Press "Enter" to skip to content

What Can We Learn From Economic Experts? | George Magnus | TEDxSevenoaksSchool


[Applause]

good evening ladies and gentlemen my

talk tonight is entitled what can we

learn from economic experts so

somebody’s already kind of pinched my

first line really as you know as you

know now at least the queen meeting was

famously asked at the London School of

Economics after the financial crisis why

didn’t anybody see this coming and the

truth is actually some people did but no

matter the point was clearly made and

last year as you will remember very

clearly during the referendum that we

had in this country a lively debate

erupted about economic experts and

whether we could actually learn anything

from them at all and this debate has

continued to this day now there’s no

question in my view that economics and

economists have issues we teach our

undergraduates much too much about maths

and modelling and not enough about

economic history and about economic

thinkers and why they change their views

obviously in the context of their time

but economists don’t actually make only

make predictions we also do quite a lot

of work actually trying to explain the

consequences of doing making choices and

what the consequences of those choices

are so as you know politicians will do

anything and say anything and promise

anything to be popular and to win your

votes at elections it’s the sad job

unfortunately of economists to be able

to have to tell you why some of these

choices are not always possible or why

they might be incompatible or if they

are compatible the conditions under

which that might be so in these days and

times economic experts I think face very

very big challenges perhaps no more no

less than other experts in different

fields but as you know there are many

things that describe uncertain times

that we live in we’re going through what

some people call the fourth Industrial

Revolution we have just come away from

25 years of the most rapid globe

réalisation that’s happened in the

world since the 98 19th century and

we’re still trying to come to terms with

the rise of China and many emerging

markets in the global system and this

has given rise to many social economic

Geographic tensions which have exposed

our institutions both at home and

internationally as being somewhat

fragile giving us a big headache and

many questions about how we cope with

unpredictability and lots of a radical

change so what can we learn from

economic experts I’d like to propose

tonight six things that you may like to

think about the first is that financial

crises really do matter and they matter

much more than we even thought they did

seven or eight years ago and they have

long-lasting effects if we hadn’t had

Lehman Brothers collapse in 2008 the

last eight years would have been

completely different from the way that

we have experienced it and remember it

now for many of the problems that we now

discuss about globalization about income

inequality about the quality of jobs and

the amount of jobs these things predated

the financial crisis by quite some time

but the crisis itself I think was the

last straw it gave rise to a very

ubiquitous political backlash not just

amongst our steel workers and car

workers and public sector workers but

amongst the middle class and even

amongst some of the one percent a

backlash against what they perceive to

be the collusion of vested interests in

finance politics and big business the

phrase we’re all in it together just

rang really hollow for a lot of people

as you know and as we’re all conscious

now so the lesson is we have to

understand the systemic causes of crises

like we’ve experienced and also the need

not only to preach fairness but also to

dem

straight fairness in our economic and

social policies the second lesson is

really a kind of a variation of a phrase

that was made famous by Bill Clinton’s

political strategist James Carville 25

years ago he coined the phrase it’s the

economy stupid and we have to rebrand

that now as it’s the political economy

stupid because what we’ve seen in 2016

was people vote not necessarily in there

what we might strictly define as their

economic interests long term so a lot of

people voted to leave the EU despite the

fact that the overwhelming amount of

evidence about leaving the EU from an

economic point of view was negative

unless it could be mitigated and a lot

of people voted for Donald Trump despite

the fact that he campaigned on policies

to cut taxes for the rich and for

companies and on trade policies which

will harm American workers so sometimes

people vote for things that have nothing

to do really with pocketbook economics

and we have to understand that economic

policies have consequences that

sometimes result in feedback that we

will find surprising or negative the

third thing that we can learn i think is

something that I call the fallacy of

disaggregation now don’t faint I’m going

to it’s a very very simple concept so in

a more conventional concept which is the

fallacy of aggregation what’s good for

one person doesn’t necessarily mean it’s

good for everybody so if you think about

saving for example if I save more that’s

good for me and you may congratulate me

for being prudent and you know a good

economic citizen but if we all save more

together the economy will tip into a

recession because nobody will spend if I

had drive my car down seven oaks high

street it’s great for me because I’m

comfortable and you know I’m going to

have a good time and i’ll get more

quickly to where I want to get to maybe

but of course if we all drive our

cars down seven oaks high street

together we’re just going to end up with

congestion and pollution so the fallacy

of disaggregation is the mirror image of

that where what’s good for everybody

doesn’t necessarily resonate for each

individual so if you think about jobs

and unemployment so in this country and

in the United States for example we have

record levels of employment and low

levels of unemployment so in the

aggregate it looks fantastic but if I

give you one example in America white

people account for seventy eight percent

of the labor force and about seventy

percent of the population in smaller

cities outside of New York and Los

Angeles and so on and so forth and if

you look at American employment since

2007 it has grown almost more rapidly

than in any recovery that America has

had since 1945 but white people have

700,000 jobs fewer today that they had

in 2007 compared with other ethnic

groups so we have to look more carefully

beyond the bland and a kind of broad

statistics which supposedly define

whether we’re doing well or not there

are individual stories and group stories

that matter the fourth lesson that I

think we’re starting to learn is that we

can walk on two legs and what I mean by

that is that for many years during the

last few what since 2008 we were told

that there’s only one game in town which

is monetary policy you’ve all heard now

of quantitative easing which is the

unusual method that was adopted by

central banks to try to keep the

financial system alive and then the

economy alive over the last seven or

eight years but we always knew that

there were limits to what central banks

Bank of England could do so the Bank of

England and Mark Carney just because

he’s the governor they have no remit

when it comes to the provision of

ubiquitous broadband they have no

remit when it comes to hospital beds or

health education educational attainment

or even for you know ways of increasing

productivity this is not the job of

monetary policymakers it’s the job of

governments and governments are starting

to fortunately and finally learn that

they do have a role to play in trying to

nurture us out of this kind of funk that

we’ve been in for some time it’s

happening in Japan Donald Trump says

he’s going to spend a lot of money on

infrastructure Theresa May today

launched an industrial strategy green

paper which will have in government

intervention is a very very prominent

phenomenon so things are beginning to

change fifthly we’re beginning to learn

also something else which is a little

bit more alarming which is to bid

farewell to freer trade so we have

widely propagated discussion about jobs

unfair competition migration and so on

and trade is widely seen as the culprit

in some respects or the agent of some of

our problems but now instead of having

kind of some of the tensions that we’ve

grown used to with trade we now have a

completely new phenomenon which is the

fact that anti free-trade policies may

be propagated by the United States under

the new presidency that’s just taking

its position so the the rather kind of

chilling prospect actually is of losing

the United States as the champion of

this kind of liberal rules-based system

which has underpinned the global economy

since 1945 the danger is that trade

outcomes now become the result of power

and leverage exercised by the biggest

economies that we might get into or the

Americans might get into a trade war

with China that could spill over seas to

other countries and regions and of

course as you know this is particularly

important to this country which is in

the process of leaving

EU and is in desperate need to build

trade agreements with others in time so

in conclusion and I think I’d like to

say that the world economy is not doing

too bad actually I just think I’ve left

out my sixth factor and which was yes no

that is my conclusion actually the

conclusion that the world economy is not

doing too bad at the moment but there

are a significant number of what I would

call what we call tail risks so tail

risks are things like food poisoning and

serious sports injuries these are things

that don’t happen all the time

especially not to us individually but

they do happen and they happen

unexpectedly and with rather unpleasant

consequences as you may know so we

should be aware of the adverse

consequences of the pursuit of

nationalism the abandonment of rules

based systems the risks inherent in

perhaps Donald Trump’s economic programs

and also the political and economic

dangers which are inherent in the

current situation in the EU and also i

would say in china so ladies and

gentlemen I economists and economics I

mean there’s no pretending about it they

can’t substitute for profits and they

certainly tend to lean more towards the

idea of probabilities and uncertainty

than to belief and conviction in in that

particular regard but by focusing on how

economic systems work and why they’re

prone to dysfunction or to change we can

help i think understand better the way

the world works and by understanding

that certainly the first route towards

trying to learn how to cope and adapt in

uncertain times so those of you in this

audience who are thinking possibly are

going to study economics in future I

would certainly urge you strongly to do

so and university courses and university

syllabuses are gradually changing

to take on board some of the information

i mentioned right at the beginning and

for those of you in the audience who are

past studying i hope that some of the

things that economic experts will say to

you in the future will resonate in some

way and help you understand a little bit

about our complicated world thank you

very much indeed [Applause]

Please follow and like us: