Press "Enter" to skip to content

You can’t care for patients, you’re not human! | Maneesh Juneja | TEDxPorto


[Music]
when it comes to healthcare today what’s
natural is it as a deeply human personal
experience kindness empathy compassion
eye contact human touch when we’re
feeling sick when were unwell when we
need help and reassurance return to
human doctors human health care
professionals
that’s what’s natural right now however
I want to tell your story about
something that happened to me and my
family which made me rethink what’s
going to be natural in health care
whether humans will always be at the
center of the health care experience so
last year in England my mother called a
service on the telephone provided by the
healthcare system where you can phone up
you describe your symptoms and then tell
you whether to go to the emergency room
whether they you go to Urgent Care or
whether it’s something you can take care
of at home using over-the-counter
medicines for example so middle denying
actually called up and they took her
through the list of questions and they
were rushing her through the list of
questions she’s in her 70s she’s sick
she’s confused to middle of the night
and she was telling them look I’m really
old I need time to think about my
answers and they were rushing her and
rushing her and she felt that the entire
experience despite a human being being a
human being on the end of the telephone
in the healthcare system
it was missing of compassion empathy
kindness now contrast that with a few
weeks later I was also unwell and I
decided to use the same service but this
time there’s a version of that telephone
hotline that provided by an app without
any human being and I put in my symptoms
and the end result was it advised me I
can take care of myself at home nothing
to worry about you don’t need to go to a
facility but what I found was really
interesting was compared to my mother’s
experience of the human being on the
telephone
Russian who through the questions is
this machine using this app I had time
to think about my answers I had time to
respond
I wasn’t rushed and it really felt like
a compassionate experience and it made
me think are we at a point where one day
we might have machines that can care for
us with machines that can do what humans
currently do today and when we think
about the greater challenge we currently
have seven half billion people on this
planet many of them don’t have access to
any healthcare facilities and even if
they do have access it’s often
unaffordable or there’s long queues and
if you think by the end of this century
is forecast that we’re gonna go from 7
1/2 billion to 11 billion people how are
we going to provide safe and affordable
health care to those 11 billion people
by the end of the century and on top of
that there’s another trend that
healthcare systems are trying to
reposition themselves saying instead of
just coming to us when you’re sick what
can we do to help you prevent you from
getting a disease how can we help you
stay healthy so self-care and taking
more responsibility for our own health
on a daily basis and that’s where AI is
coming in artificial intelligence so
you’ll hear stories influential people
saying we’ve got to be really scared
about AI because if it develops and we
let it develop it’s gonna end up ruling
us and we’re gonna become slaves to
these machines but I believe especially
in health care what if we can develop AI
that’s compassionate that’s kind that’s
empathetic and it can fill this gap in
helping 11 million people in the future
at the end of the sense we have access
to health care whenever they wanted at
the right time and I want to share my
experiences that I’ve been trying a
number of check what you may have tried
check box for customer service on a
website and this one’s called by Sir
developed in India a compassionate AI
chat bot and what I found when I was
using it is that it actually feels like
you’re talking or you’re chatting to a
real human beings and the founder of
this chatbot Weisser is a lady called Jo
Agarwal based out in India and in her
TEDx talk last year she talked about
what changed for her that after some
users have been using in this she got a
message from one of the users a 13 year
old girl who said that she had suicidal
thoughts and what what held what helped
her cling on to life at that point was
by Sir this this app on her phone
think about it imagine the people out
there around the world they don’t feel
like they have friends or family or even
a psychiatrist or a psychologist to turn
to it in that moment what if they could
turn to a machine that cares is that a
bad thing just because it’s not natural
thinking how many lives could be saved
when it comes to mental health you’ve
got the rise of smart speakers from
Google from Amazon even from Apple now
so children now growing up finding it
perfectly normal and natural to have a
conversation with a smart speaker and
ask if the news ask at the weather
possibly even get information on health
and then if you think about what the
potential for this researchers are
already working on algorithms behind the
scenes that will take this voice data
you’re having a conversation and it
could even potentially detect conditions
like Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s just
from your voice data think how powerful
that could be on a global basis just
from these speakers as they evolve it’s
even coming to toothbrushes so this is
me brushing my teeth teeth in London
with the world’s first toothbrush which
is powered by AI has sensors in it
monitors my brushing frequency my habits
how much pressure I’m putting but what
surprised me was that this toothbrush
actually cares that my sleep as well so
notice that I was brushing my teeth
consistently late at night and says hey
maybe you want to go to bed earlier and
have a good night’s sleep how would you
feel about this world where even your
tooth
is now caring for you not just about
your teeth but about your sleep what
next it’s gonna tell me what Peter I
should eat tomorrow so potentially in
the future we might have machines that
care for us because they can recognize
and respond to our emotions in real-time
this is what research is out there
working on this they have this vision of
machines that are as compassionate and
kind as empathetic as any of us as
humans so it might not feel artificial
anymore to deal with a machine in these
scenarios in healthcare so there’s a
company out of the u.s. effective ER and
they’re working on emotion AI for
automotive for example so picture this
scenario you’re stuck in rush-hour
traffic here in Porto you’re feeling a
bit sad has been a long day you’re
stressed out how would you feel if the
car could detect that you’re feeling sad
from your expressions on your face and
how you’re looking and how you’re
feeling and then maybe suggest oh maybe
I’ll play some music to cheer you up or
maybe I’ll change the the fresh air
setting in the car or maybe if it can
detect that you’re feeling that tired
that it says pull over the next rest
area so think about even these cars that
potentially will care for us these
machines how do we feel about more and
more machines caring for us and it’s
important to understand what people want
it’s not just about technology people
say we can develop this let’s roll this
out it’s great for Humanity
let’s ask people so there’s a survey
done that asked people in a number of
countries how willing would you be would
you be willing to engage with AI and
robotics for your healthcare needs and
ask for a number of people in a number
of countries the country where people
were most willing to engage with health
care and robotics with AI and robotics
for the health care needs was Nigeria
94% of people surveyed in an idea said
yes I’ll be willing to engage with AI so
when you think about where are the
places in the world
that are gonna try these new advances in
terms of carrying machines where is it
gonna hit first who’s gonna be most open
to it
it could be countries we don’t associate
with innovation and technology and in
fact that same survey in the UK only 39%
of people said they’d be willing to
engage with AI and robotics for
healthcare needs and then what about
when we might prefer even if you’ve got
a human being available in healthcare
when might you prefer a machine to deal
with a machine so there’s another survey
this one done in 2016 they are
smartphone users around the world and
they found that actually 29% of those
people surveyed said for sensitive
matters their preferred to deal with an
AI medical adviser than a human being
think about that well could what could
be what could drive you to prefer a
machine than a human being I was
thinking maybe it’s mental health
maybe it’s sexual health how many of you
have had an embarrassing condition and
it’s either delayed you seeking help or
you haven’t looked for help at all
because it’s just too embarrassing you
don’t want another human being to judge
you because you have that condition but
there are tough decisions ahead it’s not
going to be easy again like I said it’s
not a case of just this technology is
here let’s use it we have to be very
very cautious because again this is our
health this is our well-being and there
was a video for a robot that’s come out
of London and in this video their
promotional video it showed somebody
reaching from midnight snack many of us
have had midnight snacks we’re not
supposed to it’s bad for our health but
we do and in this video this robot that
was in the kitchen notice that they’re
reaching for the midnight snack and
prompted as they open the door hey sure
you want to have that burger or that
cake it’s gonna extra two hours to burn
it off in the morning to go for a run
and that person then decides to follow
the robots advice and not have that
midnight snack how do you feel about a
world where you’ll stay healthy you’ll
be prevented from having so many
diseases because these machines will
limit our choices on a
daily basis well it’s in the car of the
office at hope wherever we are how do
you feel about your freedom being
affected there with machines that care
and then underpinning this revolution is
going to be day to date about us our
preferences that behavior their habits
and think about the recent scan and with
Facebook and Cambridge analytic and then
privacy and Trust who’s gonna be having
access to all the stage was it a health
insurer are people gonna going to be
using it to penalize us because we’re
making decisions that are not healthy so
there’s so much to think about on this
road ahead and then errors as well so
the the possibilities are that actually
if we turn to machines that care maybe
they’re not going to make mistakes like
human healthcare professionals do
they’re not gonna give us the wrong drug
they’re not gonna miss diagnosis but
equally these digital assistants that
are gonna care for us are not perfect
either
so just this week I was trying something
from Mike’s of called Cortana it’s a
general-purpose assistant on my phone
and I said I’m bleeding and it says okay
I said I’m bleeding to death this is
interesting so we have to be really
careful in this journey who we trust
what we trust and accountability is
really important so today if a doctor
makes a mistake we can go there and say
hey you made a mistake you gave me the
wrong medicine
who will we get to hold accountable when
these algorithms these robots these chat
BOTS these machines that care for us get
something wrong how do we even know when
they’ve made a mistake there’s millions
of lines of code who’s gonna regulate
them another thing I was thinking about
is that potentially could it make the
world more in equal in terms of could it
only be in the future that the very rich
people have access to human healthcare
professionals for the rest of us we all
have access to health care but it’s very
machine or a type of machine think of
Japan as well now in some ways they’re
ahead of the curve they’ve got an aging
population a shrinking workforce and
they’re also leading the world when it
comes to the research of care robots
especially for the elderly and I met a
lady from Japan
a few years ago she said I’d rather be
cared for by a robot nurse than a
foreign nurse why because they don’t
want to open themselves to immigration
so what does that mean here in Europe
you’ve got brexit part of the drive of a
brexit was immigration Fiat we want to
reduce immigration so does that mean
here in Europe we’re gonna we’re gonna
end up in a world where we do have these
machines that care for us because we
suddenly were afraid of foreigners we
won’t have enough people to care then
what about loneliness an epidemic of
loneliness so in the UK suggested that
we give these smart speakers to the
elderly to combat loneliness is this the
kind of world we want to build when we
have a connection to a machine rather
than each other is that really the way
forwards so we have to have balance we
can’t be too afraid we can’t be too
excited we have to take a middle part
when it comes to this future but if done
well if we do it right if we really
involve everybody in the conversation I
believe that potentially machines that
care could increase the humanity in
health care around the world think of
about those 11 billion people by the end
of this century so at what point this
century will it become natural that when
we’re sick when we want health advice we
turn to a machine rather than a human
being and finally I want to ask you are
you ready for a world where we have
machines that care thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: