Press "Enter" to skip to content

“What Makes a Humanitarian” | Erin Kilborn | TEDxUniversityofGlasgow


[Applause]

whatever you do will be insignificant

but it is very important that you do it

somebody wants famous called Mahatma

Gandhi use those words once and if you

want to take those words and apply them

directly to the humanitarian sector

nobody would ever do any work what would

be the motivation what would be your

drive to go and work in a challenging

environment leave behind your family

your friends be in a really difficult

situation I’d like to talk to you today

using some examples for my own

experiences about what I think defines a

humanitarian worker and what makes a

good humanitarian the dictionary says

that a humanitarian is somebody who

works for the betterment of the human

condition somebody who works for the

welfare of humanity

I think that definition is a good

definition but I think that it lacks

depth and so I’m gonna explore that a

bit I was a teenager when I first heard

an interview with a doctor and a nurse

from MSF Doctors Without Borders and it

was like a lightbulb moment I didn’t

really know what I wants to do with my

life and at that point in time I

listening to that interview and I’m

hearing these people who are using

skills and knowledge and they’re going

to exciting places in the world and

they’re treating people and they’re

going into places that you can’t go you

can’t go there as a tourist and they’re

coming across cultures and languages so

so fascinating I got so excited I

thought yes that is what I want to do I

want to be a doctor I want to have an

adventure I want to be a vegetarian I

didn’t really know what that meant yet

how many of you guys in the last day

week month have come across images of

suffering and injustice

maybe images of war everybody to a

person in this room is putting it

because we see it all the time it’s in

the media it’s all around us it’s on the

news and the newspapers it’s the

magazines it’s on our television on the

radio to see it on websites and we have

is momentary flitting moments of empathy

that go as quickly as they come as soon

as we click as soon as we turn the page

as soon as we change the channel but it

is very difficult to do that when you

are faced with it directly at 17 I went

out to Sri Lanka to work in an orphan

care center and I was really struck by

the number of young people in this

orphan centre who were really severely

disabled by medical conditions

conditions like polio clubfoot and

measles conditions that are largely

preventable or treatable if you have

access to vaccinations clean water good

quality medical and surgical services

and that inequality really really felt

unfair to me and at that point it really

cemented this idea that I really wanted

to do something about it so fast forward

seven years later and I finished medical

school my junior doctor rotations and

I’m going to Belgium to learn tropical

medicine and words like leishmaniasis

and malaria and colors are are floating

around in my head and I am getting so

excited because it’s so fascinating it’s

such an interesting area of medicine and

I really am so thrilled to start my real

career not just as a doctor but as a

humanitarian I want to go to the place

and I’ve been very lucky I’ve had a very

exceptional journey so far and not just

in humanitarian work but also an

expedition I’ve been to primary jungle

in Borneo I’ve been to post earthquake

Haiti I’ve been to the Peruvian Amazon

and to the war zones in Central African

Republic and even the battlegrounds of

the UK’s NHS system all these

environments have really taught me that

there are certain key aspects that will

make or break your experience not just

as a doctor or as a humanitarian but

just as a person who’s trying to make

impact a positive impact on their

environment and those are good

communication skills

flexibility and creativity the power of

your own resilience and understanding

your vulnerabilities and your weaknesses

my first mission was with MSF in 2013

and I went to Haiti and I was sent to

work in a burns unit and I was

absolutely terrified I have never seen a

burns patient before I didn’t really

speak that great French but luckily I

arrived and I had armed with the MSF

protocols and a team of national nurses

and doctors who were incredibly

experienced and skilled we managed to

collaborate together and do some really

great work and I learned a huge amount

from them but one of the things that I

really learned about there was certainly

communication and not just about

language but also about crossing

cultural barriers and understanding the

social and cultural context in which you

work

and if particularly as a doctor that can

be very very important especially when

you want to mitigate mistrust and

misunderstanding with your patients

burns and Haiti are complex injuries and

there’s a lot of reasons why people get

them but primarily if you think about it

it’s down to poverty domestic accidents

are very common and one such accident

resulted in two patients coming into the

hospital on Christmas Day after a gas

bottle exploded in their kitchen a

couple in their late thirties were

covered in more than 30% of their body

with burns their arms their legs their

chest their faces and they were across

from each other in their medical high

dependency unit and they used to say to

each other in the mornings 7:00 on a

movie Shelley Sarah how are you my

darling yes my love I’m fine and they

were adorable they had a very very

challenging route to recovery infections

operations the skin grafts nutrition is

very challenging you need to eat a lot

of calories and protein to get better

but they made it and two months later

they were able to be discharged home the

same day and I spent a lot of time

talking to them about the medical care

physiotherapy compressive bandaging

making sure they have a good diet but

something was missing from the

consultation they left and two weeks

later I got in a phone call from the

outpatient department and one of the

nurses said the couple had come back to

speak to me really urgently

and I took the call and I said what’s

the emergency and the husband spoke to

me and said no no doctor and we’re fine

but when they I make love to my wife

again so I’d really miss something very

important and that’s really essential

when you work not just as a doctor but

in any job in the environment that

you’re in it’s really essential that you

understand what makes people tick and

that helps you to communicate with them

so I was so focused on having the best

interest of my patients really centrally

but actually I totally missed something

that was even more important to them we

work in a poor resource setting so yes

MSF meets on some frontier is one of the

richest organizations in the world when

it comes to delivering high-quality

medical care but that doesn’t mean that

we always have everything at our

fingertips sometimes you’re forced to be

creative and to get flexible with the

way that you treat your patients and you

have to remember that although there are

protocols patients are not protocols and

occasionally you’re forced to go off

protocol and treat them in the best way

that you possibly can with whatever you

have to hand imagine trying to be the

logistician in a war zone getting

materials and drugs across a border

where there’s active fighting going on

or that there’s been flooding and the

river that you normally get over is an

impassable so sometimes you have to get

as I say flexible and creative and we

discovered that using surgical abdominal

compresses works really well when you

have a large area of skin that you need

to cover with a burn for a burn in

addition if you run out of nutritional

feeding that comes in a packet you can

send a friendly logistician to the

market to buy bananas some kind of bean

and some milk powder and hey presto

you’ve got a high protein high carb feed

that’s ready to go and it works you just

have to think outside the box a little

bit

but the high highs of getting over the

odds and treating patients that you

thought we’re never going to get out of

hospital are sometimes completely

countered by the most terrible low lows

and in the resource setting that is

difficult and challenging it’s not just

about the materials but also about the

space and we are accountable not just

for our actions but also for our in

actions imagine here if you were told

you couldn’t get a GP appointment for

the next two weeks who here’s had that

before

pretty frequently right and the NHS is

always in the headlines isn’t it

Charlie weights and long term that

waiting for appointments and three

months or more for your operation but

you will always be treated and it will

be good treatment that you will get but

imagine that two-week wait was a

imagine if you came to the hospital and

they said oh sorry there’s no more room

come back in a month in some contexts

where we work we are it and the NGO

sector is the only thing that is

upholding any kind of health care for

services that exists in the country and

that can be really challenging and

sometimes it forces us to make very very

difficult and painful decisions three

o’clock in the morning in Haiti I got a

phone call from our project coordinator

asking if we had space and at that point

we did not we were full to capacity we

were bursting the next day I discovered

that we had turned away a father with

two young children with severe burns two

days later he came back his daughter had

died and the little boy also died even

though we made space for him because of

complications from his injuries we

cannot feel guilty for that though as

individuals because we are so stretched

sometimes but we have to remember that

our responsibility is for the patients

who are already under our care and that

can be really really painful but you

have to be strict when Europe but you

only have limited staff and you only

have limited materials in Central

African Republic we ran a trauma center

it was purely looking after victims of

violence victims from the war victims

from road traffic accidents and also

victims of sexual abuse and it was

challenging because we didn’t always

have the space for everybody and we

didn’t know we couldn’t treat everything

that came in the door one of the things

that you learn when you’re in the field

is also as I said about resilience and

also your vulnerability and your

weaknesses nothing could have prepared

me for the emotional roller coaster that

was awaiting me when I went to go and

work with the team looking after the

victims of sexual violence

you know in six months we saw more than

a hundred and sixty patients under the

age of eighteen and I’m not even talking

about the adults here and some of them

were as young as two years old and one

case in particular will always stay with

me an eight year old girl and her

grandmother came for a consultation both

of them had been victims of a really

horrendous attack I’m not only that but

they had witnessed the murder of their

mother the grandmothers daughter and

this little girl’s mom and the

grandmother had somehow filmed it and

because she didn’t have the words to

express the horror of what they had

experienced the video was put before us

in the consultation room and I don’t

know how we got to the end of that

consultation but we did because the

priority was our patients and they

needed care but I left that room and I

went into the office afterwards and I

totally lost it I have never cried so

hard in my life and I have never felt so

frustrated and my colleague a Congolese

nurse came and asked me my sister what’s

wrong and I told him what had happened

and he put his hand in my shoulder

courage my sister that’s part of life

part of life I have never been so angry

I have never been so frustrated I’ve

never felt so helpless and hopeless in

my entire career and not only that but I

was disgusted at humanity I was

disgusted that anybody could do that to

anybody else and that somebody else

could normalize it and on top of that I

was angry at my colleagues why were they

not as frustrated as me why weren’t they

a shocked but you have to remember that

in these contexts our colleagues our

staff our friends they are just as much

victims of the circumstances in which we

work and they have had to learn to steel

themselves and we can learn from their

power from their ability to carry on

faced with such horror and with such

challenging circumstances and they do it

with grace I spoke to the midwife about

it afterwards and I asked her Sylvie why

weren’t you so angry and she said of

course I am I have a mother and this is

my country and these are my people but I

am also a midwife I am a nurse

and that it’s my responsibility that

when they come to me I must care for

them I cannot cry for everyone and it’s

true you can’t feel everything with such

deep empathy because you would break

that day that I saw those patients my

project coordinator sent me home because

I wasn’t functional anymore and he said

it was a Wednesday so don’t come back to

on Monday at least I’m very glad he did

that because one thing that we need to

understand is where our limits are when

we pass them we stopped being functional

we stopped being able to care for our

patients and as a clinician that’s very

very important to understand where your

breaking point is and to stop before you

reach it but the thing that really

amazes me about our national staff in

these places really is their is their

resiliency it still amazes me and I have

such respect for them because they work

in really challenging environments

imagine coming to work through an active

war zone where people are shooting at

you imagine coming to work because you

have to raise money because your child

has been kidnapped them you have to pay

a ransom imagine coming to work and

treating patients with earn injuries to

their hands two days after your house

has been set on fire and you have become

a refugee and you know that these guys

were very likely to have been involved

in destroying your home and you’re gonna

treat them with the same respect as

everybody else how do you do that it’s

very difficult and it’s much easier to

do it as an expat coming into an

environment where there’s war or their

strife along religious or tribal or

political lines because we’re coming in

from the outside and we have that

distance but our staff don’t they are in

it it is their everyday existence and we

have to remember that but at the same

time an organization like MSF has really

really strong values and we must uphold

those values to treat all of our

patients with dignity and respect

regardless of what color they are what

religion they are what they eat for

breakfast it doesn’t matter they deserve

it is this complexity that drives me it

is the fact that I learned so much about

how to be a good communicator in these

environments that I have become really

creative and flexible that I’ve learned

where my vulnerability is and where my

weak points are and I have learned to be

resilient and I have learned to be

strong and this is the thing that drives

me forwards and this is the thing that

drives many people forwards so I’m sorry

Gandhi but I’m gonna partly disagree

with you because whatever you do will

not necessarily be insignificant we do

not know what the future holds and what

about that couple with the burns and

what about that little girl

what will they go on to do we don’t know

what I do know is that at that moment on

those days those patients were treated

they got to go home that they survived

and that’s what keeps me going so

whatever you do may be significant and

it is very important that you do it

thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: