Press "Enter" to skip to content

What If The Seahawks Ran The Ball Against The Patriots In Super Bowl XLIX? – Future Considerations


hi guys welcome to another edition of
future considerations this show where we
debate things and sports that could have
happened I’m Julian ashes back with me
for yet another episode you just can’t
escape the punishment oh no I can’t I
love you too much I don’t love this
moment as much though so in 2015 the
Seattle Seahawks and the New England
Patriots did battle in the Superbowl and
they didn’t run the ball in the one-yard
line and Malcolm Butler as a hero makes
the interception noon the Paige twin a
Super Bowl I’m still very angry about
that day all right are you a big
Seahawks fan I’m not even a CR that the
craziest thing is you I just can’t stand
to see incompetence and I still think
it’s incompetence I still think it’s all
of something that a lot of people feel
so for today’s episode we are going to
debate would Marshawn Lynch have scored
that ball at the one year online if he
was there I’m gonna start this first –
cuz I’m so angry about this thank you
for moving that the way that it is
Marshawn would have sport the ball on
the 1-yard line okay we’re short Lynch’s
at the time and even just this extent
today so the baddest man on the planet
Gold yard on that line you give him the
ball trucks through the oil line he
would have scored what the amount of
time left on the clock it actually would
have been in the New England’s best
interest you know to allow the score
they come up the field with the amount
of time that they have and you see from
there but Marshawn Lynch should score
either they don’t want to give it to
Marshawn even if there’s the whole fine
we don’t want Marshawn Lynch to be the
man give like a bootleg sneak to Russell
Wilson or something why are you throwing
the ball okay so you say that he would
have scored on the site on the second
down and if not it would have made sense
for the Pats 11% I agree that that
should have just been like go go go
whatever I think it makes sense in
theory basically for them to throw it
because they technically kill time and
they have two more attempts to get in I
think the reason why Pete Carroll did
this was to put Marshall in Marshawn to
put him in his place and I’ll tell you
why
because I think the idea is if Russell
throws a touchdown then he’s a hero he’s
a good guy and if somebody else gets the
score it’s a team effort
but if Lynch brings it in then it’s just
he has a bigger head he already doesn’t
get along with the coach and I think
this is what an ego of a coach gets in
the way of what’s good I don’t know hope
I don’t get that so it’s not a team
effort if Marchand scores who’s who’s
blocking in front of him I know line is
I I’m still a team effort if he scores
so much so much of coaching so much of
organizational behavior in the sports
context is about sending a message
sending signals conditioning people I
think that’s what that was really about
now it’s also let’s just give credit to
Butler I think that’s the issue to say
this was incompetence is is maybe half
of it it’s a bit unfair I think
ultimately it was just a hell of a
defensive play I think so and I think
you even see on the play Newland saw
that play coming and they had practiced
that play as well so on the part of the
Patriots of course great move on their
part but for Seattle they should have
but I think the ideal was everybody
expected them to run the ball that’s why
it’s only a foolish move in hindsight
because it didn’t work if it would have
worked it would have been genius because
it probably would have been a receiver
somewhere free if they wouldn’t have
taken that kind of you know the specific
tactic was a bit risky but I think the
concept of throwing it to somebody
further out would have made a lot of
sense you see that play all the time
either way it’s done with that’s like if
Seattle wins that game is this the
makings of a dynasty they’d won a two
years before when they destroyed the
Broncos Detroit yeah I mean they don’t
sorry they won the year before yeah yeah
they won the year before
it’s the Broncos that came back to him
the year after look I think technically
if my dynasty you mean true Super Bowls
that that is a dynasty nowadays with
free agency and all that
sure possibly I mean look I think
whenever a team wins again you start to
get a lot of other players in the
support staff that actually start to get
plucked and included away through free
agency anything could have happened I
know like Lynch says it’s a good thing
that he did not win because that’s what
led him to leave and end up in Oakland
I’m just gonna be upon who knows maybe
eventually the coach Pete Carroll signed
somewhere else
I think the Panthers were starting to
get stronger Cam Newton was still fairly
young
earlier on when the Seahawks won I think
eventually you could have argued that
that the Panthers would have knocked off
the Seahawks and they would have emerged
you know I think nowadays it doesn’t
really matter at the end of the day do
you consider two Super Bowl wins to be a
dynamo I think a dynasty is like three
four Super Bowls but I still think that
Seattle would have been in contention to
get a third or fourth one just because I
feel that with the team that they had in
place they all would have realized hey
you know what we’re winning these chips
and we can go out and get more Super
Bowls after they lost that Super Bowl
that’s when you started hearing all the
infighting with Russell wilt with with
the coaching staff and their
preferential treatment of Russell Wilson
in the defense when you start winning
those games that doesn’t seem to be a
problem in some locker rooms and I feel
like that would’ve been an issue also
Seattle they made a they got rid of one
of their offensive linemen trying to
think you know what let’s get Jimmy
Graham and since then our offensive line
has not been the same you see Russell
Wilson still doing his disappearing act
just trying to be you know Houdini in
the pocket now with with the offensive
line that’s in place but that might not
have been the case if they said you know
what let’s keep the offensive lines at
it let’s make it better and then they
would have probably won with those
pieces I think the bottom line of that
play was it was more of a negative hit
to Pete Carroll or Russell Wilson’s
legacy than Lynch’s I think Lynch of
anything it almost made him into this
mythical figure already he was our dog
he was already a mythical feat he had
the nickname beast mode for a reason but
I think the fact that he kind of I feel
like he was not just untarnished but it
just made him it was kind of like
obviously he would have scored it it was
like you should have given it to him
what were you thinking so last point
here very quickly we’re running out of
time do we remember the game as well
if Seattle scores no I think you would
remember it because it was the second
back-to-back championship you would have
remembered it for Brady’s record before
winning I think that the fourth and
fifth Superbowl not being as good I
think that would have been more people
questioning it but absolutely not it
would have been forgotten largely
I don’t think so I think Jermaine Kearse
that catch just before of the Seattle
miscue that puts it in the same way we
remember the David Tyree game where he
made the catch or the first giant Super
Bowl Mario Manningham when the Giants
won their second one bit of the same
deal in fact after the Jermaine Kearse
catch NBC did like a side by side by
side view of all three of those
catches all against Tom Brady okay
speaking of ledger I know we’re out of
time very quickly what was the more
legendary defensive move Kevin Dyson of
the Oilers being of the Titans being I’m
aging myself here by more than the
others by the way of the Titans getting
stopped around the one-yard line or the
butler interception it’s actually a
really tough one
but I think I’m gonna go with the butler
one I think because of the fact that
Seattle everyone knows they probably
should have ran the ball and even if
it’s something that everyone saw coming
I don’t think everyone would’ve blamed
them for it but the fact that it’s an
interception I think how wild that
situation was I don’t know I I put the
feather one over yeah everyone is
amazing the Dyson was amazing but my
final point is the mere fact cuz he
caught it and he had a lot more yards to
yank up by getting there that it was
kind of the mere fact that Dyson got
that close was impressive I agree I
think the Butler one was just out of
this world because it was it was a fait
accompli that the Hawks should have won
it shoutout Mike Jones who actually made
these stop on that play and with that
this concludes another edition of future
considerations Ashe thanks so much for
doing this again as always you were a
valiant in the defeat if you have any
suggestions of what we should debate on
a future episode of future
considerations up please write them in
the comment section below for Ashe I’m
Julianne saying so long we’ll see you
guys next time [Music]
Please follow and like us: