Press "Enter" to skip to content

Abolishing The Mandatory Death Penalty | Joe Middleton | TEDxSevenoaksSchool


thank you very much thank you very much

well you’ve seen the best TEDx speakers

go and stand on that red spot I’m gonna

hide behind this thing and pretend to be

a clever lawyer and that makes you like

Judge Judy so I want to start if I can

make this work

with this we’ll do it with that image

it’s a photo I took last year it may

look like something like an abandoned

bus shelter in Doncaster or a storeroom

that’s fallen into neglect but it’s

actually something much more interesting

that we’re in the believe Central Prison

there and it’s an image that for me

combines feelings of horror with

satisfaction as the best way I can put

it and I’ll explain what I mean by that

in a moment but I want to talk to you

tonight about the death penalty and in

particular the use of the mandatory

death penalty as a form of punishment at

the end of the criminal trial now the

mandatory death penalty means that and

everybody who’s convicted of a

particular offense and normally it’s

going to be murder is given that the

same sentence of death so the sentence

is automatic it doesn’t matter what the

circumstances of the offense were and it

doesn’t matter what the circumstances of

the offender are the only sentence is

death I’m not going to talk about the

merits or the demerits the death penalty

itself that’s a whole other topic and

I’d happily come back another day and

talk to you about that but by the end of

my talk about a long time before then

you’ll have worked out I think where I

stand on that the death penalty itself

is alive not particularly well and in

some parts of the world as you’ve just

heard it’s still used a great deal the

number of countries that still use a

death penalty has in fact fallen quite

significantly in the last few decades

and in many of the countries that still

execute people like America and China

China by the way accounts for more than

all the other countries in the world put

together probably by several times of

people executed but in all of those

countries they’re still executing people

and many of them

the number of people being executed has

in fact fallen quite significantly in

recent years – and they’re an extra

element of the picture is that in many

countries that still have the death

penalty in their laws they’re not

actually carrying out executions and

there haven’t been any executions in

Belize for instance and the countries I

work in in Africa for four decades so

the position is changing but we still

have the death penalty existing in many

different parts of the world and this is

a map produced by Amnesty International

I’m sure you know that Amnesty

International is one of the leading

human rights organizations in the world

I don’t work with them in the Soviet

Union when it still existed in other

parts of that part of the world and

their map shows various things that have

been happening so the countries in blue

and in sort of yellowy dirty yellow

color those countries have abolished the

death penalty completely in their laws

or almost completely filled to all

effects for all purposes been abolished

the country is in Orange a countries

that have the death penalty on their

books in the laws but are not actually

carrying out constitutions so they’re

called de facto abolitionist countries

and it’s the dirty brown whatever you

want to call that other color that’s

where people are still being executed so

and that’s the overview of the position

at the moment but the next thing that I

wanted to look at is really a bit of a

history story and that’s about the

mandatory death penalty it’s tell from

the story of the mandatory death penalty

begins right here in England so you

heard just now that we abolished the

death penalty in 1965 50 50 years ago 50

odd years ago but until then the death

penalty had been the only punishment for

murder for hundreds of years this map

here as you may have guessed is a map of

our great British Empire at its maximum

extent and as the Empire extended the

countries that we colonized acquired

legal systems that were based on the

legal system of England and as part of

that process we exported the mandatory

death penalty from England

and for murder and for certain other

offenses right across the empire the

manager death bounty was also a feature

in the United States although the

situation wasn’t the same in all the

different states of the United States

and it still isn’t the same as some a

significant differences so for instance

when you looked at the map before you

saw a big blob of Alaska as having the

death penalty the state of Alaska hasn’t

executed anyone for a very long time but

because all part of the United States it

gets covered in that color

anyway so when the British colonies

became independent in the 20th century

the countries of the British Empire

became independent in the 20th century

they kept their colonial criminal laws

and even today most countries that

inherited the mandatory death penalty

still have it in their laws although

again many of them don’t carry it out in

practice and one of those countries was

Belize the story in Belize that I’ve

been involved in connected with began

almost exactly 20 years ago there was a

man in Belize called Patrick Reyes he

had an argument with his neighbors and

like many neighbor arguments was about a

fence between their properties and mr.

Reyes came back from home one day and

his neighbor was building a fence he

didn’t think he ought to be building and

so mr. Reyes unfortunately had a gun and

he took it out he lost his temper he

shot the neighbor and killed him and he

also shot the neighbor’s wife and killed

her and then when he realized what he’d

done he turned the gun on himself and

shots himself and didn’t kill himself so

eventually he more or less recovered he

was tried for murder and he was given

the only sentence that could be given

for murder and believed to be taken to a

place of execution and hanged by the

neck until he was dead

now mr. roses lawyer was aware that

there had been challenges legal

challenges in court to the man who death

penalty in America and in India and he

thought it would be a good idea to bring

another legal challenge but this time in

Belize and he knew that there was an

organization in London called the death

penalty project that I do all my pro

bono work with that had been interested

in representing people who were facing

sentences of death so he said – the

death penalty project let’s bring a case

in Belize

and on your topic of development and

innovation let’s try and innovate here

develop extend the legal principles and

bring it to a different jurisdiction

with different set of laws but try and

get rid of the mansion mandatory death

penalty and use this case as a vehicle

and for achieving that so that’s what

happened the Belize lawyer worked with

two of my colleagues in my chambers and

the death penalty project and they

brought a case up to the highest court

of Belize which is in fact the Privy

Council which is a quarter of judges who

sit in London which is the highest court

of Belize and they argued at their case

and the fact that lawyers in England we

share a common legal heritage with

lawyers and Belize and other countries

that used to be part of the British

Empire that means that we are able to

work together on cases like this and

share our experience and our expertise

and work together on the arguments in

cases like this so what they argued in

this case was that the death penalty if

it was going to be used at all had to be

used in strict accordance with the law

and that includes the written

constitution of Belize which says that

nobody should be given a punishment

which is inhuman and that same legal

principle can be found in almost all the

Constitution’s of the former British

colonies these constitutions are the

supreme law which means that if a court

decides that a particular criminal law

is inconsistent with the Constitution

the relevant part of the law is treated

as invalid so to that extent the courts

can strike down that part of the

legislation because it’s

unconstitutional and the standard

they’re applying in that process is not

English law it’s a standard of the

belize constitution or the constitution

of Kenya physik async annual the

constitution of Singapore fits a case in

Singapore whatever it may be what they

argued was that imposing the death

penalty for murder on a mandatory basis

automatically was inhuman so the first

argument that they said applied in this

case was that essentially the penalty

has to fit the crime people are being

sentenced to death with no consideration

of the circumstances at the offense that

they had committed now you might not

have given much thought

to this but the fact is that murders

cover a huge variety of factual

situations if I am married to my wife

I’d be married for 50 years she’s

suffering from a terrible illness she’s

in pain every day she’s begging for me

to help her end her life an eye out of

my love and my mercy my compassion I

kill my wife to save her from pain that

is murder and if I go out and find lots

of little children torture and kill them

that is murder and when the sentence is

mandatory the law doesn’t make any

distinction according to the facts of

the offense it simply says kill kill

kill kill kill and that the lawyers

argued has to be inhuman the second

thing they argued is that it’s wrong not

to take account of the personal

circumstances of the offender to at

least ask the question well how did this

person get to the place they’re in how

do they come to commit that particular

offense and if you don’t look at those

things you don’t consider those

questions that to is inhuman so those

arguments were argued and they were

successful the court decided that the

mandatory death penalty was legally

invalid because it violated the

Constitution of Belize and that meant

that in future the death penalty could

only be used in really exceptionally

serious cases that was a legal principle

that came out of that case and in mr.

Reyes case it meant that he was taken

off death row he was given a life

imprisonment sentence and that’s what

he’s serving now he’s serving a life

imprisonment but beyond his own case

this case had very far-reaching

consequences because since that decision

not a single person in Belize has been

sentenced to death so although

unfortunately there are murders and

believes that in any other country the

courts have never said well this

particular case is so exceptionally

serious that it deserves to have the

death penalty so and that means that

it’s good news in terms of sentencing

that’s taking place in Belize but the

other thing to be aware of is that in

Belize nobody has in fact being executed

since 1985 since long before the rers

case happen

but the problem of giving people death

sentences at all even if they aren’t for

the time being executing executed is all

it takes is for a government minister to

say ok I think we need to send a message

out but we’re going to be tough on crime

and tough on criminals and the minister

just has to sign a piece of paper and

that person could then be executed so it

really matters that people aren’t being

sentenced to death even if they aren’t

in fact of being executed which brings

me back to where we started you’ve

probably worked out yourselves by now

what that is that is the execution

chamber in Belize Central Prison the

pictures not terribly clear but you can

probably see there’s a chain hanging

from the ceiling and that’s where the

noose would hang and there’s a trapdoor

which has been left open and just behind

it if you can see there’s a big metal

lever you pull the lever the trapdoor

opens with a very loud bang and the

prisoner falls through the hole and

hopefully is killed very quickly but

sometimes it goes wrong and gets very

messy indeed so I hope you can see now

why I said it’s an image it fills me

with horror but also a certain sense of

satisfaction because the execution

chamber as you can see is in a happy

state of neglect and disrepair it’s the

death penalty in Belize isn’t mandatory

anymore it’s not being imposed as a

sentence by the courts and nobody is in

fact being executed and that to my mind

is progress

the case of rares became famous as a

precedent for cases in other countries

that had inherited the mandrew Chi and

managed death penalty first of all it’s

spread through the Caribbean and the

death penalty was used quite frequently

in the former British colonies in the

Caribbean

today the mandatory death penalty has

almost completely been removed from the

Caribbean countries and there hasn’t

been an execution in the Caribbean for

many years and from the Caribbean the

legal arguments then spread to Africa

which is where I got involved so the

first thing that happened was that there

are some lawyers in Uganda who had heard

about the rare’s case and they contacted

the death penalty projects and said look

you know we’ve got a different

jurisdiction our laws are somewhat

different but the principles are very

similar because we’ve all inherited that

same colonial system of laws so why do

we have a go at challenging the

mandatory death penalty in Uganda and

let’s do the job properly let’s do it

for everybody on death row that’s over

400 prisoners because they’d all been

given mandatory sentences of death so my

colleagues in chambers at the death

penalty project and Ugandan lawyers all

worked together they brought a case on

the mandatory death penalty in Uganda

they won the case and that meant that

all those prisoners had their sentences

commuted what then happened was that I

was asked by my colleagues in London and

my colleagues in Malawi to help to bring

a similar case in Malawi we brought the

case in the Constitutional Court we won

the case in Malawi and the mantry death

penalty in Malawi was abolished we then

brought a case in Kenya with our Kenyan

colleagues we won that case while we

were arguing the case the president of

Kenya perhaps sensing which way the

court was going to go ordered that

everybody who’d been sentenced to death

in Kenya would have their sentences

commuted over 4000 people on death row

had their sentences commuted to life

imprisonment in that one decision then

things started getting a bit tricky in

Kenya because there was another case in

which the court said that our case was

wrongly decided and so we helped our

lawyers colleagues in Kenya to bring

another case in the new Supreme Court

Kenia and right now today we’re waiting

for the Supreme Court of Kenya to give

its decision on that case and we’re

pretty optimistic we’re going to win not

least because the government of Kenya

agrees that the mandated death penalty

is unconstitutional under the laws of

Kenya and that too if that decision is

successful will affect thousands of

people in Kenya who are on death row

then we brought case in Ghana and this

is one of the cases you heard about

where I was helping to advise and

represent the a British citizen called

Dexter Johnson who’d been sentenced to

death for murder and he was given again

a mandatory sentence of death

unfortunately we lost that case in Ghana

in the Supreme Court of Ghana that was a

highest court we couldn’t go any higher

than the the Ghana Court so we made an

application to something called the

Human Rights Committee which is a body

broadly speaking of the United Nations

and we won that case we argued that this

mandatory taking away of life for all

offenses of murder was a breach of

Ghana’s international legal obligations

and that argument had already been made

in respect of other countries and

unsurprisingly we won the argument but

unfortunately the human rights

committee’s decisions are not binding on

the government of Ghana and they ignored

it so mr. Johnson is still on death row

in Ghana so we don’t give up and right

now in fact just before I came here

today I’ve been talking with my

colleagues at the death penalty project

and we’re planning to bring a case in

the African Court of Human Rights whose

decisions are binding if we win the case

so that’s I’ll come back next year and

tell you what happened in that so apart

from that we have other cases coming up

in Tanzania we’ve had some litigation in

Nigeria and various other places and the

work as they say goes on so just

wrapping up these cases I think so how

really important ideas can flow

backwards and forwards across the world

in quite different ways on the idea of

executing everybody who’s committed a

particular kind of offense travelled

around the world

by force of colonial conquest that’s how

the idea was planted in the first place

but the reverser idea the idea of that

the ideas that have

pushed back and the death penalty

generally and the mandatory death

penalty in particular they have traveled

by a process of litigation of persuasion

of perseverance because everything has

gone our way and we keep on fighting and

as I hope I’ve made clear by a great

deal of teamwork working always with our

colleagues in Kenya and Malawi and

Belize or wherever it may be so that’s

how I spend my time when I’m not

actually making a living with my clients

in London reading and writing and

rewriting legal arguments working out

how to re present the arguments that we

need to make in various different

countries under their laws and their

constitutions earning a few air miles on

the side which is always useful looking

forward to another trip to Kenya or

another trip to Belize in the meantime

it’s been a pleasure making this trip to

702 school thank you very much [Applause]

Please follow and like us: