
be very afraid
I repeat be afraid but of what we live
in a world where fear is everywhere the
news headlines are seemingly dominated
by messages of a world falling apart
with fear Donald Trump with fear Hillary
Clinton with her breakfast with fear the
European Union with fear finding love
we fear not finding love and when we
find it we fear losing it in short a
world of fear yet there is a disconnect
between our fears and the cold hard
statistics behind them flying is a prime
example how many of you have at some
point during your lives been afraid of
flying the sphere that I thought but
aviation has a reputation of being
dangerous in comparison to other modes
of transport but if you look at the cold
hosta tist excited of falling out of the
sky is rather small all the other hand a
few of us are probably ever thought
twice about getting into a car although
statistically were much more likely to
die in a car crash falling out of said
sky well let’s look at energy it’s hard
that the sexiest of topics I know it
never quite made it as a common sation
started in the pub but it surrounds us
every moment of every day of our lives
energy is there when we turn on the
laptop to pull the all-nighter to write
the essay we just couldn’t quite be
asked to write it’s there when we turn
on the kettle to boil some tea when
we’re trying to keep warm for saving on
the energy bills for speaking of kettles
there is one particular kettle that is
rather controversial and I speak of
course about the nuclear one because a
nuclear reactor at the end of the day
has but one purpose boil water to make
electricity if we live in a society
where nuclear power is feared Agassi
it’s got a cultural narrative of fear of
death and of destruction yes if we look
at the cold hard statistics behind
nuclear power it is by far the safest
mode of energy production on the
opposite end of the spectrum we got the
the king of power itself as because but
coal be coal kills tens of thousands of
people along diseases and due to its
waste but I’m sure like myself none of
you are lying right awake at night
thinking about a coal powered energy
station unless you think about this you
think about the carbon crisis that we
are facing where for hundreds of years
human civilization has been using our
atmosphere as a virtual dump and if any
of you believe that climate change is
just to use the Trump sense of the word
an alternative facts then I hope you
brought up a good book but I’m going to
say Nexus either way not going to be
interesting but climate change seldom is
to so seemingly simple words being the
course of such debate such controversy
and judging by the headlines fear but
climate change also means a lot of very
different things depending on you who
you are if you call a Pacific island
home well then climate change is
something that’s going to see your home
submerged if you live in Glasgow have my
commiserations it’s just more rain for
you and but generally for people in in
the West climate changes was another
problem
on a pile that keeps getting longer
before me climate change represents
something that quite different for me
the signs well the science they settled
and I’m not going to contribute on it
yes there are debates to be held about
how bad is going to be where it’s going
to hit and and when the climate change
nevertheless process it an existential
threat to our ways of life that’s not
entirely a bad thing
because we live in a world that is
inherently unsustainable and inherently
unjust for me at the however nuclear
power was not the first solution that
came to mind and like most of you I
think I had concerns about the accidents
the waste problem and the weapons but I
started to look into into they should
deeper go beyond the headlines go beyond
but I have been spoon-fed at school it’s
not a look at this issues and see why do
we actively try not to use an end
resource that there’s not incredibly
powerful but also inherently clean and
what I found
surprise me I found three narratives
I was embedded within our society that I
saw as a three Nicola myths about the
waste the accidents and the weapons I
would like to invite you all on this
journey as we look at these issues at
hand and let’s start with the elephant
in the room shall we accidents
let’s make it safe but as anyone in this
room never heard of Chernobyl but it
places like Chernobyl and Fukushima hold
a near mythical place in our cultures
and in our imagination
for me I thought the Chernobyl was the
graveyard of tens of hundreds of
thousands of people and a wasteland of a
nuclear disaster but we just discuss the
surface there’s a very different image
that comes across the number of deaths
from the Chernobyl accident it’s 56 it’s
not the tens or hundreds of thousands
that we’ve been told it was but 56
therefore Kashima accident in 2011 is
never going to cost anyone their lives
that is not from radiation but if you
put that in a wider context between 1969
and year 2000 there was almost 2,000
severe energy accidents two of those
would be of nuclear nature these
accidents cost more than 80,000 people
their lives nuclear accidents cost 56
people their lives so the narrative that
we’ve been fed but as soon as something
goes wrong with a nuclear power station
hundreds of thousands of people going to
die it simply doesn’t hold up to facts
the big killer in a nuclear accident
a social stigma because of radiation
people are being shunned by society
being told there’s nothing wrong with
you because you have been touched by
something that we feel this is very
evident the scene at Chernobyl because
when the people evacuated and placed
within other societies they were shunned
many took to the bottle and subsequently
died from social stress or complications
of alcoholism
but then if accidents on the problem
well then surely surely the ways this I
mean the entire notion of having
something so dangerous need to borrow 2
kilometer down under the surface of the
planet
for hundreds of thousands of years
surely this is that’s unsustainable as
anything ever could become but yes again
if it’s not to scratch the surface and
look at the very facts and set aside
prejudices between 95 and 19 million
percent of nuclear waste is nothing but
reusable resource and the remaining 1
percent that is truly wasteful that we
cannot use in any kind of nuclear
reactor it’s not as dangerous as it’s
being portrayed and the main danger from
nuclear waste would be if somehow
terrorist groups that hold a fit built a
dirty bomb blew it up and the social
stigma history would start all over
again but if then waste isn’t the
problem then surely the bombs are
because I mean no one wants bomb
factories virtually around every corner
but if you want to build nuclear weapons
the worst way to do so is to use a
nuclear reactor it is the most
complicated it’s the most expensive and
the odds are if you’re going to try to
build a nuclear bomb you can’t want to
do so in secrecy why are you seeing a
civilian nuclear reactor you could just
as well put up a sign on the sky saying
I’m building a bomb don’t look here so
then for me when it became so clear that
what I thought would be the big problems
weren’t problems I started my research
on radiation and radiation fear because
radiation holds like accidents like the
accidents and mythical place in in the
way we see nuclear the radiation somehow
is there more dangerous than any other
environmental risk but the proper thing
it is the radiation surrounds us every
moment of our lives at the moment you
are being bombarded by the walls by
space by the core and actually from the
very bones we all radiate a lot and if
our bodies haven’t
where life hadn’t evolved over billions
of years to handle a high radiation
environment than we all be gone yet we
aren’t falling off being dead because of
radiation but then you might say Oh fine
but do we even need it
surely the headline suppose renewables
being run on a hundred percent of the
country’s energy needs are ample
examples of that we don’t need nuclear
power so why so why even bother however
when you scratch the surface yes again
it’s a very different image the graphs
behind me
this is Denmark the brown section is
biomass coal and gas the purple one is
wooden part but the wind doesn’t always
blow regardless of where you are and
storing things in it in batteries we’ve
been trying to do that for a hundred
years we are not close to something this
commercially viable and something that’s
sustainable for society I cost and this
map of Europe makes it probably even
clearer the greener you are less co2 the
dark ER the more with the exception of
Norway the greenest countries are the
ones that have a high degree of
reliability on nuclear wet on the old
weapons no on nuclear power and the
darker obviously so but then Germany the
poster boy of the renewables revolution
surely they are doing well they got rid
of their never getting rid of it and
replacing the renewables the fire on
that a little bit the claims that they
have gone cleaner is simply not that
they have gone down in nuclear they have
built more renewables but as a graph she
highlights the co2 intensity in the
electricity hasn’t changed a bit
and by the way this is the true face of
the German energy rebel
because renewables when you can’t use
them the Germans have thought let’s plug
the gaps with Brian coal and this is
what it looks like so we live in a
period of a sustainable energy crisis
whilst low carbon has increased solar
wind are still incredibly small and this
is the spider fact we’ve employed in
billions and billions of pounds into
these projects but given that we have
removed so much nuclear off the grid
because we fear what is basically a tea
kettle the amount of them of a renewable
or low-carbon energy has decline in real
terms and for our percent doesn’t sound
like a lot but that is 60 nuclear power
stations or 900 solar farms so the scope
of of the challenge at hand is immense
and if we say okay I fear this power
station but the facts aren’t there then
we are at effect failing not only to
build in a carbon-free society but also
making it more sustainable and and one
of the key problems with nuclear fear
isn’t just what we do in the West but
the way how we approach nuclear power
around the world because we fear that a
nuclear reactor would be used as a means
of proliferation of bomb-making
we are saying to the so-called
developing world or with the rest of the
well then I don’t think you’re quite up
to the challenge but don’t think that
you can handle a reactor but I think if
safeguarded we don’t think you can run
it adequately but if you look at once
again the statistics behind it not a
single country has ever built civilian
nuclear power and then build bombs there
was always
other way around by denying the rest of
the world access to nuclear para will
not only ensuring that the climate
crisis is virtually unsolvable
renewables are the best friends of one
type of energy and that is anything that
is based on carbon because with but
renewables are gone up emissions are
still at a very high level but it’s not
only about the carbon crisis it’s also
the fact that more than a billion people
around the world do not have access to
any kind of electricity by telling them
sorry you’re not quite good enough for
to use nuclear power we are condemning
them to burning their rainforests
burning their own oil their coal or as
millions of people do especially in
sub-saharan Africa but around the world
generally burn cows we live in 2017
how is this morally justifiable because
at the end of the day as Professor
Rosling said in the West we have a
responsibility to the rest of world to
share what we all would have done and
not force them to redo everything all
over again a nuclear power gives us the
opportunity to build a very different
kind of society different kind of world
altogether a clean world where everyone
could have access to high energy
lifestyle like in the West but
sustainable nuclear power has the
potential to truly revolutionize the
world we live in I say let’s take the
challenge thank you [Applause]