly limited the volume of
literature from less mainstream cultures
is being translated translation is
underappreciated and underrated yet it
is crucial to us as a society to
understanding each other
I myself was quite reluctant said to
this world when I translated in my first
poem over four years ago it was for an
English class and the teacher who had
confidence in my success so that I could
take this instead of the assessment she
gave everyone else naturally as a
14-year old I chose what I thought to be
the easy path but turns out I was wrong
it was hard it was technical it was
stressful every time I came back to my
teacher with a revision she point out
something so technical and my nude yeah
it’s also important to the meaning of
the text that I was simply frustrated
frustrated with something I didn’t
understand and something I didn’t see
the point of but by some miracle I
finished it I thought it was pretty good
but then again I was quite a confident
14 year old maybe a bit too confident
but it turns out my teacher thought it
was good too so she sent it to lady born
an American poet and author most famous
for involvement in Vietnam since the war
at one point there was even talk about
publication in a literary magazine which
I thought was pretty cool it didn’t pan
out but you know but then I went back to
my video games and music and I was done
the fourteen-year-old version of a
one-hit wonder right but then as life
would have it you know I wasn’t done yet
even if I did try to distance myself
from any further product work and bask
in the glory of feedback from a famous
poet
so when grade 9 came around and I had to
do a poetry assignment for this class it
wasn’t so hard this time and it was
engaging and interesting for those of
you are interested I translated a
version I’m sorry I adapted a version of
Romeo and Juliet into sonnet and you
don’t worry and you really don’t want to
know the detail of that but when grade
10 came around and I had to do my
personal project which is sort of like a
high school thesis except a thousand
times easier I was drawn to poetry after
two months I decided that I wouldn’t use
my project to represent Vietnamese
poetry through the ages and here’s the
cover of it ultimately I divided up
Vietnamese poetry into five main
movements and chose the poems I felt
were best representative of these
movements and translated them it’s a
sort of primer on Vietnamese poetry and
to that extent its culture as well now
I’ve been in international school since
I was five and since then I’ve spent the
majority of my days being in English so
for what someone like me it’s really
easy to feel disconnected with your own
culture and so for me this project took
on a life of its own and became a
personal journey into rediscovering or
discovering or having a better
understanding of my culture is through
my interactions with literature I was
able to broaden my notion of what
constitutes beninese culture and more
than that I was able to understand how
my identity fits into all of this and
for me that’s really where the value of
translation lives take a look at this
poem a red silken scarf I float
aimlessly with the wind whose possession
while will I become it from what I
classify as the folklore age of poetry
before written language was discovered
and this form of poetry the ten name or
my body form was incredibly popular in
which it is literally an expression of
the woman’s frustration at the
patriarchy that confines her but more
than that it’s also about this complex
resistance and everyday negotiation of
woman within the constraints that they
faced
now remember when I first read this poem
I was thinking what some of you may be
thinking right now which is that wow it
reads like a contemporary feminist poem
it’s so progressive but then I thought
to myself why why do I think this why do
I assume that those who live before me
to be less progressive than I am and so
through this process I was able to see
the different ways in which women lived
with and within the patriarchy of the
time and how they were able to resist
against this and the value in
translating is from me is for me to be
able to see these complex nuances and
translate them for others to see as well
so that they don’t just assume that
Vietnamese culture is backwards that
they don’t just assume that women lived
with an oppression as objects and for me
I’m able to turn these simple readings
and assumptions about Vietnamese life
and Vietnamese culture and there’s
something more complex and pluralized
and that’s what I mean when I say that
translation that allows you to read any
piece of text in the world but it also
allows you to read what’s all around it
because it offers you a glimpse into the
window of the context now one of the
main ways in which you appreciate a work
of literature is through understand the
authors choices and intentions as
Gregory rabhasa once said when you’re
translating
you’re playing Shakespeare but your
Hamlet as well when translating I was
able to get a sense of the culture and
the values that come along with it and I
was able to share this with my friends
my teachers my community take them for
example it is one of my favorite poems
because of how I feel it captures an
important aspect of Vietnamese culture
and history it really is I think about
the unflinching hand of war and how none
are immune to its touch but it isn’t
only depict the image that everyone
thinks of when they think of war with
bullets and soldiers all around but
rather it depicts an image of Lou I’m
only a small child caught in the
crosshairs of war and this idea of a
lost generation a general
of children who are brave and patriotic
like Liam but who are unnecessarily so
and I think once you understand that
enemy’s culture begins to make more
sense to you because you know our strong
resilience our strong national pride
that all links back to our past and how
we overcame centuries of oppression and
colonialism to become independent and
for me that’s why translation
illuminates the past not only for those
who translate it but for those who read
it as well by reading works of
translation you can get as much
knowledge as I can for translating it
and the only difference would be our
interaction with the text and through
this process I was also introduced to
term where what many of you may be
familiar with which is lost in
translation but to me that’s the biggest
misnomer of all because it’s true that
there is no perfect translation and you
know many people have different theories
and approaches to translation and
everyone is different you know some may
focus on the language and structure
whereas others may choose to focus on
the meaning and intention of the poem
neither are perfect and neither are
wrong with one you may lose the meaning
and retain the structure and with the
other you might get the opposite effect
take a look at this folklore Palma
translated for example pay attention to
the bolded lines or the highlighted
lines working in the fields I left a
shirt behind
if you have it I asked for its return
this is a folklore poem depicting the
story of a man who’s trying to court a
woman and it’s also about this rural
life now I want you to take a look at
this other translated poem this is the
same poem that’s being translated but
this is an alternate version and again
pay attention to these bolded lines for
me these two poems tell two different
stories and let me show you by having
them side by side for me the first poem
is about well suffering the first poem
it paints the guy has more direct and
blunt character simply saying what he
wants you know if you have my shirt may
have it back whereas in the second poem
it paints him as someone more diplomatic
and more charismatic and for me is
what’s really important to a trans
later and more than that and do this
process I was able to learn about the
rural life of Vietnam back then you know
the fields the Lotus the dowries it’s a
reflection of the society back then but
it’s also a reflection of that
patriarchy I was talking about now when
I first translated this poem I thought
that uploading literally meant slapping
water by the temple and for those of you
who don’t know that’s as literal
translation as you can get right but
then I learned it’s a term for
irrigation but who wants to say
irrigation by the temple so then I was
faced with this choice yeah do I keep
its literal meaning or do I try to
change it to something that perhaps will
keep the feel and soul of the poem but
will lose the structure and again this
is the dilemma that translator is often
faced and let me show you through
another poem do you recognize this it’s
an early rendition of ten name but here
it’s different my body is like a red
silk cloth dangling without direction in
the market who knows whose hands will
end up in here the pronouns are gone as
a different and not to the poem in how
you look at the aspect of the woman’s
life and perhaps it is more overt which
is indicative of this type of poetry but
in my opinion it also sounds a lot more
awkward here look at this poem and the
original side-by-side I believe in the
preferred version it is a much better
job of you know of once again tackling
this aspect of the woman’s fate in
Vietnam and here whose possession will I
become then serves as the line
condemning this view of women as
property or as an object and once again
it goes back to like tackling this
patriarchy so it’s inevitable in
translation that you will get different
interpretations that’s always going to
be a problem with translation and
equivalence but one cannot say that’s
what’s wrong with translation because
with the many different interpretations
you’re actually gaining perspectives and
through that that’s actually what’s what
still gained in translation and not what
not what’s lost
translation isn’t about being the best
writer the best poet or even the best
linguist rather it’s about finding
meaning for yourself but also finding
meaning for others as well in this
process I was able to reconnect with my
culture and a deeper way so if I can
leave you with one thought it is this
interact with translation whether it be
you translate works of translation
yourself or text an email whether it be
you read and share works of translation
there’s this whole world of knowledge
out there waiting for you and who knows
what you might gain in translation thank
you [Applause]
the day in way bleeds uncle Hanoi
returns a chat encounter they meet in
hung Bay the quick little boy is pretty
little satchel his quick little feet
his little head tilting his little
sailor hat slanted his mouth whistling a
little hummingbird hopping along the
yellow road delivering messages was such
fun in Fort monka better than being home
laughing eyes cheek so pink
until later comrade slowly he fades into
the distance I go my way you go yours as
June arrives news comes to home as it
turned out to be Oh Lula on a fateful
day like any other day
the little comrade put the letter in his
satchel swooshing past the Battlefront
whoosh whoosh the bullet defy a letter
reading urgent fearless Lee he goes the
country roads lonely rice fields of
Bunton his little sailor hat just
peeking above it all a flash of red Oh
God
oh look the little comrade a stream of
blood as he lies on the field hand
grasping a wheat stalk smelling of sweet
milk his soul ascends from the field
Oh Lula are you still there the quick
little boy is pretty little satchel his
quick little feet his little head
tilting his little sailor hat slanted
its mouth whistling like a yellow
hummingbird hopping along the yellow
road
this was the first poem I translated
over four years ago and to this day it
remains the only translated version of
it available the theme of this TEDx is
globalization and how we are moving into
a more interconnected society than ever
this is undoubtedly true and we becoming
more connected through we’re out of ways
such as economics and politics and music
yet we aren’t as thoroughly connected
with our literature the University of
Rochester has created a database of
translated texts in 2008 and since then
they have recorded 5,000 translated
texts this sounds like a lot until I
tell you that 1 million texts were
published in the US alone from 2011 to
2013 not to mention the top two
languages within translated texts are
English and French which goes to show
you how truly limited the volume of
literature from less mainstream cultures
is being translated translation is
underappreciated and underrated yet it
is crucial to us as a society to
understanding each other
I myself was quite reluctant said to
this world when I translated in my first
poem over four years ago it was for an
English class and the teacher who had
confidence in my success so that I could
take this instead of the assessment she
gave everyone else naturally as a
14-year old I chose what I thought to be
the easy path but turns out I was wrong
it was hard it was technical it was
stressful every time I came back to my
teacher with a revision she point out
something so technical and my nude yeah
it’s also important to the meaning of
the text that I was simply frustrated
frustrated with something I didn’t
understand and something I didn’t see
the point of but by some miracle I
finished it I thought it was pretty good
but then again I was quite a confident
14 year old maybe a bit too confident
but it turns out my teacher thought it
was good too so she sent it to lady born
an American poet and author most famous
for involvement in Vietnam since the war
at one point there was even talk about
publication in a literary magazine which
I thought was pretty cool it didn’t pan
out but you know but then I went back to
my video games and music and I was done
the fourteen-year-old version of a
one-hit wonder right but then as life
would have it you know I wasn’t done yet
even if I did try to distance myself
from any further product work and bask
in the glory of feedback from a famous
poet
so when grade 9 came around and I had to
do a poetry assignment for this class it
wasn’t so hard this time and it was
engaging and interesting for those of
you are interested I translated a
version I’m sorry I adapted a version of
Romeo and Juliet into sonnet and you
don’t worry and you really don’t want to
know the detail of that but when grade
10 came around and I had to do my
personal project which is sort of like a
high school thesis except a thousand
times easier I was drawn to poetry after
two months I decided that I wouldn’t use
my project to represent Vietnamese
poetry through the ages and here’s the
cover of it ultimately I divided up
Vietnamese poetry into five main
movements and chose the poems I felt
were best representative of these
movements and translated them it’s a
sort of primer on Vietnamese poetry and
to that extent its culture as well now
I’ve been in international school since
I was five and since then I’ve spent the
majority of my days being in English so
for what someone like me it’s really
easy to feel disconnected with your own
culture and so for me this project took
on a life of its own and became a
personal journey into rediscovering or
discovering or having a better
understanding of my culture is through
my interactions with literature I was
able to broaden my notion of what
constitutes beninese culture and more
than that I was able to understand how
my identity fits into all of this and
for me that’s really where the value of
translation lives take a look at this
poem a red silken scarf I float
aimlessly with the wind whose possession
while will I become it from what I
classify as the folklore age of poetry
before written language was discovered
and this form of poetry the ten name or
my body form was incredibly popular in
which it is literally an expression of
the woman’s frustration at the
patriarchy that confines her but more
than that it’s also about this complex
resistance and everyday negotiation of
woman within the constraints that they
faced
now remember when I first read this poem
I was thinking what some of you may be
thinking right now which is that wow it
reads like a contemporary feminist poem
it’s so progressive but then I thought
to myself why why do I think this why do
I assume that those who live before me
to be less progressive than I am and so
through this process I was able to see
the different ways in which women lived
with and within the patriarchy of the
time and how they were able to resist
against this and the value in
translating is from me is for me to be
able to see these complex nuances and
translate them for others to see as well
so that they don’t just assume that
Vietnamese culture is backwards that
they don’t just assume that women lived
with an oppression as objects and for me
I’m able to turn these simple readings
and assumptions about Vietnamese life
and Vietnamese culture and there’s
something more complex and pluralized
and that’s what I mean when I say that
translation that allows you to read any
piece of text in the world but it also
allows you to read what’s all around it
because it offers you a glimpse into the
window of the context now one of the
main ways in which you appreciate a work
of literature is through understand the
authors choices and intentions as
Gregory rabhasa once said when you’re
translating
you’re playing Shakespeare but your
Hamlet as well when translating I was
able to get a sense of the culture and
the values that come along with it and I
was able to share this with my friends
my teachers my community take them for
example it is one of my favorite poems
because of how I feel it captures an
important aspect of Vietnamese culture
and history it really is I think about
the unflinching hand of war and how none
are immune to its touch but it isn’t
only depict the image that everyone
thinks of when they think of war with
bullets and soldiers all around but
rather it depicts an image of Lou I’m
only a small child caught in the
crosshairs of war and this idea of a
lost generation a general
of children who are brave and patriotic
like Liam but who are unnecessarily so
and I think once you understand that
enemy’s culture begins to make more
sense to you because you know our strong
resilience our strong national pride
that all links back to our past and how
we overcame centuries of oppression and
colonialism to become independent and
for me that’s why translation
illuminates the past not only for those
who translate it but for those who read
it as well by reading works of
translation you can get as much
knowledge as I can for translating it
and the only difference would be our
interaction with the text and through
this process I was also introduced to
term where what many of you may be
familiar with which is lost in
translation but to me that’s the biggest
misnomer of all because it’s true that
there is no perfect translation and you
know many people have different theories
and approaches to translation and
everyone is different you know some may
focus on the language and structure
whereas others may choose to focus on
the meaning and intention of the poem
neither are perfect and neither are
wrong with one you may lose the meaning
and retain the structure and with the
other you might get the opposite effect
take a look at this folklore Palma
translated for example pay attention to
the bolded lines or the highlighted
lines working in the fields I left a
shirt behind
if you have it I asked for its return
this is a folklore poem depicting the
story of a man who’s trying to court a
woman and it’s also about this rural
life now I want you to take a look at
this other translated poem this is the
same poem that’s being translated but
this is an alternate version and again
pay attention to these bolded lines for
me these two poems tell two different
stories and let me show you by having
them side by side for me the first poem
is about well suffering the first poem
it paints the guy has more direct and
blunt character simply saying what he
wants you know if you have my shirt may
have it back whereas in the second poem
it paints him as someone more diplomatic
and more charismatic and for me is
what’s really important to a trans
later and more than that and do this
process I was able to learn about the
rural life of Vietnam back then you know
the fields the Lotus the dowries it’s a
reflection of the society back then but
it’s also a reflection of that
patriarchy I was talking about now when
I first translated this poem I thought
that uploading literally meant slapping
water by the temple and for those of you
who don’t know that’s as literal
translation as you can get right but
then I learned it’s a term for
irrigation but who wants to say
irrigation by the temple so then I was
faced with this choice yeah do I keep
its literal meaning or do I try to
change it to something that perhaps will
keep the feel and soul of the poem but
will lose the structure and again this
is the dilemma that translator is often
faced and let me show you through
another poem do you recognize this it’s
an early rendition of ten name but here
it’s different my body is like a red
silk cloth dangling without direction in
the market who knows whose hands will
end up in here the pronouns are gone as
a different and not to the poem in how
you look at the aspect of the woman’s
life and perhaps it is more overt which
is indicative of this type of poetry but
in my opinion it also sounds a lot more
awkward here look at this poem and the
original side-by-side I believe in the
preferred version it is a much better
job of you know of once again tackling
this aspect of the woman’s fate in
Vietnam and here whose possession will I
become then serves as the line
condemning this view of women as
property or as an object and once again
it goes back to like tackling this
patriarchy so it’s inevitable in
translation that you will get different
interpretations that’s always going to
be a problem with translation and
equivalence but one cannot say that’s
what’s wrong with translation because
with the many different interpretations
you’re actually gaining perspectives and
through that that’s actually what’s what
still gained in translation and not what
not what’s lost
translation isn’t about being the best
writer the best poet or even the best
linguist rather it’s about finding
meaning for yourself but also finding
meaning for others as well in this
process I was able to reconnect with my
culture and a deeper way so if I can
leave you with one thought it is this
interact with translation whether it be
you translate works of translation
yourself or text an email whether it be
you read and share works of translation
there’s this whole world of knowledge
out there waiting for you and who knows
what you might gain in translation thank
you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: