Press "Enter" to skip to content

Confronting Our Cultural Myopia | Beth Haubert & Sumeet Jain | TEDxUNO


the first time I met some eats family

they were in their element and I was not

in mine it was almost Christmas and

there were nearly 40 people crammed into

some eats mom’s house there was so much

energy and activity the realization that

there weren’t enough decorations for the

Christmas tree caused an uproar so a

band of cousins was sent to secure more

their victorious return hours later

initiated a mini celebration throughout

the house this raucous fellowship and

camaraderie was new to me and it was my

first lesson that Indians find a way to

celebrate and delight and even the

smallest milestones as a way to bring

people together Indian rituals are a

vast collection of celebrations that

seemed designed to include people when

you attend an Indian celebration you

feel like a participant not just a

spectator one example is an annual event

where brothers and sisters of all ages

come together to tie a special bracelet

around each other’s wrists exchange

gifts and wish each other well it’s a

short intimate ceremony followed by

siblings casually hanging out for

brothers and sisters who have grown

older and perhaps live far apart from

one another it’s great to have a

dedicated occasion to come together and

celebrate that relationship when you

attend a wedding in the u.s. you’re

usually there as an encouraging or even

sometimes just a spectator but Indians

involve every guest at their wedding in

some rituals and there’s hardly ever

less than two or three hundred people at

an Indian wedding in this ritual guests

from my side of the wedding are

preparing me to Mary Beth there smearing

a paste made of turmeric and yogurt all

it’s a very short gesture that each

person gets to do but anybody who wants

to do it can be involved whether it at a

wedding birthday party or even just a

big get-together many Indians

celebrations will have a series of

performances where guests offer a song

dance skit or something like that

sometimes people will prepare something

incredible and really show off sometimes

it’s a person’s very first time doing

something like that and whether it’s in

a grand hall or in a DIY living room set

up there’s always a lot of fun and the

ritual is not that everybody must

prepare something in order to attend

this party the ritual is that for a

short while during that celebration

everyone is sharing in the same

experience and when they think about

that occasion later they have something

special to remember it by anywhere in

the world it’s probably a big deal the

first time a newly married person enters

their in-laws house Indians have a

ritual about this as well the first time

a new bride enters her in-laws home she

steps in a red dye so that her feet

leaving literal mark on the home the

family extended family even neighbors

come to welcome her dozens of matriarch

so welcoming a new addition to their

fault it’s an empowering sight to behold

and it creates the lasting feeling of

connection rituals are just one small

part of Indian culture and as much fun

as they are sharing in them has not been

the most interesting part of our journey

together we’d like to talk to you about

appreciating cultural differences

specifically how we realized only

recently that we don’t really we don’t

really appreciate cultural differences

as much as we all like to think we do

the story of this realization is also

the story of our relationship we were

ignorant as to how much culture is

actually hidden from us until we’re

placed in situations where we’re forced

to make choices about that culture most

of us don’t chew

our culture we inherited from our family

and if our family’s been in the same

place for a long time that culture is

heavily influenced by other families in

that region our values and priorities

stem from our culture it shapes us in

ways that we often don’t even realize

but we have to admit that we don’t

choose it isn’t it strange that in a

time when we value freedom and choice so

much that we’re not choosing something

so vital in a way this confines our life

experience a consequence of where we

happen to have been born so we travel

right we visit other lands eat their

food hear their music walk their parks

tour their museums even meet their

locals that’s usually what we mean when

we say that we love different cultures

but we’re not as porous as we like to

think we are especially where culture is

concerned if you’ve been to another

country you’re probably familiar with

the sadness that can come from thinking

about that trip years later how the

feeling of having been somewhere else

has faded into a memory most of us are

not as changed by travel as our photo

albums are fattened most travel is

cultural spectatorship this doesn’t mean

it’s not wonderful but it has a

different kind of wonder than cultural

appreciation when we appreciate

something we seek its underlying value

and find space for part of it within us

we’re not overly concerned with such

things when traveling whether it’s

sipping coconut water in cancun or

cappuccino in Rome and that’s okay we

should enjoy our vacations still when we

appreciate something we seek its

underlying value and find space for part

of it within us so what is cultural

appreciation how do we seek its

underlying value and how do we find

space for that value within us the first

question has an easier answer find what

people willingly sacrifice what a group

of people sacrifices will tell you more

about them than almost anything

for example i found that indians tend to

sacrifice self-determination in order to

build stronger family bonds the indian

families we know value consistent

reliable careers and stable outcomes in

life usually at the expense of more

romantic career ambitions American

culture feels opposite to this of course

families in the u.s. also value

prosperity and togetherness but we also

expect our young people to find their

own path we want them to make their own

mistakes so that they can learn from

them and we celebrate when their

personal risks yield some great reward

but people in the u.s. say things like

it’s my life this is something I need to

do I would imagine the people all over

the world feel that way sometimes but

Indian culture is such that it

discourages them from acting upon that

belief or upon that feeling instead they

focus more on the consistency of the

career or the stability of the family

and so making sacrifices or rather

cultural appreciation means

understanding that even in our culture

we are making some sacrifices and it

also means that we have to actually

consider that there might be something

to gain from genuinely examining why

these other cultures have made the

sacrifices that they have if that sounds

like a lot of work it’s because it is

but it is not an uncommon task huge

groups of people do this passionately

regularly because their survival depends

upon it immigrants when sue meets mom

moved to this country from India in 1980

she had to learn the culture of the USA

and not things like burgers are

delicious and Ford Mustangs are cool but

things like in this culture public

displays of affection aren’t usually

meant to offend their celebrations of

love and freedom a thousand things that

we don’t notice in our day-to-day lives

are for immigrants small reconciliations

of cultural conflict and appreciation if

she hadn’t made space within herself for

new values cemitas mom would have had an

even harder

time finding a job making friends

getting a promotion for immigrants

cultural appreciation isn’t a luxury of

adventure and travel it’s necessary for

survival the real test of cultural

appreciation begins when your values and

another cultures values butt heads a bit

first meets mom this test began when she

started having kids and raising them in

her new country as my brothers and I

grew older we started to make friends

outside of the social circle that had

supported mom when she moved to the US

and we started to ape some of their

behaviors and want some of their wants

this was difficult for mom but she made

space and she introduced us to

McDonald’s and Burger King even though

in her culture violence against animals

had been aboard for literally thousands

of years and she didn’t begrudge us this

in fact she delighted in the new and

drew joy from seeing her kids a little

bit more empowered to fit in and

cultural appreciation for her wasn’t

limited to just tolerating the things

that she didn’t like she would also find

values and ideas that she would

appreciate she saw great power in the

individualism that this country instills

in its young people even though Indian

culture centers more around self

sacrifice but she made space for that

and so my brothers and I grew up

exploring our worlds more independently

and when we would hang out and chat over

the dinner table or or just hang out on

the weekends we would share with mom

deeper more meaningful and more critical

conversations than my cousin’s in India

have with their parents and so this is a

new happiness that she unlocked because

she made space for something different

within herself and if you think about it

this is part and parcel of the

immigrants experience thousands of them

will come to this country and try to do

something special for themselves but

doing this didn’t mean that mom had to

abandon her prior set of values it

didn’t mean that something was broken in

Indian culture

she continues she continues to fight for

or her indian culture and a difficulty

for her is getting her american kids to

make space within themselves for her

Indian values but if she succeeds she’ll

have succeeded in passing on to them a

more enriched complex identity and

that’s really what her job is all about

one of the most profound ideas that she

continues to advocate for to this day is

the idea that were not just individuals

we’re connected in powerful ways and

sometimes it’s better to sacrifice a bit

of our individuality in order to access

the power of the collective this idea is

much stronger in Indian culture than in

American culture here we expect people

to be self-sufficient and we’re

embarrassed when we find ourselves

lacking in some way we place so much

importance on what it means to be an

adult that we end up shaming ourselves

and others for needing help meanwhile

soon meets mom and her siblings continue

to this day to involve each other in one

another’s daily lives usually by asking

for help making decisions about things

that we might think adults should make

themselves by involving one another in

these decisions they’re reinforcing

their collective identity so then

they’re well beans are so interconnected

that it seems obvious to them that they

would be involved in each other’s daily

lives from an American perspective this

might seem like an invasion of privacy

or like not respecting and adults

sovereignty and it’s true Indians do

sacrifice some of those things for their

collective identity but it’s also true

that we sacrifice some things for our

more individual one and so my brothers

and I grew up surrounded by conflicting

definitions of simple terms like what is

an adult and what is maturity and that

conflict is frustrating but hopefully

over time we’re trying to learn to

cherish that complexity because the hope

is that there’s a greater happiness at

the end of that road all of that is made

possible by our mom’s entry to a new

country where she

countered something different and made

space for it within herself and her

story joins that of billions of other

immigrants that have done that same

exact thing so immigrants have a

built-in motivation for cultural

appreciation that most of us don’t most

of us probably won’t ever really be

forced to confront why we have our

values and why we have our culture and

this biases cultural appreciation

heavily in one direction if you think

about it we tend to believe that it’s

the immigrants job to make space within

themselves for new values not ours right

so after a while we all get comfortable

where we are and start to redefine

cultural appreciation to mean something

more like cultural spectatorship for

many of us the only occasion where we’ll

have to confront our own cultures

deficits will be we’re forced to because

we move to a new country this is our

cultural myopia from where we sit

longtime residents of the same region

having inherited our culture from our

from our family we forget that it’s not

just our food in our music that are

unique to us it’s also our values we

forget that we didn’t choose our culture

and many of our values we forget that

love itself is subject to our culture

that as many if not more people in the

world believe in compatibility before

chemistry when marrying in some of the

most populous countries in the world

arranged marriages though they are much

different in reality than how they’re

portrayed in films are still the norm

young people put faith in their families

to choose them a great partner and

Families work hard to be worthy of that

faith literally billions of people

around the world believe that love grows

between two people after they’re married

on the other hand in this country we

might spend years searching for a

partner downloading dating apps enduring

heartache all because this culture

values the romantic tale the adventure

of

really finding someone for yourself

surely there’s no single way to love or

to find love but we can’t deny that many

of us approach marriage without much

consideration as to how huge groups of

people around the world do it so

differently we forget thank you we

forget that our culture like our land is

just one small part of the world’s feast

like with any feast joy comes from

sampling a little bit of everything if

your feast looks like this and you only

eat mashed potatoes all night you really

be missing out when you sample from the

world’s cultures you begin choosing your

values instead of inheriting them for

many immigrants moving to a new country

is a dance between humility and pride

we’re over decades they have to define a

set of values by questioning and

battling reviewing revising everything

that they thought they knew and if any

values make it through that process it’s

because they chose them comparing them

with other values that might even

conflict with them when we looked inside

ourselves we saw very little of that we

found not just a complacency but an

arrogance that our culture is truest and

that arrogance is our defense mechanism

because it’s painful to admit that we

don’t have the humility that so many

other people have when it comes to

defining their values but we decided in

some hope that building that humility is

possible so we started making a list of

all the things about Indian culture that

might be worth making space for and now

we’ve shared some of those examples with

you we’re not educated social scientists

and we’re speaking in generalities that

usually get people in trouble but we

felt

means of truth in this exploration of

ourselves and we genuinely believe

there’s space in all of us for a more

complex set of values than what we

inherit thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: