Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Hunger Games vs Battle Royale


when it comes to adolescents battling
each other to the death only two films
have gotten it right
welcome to watchmojo.com and today we’ll
be pitting the hunger games against
battle royale to see which movie did it
best
Mammootty Oh Gus cool uh tada for this
showdown will only be evaluating the
original films in their respective
franchises meaning no sequels I’m not
allowed today but if I could have been
on you round one backstory war era more
in The Hunger Games we’re introduced to
the post-apocalyptic future of Panem the
country is divided into twelve districts
in addition to the prosperous capital
huge it’s incredible in retribution for
the district’s defiance every year a
televised deathmatch known as The Hunger
Games is hosted that requires one male
and one female tribute from each
district to compete now the time has
come for us to select one courageous
young man and woman for the honor of
representing district 12 in the 74th
annual Hunger Games the participants who
make it to the end award their district
with much needed food supplies and
currency and our granted celebrity
status this year’s tributes unlike the
organized approach of the Hunger Games
battle royale sees a random class of
Japanese junior high school students
become the victims of a radical law
known as the BR act guys don’t mean
nothing to me messed up Donna and I used
to like just old I said oh no holy totes
pretty much done
well don’t know I am after being
hoodwinked into attending a field trip
students of class 3b find themselves
gassed and brought to a briefing room
where they are educated on their forced
entry into the annual Battle Royale
ah fuck it over there hey Tanya Angus
car well nice about study done nice car
they are then set loose onto a remote
Island where they are expected to either
hunt or be hunted
yeeaargh a meager me know he’s he metric
a hot day you know rue cartoneros dawned
on us all taking into account the
premises rich history and attention to
detail The Hunger Games takes this round
winner The Hunger Games
she said district 12 might finally have
a winner round 2 characters we are a
tribute from district 12 well c’mon you
two shake hands the protagonist and hero
of the Hunger Games is Katniss Everdeen
I volunteer as tribute
she and Peeta Mellark find themselves
competing in the 74th annual Hunger
Games for district 12 to guide the two
tributes is Haymitch Abernathy district
12 only living victor of the games from
24 years ago you really want to know how
to stay alive you get people to like you
despite Peeta harboring strong feelings
for Katniss his love goes unreciprocated
due to her strong feelings for childhood
friend Gale Hawthorne we could do what
you know take off living the woods what
we do anyway Battle Royale differs from
The Hunger Games as it puts a strong
emphasis on class 3b as a whole decade
all
Donna misuk I’ve accrued a demo or
attach our resident a magneto damage in
Delta
however the story particularly centers
on shuya nanahara class 3 B’s teacher
Caetano acts as the students escort into
the hellish playing field
did you know every time you got top it’s
kind of this conglomerate ah bigamy Oh
gamers quaternary Moscow after the death
of Julius closest friend Nobu
he becomes compelled to protect his late
friends crush Noriko
less is always more when it comes down
to building a memorable cast of
characters The Hunger Games gets this
round for overall consistency and
strength of the main cast winner The
Hunger Games I’m sorry it didn’t go the
way they planned you know not very happy
with them here
round three rules of the game it’s 24 of
us Gale only one comes out once selected
at reaping each tribute is given a week
to prepare themselves for the deadly
Hunger Games each combatant begins the
competition on a platform in the outdoor
arena after a minute has passed the
tributes must then gather weapons and
supplies from the cornucopia bloodbath
and begin the games The Hunger Games are
deemed complete when only one tribute is
left standing
however fans of the series know that
those rules can change if it serves the
capital and the story from now on two
pictures may be crown’d
if both originate from the same district
in Battle Royale
you’ll find the rules are fairly similar
however the stakes are raised a bit
higher curriculum you know honey Joe
DiMaggio M&Ms are you gonna lean on
about it if after debriefing the
students are let out into the wilderness
one by one with nothing but a bag of
food water map of the island compass and
a random weapon hand it is Nick they are
of course also outfitted with a
detonation collar the threatens to end
the life of any student that decides to
not participate or wander outside of the
designated area these rules are
steadfast hey gang to go sweet but a
Casey again what 3000 Naboo dododododo
right era you need to stay get any dance
all good man pseudo who Bjelica hostage
sorry Hunger Games but the odds are even
less in the favor of the students of
class 3b because of how strict their
rules are this round goes to battle
royale winner battle royale my Garman
regard area round 4 weapons get to a
ball maybe not happy look you show them
how good you are
the weapons provided in The Hunger Games
don’t vary too much in terms of
specificity
most are bladed and come crafted with
holes in them for later carry the ranged
weapons are comprised of javelins
throwing knives and bows and arrows the
last of which is commonly seen sported
by district 12s Katniss guns are
strictly prohibited in the games so in
the struggle to survive the tributes get
their hands dirty
while fairness may be a virtue to some
degree in The Hunger Games you’ll find
none of that in Battle Royale
the array of weaponry is vast and can
vary from an automatic firearm to a
paper fan to a pot lid nothing about the
guy ten-pound thereby lowering the
survival likelihood of certain students
other than guns most students are
equipped with bladed or blunt objects
however the craftier participants are
more likely to use their surroundings as
their best weapon
variety is indeed the spice of life and
that gives Battle Royale the point for
this round winner battle royale ha ha ha
round 5 social commentary and so it was
decreed that each year the various
districts of Panem would offer have in
tribute one young man and woman to fight
to the death in a pageant of Honor
courage and sacrifice there’s a lot to
think about throughout the Hunger Games
but one of the more prominent themes
would have to be the statement on
fascism
in the dystopian nation of Panem the
capital is the overarching rule of the
land and they oppressed the districts by
use of their extensive wealth and
exploitation this is how we remember our
past this is how we safeguard our future
I just love that every year the
districts are forced to participate in
their deadly show for their own
entertainment they just want a good show
that’s all they want which also makes a
strong almost preachy point about our
society’s fixation with reality
television you realize that your actions
reflect badly on all of us not just use
what a good show it’s fine
while battle royale appears to tackle
similar topics it’s more a statement on
Japan’s history of student boycotts and
protests and less about the division of
power say massa takaku stead name is
connected being a controversial topic in
its own country allows the movies
underlying premise to go over the heads
of most foreign audiences which may have
been its purpose unlike the Hunger Games
the battle Royales are held in private
and not broadcast for the rest of the
world to see you know what I mean you
can attend disco goddamn I feel dizzy
sorry gonna take Agena it plays out as
an internal conflict between Japanese
students and the government economy
money asana or ANOVA Nakata character
The Hunger Games may address some
intriguing topics but fails to match its
competitors multi-layered
and more subtle approach this round goes
to battle royale winner battle royale
thank you very consideration both of
these films may contain some awesome
teenage death battles but battle royale
proves to be the more well-rounded film
congratulations
was this verdict not in your favor be
sure to debate in the comments and
subscribe to watchmojo.com for more
entertaining vs. battles one of us
should go home one of us has to die they
have to have their Victor
you
Please follow and like us: