
Orleans Louisiana our first unit begins
just before the American Revolution and
we end the year right after the Civil
War so as you can imagine slavery is
something we have to talk about a lot
and one days we’re grappling with a text
about why depression of enslaved black
lives my student iono Jefferson pulls me
over to her desk she says dr. Hargrove I
got something you gotta read it’s really
famous it’s about slavery you know the
one I’m talking about no kid um I said
who’s it by she said I don’t know even
better I said well what was it about
tell me about the subject what were they
saying about slavery she said all kinds
of stuff it was crazy and his famous dr.
Hargrove how you social studies teacher
and you don’t know that letter I said
all right babe she said give me your
phone I’m gonna look it up I said how
about after class so we get out to
recess and I can hear my name from
across the yard dr. Hargrove let me have
your phone so I handed it over she
pulled it right up of course for anyone
who is unfamiliar with Willie Lynch’s
speech to the Virginia Colony on the
makings of a slave it’s very
controversial and it’s hair-raising and
his speech Lynch articulates his methods
for pitting people of color against one
another he explicitly used fear distrust
and envy to control enslaved people
privileges over others based on their
age their gender and the tone of their
skin you must pit them against one
another he insisted the light skin
versus a dark-skinned so that they
become distrustful of each other no
matter what however they must always
trust you they must always feel
dependent on you the white slave holder
and by orchestrating the enslaved
community in this way Lynch argued that
the colonies uprisings and issues with
Runaways would significantly doesn’t
diminish because the community would
become one in which the dependence and
trust on the slave holder and distrust
of one another
would maintain the dominance of the
white man and his family and the
inferiority of those who were enslaved
and of color so you can see why she
wanted me to read it a couple months go
by we’re learning about andrew jackson
in the Trail of Tears ayanna’s hand goes
up dr. Hargrove why holding all these
slaves moving all these Native Americans
from one place to another because their
skin being a white teacher of this
subject matter in an African American
classroom has been the challenge of my
life to date I think in large part
because i feel so acutely the
differences between ayanna’s culture and
mine and the boundaries that separate my
life chances from hers in large part
because our skin colors are not the same
and as important as important as it is
for me to be in my feelings about all
that the real question is what do I have
to say to her for myself and in answer
to one of the most fundamental questions
that shapes the organization of our
society local and global how do we get
to a place and stay in a place where a
dominant group can i press another based
on any identity marker their gender
their age their orientation their skin
color even more important how do we
change it or the guiding question for
seventh grade this year how do people
liberate themselves from oppression my
answer thus far comes from studying a
civil war in Liberia a small West
African country that was born out of our
own problem of slavery in the States now
the roots of that conflict I believe
were ultimately narrative and they offer
us a number of insights and what not to
do and hopefully some insights about the
possibility for restoration equality and
justice across lines of difference that
are so apparent in my classroom and
throughout the rest of our world so a
few years ago I was doing some
ethnographic fieldwork in Monrovia the
capital city of Liberia that country
went through a really difficult bloody
long 14-year Civil War it’s known for
the use of young combatants we hear them
talked about
as child soldiers and if you look them
up you’ll see them depicted with big
ak-47s and magazines strapped across
their chests a lot of them were ayanna’s
age when they started fighting 12 and 13
years old and they in the armed groups
they serve decimated the infrastructure
displaced thousands of Liberian
civilians and killed an unknowable
number of others not to mention all the
combatants who were part of the war now
we got to ask ourselves why why would
young people her age want to do that
what would cause so many to fight in a
war for so long if I sent ayana to the
scholars in our ivory towers they would
have a number of theoretical stories
that would explain that war for her and
why young people her age might fight
there and this is what some of them
would say the war in Liberia and many
others like it occur in places where
there is a large portion of youth in
relation to the rest of the population
it’s called a youth bulge as the number
of young people increases so does the
likelihood of conflict now that
correlation remains very very consistent
we see it over and over and over again
it’s a correlation it’s not cause what’s
got young people her age wanting to pick
up weapons in a fight other researchers
will look at those who are mobilizing
them they look at men like Charles
Taylor who instigated the librarian
conflict they’re greedy they use rural
space outside of the ability of the
military to protect they harness those
resources and the people in them and
they fight for the power and urban
capitals now men like Taylor are greedy
and they are power hungry and they are
willing to stop at nothing extinguishing
thousands and thousands of lives in
pursuit of that power but is that all
there is to it is it just a few bad guys
along the way a few bad warlords and the
rest of everyone else is just a victim
seems like there should be a little more
to it both of these theories are a
historical they place blame on a person
or a generation while failing to account
for wider context
appears to ground themselves in
historical and political analysis have
observed something else in societies
like Liberia groups organized themselves
through hierarchical relationships as
benefactors and dependents social
support survival happen in networks of
reciprocity mutual dependence and
inevitably some networks become more
powerful than others as they look out
for their own interests and the
interests of their family and their kin
as some are more powerful and some not
some are left out all together and you
have grievances that fester over time
leading to distrust leading to exclusion
and eventually we have conflict now
there’s merit to all of these
explanations and a lot of others we
don’t have time to discuss here today
I’ve grown skeptical though because if
you listen carefully to each of these
and many others you’ll find some other
ring event even in the analysis look at
the young people gosh there are so many
of them and they’re violent look at the
Warlord’s gosh they’re greedy look at
the society look at the way it’s set up
just kind of leans that way doesn’t it
isn’t it easy to look over at another
neighborhood another city another age
group another skin color another society
and surmise it there’s just something
about them and the way they do life it’s
a little too messed up and that’s where
the trouble is coming from I think we’ve
missed a much more simple and difficult
truth something father Greg Boyle said a
few years ago the wrong idea has taken
hold in the world and that idea is this
some people matter more than others all
of these conflict theory Zad ress what’s
happening over there with them but what
the smallest African country has taught
me is that the problem is not a
phenomenon house in an individual a
generation or a society it’s a human
problem and we can trace it throughout
time and around the world and it’s not
just over there it’s right here it’s
with us
here’s why I think that let’s come back
to iono and that speech by Willie Lynch
he gave that speech in 1712 the makings
of a slave let’s fast forward a little
bit a few decades later the colonists
have become outraged by British
oppression they’ve thrown off English
authority they’ve crafted a government
grounded on the idea that all men are
created equal with certain inalienable
rights but we all know that our
government our nation was founded by the
minds and the pens of white slave
holding men in the contradiction between
we hold these truths to be self-evident
and the evident reality of an economy
and a nation built on slave labor did
not escape notice so what to do with the
problem of slavery amidst the protests
of white abolitionists and free people
of color who insisted that the path
towards justice was emancipation an
alternative solution emerged the
subjugation of so many black slaves over
so many generations created a multitude
of chalant of challenges that would not
be solved through emancipation alone
after all where those people go live
what they go and do what kind of trouble
might they get up to if they’re no
longer controlled and contained and so
very early on in our nation’s history
men like Thomas Jefferson started
advocating for emancipation to another
location he wrote it is most desirable
that emancipation to another land would
be advantageous for gradually drawing
off that portion of our population they
can take the seeds of civilization we
have planted in them here and take them
forth back to the country of their
origin in Africa a few years later that
project actually came to fruition and
free people of color began boarding
ships bound for the Wild West African
coast let’s put that on pause for a
second we all know what happened here in
the States there was not a chance of
drawing off boat by boat all of the
people who had sown and harvested and
built our nation and so there were
uprisings and then there was Civil War
and the legacy of that kind of
stomach oppression is at the root of the
police shootings and the protests and
the riots that played the plague our
communities in our national discourse
today in West Africa what happened there
a story that’s actually very parallel to
our own the principal reason the
underlying narrative that free people of
color were sent with was that they would
be the civilized errs now they were not
civilized enough for our country but
certainly they would be more civilized
and definitely civilized enough for
those people over there and the
resounding evidence from history is that
the people who came all the way over to
West Africa built a nation grounded on
the idea that their group mattered more
they were more civilized than any of
those who had already been there and as
the years of nation-building progressed
marginalization occurred in more and
more explicit waves indigenous children
were not afforded the same kinds of
education indigenous people were not
allowed the same privileges and
government it got so bad that in 1964 a
young indigenous university student said
of the privileged elite those who had
descended from free slaves these people
are too hard in their hearts and they
cannot change she said there will be a
civil war because they think so much of
themselves and who are they and she was
right 25 years later there was a bloody
bloody civil war now these intertwined
stories of slavery in the US and civil
war in both countries have left me with
at least two insights about liberation
and oppression first we must own our own
narrative there were many factors that
made that transition from the u.s. to
West Africa enormously difficult for the
men and women who risked their journey
to establish their lives somewhere else
that they had never known however their
narrative was not their own in fact it
was a value system of the dominant white
oppressors in the u.s. that they
transplanted and reproduced in Liberia
thus reproducing as well forms of
oppression that led to civil war in both
countries
as long as we accept another group’s
assessment of our worthiness our dignity
we will never rise beyond the limits of
their prejudice second these intertwined
stories demonstrate that when the
dominant group denies the dignity of
others the result is exclusion period
the result is conflict period for those
of us in the dominant group the question
I come back to is have we really
preserved our own dignity if we have in
fact denied that of others ion is going
to raise that hand of hers and she does
want to know is it really because of the
color of their skin so many people were
enslaved or pushed out of their homes
that university student in Liberia was
definitely ready to point out of the
privileged elite they are too hard in
their hearts as long as some people
matter more than others the dominant
group has lost part of its humanity
because what it has how it calculates
its worth or strives towards life
liberty and the pursuit of happiness
depends on those it excludes keeps out
pushes down or avoids that requires a
hardening of the heart adda botching of
the mind a loss of our humanity now
certainly the oppressed are in need of
liberation the black lives matter
movement the spoken word movement among
others are a testament to that reality
what we speak far less about though is
the tremendous need for liberation among
those who oppressed and who benefit from
oppression the restoration of our
humanity as the privileged I believe is
the linchpin to liberation of our
society’s local and global and this is
what I mean what Thomas Jefferson and
others were saying all of those years
ago is that what we as white people have
you as people of color are not worthy
enough to share in when we deny the
humanity of someone else we also deny
our own we define our existence based
upon identity markers like skin color
and build worlds of superior of
superiority around external factors like
money or cultural expression
which define our social standing against
those of others without that we lose our
position as the privileged and as the
worthy as the good enough that’s how our
hearts get hard now we all know from
personal experience and from a growing
mountain of research in the social
science but what we really want is to
know and be known and that cannot happen
without a softness of heart one of the
biggest push backs I get when I speak to
privilege friends family members and
colleagues about dominance about
privilege is I don’t know what to do
about it but it’s not my fault I didn’t
want it this way and I think that’s
probably true for a lot of us we don’t
but what the police shootings the
protests and the riots have to tell us
is that unless we are actively working
to disrupt systems of oppression we are
allowing them to be reproduced among us
dr. King very astutely noted that a riot
is the language of the unheard we have
to listen we have to open up and open
out and be vulnerable willing to receive
and here and when we do that we’re not
just working towards some sort of
equality and justice on this macro
theoretical level we’re sharing in a
common humanity where dignity is defined
not by what we hoard or keep to
ourselves but by what we share in common
and that’s when we begin to know and be
known that’s when the joy of moments
like the ones I anna and i share have
the ability to restore and reiterate the
dignity of what we share in common when
there is trust and respect there is
little opportunity for destructive
conflict the emancipation of the hearts
and minds of the dominant the privileged
among us is the final frontier of
liberation and it is restorative for all
of us
thank you for listening [Applause]