
three years ago I tried to be a
vegetarian first couple of days even
really great I ate lots of salads I fell
fresh and healthy and even I felt
slimmer already but the problem began on
day four I start to have a great craving
for one of my favorite food which is a
big burger but I knew that I shouldn’t
have this I’m a researcher who studies
self-control in food consumption so it’d
be really shameful if I give up so
easily it’s just after a couple days so
I went to a vegetarian restaurant for
lunch to prevent me from eating any
kinds of meat and of course I chose a
veggie burger because that was the most
simple option to what I create it was a
pretty distant veggie burger I would say
and I finished all but can you guess
what happened that night
stomachache no actually that was the
last day of being a vegetarian ever in
my life
I went absolutely crazy for the big
burger I mean the real burger so I went
to a burger restaurant and I ordered a
giant big burger and I finished it by
myself my choice of a veggie burger the
problem that made me quit so quickly I
think so and today I’m going to talk
about why choosing a similar alternative
is not a good idea when we cannot get
what we want so every day we make
thousands of choices we chose what to in
for breakfast we chose what to wear for
today and we chose to come and listen to
TEDx talks which is very nice choice
instead of doing something else you’d be
really ideal if we can get our number
one choice but we can always get what we
want so according to a recent report by
TNS research group about 42% of shopping
locations consumers cannot get their
most preferred man sometimes it is a
loose talk sometimes it is too expensive
and in this cases we have to settle for
the second best alternatives which we
call substitutes so substitutes are
products that can be used to replace one
another by satisfying the same
consumption goal so if a desired product
is not available or unaffordable
customers often look for and switch to
to substitute and there are different
types of substitutes and you will
recognize this car there’s a Lamborghini
so suppose you have a great desire to
buy this fancy Lamborghini sports car
but it’s too expensive and you can’t
afford it what would you do you have to
find other options right so you may
consider a similar sports car but more
affordable one so this similar
substitute has similar features as
so yeah it has two doors and it has two
sets and it is a low filter sports car
but you can actually choose something
different such as SUVs so SUV is not a
sports car but it satisfies our general
goal of having a private car
so is it serves as a dissimilar
substitute another example suppose you
have been dreaming about having a
vacation in Maldives actually this is
one of my dream vacation options but if
it is too expensive then you have to
find other options so you may consider a
similar beach vacation or you can
consider something different such as
going for skiing instead of relaxing at
the beach so you see there are similar
substitutes and dissimilar substitutes
which one will be a better choice which
one will satisfy our craving better so
in a study that I conducted with jock
and mascara and Carrie mortgage we
tested how consumers choose a substitute
when a desired product is not available
and how effective their choice of
substitutes are and we tested this
question in the domain of food
consumption so in one study we studied
what kind of substitutes people
generally prefer so we invited
participants to come to the lab and
first we gave one tiny little piece of
delicious chocolate so that was reader
sports brand it’s pretty delicious and
we pre tested to make sure that this is
delicious and desirable chocolate to our
participants and when you eat only a
small portion of food how do you feel
you want to eat more right and this is a
very well-known effect called
sensitization
or wedding effect so we intentionally
gave one tiny piece of this reader
chocolate to increase our participants
desired to eat more of the reader
chocolate and after they ate one piece
they indicated how much they wanted to
be more out this chocolate and after
that we told participant sorry but this
chocolate is not available but you can
choose one or two options so the first
option was a store pocket so it’s like
parking shop chocolate brand in Hong
Kong so it was the similar substitute
and the other option was granola bars so
granola bar is not chocolate but he
satisfies our consumption goal of having
a snack rate so it serves as the
dissimilar substitute and participants
indicated their choice and they actually
consume their choice of alternatives we
found that majority of participants
about 73% of participants they chose
similar substitute whereas only 27% of
participants they chose the dissimilar
substitute and a further analysis showed
that the more they craved reader
chocolate after they ate one piece the
more they were likely to choose the
similar substitute so in one study we
tested with different sets of food so we
tested with ice cream donut fried
chicken but all the time we found the
same thing people believed consuming a
similar substitute who satisfy our
desire better than consuming a distant
or substitute so we tested whether this
the intuition is correct in other study
so in this study participants came to
the lab and we gave one tiny piece of
reader chocolate and after that
participants were randomly assigned to
and received 103 different food so one
group of participants they received the
readers
the same delicious chocolate again and
the second group they received the storm
rain chocolate again which was a similar
substitute and the last group they
received a granola bar which was the
dissimilar substitute and they concerned
and its participants they received
pretty fair amount of food that they
were signed to as a snack and they
finished all and after that unexpectedly
they received a reader chocolate again
so a lot of chocolates going on in this
study but this time they ate as much as
they wanted and we measure how much they
consumed serratus asleep so if our
intuition is correct in that consuming a
similar substitute satisfies our craving
better then those participants who had
consumed the store-brand chocolate they
should subsequently consume less reader
chocolate when they received it again
because there should be more satisfied
by consuming the substitute as compared
to participants who consumed the rental
of r-ray but this is not what we found
we found actually the opposite
so actually participants who had
consumed the similar substitute they
stopped sick until consume more reader
chocolate when they received it again as
compared to participants who had
consumed the dissimilar substitute or
who had consumed the reader chocolate
all the time so the result actually
suggested those who had consumed the
dissimilar substitute they should last
rigid your craving for videos chocolate
after they consumed the substitute than
those who consumed a similar substitute
right
then why unlike our intuition why
consuming or dissimilar substitute
satisfies our equiping better than
consuming a similar substitute well in
our research we found that this is
because of the mental compare
between the substitute and the desire
option that was not available so
substitutes are usually less preferred
than the products that they are intended
to replace because they were not the
number-one choices in most cases so if a
substitute is similar to the desire
option then we are more likely to
compare these two because it is easy to
compare and we are more likely to notice
that this is worse than what I wanted to
have but in contrast consuming a
dissimilar substitute does not induce
such a negative contrast because we
don’t really compare different things so
easily and this substitute looks very
different from the desire option that I
create so back to my experience as a
vegetarian I chose the veggie burger
because that was the most more option to
what I created but ironically this
similarity actually made my experience
worse because I was comparing the taste
of veggie burger to the rear burger that
I craved and I realized that this is
worse than what I wanted I want a rear
burger right so I believe if I have
chosen something different such as
mushroom pasta then I might have been
able to extend my days as a vegetarian a
little longer maybe LS a couple of days
so in concluding life often present us
with situations where we cannot get
exactly what we want we may not get our
dream job we may not be able to offer
our dream vacations and many cases we
have monetary constrain or dietary
restrictions that prevent us from eating
the food that we really crave our
intuition suggested the second best
option is a similar one to the most
desired option but our research suggests
that second best option is actually a
dissimilar alternative we satisfy the
same general goal so if we choose
these similar alternatives then we will
be less likely to compare what we have
and what we wanted to have and we will
be more likely to be satisfied with our
choice of second-best option thank you
[Applause]
vegetarian first couple of days even
really great I ate lots of salads I fell
fresh and healthy and even I felt
slimmer already but the problem began on
day four I start to have a great craving
for one of my favorite food which is a
big burger but I knew that I shouldn’t
have this I’m a researcher who studies
self-control in food consumption so it’d
be really shameful if I give up so
easily it’s just after a couple days so
I went to a vegetarian restaurant for
lunch to prevent me from eating any
kinds of meat and of course I chose a
veggie burger because that was the most
simple option to what I create it was a
pretty distant veggie burger I would say
and I finished all but can you guess
what happened that night
stomachache no actually that was the
last day of being a vegetarian ever in
my life
I went absolutely crazy for the big
burger I mean the real burger so I went
to a burger restaurant and I ordered a
giant big burger and I finished it by
myself my choice of a veggie burger the
problem that made me quit so quickly I
think so and today I’m going to talk
about why choosing a similar alternative
is not a good idea when we cannot get
what we want so every day we make
thousands of choices we chose what to in
for breakfast we chose what to wear for
today and we chose to come and listen to
TEDx talks which is very nice choice
instead of doing something else you’d be
really ideal if we can get our number
one choice but we can always get what we
want so according to a recent report by
TNS research group about 42% of shopping
locations consumers cannot get their
most preferred man sometimes it is a
loose talk sometimes it is too expensive
and in this cases we have to settle for
the second best alternatives which we
call substitutes so substitutes are
products that can be used to replace one
another by satisfying the same
consumption goal so if a desired product
is not available or unaffordable
customers often look for and switch to
to substitute and there are different
types of substitutes and you will
recognize this car there’s a Lamborghini
so suppose you have a great desire to
buy this fancy Lamborghini sports car
but it’s too expensive and you can’t
afford it what would you do you have to
find other options right so you may
consider a similar sports car but more
affordable one so this similar
substitute has similar features as
so yeah it has two doors and it has two
sets and it is a low filter sports car
but you can actually choose something
different such as SUVs so SUV is not a
sports car but it satisfies our general
goal of having a private car
so is it serves as a dissimilar
substitute another example suppose you
have been dreaming about having a
vacation in Maldives actually this is
one of my dream vacation options but if
it is too expensive then you have to
find other options so you may consider a
similar beach vacation or you can
consider something different such as
going for skiing instead of relaxing at
the beach so you see there are similar
substitutes and dissimilar substitutes
which one will be a better choice which
one will satisfy our craving better so
in a study that I conducted with jock
and mascara and Carrie mortgage we
tested how consumers choose a substitute
when a desired product is not available
and how effective their choice of
substitutes are and we tested this
question in the domain of food
consumption so in one study we studied
what kind of substitutes people
generally prefer so we invited
participants to come to the lab and
first we gave one tiny little piece of
delicious chocolate so that was reader
sports brand it’s pretty delicious and
we pre tested to make sure that this is
delicious and desirable chocolate to our
participants and when you eat only a
small portion of food how do you feel
you want to eat more right and this is a
very well-known effect called
sensitization
or wedding effect so we intentionally
gave one tiny piece of this reader
chocolate to increase our participants
desired to eat more of the reader
chocolate and after they ate one piece
they indicated how much they wanted to
be more out this chocolate and after
that we told participant sorry but this
chocolate is not available but you can
choose one or two options so the first
option was a store pocket so it’s like
parking shop chocolate brand in Hong
Kong so it was the similar substitute
and the other option was granola bars so
granola bar is not chocolate but he
satisfies our consumption goal of having
a snack rate so it serves as the
dissimilar substitute and participants
indicated their choice and they actually
consume their choice of alternatives we
found that majority of participants
about 73% of participants they chose
similar substitute whereas only 27% of
participants they chose the dissimilar
substitute and a further analysis showed
that the more they craved reader
chocolate after they ate one piece the
more they were likely to choose the
similar substitute so in one study we
tested with different sets of food so we
tested with ice cream donut fried
chicken but all the time we found the
same thing people believed consuming a
similar substitute who satisfy our
desire better than consuming a distant
or substitute so we tested whether this
the intuition is correct in other study
so in this study participants came to
the lab and we gave one tiny piece of
reader chocolate and after that
participants were randomly assigned to
and received 103 different food so one
group of participants they received the
readers
the same delicious chocolate again and
the second group they received the storm
rain chocolate again which was a similar
substitute and the last group they
received a granola bar which was the
dissimilar substitute and they concerned
and its participants they received
pretty fair amount of food that they
were signed to as a snack and they
finished all and after that unexpectedly
they received a reader chocolate again
so a lot of chocolates going on in this
study but this time they ate as much as
they wanted and we measure how much they
consumed serratus asleep so if our
intuition is correct in that consuming a
similar substitute satisfies our craving
better then those participants who had
consumed the store-brand chocolate they
should subsequently consume less reader
chocolate when they received it again
because there should be more satisfied
by consuming the substitute as compared
to participants who consumed the rental
of r-ray but this is not what we found
we found actually the opposite
so actually participants who had
consumed the similar substitute they
stopped sick until consume more reader
chocolate when they received it again as
compared to participants who had
consumed the dissimilar substitute or
who had consumed the reader chocolate
all the time so the result actually
suggested those who had consumed the
dissimilar substitute they should last
rigid your craving for videos chocolate
after they consumed the substitute than
those who consumed a similar substitute
right
then why unlike our intuition why
consuming or dissimilar substitute
satisfies our equiping better than
consuming a similar substitute well in
our research we found that this is
because of the mental compare
between the substitute and the desire
option that was not available so
substitutes are usually less preferred
than the products that they are intended
to replace because they were not the
number-one choices in most cases so if a
substitute is similar to the desire
option then we are more likely to
compare these two because it is easy to
compare and we are more likely to notice
that this is worse than what I wanted to
have but in contrast consuming a
dissimilar substitute does not induce
such a negative contrast because we
don’t really compare different things so
easily and this substitute looks very
different from the desire option that I
create so back to my experience as a
vegetarian I chose the veggie burger
because that was the most more option to
what I created but ironically this
similarity actually made my experience
worse because I was comparing the taste
of veggie burger to the rear burger that
I craved and I realized that this is
worse than what I wanted I want a rear
burger right so I believe if I have
chosen something different such as
mushroom pasta then I might have been
able to extend my days as a vegetarian a
little longer maybe LS a couple of days
so in concluding life often present us
with situations where we cannot get
exactly what we want we may not get our
dream job we may not be able to offer
our dream vacations and many cases we
have monetary constrain or dietary
restrictions that prevent us from eating
the food that we really crave our
intuition suggested the second best
option is a similar one to the most
desired option but our research suggests
that second best option is actually a
dissimilar alternative we satisfy the
same general goal so if we choose
these similar alternatives then we will
be less likely to compare what we have
and what we wanted to have and we will
be more likely to be satisfied with our
choice of second-best option thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: